Turkish press: Istanbul’s porters carry trade traditions on their backs

A porter carries belongings on a street near the Grand Bazaar in Istanbul, Turkey, Oct. 28, 2021. (AFP Photo)

Just blocks from Istanbul's Grand Bazaar, porter Bayram Yıldız waits his turn in a dark alley to heave a huge bale on his back nearly double his body weight.

A few others linger beside him, picking up textiles from a lorry and lugging them to local shops before sunrise, their heads bowed and their knees bent.

"I am half Hercules and half Rambo," the muscle-bound 40-year-old joked, claiming he can carry up to 200 kilograms (440 pounds) at a time.

Yıldız is one of hundreds of men who gather before dawn in the ancient heart of Turkey's commercial capital, extending a tradition stretching back to Ottoman times.

Loaded with clothes and fabrics, they move in slow motion across deserted streets before the city wakes, carrying its trade on their backs, some grumbling about their luck.

"It is the worst job, but there is nothing else to do," said fellow porter Osman, who has been doing this backbreaking work for 35 years.

Urban historian Necdet Sakaoğlu dates the zenith of Istanbul's porter tradition to the early 1800s, when Sultan Mahmud II ruled what was still known as Constantinople.

Most of the porters (called "hamal" in Turkish) were then Armenian, reflecting the throbbing metropolis's multicultural history.

Today, the trade is mainly held by Kurds from the ethnically diverse provinces of Malatya and Adıyaman in the southeast, where generations of families have cultivated relationships with the Istanbul merchants.

"These porters were able to develop trust (with the business owners) before there were cell phones," Sakaoğlu said.

"Because of the structure of the city, the structure of trade and the topography, the city cannot function without porters."

The porters usually work in squads, under the leadership of a captain who is responsible for coordinating jobs with merchants and distributing pay at the end of shifts.

Yıldız says he earns about TL 200 to TL 300 ($20 to $30), sometimes more on a good day.

But the job requires a strict code of conduct, with each squad controlling a particular micro-district and unable to cross into another's territory.

"If I try going over there, they won't let me – it's their territory," said porter Mehmet Toktaş, 49, pointing to buildings on the opposite side of the street.

For nearly 30 years, six days a week, Toktaş has been carrying loads up the stairs of the same seven-story building, developing the physique of a wrestler but earning less and less with time.

More than a hundred merchants in the building rely on men like Toktaş – ordinary carts on wheels are of little use in old dwellings without elevators and only narrow hallways.

But standing under a pale neon light on the ground floor, Toktaş feels like one of the last survivors of a vanishing trade, abandoned by merchants who move to more easily accessible locations and friends who opt for less grueling work.

"There were once four or five of us here, but the older ones have left and now I am alone. At the time, it paid well," he said.

"Now, the amount of work has fallen and we do not earn as much."

Toktaş says he still earns up to $20 a day, but can hardly afford to take any time off if he wants to make the official minimum wage, which is now worth about $350 a month.

In addition, he has no health plan or social security, meaning that he has to take extra care to make sure his back holds out until his planned retirement at the age of 60.

"Everyone who is older than me has had their knees or backs operated on," said Toktaş.

Around the neighborhood, some of the porters look like old men, their hair silver and their legs as thin as stilts.

Still, despite the damaged cartilage and occasional hernias, some of the porters work until they are 70.

For the old city's traders, these men are a blessing.

"They are the link we cannot give up," said trader Kamil Beldek, standing behind the counter of his tiny shop.

"To us, what they do seems very difficult, but for them it is easy."

Toktaş is less certain. Although he feels useful and needed, he doubts that many others will follow in his steps.

The upper floors of his building are now empty, with wholesalers preferring to move out to more remote locations where logistics are easier to arrange.

"In 10 or 15 years, this job will no longer exist," Toktaş predicted.

Sports: Armenia vs. Germany: FIFA World Cup qualifying probable line-ups, match stats and LIVE blog!

Nov 12 2021

Lukas Nmecha is pushing for his first international start when Germany conclude their 2022 FIFA World Cup qualifying campaign against Henrikh Mkhitaryan's Armenia on Sunday (kick-off: 6pm CET).

The Wolfsburg forward – who was previously an England youth international – came off the bench in Thursday's 9-0 thrashing of Lichtenstein. With coach Hansi Flick expected to release several members of his squad, such as Manuel Neuer and Thomas Müller, early, and with World Cup qualification already secured, Nmecha is among those expected to start. He could have Wolfsburg teammates Ridle Baku and Maximilian Arnold in support, but fellow fringe player Nico Schlotterbeck has joined a long injury list which includes Florian Wirtz and Julian Draxler. With Neuer and Joshua Kimmich absent, veteran Borussia Mönchengladbach centre-back Matthias Ginter could be the man to lead the team out at the Republican Stadium in Yerevan.

Armenia could draw level on points with North Macedonia in second in Group J in the unlikely event they beat a team ranked 77 places higher than them in the latest FIFA World Rankings, but they have a vastly inferior goal-difference anyway. The side captained by former Borussia Dortmund star Henrikh Mkhitaryan will be playing for pride in front of their home fans. Hoffenheim forward Sargis Adamyan is another familiar face for followers of the Bundesliga. Argentina-born Norberto Briasco could join Mkhitaryan and Adamyan in the final third.

Watch: Nmecha "proud" after first Germany call-up

  • Germany were the first team to qualify for the 2022 World Cup, after hosts Qatar.
  • Nmecha previously scored eight goals in 31 youth international appearances with England, and then 12 in 20 with Germany's U21s.
  • Die Mannschaft have never lost an away game in World Cup qualifying.
  • Serge Gnabry was Germany's most potent attacking outlet in this qualifying campaign with five goals and an assists, four of those goals coming in five games under Flick.
  • Mkhitaryan had 41 goals and 49 assists in 140 games in all competitions for Dortmund before leaving for Manchester United in 2016.
  • Germany have won all four of their previous meetings with Armenia, with an aggregate score of 21-2.

Probable line-ups

Armenia: Yurchenko – Terteryan, Haroyan, Voskanyan, Hovhannisyan – Barseghyan, Udo, Bayramyan – Mkhitaryan (c) – Adamyan, Briasco
Out: -
Doubtful: 
Coach: Joaquin Caparros

Germany: Leno – Hofmann, Ginter (c), Kehrer, Raum – Neuhaus, Arnold – Baku, Brandt, Nmecha – Volland
Out: Adeyemi (not included), Draxler (muscular), Gnabry (not included), Kimmich (not included), Musiala (not included), Süle (not included)
Doubtful: Schlotterbeck (thigh), Wirtz (hip)
Coach: 
Hansi Flick

Karabakh’s Development Set to Transform the South Caucasus

Nov 10 2021

While no one is watching, the social and economic geography in the South Caucasus is continuing swiftly to evolve. Signal among these developments, indeed its driving force, is the rebuilding of the Karabakh region following the expulsion of occupying military forces from the Republic of Armenia, or under its direct control, which had been there for 30 years. The development has deep implications for the geopolitics of the broader region.

Danger still exists from Armenian irregular forces that continue to operate from the Azerbaijani territories where Russian peacekeeping troops are located. At the same time, there are periodic attempts to infiltrate special-operations teams from the body of Armenia proper into the newly liberated lands.

So far the headline story, but far from the only one, in the redevelopment of the Karabakh region is the opening of a new international airport in Fuzuli, a city that became a ghost town after its Azerbaijani population was driven out following its capture in August 1993 by Armenian forces who destroyed its civilian infrastructure.

It happens that the Azerbaijani army was able to retake important areas of Fuzuli district in 1994, although not the city itself. The development of non-occupied Fuzuli distinct since 1994 is an indicator of what to expect not only for Fuzuli city but for the whole of the de-occupied territories, once they are de-mined from the vast amounts of ordnance implanted by Armenian forces. This procedure is complicated by Yerevan’s general refusal to turn the requisite maps over to Baku. In one case where they did so, for the city of Aghdam, it was determined by inspection that these maps were only about 25 percent accurate.

In 1979, the city of Fuzuli had a population of 13,091. The whole of the Fuzuli district had population of 76,013, of which almost 97 percent was ethnic Azerbaijani. By 1989, the population of Fuzuli city had reached 17,090, an increase of 23 percent. Applying this rate of growth and ethnic apportionment to Fuzuli district would give it a population of 93,450, of which over 90,000 ethnic Azerbaijanis. This would be the number ethnically cleansed by Armenian forces from Fuzuli district alone during the First Karabakh War.

Making a very rough calculation based on Azerbaijan’s population growth of 42 percent over three decades, from 7.02 million in 1989 to 9.98 million in 2019, these figures indicate that proportionally the old Fuzuli district should be able to support almost 128,000 Azerbaijanis, or indeed more, given the now-planned economic development there.

It is estimated that in the mid-1990s 40,000 Azerbaijanis had returned already to those areas of Fuzuli district not under Armenian military control, where they have thrived. This established demographic and economic base, an advantage that most of the de-occupied administrative districts do not enjoy, will facilitate the further development of Fuzuli city and the rest of Fuzuli district.

Azerbaijan is building two more airports in the formerly occupied territories, in Zangilan and Lachin districts. Construction of Zangilan International Airport began in May 2021 and will be completed next year. These three airports will go far to re-integrate the region economically back into Azerbaijan. It is planned to create industrial zones adjacent to the airports. Private Turkish companies have already started to construct an agropark in Zangilan district.

Thus, it is planned that the new airports will also become foci for modern logistics and transportation centres. The airports and their associated infrastructure will strengthen the region’s own security and connectivity by linking important new highways there, already under construction. New highways have already been finished that link major Karabakh cities, in the mountains, to the country’s eastern plain.

The catastrophe of the contamination of the de-occupied territories by land mines is becoming more widely recognized. Estimates made in 1998 supposed about 100,000 mines in the occupied territories. However. the mine maps provided for the city of Aghdam alone on 12 June 2021 showed no fewer than 97,000 mines. Official Baku believes that the occupying Armenian forces sowed no fewer than a million mines throughout the territories over the course of 30 years.

The United Kingdom has provided US$677,000 to Azerbaijan for de-mining activities via the United Nations Development program. France has donated US$473,000 directly to Azerbaijan for the same purpose. The United States has recently pledged US$500,000. Other countries have stepped up by providing trained personnel as well as funding.

Unfortunately Canada has not been among them, despite its having once vaunted itself with pride for having promoted and motivated the 1997 signature of the so-called “Ottawa Treaty” (full title: Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Land Mines and Their Destruction), which entered into force in 1999.

Azerbaijan’s deputy foreign minister Elnur Mammadov has told the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that Armenian forces continue to lay landmines in a “campaign of ethnic cleansing and incitement to violence against Azerbaijanis [that] is ongoing” and which have killed or injured “at least” 106 Azerbaijanis, including 65 civilians as of the middle of last month. Azerbaijan has applied to the ICJ for an order to Armenia to hand over maps showing the location of land mines in the liberated territories.

Even if it takes a decade to clear the mines, the economic development of the liberated territories is not being delayed. Baku is dedicating already in 2021 $1.5 billion dollars for the restoration of these territories. Similar figures may be foreseen for the future. This sum is not a great burden on the country’s state budget, which estimated an oil price of $45 per barrel; this price has risen to over $80 lately, with further increases likely.

The results of these investments will not only transform the territories themselves. The broad rebuilding of the infrastructure, including international links, will equally transform the geostrategic map of the whole South Caucasus region and beyond.

 

Robert M. Cutler is a Fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute.

The views expressed in this article are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily reflect those of Geopoliticalmonitor.com


Baku accuses Yerevan of trying to discredit Russian peacekeepers in Nagorno-Karabakh

TASS, Russia
Nov 9 2021
Renewed clashes between Azerbaijan and Armenia erupted on September 27, 2020

BAKU, November 9. /TASS/. Armenia is seeking to escalate the situation in the region and discredit the activities of Russian peacekeepers in Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Leila Abdullayeva said on Tuesday, commenting on the Armenian foreign ministry’s statement following an armed incident near the city of Shusha.

"The Armenian foreign ministry has neither political, nor legal, nor moral right to make any statements about developments on Azerbaijan’s territory. As for the incident, it was yet another provocation of the Armenian side," Abdullayeva said in a statement.

On Monday, Armenian media reported about an armed incident near the city of Shusha in Nagorno-Karabakh. According to Armenpress agency, "civilians conducting works on a water pipeline at a crossroads near the city of Shusha came under shelling by the Azerbaijani side." As a result, one person was killed and three more received gun wounds.

According to the Azerbaijani foreign ministry spokesperson, the Armenian side notifies Russian peacekeepers about any works near Shusha and such works are to be conducted in the presence of peacekeepers. "This time, no one informed the Russian peacekeepers and they were not present during the ‘works.’ Naturally, it gives grounds to questions," she noted.

She recalled that Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and other officials took part in an event in Shusha. "Naturally, security measures are enhanced on such occasions. Bearing this in mind, it is absolutely illogical to organize any repair works on the adjacent territory," she stated.

She also recalled that Armenia’s defense minister made a trip to Karabakh a day before and described it as "another provocation."

"The above-mentioned episodes demonstrate that the Armenian side is deliberately escalating the situation. And the fact that these actions were taken ahead of the anniversary of the signing of the trilateral statement on ceasefire reveals Yerevan’s attempt to discredit the activities of Russian peacekeepers," she added.

Renewed clashes between Azerbaijan and Armenia erupted on September 27, 2020, with intense battles raging in the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh. On November 9, 2020, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed a joint statement on a complete ceasefire in Nagorno-Karabakh. Under the document, the Azerbaijani and Armenian sides stopped at the positions that they had held and Russian peacekeepers were deployed along the engagement line in Nagorno-Karabakh and along the Lachin corridor that connects Armenia with the enclave to exercise control of the ceasefire observance. Apart from that, several districts came over to Baku’s control.


CivilNet: Remembering Mariam Shahinyan, Turkey’s first professional female photographer

CIVILNET.AM

07 Nov, 2021 06:11

When writer and researcher Anahit Ghazaryan saw Mariam Shahinyan’s work, it was love at first sight. 

It all started in Istanbul, with a little photo of a girl with long hair taken by Shahinyan. 

An Armenian genocide survivor, Shahinyan  is Turkey’s first female studio photographer. Outside some corners in Turkey, very few know about her work. 

Anahit Ghazaryan spent five years researching and finding original photos by the artist, who died in 1996 after dedicating 50 years of her life to photography. 

Anahit gathered a small collection of the photos taken by the artist and opened a temporary exhibition in Yerevan, titled “Living room of images”. The collection honors Shahinyan’s work. 

Newspaper: PACE co-rapporteurs astonished by Armenia authorities’ decision on press

News.am, Armenia
Nov 5 2021

YEREVAN. – Hraparak daily of the Republic of Armenia (RA) writes: During yesterday's meeting with the parliamentary opposition, the PACE co-rapporteurs on Armenia, who have been in Yerevan for several days and are meeting with various circles, did not hide their astonishment by the restrictions being imposed on the media by the current authorities.

[Opposition] “Armenia” Bloc MP Aram Vardevanyan told them that for the first time in 30 years, the RA authorities have decided to restrict the reporters’ free movement in the parliament, which [now] resembles a penitentiary during the days of the session. He said that [now] it is easier to move around in penitentiaries than reporters are allowed in the [country’s] parliament.

The co-rapporteurs rolled their eyes, asking when that decision was made, by whom, how it was manifested, and so on. Then they asked the opposition MPs to provide them with that decision in a written version. Vardevanyan came ready for the meeting, and handed them the [respective] package on the spot, which included this and all other problematic decisions and laws related to the press.

The co-rapporteurs were presented also the issues of the judiciary, human rights and other domains, which, naturally, authorities’ officials and MPs do not present to the co-rapporteurs.

Armenia reports 2074 daily COVID-19 cases

Save

Share

 11:30,

YEREVAN, OCTOBER 27, ARMENPRESS. 2074 new cases of COVID-19 have been confirmed in Armenia in the past 24 hours, bringing the total number of confirmed cases to 300,143, the ministry of healthcare reports.

13,696 COVID-19 tests were conducted on October 26.

714 patients have recovered in one day. The total number of recoveries has reached 263,716.

The death toll has risen to 6151 (39 death cases have been registered in the past one day).

The number of active cases is 29,007.

The number of people who have been infected with COVID-19 but died from other disease has reached 1269 (6 new such cases).

 

Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan

New Apostolic Nunciature office opens in Armenia

Vatican News
Oct 26 2021
A new office of the Apostolic Nunciature to Armenia opens on Wednesday in the capital, Yerevan. It will not, however, replace the official Apostolic Nunciature in Tbilisi, Georgia, which serves as the Holy See’s diplomatic mission to Georgia and Armenia

By Salvatore Cernuzio

As the Holy See and Armenia mark 30 years of diplomatic relations, a new office of the Apostolic Nunciature to Georgia and Armenia is to be inaugurated on October 27, in the Armenian capital Yerevan. The inauguration will take place in the presence of Archbishop Edgar Peña Parra, Substitute of the Secretariat of State. 

The opening of the Yerevan office represents a provisional setup in view of a wider arrangement in order to have sufficient space to adequately support the multiple commitments of the mission of the Holy See and of the Catholic Church in Armenia.  For the Holy See, it is a further opportunity to look "at building a prosperous relationship for the benefit of all Armenians".

The Apostolic Nunciature in Armenia was established on May 24, 1992, with the apostolic letter Armeniam Nationem of St. John Paul II. The relations between the Church of Rome and Armenia go back to ancient times, almost to the very origins of Christianity, when faith in Jesus spread from Jerusalem to the "known world", where meetings and commercial and cultural exchanges between peoples became an occasion for debates that touched the "meaning" of life and existence.

Over the centuries, this ancient and prolific relationship between Armenia and the Holy See has grown in strength. Official diplomatic relations in modern times can be traced back to May 23, 1992, after Armenia gained independence following the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Since then, the Holy See has continually maintained diplomatic representations to foster relations, along with other initiatives and channels of various Catholic institutions. The first apostolic nuncio appointed to Armenia was Monsignor Jean-Paul Aimé Gobel (1993-1997).  The current Holy See’s representative since 2018 is Archbishop José A. Bettencourt.

Over the years, the relationship between the Holy See and Armenia has also taken shape with the work and presence of the Mechitarist Congregation, the Armenian Sisters of the Immaculate Conception, the clergy of the Ordinariate for Catholics of the Armenian rite in Eastern Europe, the Sisters of Charity of Mother Teresa in Spitak and Yerevan, the Camillian Fathers of the “Redemptoris Mater” hospital in Ashotzk, built after the 1988 earthquake, and Caritas Armenia. These are just some of the most well-known Catholic presences that draw on the resources and support of the worldwide Catholic Church and which, over the years, have provided valid support to the mission of the Nuncios in the country, who have always been able to count on the generosity and support offered by the Armenian-Catholic archbishops.

In 2019, during his visit to Armenia, Vatican Secretary for Relations with States, Archbishop Paul Richard Gallagher said: "The intention of all the Catholic communities present in Armenia – the Armenian-Catholic, the Roman and other rites – is to strive for the welfare of Armenian society as a whole.” “Our communities continue to do so through their activities in the spiritual, cultural, educational, charitable and humanitarian fields.”

Pope Francis visited Armenia, June 24-26, 2016.   In his meeting with the country’s civil authorities and members of the diplomatic corps, the Pontiff recalled the history of the country, marked by Metz Yeghern (the ‘Great Evil’ or what is known as the Armenian genocide under the Ottoman Empire during World War I), which has always gone “hand in hand with its Christian identity, preserved over the centuries". “This Christian identity,” the Pope said,  “far from hindering the healthy secularism of the state, nourishes it, favouring the shared citizenship of all members of society, religious freedom and respect for minorities.”  “The cohesion of all Armenians, and the increased commitment to identify useful ways to overcome tensions with some neighbouring countries,” he said, “will make it easier to achieve these important objectives, ushering in an era of true rebirth for Armenia.”

 

Armenian expert: Those who renounce Artsakh, Mush, Van, Sassoun are ‘traitors’

Panorama, Armenia
Oct 26 2021

Expert on Turkey, Doctor of History and Professor Ruben Melkonyan says the ones who “renounce Artsakh, Mush, Van, Sassoun are traitors”, adding domestic enemies with Armenian names are “even more disgusting”.

His comments came after Gegham Manukyan, an MP from the opposition Armenia faction, on Tuesday was forcibly removed from the parliament podium for the statement, “The ones who renounce Artsakh are traitors”.

“I would like to ask a semi-rhetorical question: what were those, who entered politics in 1988 and were in power in the first half of the 1990s, as well as believed and continue to believe that Artsakh can be part of Azerbaijan, were thinking when they enthusiastically chanted "unification" during the numerous rallies of the Artsakh movement? What did they want to unite to? Artsakh to Armenia or Azerbaijan to Nakhichevan through the so-called "Zangezur corridor"?” he wrote on Facebook.

“This question concerns figures of different "caliber" and no "caliber", who came to power in the 1990s and distanced themselves from the idea of “unification” in their political career.

“The enemy is predictable, while the enemy-loving domestic enemies with an Armenian name and surname are even more disgusting.

“Therefore, yes, those who renounce Artsakh, Mush, Van, Sassoun, who ridicule this idea are traitors and sooner or later will end up in the political dump where traitors of different times were sent.

“You have to eventually realize that our enemy does not expect us to make concessions, it seeks our non-existence both as a state and as a nation. Consequently, political pragmatism (of which I am an advocate) and the national identity shaping memory, the components of the perception of the homeland cannot be opposed to one another," Melkonyan said.

Unnamed sources claim Armenia and Azerbaijan close signing new agreement

Oct 25 2021
 

Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Russia are reportedly close to signing a new agreement on the demarcation and delimitation of borders and the opening of transport links. According to Russian and Armenian news outlets, the agreement is set to be announced on the anniversary of the Russia-brokered ceasefire.

Russian state-run RIA Novosti wrote on Saturday that the trilateral meeting will be held in the first ten days of November. According to an unnamed source ‘familiar with the matter’, at this meeting, Russia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan will sign a new agreement.

On 22 October, Armenian news outlet Aliq Media, citing unnamed ‘reliable diplomatic sources’ reported that the three countries will sign two new documents in early November.  

The first will concern border delimitation and demarcation between Armenia and Azerbaijan, according to which ‘Yerevan and Baku will recognise each other's borders and territorial integrity, based on the maps of the General Staff of the Soviet Defense Ministry of the 1920s’. 

[Read more: Border crisis between Armenia and Azerbaijan continues]

The second will reportedly secure an opening of transport links between Armenia and Azerbaijan, specifically, allowing for a transport link between Azerbaijan’s western regions and Nakhchivan through southern Armenia, as well as giving Armenia a connection to Iran and Russia through Azerbaijan. 

The possibility of a transport connection between Nakhchivan and Azerbaijan’s western regions has been a point of contention between Armenia and Azerbaijan in recent months, with Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev demanding a ‘corridor’, which he also threatened to establish by military force. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has previously denied that such a transport connection would constitute a ‘corridor’.

[Read more: Aliyev threatens to establish 'corridor' in Armenia by force]

No official confirmation of any of these claims has yet been forthcoming from any of the three countries. However, speaking with RIA Novosti, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that if an agreement on a trilateral meeting is reached ‘the Kremlin will report on it in due time’. 

Earlier this autumn, both Pashinyan and Aliyev made comments stating that they were ready to meet.

On 22 October,  Armenia and Russia started joint military exercises in the province of Syunik, near the border with Azerbaijan.  The exercises have the participation of ‘almost all military units’ of the Armenian armed forces as well as Russian forces from the 102nd military base in Gyumri. 

According to Tigran Parvanyan, the commander of joint Russian-Armenian forces, the exercises are part of an annual plan of military cooperation between Russia and Armenia.