UCLA: Armenian Genocide Reveals Lessons for Today

The Daily Bruin
April 21, 2004

Armenian Genocide Reveals Lessons for Today
By Garin Hovannisian
Daily Bruin Columnist
[email protected]

On April 24, Armenians around the world will commemorate the darkest
period in their history. Through organized deportations and massacres
of 1.5 million people, over half of the Armenian population was
forcibly removed from its home of 3,000 years.

The crimes began on April 24, 1915 and were continued by successive
Turkish governments until 1923, when the ethnic cleansing of Armenians
in the region was virtually complete.

Today, the Armenian Student Association will join in the commemoration
of these crimes with a silent march across the campus to Bruin
Plaza. There, the group will open an hour-long ceremony, including
poetry, music, recitations and addresses to spread awareness of the
first genocide of the 20th century.

For most participants, the day will be filled with memories of
ancestors and relatives who either died or miraculously survived but
remained scarred for life. Yet the dominant emotion will be a deep
resentment toward the Turkish government and others that continue to
deny the reality of the Armenian Genocide.

The commemoration today and this column are not meant to garner pity
for the suffering of the Armenian people. Even the most sinister of
historic tragedies lose much of their poignancy and impact over
time. What is crucial is that people understand the magnitude and
historic legacy of this precedent-setting event – especially when
their own government does not.

Like most cases of deliberate violence against members of a society,
the Armenian Genocide was executed by the government itself.

On April 24, 1915, several hundred Armenian civic leaders and
intellectuals were arrested in Istanbul, and subsequently exiled and
murdered. While the world was preoccupied with the Great War, the
so-called Young Turk government created its own blueprint of genocide.
First, the young men were drafted and placed into unarmed labor
battalions, where most would be killed. Then, the populations of all
Armenian towns and villages were forced to relinquish any weapons in
brutal arms searches. After the religious and political leaders had
been led away to meet a bloody end, the remaining population – largely
women and children – were placed in caravans of death leading to the
desert wasteland of inner Syria. En route, the caravans practically
melted away under the scorching sun. As women were raped and
tormented, children were kidnapped and forcibly converted as the
elderly died of starvation and dehydration.

The relatively few people who somehow made it to the final
destination, the desert of Deir-el-Zor, were murdered there or burned
alive in their cave-shelters.

In the end, the Armenian nation lost its homeland to a xenophobic
regime that used genocide to achieve its vision of a new regional
order based on one people, one religion, one language and one
identity.

To this day, the Turkish government denies an Armenian Genocide ever
happened. Other governments, including the United States, are
complicit in the cover-up for economic, political and military
reasons. These deniers dismiss a historic happening that stripped an
entire people of its rights, properties and homeland.

They fail to acknowledge the need to face history and engage in acts
of redemption that may lead to reconciliation, or at least
conciliation. They spurn the eminent importance of truth.

What does this mean for you and me in the contemporary world? It means
mass murder has been carried out without repercussions. It means that
even now, our right to life – the most basic of rights – is vulnerable
and should never be taken for granted.

The events of 1915 are not antiquated occurrences of a bygone
era. They were repeated throughout the 20th century by Hitler, by the
Khmer Rouge to the Cambodian people, and through slaughters in Burundi
and Rwanda, among others. The 20th century began and ended with
genocide. All of these mass killings shared important aspects in a
historic pattern scholars and human rights activists are trying to
decode and prevent.

The passionate commitment of individuals and the integrity of
governments is required. Only through recognition can this history be
understood and made meaningful to prevent future crimes against
humanity.

Recognizing, understanding and learning from the Armenian Genocide is
not an end in itself. It is only a means through which we can craft a
free, just and prosperous new century.

On April 24, take a moment to remember the lost Armenians — if not
for the memory of their lives, then for the longevity of our own.

Hovannisian is a first-year history and philosophy student. E-mail him at
[email protected]. Send general comments to
[email protected].

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Beirut: Students unite to remember the 20th century’s first genocide

Daily Star, Lebanon
April 24 2004

Students unite to remember the 20th century’s first genocide
Armenian groups mount program to shine light on Atrocity

By Kaelen Wilson-Goldie
Daily Star staff

On April 24, 1915, the Turkish government placed some 200 Armenian
community leaders under arrest in what was known at the time as the
city of Constantinople. According to the Armenian National Institute,
many arrests would follow, as would many forced expulsions and
summary executions.

Eighty-nine years later, Armenians all over the world solemnly
commemorate April 24 as the start of the Armenian genocide, when the
Young Turks killed 1.5 million Armenians. By 1923, the Turks had
succeeded in pushing the rest of the community out of eastern Turkey.

It is a tragedy that has, for decades, fought for the most basic
reaction – the simple act of recognition.

The Armenian genocide is considered the first such atrocity of the
20th century, but since it occurred a good 30 years before the UN
Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide, getting the
event acknowledged as such has been difficult. Such countries as
Lebanon, France, Greece, Cyprus, Russia, and Argentina have
recognized the genocide, while Turkey has steadfastly refused. As a
result, the commemorations on April 24 tend to carry an activist
cast, part of a longstanding effort to force Turkey’s hand in coming
clean about its history.

This year, for the first time, students from five major Lebanese
universities have joined forces to assemble a two-week program of
events marking April 24. “The Armenian Genocide: 89 Years of Unfolded
Truth” started last week and continues through April 30. It includes
an intelligent mix, from photography exhibitions and slide
projections to academic lectures and several film screenings.

The centerpiece of the program is Atom Egoyan’s critically acclaimed
feature film “Ararat,” which will be shown at the American University
of Beirut (AUB) on Monday and at the Saint Joseph University (USJ) on
Friday.

“‘Ararat’ is very modern,” says Aram Kradjian, a 21-year-old student
at AUB who heads up the Lebanese-Armenian Heritage Club. “It’s not a
typical black-and-white documentary. Going to see it is like going to
the movies normally.”

As such, Kradjian hopes to attract a wider audience to the screenings
than that which might otherwise attend. But balancing the popular
appeal of going to the movies is the academic specificity of
attending a lecture at AUB on Wednesday by philosopher Henry
Theriault.

A professor at Worcester State College in western Massachusetts and
the coordinator of the Center for Human Rights there, Theriault will
deliver a talk on social theory and the denial of genocide. He has
long studied the after effects of genocides, especially on diaspora
populations and in the Armenian case.

The Lebanese-Armenian Heritage Club invited Theriault specifically,
but his lecture fits in well with the week’s events. All told, the
student-run commemoration took almost three months to coordinate. “It
was a big achievement,” says Kradjian. “There are so many different
political parties that Armenians living in Lebanon belong to. Getting
five clubs together is a big deal. And from every club, there are
three representatives who all have different opinions.”

Still, students from AUB, USJ, Haigazian University, Notre Dame
University (NDU), and the Lebanese American University (LAU) managed
to find common ground.

Because AUB has a fairly established network of student clubs and a
method for allocating resources to them, the Lebanese-Armenian
Heritage Club was able to finance about three-quarters of the budget.
NDU, by contrast, established its Armenian Student Association only
quite recently, while LAU just has a loose federation of Armenian
students. Still, the groups pooled their resources and came up with a
diverse program. They also put a strong effort into public relations,
printing 15,000 copies of their well-designed brochures and stickers
and distributing them both through official university channels as
well as by hand.

“Each university has its program and its budget,” says Armig
Vartanian, 20, a law student at USJ who serves as secretary of the
school’s Armenian student association. “Each year when we do this,
students ask about the case. Some students are still indifferent. But
all the clubs help each other out.”

Vartanain points to the strength of the BBC documentary, “Armenia –
The Betrayed,” as a particular highlight of this year’s commemoration
and as an effective means of bringing contemporary relevance to the
nearly 90-year-old tragedy. “That the BBC has given its time to this
issue means a lot to us. Sometimes people say that it has been a long
time, and Turkey still denies it. But this documentary proves” that
the issue still matters.

“Armenia – The Betrayed” first screened on the BBC last January.
Correspondent Fergal Keane looks at how relations between the US and
Turkey, especially in the lead-up to the war in Iraq, have
politicized the issue of recognizing the Armenian genocide. Turkey
has always maintained that the Armenian population that was killed
between 1915 and 1923 died in the context of a civil war and not a
genocide.

But the documentary gives an eye-opening account of both historical
documents supporting systematic extermination as well as insight into
current events, in which Presidents Clinton and Bush were both
apparently pressured to withdraw bills from Congress seeking to
recognize the Armenian genocide because the US did not want to
disrupt diplomatic relations with Turkey at critical moments.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Glendale: Cable shows debate merits of Americana

Glendale News Press
LATimes.com
April 24 2004

Cable shows debate merits of Americana

Armenian-language TV hosts said to be claiming project will drive
Armenians out of Glendale.

By Josh Kleinbaum, News-Press

GLENDALE – Viewers of local Armenian-language television programs
said that several hosts, including Vrej Agajanian of ABC TV Live,
have argued that the proposed Americana at Brand development will
drive Armenian Americans out of Glendale and will not provide jobs
for them.

Agajanian denied bringing the ethnicity issue into the Americana
debate.

“On my program, people were raising that,” Agajanian said. “On the
program, it’s a call-in show. Those were the people who were saying
that.”

Viewers said Agajanian told his audience that the project will drive
up land values in southern Glendale, raising rents and forcing
Armenian Americans to leave the city.

Agajanian said his criticism of the Americana focuses on the harm to
existing business owners.

“I’m hearing from small businesses that they’re worried,” Agajanian
said. “I’m very close to people, and they convey their message to me.
They are worried.”

The project’s proponents, including City Councilmen Rafi Manoukian
and Bob Yousefian – both of whom are Armenian American – called the
ethnicity argument nothing more than fear tactics.

“I had heard this thing,” Yousefian said. “He said, ‘If they’re going
to be charging so much rent, isn’t it going to be pushing up rents in
all of Glendale?’ No, it’s not. Just because high luxury items and
houses are selling for several million dollars, that doesn’t mean a
house built in the ’20s is going to sell for the same price.”

At a March 30 City Council meeting, developer Rick Caruso questioned
Agajanian’s objectivity, claiming that Agajanian said he could
deliver the Armenian vote if Caruso put him on his payroll.

“I told him, you have to change the project,” Agajanian said at the
time. “I’m willing to help you change the project to work. We didn’t
discuss payment or money. Now, it becomes a personal matter. I will
fight.”

The council on Tuesday approved the business terms and environmental
impact report for the 15.5-acre commercial and residential campus in
downtown Glendale. It will vote Tuesday on necessary zoning changes
to allow for the residential component.

Caruso disputed the claim that the project will drive Armenian
Americans out of Glendale, saying that his project adds 338 housing
units to the city.

“The value of rental units is dependent on supply and demand,” Caruso
said. “What we’re doing, we’re adding more units to the market. If
anything, we’re creating more opportunities for people to live in
Glendale, not less.

“Wouldn’t it be great if the land values do rise, and everybody in
Glendale who owns homes, including the Armenian community, benefits
from this project? And that will happen. That doesn’t mean people are
going to be driven out of town. People are going to be wealthier.”

Agajanian’s show appears on Charter Communications Channel 26 at 10
a.m. Sundays.

Armenian lights star to honor slain family

El Paso Times, TX
April 24 2004

Armenian lights star to honor slain family

Darren Meritz
El Paso Times

Linda Stelter / El Paso Times

Photo: Greg Yakoobian has extensively studied the history of Armenia
and the killings in 1915 of some of his mother’s family. He has
lighted the Star on the Franklin Mountains in their memory and the
others killed. The family picture shows his mother Rose, right, with
her mother and father and her sisters.

A century-old dispute between the Turks and the Armenians is bringing
some attention to El Paso’s Star on the Franklin Mountains.

Though only small populations of either ethnicity live here, El
Pasoan Gregory Yakoobian has sponsored lighting the Star on the
Franklin Mountain today in remembrance of the Armenians who were
killed at the hand of the Ottoman Empire during World War I.

Yakoobian, who spent 20 years in the U.S. military, contends that the
Turks killed as many as 1.5 million Armenians during ethnic cleansing
in what some have called the first Holocaust.

Though questions abound about the accuracy of describing the deaths
of Armenians in the then Ottoman Empire as a genocide, Yakoobian
stands firm.

“My parents were there, and their parents and other relatives were
killed,” he said. “My father did not like to talk about the subject
at all. It was almost like post-traumatic stress disorder.”

He recounted the oral history that has been passed down through his
family. He said that Armenian women during that time were often given
three choices — convert to Islam, be sold into slavery or be killed
— and that men were summarily executed during a march of the
displaced.

Other perspectives on treatment of Armenians by the Ottoman Empire
are also widely believed.

Emriye Ormanci, vice consul at the Consulate General of Turkey in
Houston, said that while few clues point toward ethnic cleansing or
genocide of the Armenians during World War I, the Turks made the
decision to displace the Armenians because of their allegiance to the
Russians.

“Feelings are on the one hand, but the truth is something really
different,” she said. “Yes, the Ottoman Empire had to make some
regulations to change the place of the Armenian population because
they were sided with the Russians, but of course you should also take
into consideration that it was a time of war.”

She also said, “We admit that there was loss on the Armenian side and
we are really sorry, but they should also understand that there was
loss on the Turkish side. This is something that should be left to
the historians.”

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.borderlandnews.com/stories/borderland/20040424-109648.shtml

Canada: Liberal Party workers worry about pink Paul

The Globe and Mail, Canada
April 24 2004

Liberal Party workers worry about pink Paul

By JANE TABER

Prime Minister Paul Martin’s team, in an effort to showcase the new
leader, has put his picture on their campaign lawn signs, causing
concern among some party workers who say his face is too “pink” and
he looks like he’s had a “rough night.”

There is worry, too, that political opponents will take marker pens
to deface his image, drawing horns on his head or adding funny
glasses. Putting a candidate’s face on signs breaks a cardinal rule
of political sign design. This, according to the party’s own campaign
manual: “Don’t use a slogan ever. Don’t use a photograph of the
candidate.” A campaign worker, who attended last weekend’s event,
said participants were told that if they are concerned about the
pinkness they may opt to include black in the sign, which will
apparently mute the pink in the PM’s face.

Scrumming on

the campaign plane

In leasing their campaign plane, members of Mr. Martin’s team had
some specific requests. First, they wanted a plane with “integrated
air stairs.”

This is a plane with its own stairs. It does not have to dock against
an airport bridge or have stairs wheeled out from the tarmac. It
allows the Liberals to land anywhere in the country. The Liberals,
sources say, have leased a three-engine 727.

Team Martin’s other request was that the plane be configured to allow
a “scrum area” for the press. This will make the optics much better.

Gone will be the inside-the-airplane shots of the Prime Minister
crouching to avoid the overhead bins or leaning over seats.

The Conservatives, who have leased an A319 Airbus, are also
configuring a scrum area.

Elsie Wayne:

‘I am not a bitch.’

After the Prime Minister accused the opposition this week of baying
“like hounds in heat” during a particularly passionate exchange over
the awarding of government contracts, Conservative New Brunswick MP
Elsie Wayne took offence: “Mr. Speaker, during Question Period the
Prime Minister referred to some female members of this chamber as
baying like hounds in heat. I do not bay like a hound. A baying hound
is a bitch, and I am not a bitch.” Mrs. Wayne is not running in the
next election.

Lama-mania

The Dalai Lama was treated like a rock star when he came to
Parliament Hill Thursday. Here is a breathless e-mail sent around by
an MP’s staffer to all Hill staff: “I had an incredible opportunity
to meet the Dalai Lama outside of Room 160-S and I was just wondering
to all those who were there with a camera if anyone would have
happened to catch that experience on film? I was wearing a black
dress, black shoes and I had a big yellow flower in my hair. If
anyone would happen to have a picture with me in it, would I please
be able to get a copy? (I don’t mind paying for it.)”

Hot and not

Hot: Commons deputy Speaker Bob Kilger. The Liberal MP from Cornwall
replaced his speaker’s robes with a Maple Leafs jersey this week to
watch his son Chad score the first goal and then an assist in the
Leafs’ romp against the Ottawa Senators.

Not: Treasury Board President Reg Alcock. Once the great defender in
Question Period of Paul Martin and Liberal ethics, Mr. Alcock appears
to have been sidelined — coincidentally just after admitting he
mistakenly said the sponsorship scandal only cost $13-million.
Finance Minister Ralph Goodale and Public Works Minister Stephen Owen
are doing the talking. And opposition MPs are now making fun of Mr.
Alcock, referring to him as a “wookie,” which is the tall, hairy
creature from Star Wars.

Hot: Conservative Leader Stephen Harper. Prime Minister Martin can’t
stop talking about him and his so-called scary right-wing policies.
What is he worried about?

Hot: Scarborough Liberal MP Jim Karygiannis for his persistence in
lobbying on behalf of Armenian Canadians. This week MPs recognized as
genocide the mass killing of Armenians during the First World War.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

US citizen detained in Yerevan, accused of subversive actions

ITAR-TASS, Russia
April 24 2004

US citizen detained in Yerevan, accused of subversive actions

YEREVAN, April 24 (Itar-Tass) — The Armenian Prosecutor General’s
Office has questioned and detained a former resident of Yerevan,
currently U.S. citizen Artur Vartanian, who `took an active part in
opposition rallies in Yerevan and actions aimed at the forcible
seizure of power,’ the Prosecutor-General’s Office public relations
office chief Gurgen Ambarian has said.

According to the Prosecutor General’s Office the investigators have
found that Artur Vartanian has been permanently resident in the
United States since 1991 and has had U.S. citizenship since 2002.

Although he is a citizen of a different country, Vartanian retained
his Armenian passport and used the rights of an Armenian citizen and
repeatedly crossed Armenia’s state border and participated in
political and electoral processes.

His latest arrival was registered on April 11. Vartanian has since
participated in opposition rallies and actions aimed at the forcible
seizure of power.

Last Thursday Vartanian was detained and charged under two articles
of the criminal code – actions aimed at the forcible seizure of power
and illegal crossing of the state border.

The Armenian Prosecutor-General’s Office has briefed the Foreign
Ministry on the incident. Under the Constitution Armenian citizens
cannot have the citizenship of another country.

`The investigation department of the Prosecutor-General’s Office is
continuing a preliminary probe into the criminal case opened over the
instances of public calls and actions aimed at changing the
constitutional and state system and also public insults against the
authorities,’ the Prosecutor-General’s Office said.

There has been no response from the U.S. embassy to the arrest of
Vartanian yet.

The Opposition says the police has searched the flat of Vartanian’s
friend in Yerevan where the man was staying as a guest.

Nothing illegal was found.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenia’s head to visit France’s Chirac

Washington Times, DC
April 24 2004

Armenia’s head to visit France’s Chirac

Yerevan, , Apr. 24 (UPI) — The president of Armenia was to travel
Sunday to France for a meeting with French president Jacques Chirac,
the Itar-Tass news agency reported Saturday.

President Robert Kocharyan will reportedly be discussing efforts to
settle the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

France is a co-chairman of the OSCE Minsk Group on Nagorno-Karabakh,
along with Russia and the United States.

On April 27, Kocharyan and his delegation will leave Paris for Warsaw
to attend the World Economic Forum. He will take part in a working
meeting on the Caucasus and meet with the Forum’s President Klaus
Schwab.

Kocharyan also will meet with the Polish and Georgian presidents,
Alexander Kwasniewski and Mikhail Saakashvili.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenias president Robert Kocharyan to visit France

ITAR-TASS, Russia
April 24 2004

Armenia’s president Robert Kocharyan to visit France

YEREVAN, April 24 (Itar-Tass) – President Robert Kocharyan of Armenia
will head for France on a working visit on Sunday. He plans to meet
his French counterpart Jacques Chirac on Monday, the presidential
press service reported on Saturday.

One of the key topics of the talks will be the settlement of the
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. France is a co-chairman of the OSCE Minsk
Group on Nagorno-Karabakh alongside with Russia and the USA and takes
an active part in the conflict’s settlement.

During the talks the presidents will also discus bilateral political
dialogue and economic cooperation.

On Sunday evening, Kocharyan and his wife will attend a concert by
Charles Aznavur at the Paris Palace of Congresses that will be
devoted to the 80th birthday of the prominent French singer and
songwriter of Armenian descent.

The Armenian president also plans to meet the head of the French
company `Bouig’ Olivier Bouig.

On April 27, Kocharyan and his delegation will leave Paris for Warsaw
to attend the World Economic Forum. He will take part in a working
meeting on the Caucasus and meet with the Forum’s President Klaus
Schwab. Within the framework of the Forum Kocharyan will meet with
the Polish and Georgian presidents, Alexander Kwasniewski and Mikhail
Saakashvili.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Kocharian’s address on Genocide victims’ remembrance day

ArmenPress
April 24 2004

PRESIDENT KOCHARIAN’S ADDRESS ON GENOCIDE VICTIMS’ REMEMBRANCE DAY

YEREVAN, APRIL 24, ARMENPRESS: Dear compatriots, today we remember
the victims of the Armenian Genocide. An entire nation with its
thousands-years-old civilization, culture and material heritage was
wiped out under the Ottoman Empire’s state program and with the use
of state institutions. Bowing our heads before the memory of millions
of innocent victims, we as a nation reiterate our determination to
achieve full and unequivocal international recognition and
condemnation of this crime against humanity.
Unpunished crimes can lead to new similar crimes. The
international community has to do everything it can to prevent such a
crime from ever happening again in any part of the world.
Like every year on April 24, today we reiterate our will to stand
above rancor and revengefulness. We are prepared to establish normal
relations with all the countries of the region, including Turkey.
Our efforts are aimed at lasting peace, stability and cooperation
in the region. To this end, we are prepared to assume an active and
constructive role. Today we are building a new, peaceful, secure and
prosperous fatherland. To build such a fatherland, we look to the
future.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Not our place to pronounce

The Gazette (Montreal, Quebec)
April 24, 2004 Saturday Final Edition

Not our place to pronounce

Tragedy is a cheater word, usually deployed to evade a charge of
guilt while recognizing the deplorable character of an event or
situation. What happened to the Armenians in 1915 was a tragedy and
more. Few independent historians disagree with this. The body count
runs as high as 1.5 million.

But must the Parliament of Canada pronounce on the subject, as they
did Wednesday? Do the votes of MPs who know nothing of the history of
Asia Minor really matter?

There is a place for parliamentary resolutions on current affairs
abroad and even on historical affairs at home. It was natural for
Japanese Canadians to seek moral and monetary redress for their
incarceration during the Second World War. Louis Riel remains a
perennial object of newspaper copy parliamentary attention. He was,
after all, a Canadian.

On the subject of the Armenian genocide, however, we believe our
lawmakers have the right, and perhaps the obligation, to remain
silent. As hideous as this episode was, it was not unique in the
annals of human conflict. If Parliament speaks on this issue, why
should it remain silent on others?

It is obvious that Armenian Canadians care deeply about their past.
Turks are no less passionate. This is an excellent reason for
Parliament to keep its distance from this and all such debates.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress