Thursday, December 9, 2021 Constitutional Court Rules In Favor Of Jailed Opposition Lawmakers • Naira Bulghadarian Armenia - The Constitutional Court holds a hearing in Yerevan, July 9, 2021. The Constitutional Court has effectively ruled that the controversial arrests of three members of Armenia’s leading opposition group elected to the parliament in June were illegal. The lawmakers -- Armen Charchian, Mkhitar Zakarian and Artur Sargsian -- are facing different charges rejected by them and their Hayastan alliance as politically motivated. Hayastan has repeatedly demanded their release from custody, citing an article of the Armenian constitution which stipulates that “a deputy may not be deprived of liberty without the consent of the National Assembly.” Prosecutors and leaders of the parliament’s pro-government majority have said, however, that the opposition lawmakers do not enjoy immunity from prosecution because they were indicted before formally taking up their parliament seats. Hayastan dismissed those claims and appealed to the Constitutional Court in September. In a ruling made public on Thursday, the court sided with the opposition bloc as well as lawyers representing the arrested men. It ruled that any citizen automatically gains immunity from prosecution after being elected to the National Assembly and cannot be arrested without the parliament’s consent. Armenia - Former President Robert Kocharian (R) greets Armen Charchian, director of the Izmirlian Medical Center, during a rally in Yerevan, May 9, 2021. Hayastan’s leadership was quick to hail the ruling and demand the immediate release of the lawmakers. Charchian’s lawyer said he is already preparing to petition a court in Yerevan for that purpose. Charchian, who headed Yerevan’s Izmirlian Medical Center, is prosecuted for allegedly pressuring his subordinates to vote in the June 20 parliamentary elections. He was first arrested three days after the vote. Charchian was released on bail at the start of his trial a month later. Armenia’s Court of Appeals sent the prominent surgeon back to jail on August 23. The two other detainees headed major communities in Syunik province. They were among elected local government officials who demanded Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian’s resignation following last year’s war in Nagorno-Karabakh. Zakarian and Sargsian were arrested on separate corruption charges shortly after the June elections won by Pashinian’s party. Fresh Fighting Reported On Armenian-Azeri Border • Robert Zargarian ARMENIA -- Azerbaijani (L) and Armenian checkpoints at the Sotk gold mine on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border, Gegharkunik province, June 18, 2021 Armenian and Azerbaijani forces have again exchanged fire along some sections of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border amid lingering tensions between the two states. The two sides blamed each other for the latest skirmishes that reportedly began on Wednesday, continued overnight and resumed on Thursday afternoon. The Armenian Defense Ministry said in the evening that Azerbaijani troops "opened intensive fire from firearms of different calibers" at Armenian military positions in Gegharkunik province bordering the Kelbajar district west of Nagorno-Karabakh. It said two Armenian soldiers were lightly wounded as a result. The ministry reported similar Azerbaijani ceasefire violations in the same area on Wednesday. The mayor of Verin Shorzha, a border village in Gegharkunik, told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service that he heard automatic gunfire “from one o’clock to around five o’clock in the morning.” The Azerbaijani Defense Ministry said that one of its soldiers "was killed overnight as a result of a provocation by Armenia's armed forces" at a Kelbajar section of the border. It said later on Thursday that Armenian army units again fired on Azerbaijani military positions there. The two sides accused each other of violating the ceasefire two weeks after Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev met in Sochi for talks hosted by Russian President Vladimir Putin. The three leaders announced that they agreed to speed up preparations for demarcating the border between the two South Caucasus states. It was announced ahead of the Sochi talks that the Armenian and Azerbaijani militaries will launch a direct communication link to prevent or minimize armed incidents. It was not immediately clear whether they used that link to stop the latest skirmishes. Armenian Opposition Demands End To Travel Bans • Gayane Saribekian Armenia - Parliament deputies fromt the opposition Hayastan alliance attend a session of the National Assembly, Yerevan, August 4, 2021. The main opposition Hayastan alliance has decided to boycott sessions of international parliamentary bodies until Armenian authorities lift travel bans imposed on its lawmakers facing what it sees as politically motivated charges. Twelve of the 29 deputies representing Hayastan in Armenia’s parliament are currently not allowed to leave the country because of having been indicted in various criminal cases. They include the bloc’s parliamentary leader Seyran Ohanian, deputy speaker Ishkhan Saghatelian and Armen Gevorgian, the chairman of the parliament’s Committee on Regional and Eurasian Integration. Gevorgian is the sole full-fledged opposition member of the Armenian delegation in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE). He and Hayastan’s top leader, former President Robert Kocharian, are standing trial on corruption charges strongly denied by them. The judge presiding over the trial, Anna Danibekian, refused to allow Gevorgian to attend the PACE’s autumn session held in Strasbourg in September. She also banned Kocharian from visiting Moscow at the invitation of Russia’s ruling party. Hayastan condemned those decisions, saying that they were made under strong government pressure. Armenian - Armen Gevorgian, a former senior aide to ex-President Robert Kocharian, speaks to journalists in a court building in Yerevan, January 29, 2019. The bloc announced this week that its parliamentarians not charged with any crimes will not join Armenian parliamentary delegations travelling abroad out of solidarity with their indicted colleagues. Armen Rustamian, another senior Hayastan lawmaker, has the status of a “substitute” in the Armenian delegation in the PACE. Rustamian confirmed on Thursday that he will not attend PACE sessions as long as the travel bans remain in force. “I would not respect myself if I did,” he told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service. “Our deputies are deprived of the possibility of performing their duties in full. We will not tolerate that,” said Rustamian. Three of the indicted Hayastan deputies, including a prominent surgeon, are currently under arrest. Kocharian’s bloc has repeatedly described the accusations brought against them as baseless and politically motivated. FRANCE – A session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg, April 25, 2017 Also facing criminal charges are the parliamentary leader and two other members of the Pativ Unem bloc, the second opposition force represented in the Armenian parliament. One of them, Hayk Mamijanian, denounced the resulting travel bans as “blatantly illegal.” But Mamijanian made clear that the other Pativ Unem deputies will boycott only those trips abroad which will be regarded by them as “political tourism.” They will participate in meetings that could be used for “furthering our country’s interests,” he said. Anush Beghloyan, a deputy from the ruling Civil Contract party, dismissed Hayastan’s complaints and criticized the boycott announced by the opposition bloc. She said her opposition colleagues not allowed to leave Armenia can attend international meetings remotely. Armenian Parliament Approves 2022 State Budget Armenia - A session of the National Assembly in Yerevan, December 7, 2021 The Armenian parliament approved on Thursday the government’s draft state budget for next year that calls for a more than 15 percent increase in public spending. The bill at the same time commits the government to cutting the budget deficit through an even sharper rise in its tax revenues. It was backed 65 parliamentarians, all of them members of the ruling Civil Contract party, and rejected by 19 others. Overall public spending is to total almost 2.2 trillion drams ($4.4 billion) in 2022. Social security will remain the single largest recipient of public funds, with almost 580 billion drams allocated for that purpose. Another 346.5 billion drams is to be spent on road construction and other capital projects, a year-on-year rise of almost 49 percent. The government also pledged to increase its defense spending by 11 percent to 345.4 billion drams ($700 million). The main opposition Hayastan bloc, whose parliamentary group voted against the budget, said this increase is not big enough given the “existential” security challenges facing Armenia after last year’s war with Azerbaijan. Hayastan also questioned the choice of capital projects to be financed in 2022, saying that the government has not come up with any calculations substantiating their necessity and efficiency. Deputies from the bloc led by former President Robert Kocharian also deplored the fact that the 2022 budget does not call for increases in the minimum wage, most pensions and public sector salaries. The government is not planning to raise them despite significant rises in the prices of key goods observed this year. According to its Statistical Committee, consumer price inflation in Armenia reached 9.1 percent in October. The budgetary targets are based on the assumption that the Armenian economy will grow by 7 percent next year. Opposition politicians and some economists say that this growth projection is not realistic. The economy shrunk by 7.6 percent last year due to negative effects of the coronavirus pandemic compounded by the six-week war. It returned to growth this spring. Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc. 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.