Armenia’s PM says the army attempted a coup. What’s really going on?

EuroNews
Feb 26 2021
Opposition demonstrators rally to pressure Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan to resign in the center of Yerevan, Armenia. Feb. 25, 2021.   -   Copyright  Hrant Khachatryan/PAN Photo

Flanked by thousands of his supporters, the Armenian Prime Minister on Thursday marched through the streets of Yerevan in a bid to rally people behind him after claiming the army had attempted a coup.

While Nikol Pashinyan's advocates came out in Republic Square in the heart of the Armenian capital, throngs of opposition protesters also convened in the city, bringing traffic to a halt and chanting “Nikol, resign!"

Euronews looks at what's behind the swell of unrest in Armenia.

Armenian PM Nikol Pashinyan (centre front left carrying a megaphone) walks with his supporters in the centre of Yerevan, Armenia. Feb. 25, 2021.Hrant Khachatryan/PAN Photo via AP

The catalyst for the recent unrest in Armenia is last year's bloody conflict with Azerbaijan over the Nagorno Karabakh region, which saw thousands killed on both sides.

Swathes of territory in and around the mountainous region were ceded to Azerbaijan when the two sides signed a November 10 Russian-brokered peace deal and Pashinyan has faced protests ever since.

This week's unrest centres around a "reckoning on Armenia's perceived failings in that conflict and who is responsible," associate fellow on the Russia and Eurasia Programme at Chatham House, Laurence Broers, told Euronews.

The importance of the Nagorno Karabakh region to Armenia and Azerbaijan should not be underestimated.

"This is an issue of identity for both sides," Dr Kevork Oskanian, Honorary Research Fellow at Birmingham University, who specialises in Eurasian politics, told Euronews.

"Nagorno-Karabakh is central to the identity of both Armenians and Azerbaijanis — it is very hard to compromise when it's about such a deep-held part of your identity."

Oskanian observes there are "two camps now ranged against each other" in Armenia.

"The opposition camp, Pashinyan, basically taking his supporters into the streets, and the army in between," he said.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan: Since taking office, Pashinyan has faltered, making a series of mistakes and missteps, observed Richard Giragosian, director of the Regional Studies Center think tank in Yerevan.

The leader of the "My Step" was massively popular two years ago, winning the elections in 2018 with a landslide result of over 70%, but recent polls have shown this score has dramatically slumped to around 45%.

Anti-government sentiment has surged since the November conflict, with Pashinyan's critics criticising him for "losing the war", according to Oskanian, and "as the losing side, he has to resign".

The opposition: There have been ongoing opposition protests since a November 9 ceasefire in Nagorno Karabakh, spearheaded by a group of 17 opposition parties, all but one of which are not in parliament,

"They mostly represent the old regime – the people who were in power before 2018 – and are more nationalist," said Oskanian. "And, they have, of course, been demanding the resignation of Pashinyan since November."

He went on that there has been a "to and fro" between these groups and government on whether to hold snap preterm parliamentary elections, with the opposition wanting the prime minister to resign before they go ahead.

The opposition has been fractured in terms of whether it wants the new elections or not and Pashinyan remains "less unpopular than any other figure", according to Broers.

The army: "There's a lot of frustration in the top brass of the general staff of the army," he added.

They are "pushing back" and have taken a "clear stance" in a statement they sent out calling for Pashinyan to resign.

"That is quite an extraordinary thing to happen," Broers added.

The trigger for recent events was comments made by Pashinyan about the alleged ineffectiveness of the Iskander missile system.

"He made comments in the local media that they hadn't ignited on impact, or only a very small percentage of them had done so. So, kind of putting the blame on the army and on its procurement strategies," Broers explained.

This came in the wake of the terrible trauma, human losses, from the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, into an "already with a quite dysfunctional political context", he added, mixed in with a country and government grappling with the COVID pandemic.

The military's top brass released a statement saying "the prime minister and the government are no longer able to make reasonable decisions", according to Armenpress, the country's state news agency.

"For a long time, the Armenian armed forces were patiently tolerating the 'attacks' by the incumbent government aimed at defaming the armed forces, but everything has its limits," the officials were cited as saying.

Pashinyan retaliated by sacking the head of the army’s General Staff, Onik Gasparyan, further angering the military elite.

He accused top military officers of attempting a coup, at this point rallying his supporters to gather at the march telling them: "The army is not a political institution and attempts to involve it in political processes are unacceptable."

Broers and Oskanian were both in agreement that the move didn't amount to a military coup. "Technically, it's not (a coup) because you don't have tanks on the streets. There's no resistance by the army to take over. I think this is more a case of insubordination," the latter said.

But the move did mark an "unprecedented intervention" in the political arena, Giragosian said.

For the experts, the only routes out of the crisis is a dialogue on elections, which is the outcome that most Armenians want, according to recent polls.

"Elections are, I think, inevitable at this point," said Oskanian. "I don't think the question is whether there will be elections but when there will be elections."

Broers also called for a formal, authoritative enquiry into the recent conflict, saying it "needs to be understood and learned from, not leveraged".

He urged people to think about the "silent majority of Armenian citizens who actually don't want this polarisation and actually want a competent government, an accountable government, and their voices are completely lost in this very polarised, fiery rhetoric".

Broers said he "worries about them and their concerns" amid the "very polarised context in terms of government and opposition".

Armenia's president, who holds a ceremonial role, is today mediating talks between the government, and members of the opposition, which Oskanian hopes "something might actually come out of".

Armenia’s Defense Ministry denies reports of provocations on Nakhichevan border

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 26 2021

The Armenian Defense Ministry on Friday dismissed media reports alleging the Azerbaijani military carried out provocative actions on the Nakhichevan-Armenia border.

“A number of media outlets widely disseminated information published by some Facebook users about provocations carried out by the Azerbaijani forces on the Nakhichevan border,” the ministry said in a statement.

“Such information has nothing to do with reality. We once again urge to refrain from spreading disinformation,” it noted. 

Kremlin sees no risk now of Karabakh agreements being derailed due to events in Armenia

Save

Share

 14:55,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 26, ARMENPRESS. Developments in Armenia have so far not affected the implementation of the agreements on Nagorno Karabakh, Russian Presidential Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said when asked whether Moscow saw the threat of the Nagorno Karabakh settlement process being derailed because of the situation in Yerevan, reports TASS.

“No, everything is being implemented so far”, he said. The Kremlin spokesman noted that, despite the developments in Armenia, it is important to follow the path of the implementation of the agreements on Nagorno Karabakh.

On February 25 the General Staff of the Armenian Forces of Armenia issued a statement, demanding the resignation of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his Cabinet.

In his turn Pashinyan commented on the statement, calling it as a “military coup attempt”. He invited all his supporters to the Republic Square to discuss the ongoing developments.




Armenpress: CoE Secretary-General calls for restrains to all parties in Armenia

CoE Secretary-General calls for restrains to all parties in Armenia

Save

Share

 21:11,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 26, ARMENPRESS. Council of Europe Secretary General Marija Pejčinović Burić commented on the developments in Armenia and called for calm, restraint and responsibility.

“I have been closely following recent developments in our member state Armenia and I call for calm, restraint and responsibility.

All political disagreements should be discussed and resolved in a peaceful manner, around an inclusive negotiating table involving civilian representatives of society and in line with the principles of democracy and the rule of law.

The Council of Europe remains at the disposal of the Armenian authorities and civil society to provide assistance in this respect'', ARMENPRESS reports, citing the official website of the Council of Europe, Marija Pejčinović Burić wrote.

No cash: new campaign of Idram and IDBank against cash

Save

Share

 17:38,

Idram, the leader of e-money in Armenia, together with IDBank, which continuously introduces innovative digital products to the market, declare war against cash by reminding about the relevance and advantages of non-touch and online payments.

From everyday shopping to electronic tips, from digital loan to online banking: these are only a few opportunities of e-money and benefits of Idram-IDBank business alliance. In the coming months in the frames of “No cash” campaign, via their official pages on social media and other channels the companies will present the advantages of e-money and tools offered over cash, they will tell about users and entrepreneurs who refused cash, they will work with famous artists of the town on the posters on “Cash crash”, which will be followed by an open competition on the same topic with a large prize fund.

Progressive countries have been pursuing a policy of minimizing the use of cash. In our country the pandemic has changed the picture in favor of non-cash payments, however, more than 50% of transactions are still made in cash, which deprives buyers of many benefits and hinders the process of transparency of the overall economic activity.

The Idram and IDBank business alliance, as a leading fintech digital platform, has created and offers all the necessary tools to provide the citizens with an opportunity to make safe and fast payments, and to provide the business with solutions to receive payments online and non-cash and to gather funds. Moreover, these solutions do not require any additional effort or investment in software or equipment.

Today on the whole territory of Armenia it is possible to make payments via Idram&IDBank application in more than 4400 points of sale, including supermarkets, pharmacies, service sector, in more than 400 online shops and for more than 300 services.

Idram urges to refuse cash, reminding once again that "Life is easy with Idram”.

 

COMPANIES ARE CONTROLLED BY CBA






Suspect revealed after Holocaust memorial desecrated in Yerevan

Public Radio of Armenia
Feb 17 2021

Police have revealed the suspect in Holocaust memorial desecration case.

The “To Live and Not Forget” Holocaust memorial in Yerevan was desecrated with paint sprayed all over the Hebrew writings.

The man, 36, turned himself to law-enforcement odes and confessed to the crime after “explanatory work.”

Criminal case has been initiated under Article 260 of the Armenian Criminal Code, investigation is under way.

The memorial was built to honor both the Holocaust and the Armenian Genocide victims and consists of two primary pillars, with “To Live and Not Forget: To the Memory of the Victims of the Genocides of the Armenian and Jewish Peoples” written in Armenian on the right pillar and Hebrew on the left pillar.

Nagorno-Karabakh: A Case Study Of Conflict Leading To Globalization

Modern Diplomacy
Feb 14 2021

By Ayesha Shukhat

– Modern Diplomacy

How conflict and casualties of Nagorno-Karabkh lead to globalization?”

In this research paper one will go through the history of the two states and their role during the Soviet Era.One will also undergo the casualties faced by the troops on the both sides, Armenians as well as Azeris. Two Wars fought by Armenia and Azerbaijan other than the conflict that has occurred on the cause of negative Nagorno-Karabakh. One will discuss the role of Russia and Turkey in the peacekeeping and how these countries globalized to seek resolution for the conflict. One will also go through the role of United Nations and Pakistan in a very brief manner. Factors leading to resolution will also be discussed.

HISTORY

The mountainous territory of Nagorno and Karabakh having Armenian Christian majority and ruled by Muslim Azeri ruler, called, Khan. It is in south west of Azerbaijan. In early 1800s, control was passed to Russian Empire and then to Soviet Union following Bolshevik revolution in 1918 after World War I. After World War I, in the middle of confusion and chaos pf Russian civil war, Armenia and Azerbaijan declared independence. From then the real conflict originated. There was often clash for territories among two states. Nagorno-Karabakh was one of them. Russia called a territory Caucasus, was surrounded by red army. Stalin being native of that area. Borders of Karabakh were assigned in 1923 and Nagorno-Karabakh sovereign territory became a part of Azerbaijan S.S.R(Soviet Socialist Republic). Due to this settlement an area called Naxcivan came into being which is sandwiched between Armenia and Iran but, does not define properly, the border of Azerbaijan. At that time Nagorno-Karabakh was claimed by both Armenia and Azerbaijan.

In 1918 ethno-religious rigidity arose between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Thousands of Muslims were assassinated. Azerbaijan seek aid from Great Britain to occupy Nagorno-Karabakh.

WAR OF NAGORNO-KARABAKH (1920)

In 1920 a war was fought between Azerbaijan and Armenia for Nagorno-Karabakh. It all began when Armenia unpredictably launched attacks. But due to bad co-ordination the attacks failed badly and city of Shusha, Armenia was shattered into pieces.

THE SOVIET ERA

In July 1920, Soviet Union without any plebiscite decided the faith of Karabakh. It was decided to merge Karabakh in to Armenia, but later on this plan was cancelled. Many decisions were made to relocate the territories during the times of Stalin in 1923. Azeri people were largely discriminated by dominant Armenian population.

 WAR OF NAGORNO-KARABAKH (1991)

On September 26, 1991 Soviet Union dissolved which resulted in 15 independent republics. Both Armenia and Azerbaijan became independent states. Military action between two countries continued and it was impacted by Russia. This war caused many casualties and both countries suffered harsh consequences. Thousands of people died on both sides. Countries like Russia, Kazakhstan and Iran tried mediation, even UN tried to resolve the issue which advanced to peace talks. In 1993 UN asked Armenia for ceasefire. Turkey deployed its forces on Armenian border to threaten Armenian forces forceasefire was signed but most of territory was still under Armenian forces. But this region is internationally known as Azerbaijani territory but it was under Armenian forces since 1994.

TOWARDS RESOLUTION(1994)

The search for solution to conflict was complicated due to territories political yearning and hope.

Territory of Nagorno-Karabakh announced independence in 1992 and held several elections yet it was not free from forces of the sides.

In 2008, Armenian president Serzh Sarkisyan and Azeri president signed a pact so intensify the efforts towards resolution. Despite of the efforts, many clashes occurred during 2010s.

Four days of war

In April 2016 there was a wave of war between Armenia and Azerbaijan. This war continued for four days but it was very destructive. It caused many deaths of military troops as well as civilians. More than 30,000 people were killed on both sides since 1992.

In 2019, new government came in Armenia after long term ruler Serzh Sarkisyan. But, there was disintegration in diplomacy which lead to a huge conflict in 2020.

NAGORONO-KARABAKH WAR OF 2020

July 12 2020, on the day of Sunday, conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan was once again initiated. Initial conflict initiated in Province Tavush in Armenia and Tovuz district in Azerbaijan, at the borders of two states. Armenia and Azerbaijan, both countries accused each other of re-engaging in the conflict. Ganja gap, a route that is economic, energy and transport corridor of Azerbaijan. Armenia , in that region revived its old military checkpoint. According to a source it was revealed that scrimmage was initiated by Armenia. This ignition disrupted the function of Ganja gap. These skirmishes caused many casualties. Many people went homeless, many died including military personnel and civilians.

OPERATION IRON FIST

War of 2020 is named as “Operation Iron Fist” by Azerbaijan. It was an armed conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan following the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh. It was ignition of the past unresolved conflict. Armed confrontation began on September 27, 2020 on the line of control. Armenia and Azerbaijan, both announced martial law, and mobilization was also introduced by Armenia. Turkey, in order to increase its scope of influence supported Azerbaijan militarly. In this war types of modern warfare were used. Heavy artillery, drones and long range missiles were used. United Nations vigorously accursed both countries and advised for ceasefire.

PEACE TREATY

After the occupation of Shusha which is 2nd  largest occupation of Nagorno-Karabakh a peace treaty was signed between two countries with help of Russian President. On 10th  November 2020. It was decided in the peace treaty that Azerbaijan would keep the territory it occupied and Armenia will return the areas that it occupied in past (1994).

BREACHING OF PEACE TREATY

On November 26 2020, peace treaty was breached when 3 Azeri servicemen were killed Armenian forces. Same steps were followed on December 8, when another person was killed by Armenian forces. Russian peace keeping forces also witnessed breaching of ceasefire on December 11th.

TURKISH AND RUSSIAN PEACEKEEPING (PATH TOWARDS GLOBALIZATION)

Russia have good ties with Azerbaijan and Armenia as well and it had to defend Armenia in the recent conflict Russia contributed 2000 servicemen for peacekeeping mission. It was part of ceasefire agreement. ICRC was accompanied by Russian peacekeeping forces in collecting the dead bodies of people and soldiers. Turkey and Russia signed a memorandum for creating a monitoring center in Azerbaijan. Both countries are going to work together to enhance the phenomenon of “Globalization” Turkish parliament approved the request for deploying peacekeepers in Azerbaijan, the motion got approval. Turkish excavator came to Azerbaijan. Turkish defense minister and minister of foreign affairs of Russia agreed that both countries will work remotely in the monitoring center. On December 16th, 136 Turkish land troops were deployed in Azerbaijan. Further, Turkey has religious and ethnic ties with Azerbaijan. They also have some historical ties. Back then when Turkey was Ottoman empire it helped Azerbaijan regain independence from Russia in 1918.

Pakistan and Turkey are great allies. Pakistan firmly supported Azerbaijan on the cause of Nagorno-Karabakh.

This support influenced the diplomacy of Pakistan greatly.

CONFLICT LEADING TO GLOBALIZATION

 We saw how two countries globalized for peace process. Role of United Nations, Pakistan, Iran, Syria is worth mentioning. This conflict lead to globalization of many countries of world which  lead to resolution of the conflict.

 TOWARDS TRIUMPH

After the conflict that has continued for more than a century, even after ceasefires, conflict finally came to an end in 2020 when Azerbaijan was announced victorious after more than two wars  on the cause of disputed territories. Azeri people commemorated this triumph with great joy and vigor.

CONCLUSION

Conclusion of all this above held argument was that to describe the role of the two states in the conflict of Nagorno-Karabakh. Azerbaijan and Armenia have been facing many casualties since past times. More than two Wars were fought between the two countries. first war did not provide any fruit to either of the state but the second war which was initiated by Armenia itself decided the fate of Nagorno-Karabakh. The Second war which was initiated in 2020 came with outcomes, Azerbaijan as the victor will Armenia as the loser. Control of Nagorno-Karabakh and other disputed areas was given to Azerbaijan subsequently peace Treaty which was signed between the two States with assistance of Russia. Wars are never joyous after-shots of War are unpredictable. The war between Armenia and Azerbaijan also resulted in many casualties including the death of many troops as well as civilians on both sides and destruction of houses and many buildings.

Dozens of peaceful protesters detained in Yerevan – ARF student union

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 9 2021

Dozens of peaceful protesters, including Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF, Dashnaktsutyun) Nikol Aghbalyan Student Union Chairman Taron Ghazaryan and Hayk Manukyan, were detained near the Ministry of Economy in Yerevan on Tuesday morning, the union said in a Facebook post, adding no proper justifications were offered for their detention.

"Sadly, to the detriment of the state, the Armenian Police continue to serve as a puppet in the hands of the current authorities and a guarantor of their criminal activities," the student union added. 

 

Ժամը 9-ի դրությամբ, Էկոնոմիկայի նախարարությանը հարող մայթից, առանց պատշաճ հիմնավորման բերման են ենթարկվել խաղաղ ակցիայի…

Posted by ՀՅԴ «Նիկոլ Աղբալյան» ուսանողական միություն on 

 

https://www.panorama.am/en/news/2021/02/09/ARF-student-union/2448683

Armenia ready to expand cooperation with Sweden in different sectors

Save

Share

 10:14,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 10, ARMENPRESS. Minister of territorial administration and infrastructure Suren Papikyan received on February 9 Ambassador of Sweden to Armenia Patrik Svensson, the ministry told Armenpress.

The minister congratulated the Ambassador on assuming office in Armenia, wishing success to all his future activities.

“We are ready to strengthen and expand the Armenian-Swedish cooperation in different areas. The multi-sectoral directions which are under the coordination of our agency can outline new cooperation opportunities in the agenda of the Armenian-Swedish partnering relations”, the minister said.

Mr. Papikyan added that the successful experience of the Armenian-Swedish partnership has been especially demonstrated in the cooperation with the civil aviation, the migration service.

The Ambassador reaffirmed the readiness of the Swedish side to develop the mutual partnership with Armenia and expressed confidence that his activities will contribute to deepening the current partnering relations with the ministry. He stated that the Swedish side is interested in the exchange of experience on strengthening local democracy and administration reforms.

Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan