LEVON TER-PETROSSYAN DISRESPECTFULLY DISMISSES THE CATHOLICOS OF ALL ARMENIANS FROM THE GATE OF HIS HOUSE
By Appo Jabarian, [email protected]
DeFacto
2008-03-13
Ter-Pe trossyan: A straw man for foreign forces who seek the weakening
and destruction of Armenia.
The post election turmoil and the state of emergency in Armenia,
caused by riots in Yerevan, took several ugly twists and turns.
In a March 5 essay in the Washington Post, failed presidential
candidate Levon Ter-Petrossyan complained that the media coverage
of the presidential campaign during the pre-election was "tightly
controlled by the regime, churning out propaganda that would have
made Brezhnev-era Soviet propagandists blush in shame."
However, Mr. Ter-Petrossyan was blasted last week, by a watchdog
citizen group "Armenian Americans for Stability in Armenia" for being
"a Gandhi on the surface, and a Bolshevist in essence."
Mr. Ter-Petrossyan lamented: "We in the opposition were angered by
all of this but not surprised. What surprised and dismayed us was the
deafening silence from the West. What dismayed us even more was the
technical report of the observer mission from the Organization for
Security and Cooperation in Europe, which rubber-stamped Sarkissian’s
farcical claim of victory."
But Mr. Ter-Petrossyan failed to note that according to the Republic
of Armenia Prosecutor General great irregularities were revealed as a
result of the investigation of the ballot-papers in Polling Station
22/21 of the region of Gegharkunik. The March 4 investigation,
in the presence of Hamlet Abrahamian, the representative of the
Central Electoral Commission, representatives of mass media and
other observers, uncovered that the real votes given for three
presidential candidates, Vahan Hovhannisian, Serge Sargsian and
Levon Ter-Petrossyan, have been tempered with by Hripsime Haytian,
the Chairwoman of Polling Station 22/21. The document presented by
her to the Central Electoral Commission misrepresented the votes for
Vahan Hovhannisian as being 100 instead of the real 63; those of Serge
Sargsian were misrepresented as 500 instead of 359 and the votes for
Levon Ter-Petrossyan as 559 instead of the real 41. She was arrested
and a charge has been brought against her. She has admitted her guilt.
In his Washington Post article, Ter-Petrossyan unwittingly acknowledged
that he and his supporters "staged a continuous protest at Opera
Square that became the most wonderful celebration of freedom," even
though these mass rallies were not sanctioned or authorized by the
municipality of Yerevan.
He then complained: "Deeply concerned that the ranks of protesters
were swelling by the day, the regime decided early Saturday to resort
to force.
Riot police were ordered to disperse the crowd, detain the opposition
leaders and put me under house arrest. After several hours, citizens
reassembled at another site, demanding to see their leaders, but
instead they encountered more riot police, later reinforced by units
of the Armenian army, which was ordered to crush the protest. At
least eight people were killed this weekend, and emergency rule has
been declared."
On March 8, The Armenian Reporter, an independent Armenian
weekly, published a scathing account of Ter-Petrossyan’s unfounded
allegations. The English-language weekly’s Yerevan-based correspondent
reported: "In the early hours of March 1, security forces in riot gear
moved into Freedom Square with the stated intention of searching for
weapons. According to the pro-Ter-Petrossyan A+ online news agency,
Mr. Ter-Petrossyan had been told that special troops from Parakar
(west of Yerevan) and Davtashen (in the northwestern part of Yerevan)
were moving into Freedom Square and that they were not armed."
The Reporter added: "According to Mr. Ter-Petrossyan, the police
did not warn the crowd to disperse. ‘The troops came in rows from
the right and left and stood in front of the people,’ he said. But
police video, which was shown on Public Television’s Haylur program
on March 4, clearly shows that protesters were warned to disperse
before impending operation."
Another independent eyewitness, Dr. Armen Ayvazyan, the Director of the
"Ararat" Center for Strategic Research, stated: "Ter Petrossyan and
his team did not come ‘to right the wrongs,’ but just to exacerbate
the situation to the edge. I’m a first-hand eyewitness of these
recent events. The major clashes happened just 300 feet from my home
and I’ve been hearing and watching everything from the beginning to
the end. That day, Ter Petrossyan and his team brought Armenia to the
very brink of DISASTER. No one can prove to me that it was the police
who instigated the clashes. It was not just a coup attempt. It was
a cold-blooded attempt by Ter Petrossyan & Co. to instigate a civil
war! Ter Petrossyan and his team are an immediate and overwhelming
national security threat!"
Contrary to the circulating rumors that Mr. Ter-Petrossyan "is under
house arrest," The Reporter indicated that Armenia’s State Security
Service informed the former President that "his bodyguards would
not allow him to go to ‘illegal gatherings’ or other places where
they could not guarantee his safety. They offered him the option of
formally waiving state protection, in which case he would be free to
leave his mansion without bodyguards from the State Security Service."
Obviously, Mr. Ter-Petrossyan chose to stay in "his residence, where
he held press conferences and telephone conversations. At a press
conference on the evening of March 2, he said he did not leave his
house for fear of his life," according to The Reporter.
While he enjoyed state-provided protection and safety of his house,
he even made use of his freedom by rejecting His Holiness Karekin II,
the Catholicos of All Armenians. Vehapar had come to Ter-Petrossyan’s
mansion as a mediator, and was rudely turned away at its gates.
President Robert Kocharian lambasted Ter-Petrossyan during a subsequent
press conference: "But what happened is unbelievable. His Holiness
went there and wasn’t simply let in. It’s just perplexing. I would
never have imagined that any Armenian in any part of the world could
refuse to receive His Holiness in his place."
All efforts to diffuse the standoff between the protesters and the
police even by Ter-Petrossyan’s close ally David Shahnazaryan were
sabotaged by another key ally. The Reporter clarified that the Police
"offered two other venues for the rally to be held. Mr. Ter-Petrossyan
later confirmed that negotiations were taking place between him
and the authorities over alternate locations for his supporters to
gather. Those included the central railway station by the statue of
David of Sassoun or the Republican Stadium.
Both were rejected because Mr. Ter-Petrossyan said they would be
far from the eyes of the international community and he needed
them to witness what was transpiring. When the protesters refused
to move to these venues, the vicinity of the centrally located
repository of ancient manuscripts, the Madenataran was offered as
an alternative." Shahnazaryan "asked the protesters to move to the
Madenataran. But then Nikol Pashinian, who had served as the emcee
of Mr. Ter-Petrossyan’s rallies" and edits Haykakan Zhamanak daily,
"informed that they were to stay in the vicinity of the French
Embassy. … The protesters were to commandeer buses to set up
barricades. Six major streets were barricaded using not only buses,
but benches, bricks, and anything else that could be found."
The Reporter continued: "All attempts by riot police to push back
against the crowd were pushed back. The protesters had now reached City
Hall where 20-to-30 person riot police unit with shields and truncheons
was pushed inside the building, followed by some of the protesters. ‘We
saw that some people fell on the police. We ran there to prevent the
brawl. They were beating a colonel. I lay down on his back to protect
him from being beaten,’ Member of Parliament Armen Martirosian told A1+
Mr. Martirosian was reportedly knifed as he tried to protect from the
protesters, the officers who had fallen to the ground near the City
Hall. … Youth armed with sticks as well as shields and truncheons
captured from the police ran down the streets, turning over and setting
on fire police vehicles and private cars. People living in the vicinity
told the Armenian Reporter that the protest at this point had turned
uncontrollable and unarmed police were being forced to move back;
some even chased down into nearby courtyards by the mob. The looting
of stores began. …It was free-for-all as people began hauling out
everything from candy to brandy."
So how can Mr. Ter-Petrossyan have the gall to say that he expects "a
strong and unequivocal condemnation of the violence that occurred [sic]
March 1 and a recognition that the government, not the opposition,
bears responsibility?" And how can he claim that "We in Armenia have
been trying to understand the roots of such indifference to the rape
of our democracy by the Kocharian-Sarkissian regime," when in fact
he is squarely aiming at raping the stability and statehood of Armenia?
Adding another dimension to his perverse approach to electioneering,
Mr.
Ter-Petrossyan said: "More important is the oft-stated claim that
the only people able to settle Armenia’s long-standing conflict
over the Nagorno-Karabakh region will be leaders who are themselves
from Nagorno-Karabakh — as Kocharian and Sarkissian are." But
Mr. Ter-Petrossyan himself is from Syria and his Machiavellian
expression has earned him widespread outcry. His ill-guided faux pas
has caused a strong backlash in Armenia-Artsakh and the Diaspora.
Soon after Ter-Petrossyan’s article appeared in the Washington Post,
a sizeable number of American readers rebuked him. One reader wrote:
"I will have to take issue with Mr. Ter-Petrossyan’s comments. The
current government had allowed the protests to continue for as long as
they were peaceful, despite the fact that the rallies were unsanctioned
and unauthorized. When riots broke out in Los Angeles (Rodney King), or
Paris, I didn’t think the US and French governments should have stood
by and let rioters tear down the cities. … As far as the Karabagh
problem goes, there is a growing opinion amongst the Armenian people
that Ter-Petrossyan is in collusion with certain western governments
to destabilize the region, and bring it out of the relative peace of
the past few years, in order to gain access to the oil in Azerbaijan
with pipes laid through that region. No wonder as soon as the troubles
began in Armenia, the Azeris started military activities and incursion,
as if they have gotten the green light from somewhere."
Recently, a group of citizens and/or friends of Armenia, Tigran
Kocharyan, Peter Maghdashyan, and Karen Vrtanesyan created an on-line
petition condemning the riots by Mr. Ter-Petrossyan’s supporters. The
petition, called "The March 1st Riots in Yerevan, Armenia," is being
hosted at
On March 8, a group of Armenian American journalists, TV hosts, writers
and activists, deeply concerned with post-election developments in
Armenia, held its inaugural conference in Los Angeles. The group,
called "Armenian Americans for Stability in Armenia," issued its first
public appeal. The appeal reflects the online petitioners’ statement.
The appeal stated: "We strongly believe that now Levon Ter-Petrossyan
is a direct threat to the statehood of Armenia. The feeling of revenge,
personal business interests and affiliations are the motives behind
Levon Ter-Petrossyan’s scandalous comeback. While we criticize our
government for many weaknesses and faults we strongly believe that
Levon Ter-Petrossyan is the last person in the world to be interested
in strengthening democracy in Armenia."
The appeal concluded: "We call on the government of Armenia to conduct
a thorough investigation and bring to fair trial all instigators of
disturbances and civil unrest. With enough evidence of complicity
immunity should be lifted from Ter-Petrossyan himself. In a true
democracy, no one can be above the law."
Armen Khandjian, the director of the Aquarian Millennium Armenological
Studies, Research and Exhibits, wrote to USA Armenian Life Magazine:
"It is not surprising that Israeli flags were displayed at
Ter-Petrossyan’s rally.
This loser has caused immeasurable harm to Armenia’s international
reputation by his organized anti-Armenian government protests. Is he
an Israeli agent?"
There is no doubt that in these trying and turbulent times, Armenians
in Armenia-Artsakh and the Diaspora will surely rally around their
newly re-established independent state.
The patriotism among the absolute majority of the Armenian people
will prevail over Ter-Petrossyan’ s careerism. The coming days will
further reveal as to how much Mr. Ter-Petrossyan and his cohorts are
willing to be the proxy fighters for outside dark forces that are
seeking the destruction of Armenia-Artsakh and the Armenian nation.