RFE/RL Armenian Report – 12/13/2021

                                        Monday, 


Far-Right French Presidential Candidate Visits Armenia


France - French far-right media pundit and 2022 presidential candidate Eric 
Zemmour waves to supporters during his campaign rally in Villepinte, near Paris, 
on December 5, 2021.


French far-right presidential candidate Eric Zemmour called for strong Western 
support for Armenia at the weekend as he began a surprise visit to what he 
described as a Christian nation situated “in the middle of an Islamic ocean.”

The former journalist and commentator, known for provocative statements against 
Islam and immigration, is the main challenger to longtime far-right figure 
Marine Le Pen for a place in a second round of France’s presidential election 
slated for April. One of them could face the incumbent President Emmanuel Macron 
in the runoff vote.

Zemmour announced his decision to officially join the presidential race last 
Tuesday. He said on Friday that he chose Armenia for his first campaign trip 
because "it is an old Christian land” and “one of the cradles of our 
civilization.”

"Armenia is in danger,” the AFP news agency quoted him as saying. “It was once a 
martyr land during the times of the Ottoman Empire and massacres like the 
Armenian genocide. This country is harassed again by its neighbor Azerbaijan and 
especially by Turkey.”

Zemmour laid flowers at the Armenian genocide memorial in Yerevan and attended a 
Sunday mass at the ancient Khor Virap monastery located just a few kilometers 
from the Armenian-Turkish border.

“On the border between Armenia and Turkey, facing Mount Ararat, I want to tell 
the Armenians what a model of resistance they have been for centuries,” the 
63-year-old tweeted afterwards.


Armenia - French far-right presidential candidate Eric Zemmour (third from 
right) poses for a photograph with members of the Armenian parliament, Yerevan, 
.

Zemmour spoke of a renewed “great confrontation between Christianity and Islam.” 
“We see it here, with Armenia, a Christian nation … in the middle of an Islamic 
ocean", he told French journalists at Khor Virap.

In Yerevan, Zemmour also dined with members of the local French chamber of 
commerce and met with Armenian Catholic Patriarch Raphael Bedros XXI before 
holding talks on Monday with four members of Armenia’s parliament affiliated 
with the ruling Civil Contract party.

Two of those lawmakers head the parliament’s standing committees on legal and 
foreign affairs. The parliamentary press service said they discussed with 
Zemmour the “development of French-Armenian relations.”

While accusing Azerbaijan of systematically destroying Armenian churches, 
Armenian leaders have long insisted that the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is not a 
religious one. Armenia has also had a cordial relationship with another Muslim 
neighbor, Iran.


France - French President Emmanuel Macron speaks during the annual dinner of the 
Coordination Council of Armenian organizations of France (CCAF) on February 5, 
2019, in Paris.

France is home to an influential Armenian community. The latter was instrumental 
in the December 2020 passage by both houses of the French parliament of 
resolutions calling on Macron’s government to recognize Karabakh as an 
independent republic.

Macron criticized Azerbaijan and accused Turkey of recruiting jihadist fighters 
from Syria for the Azerbaijani army shortly after the outbreak of last year’s 
war over Karabakh. The French president stated in September this year that 
France and Armenia enjoy a “special relationship” that should be deepened 
further.

Zemmour complained at the weekend that French leaders “talk but don't really 
defend Armenia.”



EU Announces Fresh Talks Between Aliyev, Pashinian

        • Heghine Buniatian

Charles Michel, president of the European Council, chairs the EU-Western Balkans 
Summit on 6 October 2021 in Slovenia


Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev 
will meet in Brussels on Tuesday for talks hosted by European Council President 
Charles Michel, a senior European Union official said on Monday.

The official told RFE/RL that Michel, who heads the EU’s top decision-making 
body, will hold separate talks with Aliyev and Pashinian before attending a 
trilateral meeting with them.

“I wouldn’t like to preempt what would be the outcome tomorrow evening. There is 
still a lot of work going on at the moment,” said the official.

“We are working very hard at the moment with our Armenian and Azerbaijani 
friends on measures that can further strengthen confidence between them, 
building as well on the very, very successful establishment of a direct 
communication link between the ministers of defense of both countries that was 
facilitated a couple of weeks ago by President Michel,” he said.

“I do think this direct line has already been able to help deescalate some of 
the tensions on the ground and can also serve to prevent future incidents,” the 
official claimed just days after fresh fighting on the Armenian-Azerbaijani 
border left at least two soldiers from both sides dead and several others 
wounded.

Michel, he said, “has been particularly committed to finding a way out of 
tensions and this planned meeting is an important step forward.”

Aliyev and Pashinian are scheduled to meet on the sidelines of the EU’s Eastern 
Partnership summit with several ex-Soviet states that will be held in Brussels 
on Wednesday.

The two leaders most recently met on November 26 in Sochi in the presence of 
Russian President Vladimir Putin. They reported major progress towards opening 
transport links between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Putin said a Russian-Armenian-Azerbaijani working group dealing with transport 
issues will formalize in the coming days relevant “decisions which we agreed 
today.” However, the group co-headed by deputy prime ministers of the three 
states announced no agreements after holding a meeting in Moscow on December 1.



Armenian Opposition Demands Parliament Speaker’s Ouster

        • Naira Nalbandian

Armenia - Newly elected speaker Alen Simonian chairs a session of the National 
Assembly, Yerevan, August 3, 2021.


The main opposition Hayastan alliance has formally demanded that the National 
Assembly remove its pro-government speaker Alen Simonian, accusing him of 
undermining Armenia’s national security with controversial statements.

Presenting the impeachment motion on Monday, a senior Hayastan lawmaker, Artsvik 
Minasian, pointed to Simonian’s disparaging comments about Armenian prisoners of 
war and other statements that carry “risks for our foreign policy.”

Minasian clearly alluded to Simonian’s recent claim that Russia sought to 
restore Azerbaijani control over Nagorno-Karabakh through peace proposals made 
before last year’s war.

The Russian Foreign Ministry denounced the “baseless” claim on December 3. It 
argued that the peace plan jointly drafted by Russia, the United States and 
France stipulated that Karabakh’s internationally recognized status would be 
determined through a future referendum.

Simonian, who is a leading political ally of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian, was 
also caught on camera saying recently that many of the Armenian soldiers taken 
prisoner by Azerbaijan “laid down their weapons and ran away” during 
hostilities. He claimed that their relatives have not protested lately because 
they realize that the soldiers are deserters.

The remarks sparked uproar in Armenia, with angry relatives of POWs staging 
street protests and opposition and civil society members demanding the speaker’s 
resignation. Pashinian’s Civil Contract party did not disavow or disapprove of 
them.

Predictably, a lawmaker representing the party made clear that it will reject 
the impeachment motion also backed by Pativ Unem, the other opposition bloc 
holding seats in the Armenian parliament. Vahagn Aleksanian accused the 
parliamentary opposition of trying to earn “cheap political dividends” with 
initiatives that are doomed to fail.

Simonian also scoffed at the demands and stood by his statements. “Your 
political ineptness is at its peak. As for me, I have gotten everything right so 
far,” he wrote in a Facebook comment addressed to the opposition.



Russia Hosts Multilateral Talks On South Caucasus Peace


RUSSIA -- A view of the Russian Foreign Ministry building in Moscow, April 6, 
2018


Senior diplomats from Russia, Turkey, Iran, Armenia and Azerbaijan have held the 
inaugural session of a multilateral platform supposedly aimed at promoting peace 
and economic cooperation in the South Caucasus.

The idea of the so-called “3+3” peace platform involving the three South 
Caucasus states and the neighboring powers was floated by Ankara shortly after 
last year’s war in Nagorno-Karabakh. It was backed in one way or another by all 
but one of those countries. Georgia said it will not join the cooperation 
framework because of its long-running conflict with Russia.

Deputy foreign ministers of the five other nations met in Moscow on Friday in 
what the Russian Foreign Ministry described as the launch of the “Consultative 
Regional Platform 3+3.” A ministry statement said they agreed to concentrate on 
confidence-building measures, regional economic cooperation and transport links 
as well as “common threats and challenges.”

The Turkish Foreign Ministry said the talks involved a “constructive exchange of 
views” on “practical issues of common interest to all participants.” The five 
sides agreed to “give priority to trade, economy, transport, culture and 
humanitarian issues,” it said in a statement.

“Representatives of the five participating countries agreed to adopt a flexible 
working format and expressed their hope that Georgia too will join the 
consultations in the future,” added the statement.

Armenia was represented at the meeting by Deputy Foreign Minister Vahe 
Gevorgian. According to the Foreign Ministry in Yerevan, Gevorgian reaffirmed 
the official Armenian position that the regional initiative must avoid any 
“duplication of other international platforms, including those with conflict 
settlement mandates.”

The ministry clearly referred to the OSCE Minsk Group co-headed by Russia, the 
United States and France. Moscow has also been mediating ongoing 
Armenian-Azerbaijani negotiations on opening transport links between the two 
South Caucasus foes.

The Armenian government has sought to allay in recent weeks domestic fears that 
Turkey could use the five-party platform to further increase its presence in the 
region to the detriment of Armenia and its national security. Ankara provided 
decisive military support to Baku during the 2020 war.


Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.

 

Emil Lazarian

“I should like to see any power of the world destroy this race, this small tribe of unimportant people, whose wars have all been fought and lost, whose structures have crumbled, literature is unread, music is unheard, and prayers are no more answered. Go ahead, destroy Armenia . See if you can do it. Send them into the desert without bread or water. Burn their homes and churches. Then see if they will not laugh, sing and pray again. For when two of them meet anywhere in the world, see if they will not create a New Armenia.” - WS