JEWISH GROUP IN US REVERSES STAND, CALLS ARMENIAN MASSACRE ‘GENOCIDE’
Jay Lindsay
AP Worldstream
Published: Aug 22, 2007
The Jewish group Anti-Defamation League reversed itself and called
a World War I-era massacre of Armenians a genocide, a change that
comes days after the ADL fired a regional director for taking the
same stance.
ADL director Abraham Foxman’s statement that the killings of Armenians
by Muslim Turks "were indeed tantamount to genocide" came after weeks
of controversy in which critics questioned whether an organization
dedicated to remembering Holocaust victims could remain credible
without acknowledging the Armenian killings as genocide.
The New York-based organization had called the deaths of up 1.5
million Armenians at the hands of Muslim Turks between 1915 and 1923
an atrocity, but stopped short of saying it was genocide _ a planned
extermination of the Christian Armenian minority.
Last week, the town of Watertown, home to a large Armenian population,
withdrew from the ADL’s "No Place for Hate" anti-bigotry program
because of the organization’s refusal to call the massacres
genocide. The ADL also fired New England regional director Andrew
Tarsy after he said he agreed the killings were genocide.
The towns of Acton and Newton were among those considering whether
to break ties with the ADL, and several Jewish organizations, led by
the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Boston, signed a
letter urging the ADL to acknowledge the killings as genocide.
In a statement Tuesday, Foxman said he consulted with historians and
his friend, Holocaust survivor Elie Weisel, after the controversy
began and became convinced genocide had occurred.
In an interview, Foxman said the letter from the Jewish groups revealed
divisions Jews cannot afford to have at a time of increased threats
to them around the world.
"This is not a time for us to be squabbling about historical fact
or non-fact," he said. "That’s what really shocked me into saying,
you know what, I’ve got to find a way to bring us together."
But Foxman said his group would not support a pending Congressional
resolution that calls the massacre a genocide, saying it was
"a counterproductive diversion and will not foster reconciliation
between Turks and Armenians."
Foxman would not comment on whether Tarsy would be rehired.
Nurten Ural, president of the Assembly of Turkish American
Associations, said she was disappointed by the ADL’s decision. Turks
and Armenians both suffered during the war, and calling it genocide
by the Turks is like being accused of a crime you did not commit,
she said.
Ural said many historians do not believe a genocide occurred, and
said if the Congressional resolution passes it would damage relations
with Turkey, which is valued in the West as a friend of Israel in
the hostile Middle East and a bulwark against radical Islam.
"This is not a political issue, this is an historical issue, it
should be left to the historians," Ural said. "The U.S. needs Turkey,
Turkey needs the U.S. in many, many ways. It would be really bad for
both countries."
The controversy began in July after Newton resident David Boyajian
wrote a local Watertown paper about the ADL’s stance and urged
the community’s No Place for Hate program to sever ties with the
ADL. During a meeting on the subject in Watertown last week, Tarsy
was booed by the overflow crowd. Later in the week, he changed his
stance and said he strongly disagreed with the national organization.
James Russell, professor of Armenian studies at Harvard University,
said evidence of the Armenian genocide is overwhelming, including
eyewitness accounts and copious documentation. He said the word
"genocide" was invented in the 1940s by an attorney trying to come
up with a legal term to describe what had happened to the Armenians.
"The word was invented to describe what had happened to the Armenians
in the first place," he said. "If there’s any ambiguity there, then
the Declaration of Independence might as well be considered a British
royalist document."
State Rep. Rachel Kaprielian, an Armenian and Watertown resident,
said she was "relieved and heartened and glad" about the ADL’s
decision. But asked if Watertown would re-establish its connection
to the ADL, Kaprielian said, "The dust has to settle on this."
Kaprielian criticized the ADL for failing to support the Congressional
resolution, which she said just repeats what the ADL acknowledged
Tuesday.
She said the group was letting geopolitical concerns take precedence
over its core commitment to human rights.
Dikran Kaligian, chairman of the Armenian National Committee Eastern
U.S., while welcoming Foxman’s new stance, said he is not going far
enough and called on him to support the Congressional resolution.
"What we’re looking for is what the regional ADL is looking for, and
that is Congressional affirmation of Armenian genocide," he said. "We
welcome this first step and hope he’ll go the rest of the way."
Foxman said the ADL does not just fight for equal rights, but also
works to protect the Jewish community. Members of the Jewish minority
in Turkey flew to the U.S. to ask the ADL to remain neutral on the
genocide question, and Foxman had honored the request. But he said
with the Armenian issue "tearing the community apart" he had to take
a stand in the interest of unity.
"It’s the balancing of moral points of view," he said. "It’s not one
above the other, but sometimes you have to make a decision."