BAGHDAD’S MUSIC MAKERS PLAY ON

The Independent (London)
First Edition
September 27, 2007 Thursday

The many tragedies that have befallen Iraq in recent years include the
wholesale destruction of much of its cultural heritage. But one plucky
band of musicians has continued to play through the bloodshed and
the bombs. Kim Sengupta meets the world’s bravest symphony orchestra;

Conducting a comeback

A US Apache attack helicopter roared across the sky, flying low and
fast. In the distance, there was the dull thud of an explosion followed
by brief machine-gun fire. Everyday noises of Baghdad. Then, suddenly,
from behind a flaking white wall, the sounds of a Chopin concerto
floated up in the air. The people hurrying by in the street paused,
momentarily, to listen as the notes faded away.

The Iraqi National Symphony Orchestra was rehearsing for a series of
concerts. It was one of the first times they had got together after
the summer break, which had been an eventful time for some of the
ensemble, two of whom had been kidnapped and two more had fled abroad.

But the orchestra plays on, part of a reawakening of art and culture
in Baghdad, faltering steps in a society imploding under brutality,
intolerance and death. Formed in 1959, the Iraqi National Symphony
Orchestra was once one of the most renowned in the Middle East, able
to recruit conductors and musicians from Europe, South America and
the rest of Asia.

Following the US-led invasion of 2003, most of the instruments and
the music collection was looted or burnt by a mob. American soldiers,
under orders not to interfere because Washington wanted to portray the
criminal destruction as popular national outpouring against Saddam’s
regime, stood by and watched.

The instruments and the music have been slowly gathered together
by the orchestra’s own efforts and donations from abroad. In 2003,
they played the Kennedy Centre in Washington, with President George
Bush and senior administration officials attending. But, since then,
25 of the members have joined the two million Iraqis who have sought
sanctuary abroad from the upsurge in violence.

Both rehearsals and performances now take place in the afternoon,
with Baghdad not a safe place to be about in the evenings. The venue
has changed from the Rashid Hall, which was bombed, to the Ballet
and Music Institute behind armed guards .

On a hot afternoon the orchestra were hard at practice, string and
brass separately and then together. The repertoire they would run
through for the next few weeks was laid out in neat piles, Chopin’s
piano concerto, Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony, Dvorak’s Ninth, and an
assortment of Duke Ellington and George Gershwin. The piece being
played was by an Iraqi composer, adopted by a former German conductor
of the orchestra "Since we have no protection", a slow and sad tune,

At 14, Duaa Musa is the youngest member of the orchestra, taking over
the first chair at oboe from someone who has gone to Jordan. She
wants to be a professional musician. But would the conditions in
Baghdad allow that to happen? "It will take a long time I think,"
she said. "Maybe not until I get older. There are a lot of bad things
happening now."

Her father, Majid Hussein Musa, trumpet player and music librarian,
has first-hand experience of such bad things. He was kidnapped by
gunmen from outside his home. "They blindfolded me and put me in
the boot of a car," he recalled. "They took me to a room somewhere
and accused me of being a soldier. But I had papers to show that I
was only a humble musician. Then they asked me whether I was Shia or
Sunni. It is not something I even think about, but once I said I was
a Sunni they let me go."

Mr Musa, 42, had tried to stop the vandalism which took place in
2003. "They were burning the sheet music, smashing up violins and
pianos and putting them in the fire. When I asked why they were doing
this, I was told, ‘if you stay you will burn with them’. I saw some
American soldiers and asked for help but they said they had been
told not to interfere. So much was just ruined at the time, it is
such a pity".

Mr Musa also suffered a loss recently, a Selmer-Bach Stradivarius
trumpet sent by a friend abroad. "They took it off me at an army
checkpoint. I do not know whether they thought it contained a bomb.

Anyway they smashed it open to look inside. Then they offered me
compensation of a few dinars. It was very upsetting but, in Baghdad,
people disappear while travelling, so you cannot be too sentimental
about objects, but it was hard losing something so lovely".

Annie Melconian’s family worry about her each time she attends a
rehearsal. "I have to telephone them during the journey, when I arrive
and then when I leave," said the 27-year-old violinist. "I know the
dangers but I just try not to think about it. I think for all of us
music is a great escape from what is going on, once we start playing
we no longer hear the sounds of guns. But what drives me crazy are
the generators which are on all the time because we only have one or
two hours of electricity supply."

Ms Melconian, of Armenian descent, was born and brought up in
Baghdad. She is a biologist but has given up her job temporarily to
concentrate on music. "Because we play in the afternoon, it clashed
with my work, so I stopped that for the time being. I help at our
local church but fewer and fewer people go there now, most have
left the country. Sometimes we have more in the choir than in the
congregation. The only big numbers now are for funerals, I am afraid,
and there are too many of them.

"I remember taking part in that concert in Washington. We were in
Amman for four days waiting for a visa but when I got there it was
like a movie. Of course our knowledge of America was based on movies
at the time. It’s different now."

Mohammed Amin Ezzat became the first Iraqi-born conductor of the
orchestra in 1989 after a succession of Europeans. He has composed
a widely praised requiem called Back to Reality about "how life goes
on, music takes us to another place, but eventually we are here, back
in Iraq". Mr Ezzat and supervisor Munthar Jamil Hafidh are trying to
organise concerts abroad.

"We are sometimes playing to full houses here. But it will be a great
experience for the members to go out of the country, maybe some of
them will get scholarships abroad," said Mr Hafidh. "For myself, I
will always come back to Iraq, it is my home. But I cannot understand
what is going on here, this need to destroy, this is new, it wasn’t
here before."

The Mutanabi Street book market was famous for hundreds of years as
an intellectual core of Baghdad. It was blown up in March by a suicide
bomber, but has just reopened, albeit with a few stalls and a handful
of customers. The Shah Bandar cafe next door, a place of stimulating
literary and political debates, which was also destroyed in the blast,
is to be rebuilt. A small number of art galleries are opening in the
city. There are virtually no customers but Iraqi artists, many of them
exiled, are hungry for their work to be exhibited in their homeland.

When the Mongols under Hulagu Khan captured Baghdad in 1258 the Tigris
was said to have first turned red, with the blood of its slaughtered
citizens and then black with ink, when the Grand Library of Baghdad,
then one of the biggest and richest in the world, was ransacked and
the books thrown into the river.

"It is the same kind of mentality that led to the bombing here",
said Abdul Rahim, an unemployed teacher, standing at the newly opened
book market at Mutanabi Street. "It is contempt as well as fear of
learning. Books open the mind to rational argument and debate, and
that is what a lot of people do not want in Baghdad at present."

He pointed to one of half a dozen stalls operating. "Look here we have
American books, British books and Shia religious books which were
banned under Saddam. One can buy these and make up their own minds,
maybe some American soldiers should come here and get some books,
it will teach them about the outside world and other people."

Naim al-Shatry, who opened his stall at the market 40 years ago,
remained optimistic. "But it is open again now and more people will
come in the future, you will see. You cannot keep people away from
books any more than you can keep them away from water. The thirst of
the mind is always there, it needs to be quenched."

Raad Ahmed Ali will not be going to Mutanabi Street for a while.

"Frankly, I am afraid of going there, how do we know they will not
bomb the place again? But I would like to go. My father took me there
when I was a young boy and I would like to take my son there."

Mr Ali, a painter, is already under a threat, accused of work which is
deemed to be "against Islam". He smiles wryly. "Under Saddam, we had to
be careful about producing anything which was political. Now we have
to be careful not to offend anyone, Sunni, Shia or the Americans. The
extremist Sunnis and Shias will shoot you, the Americans will put you
in prison if someone denounces you for painting against the occupation,
they will say you support the insurgents.

"Now, if we draw or paint anything controversial, we try to
have it sold outside the country, maybe under a different name,
non-controversial work we try to sell through art galleries here. And
then some of the people here, who have become rich with contracts
in the occupation, they will pay to have themselves and members of
their families painted. But that will happen behind closed doors.

"But there is a feeling things will change and we will get freedom
to paint like never before. It is the human spirit, you cannot keep
it like a caged bird."

The few art galleries open operate in an atmosphere of semi- secrecy.

At the Bahas al-Azraq in the Karada district, owner Mohammed Ali
Salman did not want his photograph or address published. "You do not
know what can happen, who can take offence" he said. "We have also
got to be very careful about kidnappings so we cannot even advertise".

The gallery first opened in 1980, stayed open through the war with
Iran and the 1990-91 Gulf War until the 2003 invasion. "Even during
the years of [UN] sanctions, we were selling paintings both to Iraqis
and foreigners. But now it is very difficult,"said Mr Salman.

Baghdad has also seen an infusion of free arts for the masses. The
high blast walls, topped with barbed wire, which segregates the city
into Shia and Sunni ghettos, are having murals painted on them as
are some of the road surfaces. The funding is being provided by an
unnamed American organisation.

Last week, work finished on painting red, blue and pink flowers at
Nisour Square, in Mansour. Two days later, employees of the US private
security company, Blackwater, guarding State Department officials,
opened fire after being spooked by a bomb some distance away, killing
28 men, women and children. The "flowers of peace" on the road are
now pockmarked with bullet holes and charred by burnt cars.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress