Thursday, November 25, 2004
*************************************
André Gluckmann is a contemporary French philosopher and the author of over twenty books, the most recent being A TREATISE ON HATRED. The following three quotations are from an interview dealing with this book.
*
“It is said that hatred is born of oppression, destitution, and humiliation, as if everyone living in deplorable conditions were ravaged by hatred. What could be more offensive to the poor and the disadvantaged of this world!”
*
“The terrorist is not a robot manipulated by material conditions. The terrorist is an assassin who takes pleasure in indiscriminate killing….”
*
“The great writer is a prophet of doom. He exposes that which has gone wrong and that which is evil.”
*
Portuguese proverb: “Better a red face than a black heart.”
*
Stephen Leacock: “A half truth in argument, like a half brick, carries better.”
*
Bulgarian proverb: “Other people’s eggs have two yolks.”
*
Speechifiers and sermonizers are like men who praise vegetarianism while dining on shish kebab.
*
When it comes to thinking, real thinking, asking questions and raising doubts are more important than making dogmatic assertions and relying on authority.
*
I am an Armenian, which means when I think of my fellow Armenians, I lose both sleep and appetite.
#
Friday, November 26, 2004
************************************
Whenever I question Zarian’s contemporaries, I notice again and again that they refuse to discuss the work and prefer to gossip about the man, and more specifically the insults he apparently inflicted on them.
A minor novelist: “We organized a picnic in his honor and instead of thanking us he complained about the food.”
A third-rate versifier who considers himself a first rate poet: “He was an arrogant name-dropper. Unamuno told me this, Verhaeren told me that, Picasso told me, me, me, me!”
An academic in Yerevan: “He was unbearably self-centered. No one liked him.”
An occasional journalist: “Once, when I was a boy, I carried two of his atrociously heavy bags to the top of a mountain in Cyprus and he didn’t even thank me.”
*
Of Zarian we can truly say that he was too good for his people, including our so-called intellectual elite. To those who say, “But there must be some truth in all that anecdotal evidence. The man must have been inconsiderate, perhaps even rude, in his dealings with his fellow Armenians.” I say, yes, certainly, I agree. Rudeness is unforgivable in any man, including writers, especially writers. But then, Charents was an attempted murderer: that doesn’t seem to stop our academics from studying his works and the public from idolizing him.
*
More from André Gluckmann’s interview:
“Anti-Semitism antedates any encounter or dealing with a real Jew.”
*
“Hatred is directed at imaginary objects of a certain type: reflections of oneself that one refuses to recognize.”
*
Simone Weil: “It is impossible to forgive whoever has done us harm if that harm has lowered us. We have to think that it has not lowered us but revealed our true level.”
*
Writes Olivier Messiaen: “Among birds most fights are settled by tournaments of song.”
Imagine, if you can, American marines and Iraqi insurgents today (or, for that matter, Armenians and Turks, or even Armenians and Armenians), settling their differences by bursting into song. And to think that homo sapiens thinks he has attained a level of civilization never before achieved.
*
My favorite three funeral marches: the slow movement from Beethoven Eroica Symphony, the first movement of Mahler’s 5th Symphony, and Siegfried’s orchestral threnody from the final act of Wagner’s GOTTERDAMMERUNG (which was also Hitler’s favorite).
#
Saturday, November 27, 2004
************************************
There are those who think by writing one or more articles in our weeklies they have made a valuable contribution to the solution of our problems. There are even those who think if they succeed in solving all our problems, the nation will be grateful to them. I thought so too when I was young, naïve and inexperienced – in short, a dumb jerk. The truth is (and historic evidence is clear on this point) no power on earth, not even a messiah, can solve the problems of a nation that does not want to solve its problems. And if you are ever successful in solving all our problems, consider yourself lucky if they let you live.

It was Maimonides, a medieval Jewish philosopher, who said that for every wise man you meet, be prepared to deal with ten thousand fools, or words to that effect. He also said: “Astrology is a disease, not a science.”
A thousand years of progress and what do we have? For every astronomer today there are probably ten thousand astrologers and a hundred thousand fools who believe in them.
*
It is the same in politics. Think of the millions of dupes who were taken in by the likes of Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini and completely ignored the voices of such dissidents as Thomas Mann, Gramsci, Solzhenitsyn and our own Zarian.
If this be progress then it must be the progress of a disease.
*
Denis Donikian: “Being Armenian means to have a license to exploit fellow Armenians in the name of Armenianism.”
*
Russian proverb: “Dwell on the past and you will lose an eye. Ignore the past and you will lose both of them.”
*
With enough checks and balances even a mediocrity may behave like a statesman. Without checks and balance even the greatest statesman may behave like a serial killer.
#