Book Review: Counting the cost of the Ottomans: Saul David on a brilliant travelogue through eleven countries that were once part of the Ottoman empire

The Daily Telegraph (London)
November 3, 2018 Saturday
Counting the cost of the Ottomans
BOOKS REVIEWS:  Saul David on a brilliant travelogue through eleven countries that were once part of the Ottoman empire
 
by Saul Davidon
  
OTTOMAN ODYSSEY
by Alev Scott
320pp,
Riverrun, £20, ebook £13.99
The First World War did for the Ottoman Empire – as it did for so many others – and in 1923, Ataturk's Republic of Turkey rose from its ashes. Almost a century on, President Erdogan is trying to reassume the Ottomans' role as leader of the Middle East, which seems as good a time as any for Alev Scott to ask: what was the legacy of Ottoman rule for the people of the Balkans, the Caucasus and the Levant? And what impact is that having on the political and social make-up of this troubled region? To answer these questions, the Anglo-Turkish Scott – recently banned from returning to her Istanbul home for writing articles critical of Erdogan – goes on her own odyssey through 11 countries of the former empire. Among her interviewees are descendants of ancient minorities that flourished in the empire, but have since been intimidated, or even expelled; and those who live far from Turkey but who identify as "Ottoman in some vague but visceral sense, encouraged by the current Turkish government's attempts to resurrect regional influence".
 
Along the way, Scott quizzes them – and herself – about difficult subjects such as "forced migration, genocide, exile, diaspora, collective memory and identity, not just about religious coexistence". One of the most moving sections of this beautifully written book – which combines history, travel writing and personal discovery – is when Scott, an avowed Turkophile, visits Yerevan's Genocide Museum in Armenia, set up in memory of the million or so Armenians killed by the Turks in 1915. As a child, Scott "absorbed a certain suspicion that the West had used the genocide unfairly as a stick with which to beat Turkey for the crimes of their Ottoman predecessors". The trip to the museum changes everything. "There was," she writes, "so much proof, too much proof that a genocide had taken place."
 
Comparing the relationship between Turkey and Armenia with that of Israel and Palestine – "historical claims to land, displaced people, religious partisanship, genocide recognition and beleaguered diplomacy" – she worries that countries that fail to acknowledge their dark past are in danger of repeating their crimes. The solution, she feels, is for Turkey to take a leaf out of Spain and Portugal's book – both have offered citizenship to Sephardic Jews to atone for the Inquisition – and offer residency to all Armenians.
 
Scott is similarly clear-eyed about the forced migration of millions of Greek-born Muslims to Turkey and the reciprocal dispatch of Ottoman Christians to Greece, as per the terms of the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne. Despite their religion, many spoke only their national language – Turkish in the case of the former group, Greek for the latter – and were understandably traumatised by the upheaval.
 
But there has been the odd silver lining. Modern ethnically cleansed Turkey – and Greece for that matter – is less susceptible to the sort of internecine strife that is tearing Syria apart. Scott thinks it is no coincidence that the residents of Lesbos – about 60 per cent of whom are descended from Christians deported from Turkey – have shown great generosity to the thousands of Syrian refugees who have descended on their shores.
 
Visiting Jerusalem, she notes the alarming statistic that, in 1917, in the last days of Ottoman control, "Arabs made up 90 per cent of the population of Palestine". Today they comprise just 20 per cent of the state of the Israel, a huge population shift that was set in motion by the Balfour Declaration, the British government's statement of support for a Jewish homeland in Palestine in November 1917. Before that, notes Scott, there was a lot of social interaction between Jewish and Muslim families. Not any more.
 
In Lebanon, Scott meets the former Druze warlord Walid Jumblatt, who asks: "Who is not bloody and ruthless in Lebanon? We are all ruthless; everybody is a warlord!" For all his bluster, Scott detects a Macbeth-like figure: "ambitious and ruthless", but also "horrified by the inevitability of conflict – and perhaps by his own part in it". Keen to understand more about the Druze, a "pacifist, puritanical faith" that believes in reincarnation and gives Plato and Pythagoras's teachings "equal weight to those of the Abrahamic prophets", Scott meets two spiritual leaders, sheikhs Saleh and Majed.
 
The first tells her that she, a non-Druze, is damned because of her choices "over the past hundreds of millions of years". The second insists his faith is gender-blind, yet refuses to have his picture taken with her (he has no problem posing for one with her male colleague).
 
Scott's writing is lyrical.
 
Jerusalem is "pockmarked by conflict and heavy with tension", its air "laced with a mix of winter street food: roasted chestnuts, Turkish coffee and frying meat, overlaid with the occasional waft of cheap frankincense". This book is only her second, yet she writes with a maturity and insight that belies her age, and is surely a rising star of the literary world. Her overall message is one of optimism: that identity is as much about language as it is about location and religion; and that a "shared culture" will trump jingoistic national differences. I hope she's right.
 
Call 0844 871 1514 to order a copy from the Telegraph for £16.99
 
Almost a century on, Erdogan is trying to make Turkey leader of the Middle East again

UNICEF Representative in Armenia: Actions aimed at reducing poverty have possibly been taken over the past 10 years but obviously they were not enough

Arminfo, Armenia
Oct 31 2018
UNICEF Representative in Armenia: Actions aimed at reducing poverty have possibly been taken over the past 10 years but obviously they were not enough

Yerevan October 31

Naira Badalian. UN Resident Coordinator in Armenia Shombi Sharp welcomes policy of the new government of Armenia, which focuses on a person. Sharp said this on the sidelines of the three-day conference on the "Role of social protection in the sustainable development agenda: leaving no one behind in Armenia'' that started on November 31.

According to the UN representative, today more than 1 mln people in Armenia live in poverty, 2% of them are extremely poor. Despite a number of events, over the past 10 years the republic has failed to solve the problem of the poverty of the country's population. At this stage, according to Sharp, the Cabinet of Ministers of the country, aimed at protecting the interests of all its citizens, will be able to fulfill the task if it primarily makes social support more targeted.

As UNICEF representative in Armenia Tanja Radocaj pointed out, perhaps over the past 10 years, steps have been taken to reduce poverty, but they were obviously not enough. One third of children in Armenia live below the poverty line, and in the Shirak region more than half. This, she said, is fraught with negative consequences for the future development of the country. Today, without paying due attention to this potential, the country is undermining its long-term economic development. To this end, according to Radocaj, the organization, in close cooperation with the Armenian government, is looking for more effective ways to overcome poverty. One way is to ensure access and quality education for children. "From time to time we face a shortage of quality education in rural areas of Armenia. Thus, we consider the possibility of obtaining quality education and relevant skills as one of the most efficient methods in improving the well-being of the population in the future," she said.

Sylvie Bossoutrot, Country Manager of the World Bank in Armenia, in turn, believes that social security can protect citizens from external negative shocks. And poverty and unemployment also lead to lower fertility rates. As a result, Armenia, like many developing countries, will face the problem of an aging population in the future.

To note, the level of poverty in Armenia in the conditions of last year's economic growth of 7.5% and with 220 thousand unemployed people makes up more than 30% of the population. At the same time, Acting Minister of Labor and Social Affairs Mane Tandilyan answering the question of ArmInfo stated that Armenia aims to reduce poverty by 0.5% or more annually. Today, Mane Tandilyan believes that the social protection system needs to be revised, first of all, to improve the targeting of financial support from the state.

According to the latest official statistics, the poverty rate in Armenia in 2015 was 29.8%, which is 0.2% less than in 2014. The total number of poor people in Armenia was 900 thousand people, 310 thousand of which are very poor, and extremely poor – 60 thousand people. In 2015, about 19.4% of the country's population were classified as poor, 8.4% were very poor and 2% were extremely poor. At the same time, according to statistical data, at the end of June 2018, unemployment in Armenia, calculated using the new method that does not take into account those employed in the household, was 20.6%, having decreased by 1.2% in y-o-y terms. According to the forecasts of the World Bank, the unemployment rate in Armenia in 2018 will be 18.1%. The World Bank predicts that the poverty level (with a purchasing power parity (PPP) of $ 5.5) may reach 38.2% in 2018, with a decline to 36.8% in 2019, while the PPP calculation of $ 3.2 may reduce the poverty level in 2018-2019 from 10.1% to 9.1%.

Panorama: Art that brings joy: Harutyun Chalikyan’s exhibition of caricatures and sculptures is on at Artists’ Union

16:36 29/10/2018

Personal exhibition of Harutyun Chalikyan’s artworks opened on Oct. 27 in Artists’ Union, Yerevan. It features Chalikyan’s caricatures, medals and sculptures of famous personalities from Armenia and all over the world. The exhibition will be on till 01 Nov.

Charles Aznavour, Serzh Tankian, Vladimir Putin, Pope Francis, Angela Merkel, Theresa May, Ohan Duryan, Kirk Kerkorian, Egishe Charents, Sos Sargsyan and many others have found themselves in one cool company! What unites all of them is that they embody a new art style by Harutyun Chalikyan which he calls Sculpture-Caricatures or Caricature-Medals – a unique combination of caricature and sculpture art. Combining humour and art, Harutyun’s works give the emotion of joy – you can see smiles on the faces of all the visitors.   

At the exhibition the presidents of Artists’ Union, Caricaturists’ Union and the Union of Architects congratulated Harutyun with their opening speeches. The president of Caricaturists’ Union awarded him with the title of Honoured Knight of Caricature. 

“My caricatures do not aim to mock or ridicule; they show the character and inner essence of the person. That’s why I often refer to them as psychological portraits”, – says the author. So if you want to learn more about someone just ask Harutyun to draw them – it actually takes him only 10 minutes to draw a masterpiece!

“You can recognize Harutyun’s works at first glance by his unique graphic style. And in his sculptures you can see his strive to show the moral beauty of the person”, – says Vladimir Abroyan, honoured artist of Armenia.

Harutyun Chalikyan is a renowned Armenian artist and architect well-known for his brilliant caricatures of politicians, artists and celebrities of various nationalities. He draws with charcoal and has a graphic technique that differentiates him from other artists of this genre.

In cooperation with the Gold Factory of Armenia Harutyun Chalikyan created two collections of gold medals in 2017 – those of Presidents of the Big Eight and those of famous football players. Both collections were presented in an international forum in Germany in 2017, also in Russia and in other countries. 

Harutyun’s artworks have been presented in Paris, New York, Moscow, Cambridge, Yerevan and elsewhere. He is the recipient of international awards in art and caricature. A man of many talents, he also writes humoristic and witty poems.

Harutyun Chalikyan has published a collection of his artworks in a book “Graphics and Sculpture”. He lives and works in Armenia, with his works having an international outreach.

When asked what gives him inspiration in creating art he said briefly and sincerely, “My wife”.

  
Photos are taken from Harutyun Chalikyan’s Facebook page.
 

 

Source Panorama.am

A unique exhibition of world modern art held in "Hay Art" Museum of Contemporary Art renovated by Italians

Arminfo, Armenia
Oct 20 2018
A unique exhibition of world modern art held in "Hay Art" Museum of Contemporary Art renovated by Italians

Yerevan October 19

Ani Mshetsyan. The "HayArt" Museum of Contemporary Art in Yerevan hosts an exhibition of works by eight dozen authors of paintings and installations, representing 26 different countries of the world. It became possible to open the round halls of the museum unique in their architecture for the unique exhibition only thanks to the renovation of the museum at the initiative of the Italian Embassy in Armenia.

As Rita Sharoyan, director of HayArt Cultural Center told ArmInfo in an interview, the Italian Ambassador to Armenia visited the museum with a working group of specialists during the preparatory work for the opening of the exhibition of works by famous European authors of modernity. ''They studied the state of the exhibition halls of various museums in Yerevan in order to organize this exhibition. In general, many guests from Europe highly appreciate the architecture of our building and they really liked the design of the building, but, unfortunately, it was in a rather poor condition, "Sharoyan said.

The Director emphasized that the embassy representatives still felt that the HayArt museum's capabilities were the most optimal for the fulfillment of their ideas, but the lack of repair was a serious hindrance. "We stated that we were ready to discuss the issue of renvation. Head of the EU delegation in Armenia, Ambassador Piotr Switalski was also very interested in this issue, who had also visited the building of our museum. Various proposals were made to us, the exhibition organizers proposed to repair the museum free of charge if we agreed to provide exhibition halls for the exhibition, and we happily agreed, because it was a great achievement for us, because our museum would have acquired its original appearance again, " Sharoyan said. She stressed that the repair work, in which Italian specialists and even volunteers were involved, gave an amazing result. The exhibition of world modernists opened on September 28 and will last exactly one month, until October 25. Admission is free for everyone. Artworks, installations, short films "without end and beginning", and sculptural works are presented as exhibits. All the interior of the museum is a the synthesis of movement, sounds and colors.

To note, the "Hay Art" cultural center is the first Soviet Museum of Contemporary Art in Yerevan, founded in 1972 by famous art critic and public figure Henrich Igityan. A modernist-style building was erected – an ensemble of several round rooms located above the ground – the so-called "kruglyashek" was allocated for the museum on the main avenue of Yerevan, Then in 1987, the museum was allocated the area of the first floor of a new residential building, built across the street due to too many storage rooms. In 1997, the Museum of Contemporary Art for some reason left its unique architectural building of concrete circles and moved to the first floor of a new building that does not even have an entrance to the street. Thanks to the heads of the mayor's office a unique architectural ensemble of the first museum was fully used by commercial stalls and facilities. For many years, being on the balance of the mayor's office, the museum was completely abandoned, plaster collapsed in its halls, mountains of garbage lay, it was completely unsuitable for organizing exhibitions. For 2 decades, not a penny was allocated for its restoration. Only in one of the halls, in a completely unattractive atmosphere, some exhibitions of Armenian artists were periodically organized under the special patronage of the mayor's office of the capital. One of the latest exhibits was dedicated to the works of the famous Armenian artist Eduard Isabekyan. According to the testimony of museum workers who are not provable, Isabekyan's son Rector of the Academy of Arts Aram Isabekyan gifted the former mayor of Yerevan Taron Margaryan with one of his father's works to organize the exhibition.

Azerbaijani ceasefire violation incidents decrease, says Artsakh

Categories
Artsakh
Official
Region

Azerbaijani forces committed more than 100 individual ceasefire violations in the period from October 7 to October 13 in the Artsakh line of contact.

The defense ministry of Artsakh said that Azerbaijani troops fired approximately 1000 rounds from various caliber small arms at their military positions.

The ministry said that Artsakh’s military refrained from taking countermeasers and confidently continued service.

From September 30 to October 6 Azerbaijani forces had made nearly 150 individual ceasefire violations.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Armenians and Progressive Politics to Host David Barsamian

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:

Armenians and Progressive Politics to Host David Barsamian


GLENDALE, CA — The Armenian Revolutionary Federation-Western Region will be hosting an upcoming talk with David Barsamian, as part of its “Armenians and Progressive Politics” initiative. The event will take place on Wednesday, October 24, 2018 at 7:30 pm at the Mariam and Kirkor Karamanougian Youth Center in Glendale.

Barsamian’s talk, titled “Rise Up and Resist,” will touch upon what it takes for a people to move from passivity to active resistance. History has presented numerous instances of people defying tyranny and fighting back regardless of the odds. Barsamian will draw upon an example from Nazi Germany, often considered the benchmark of evil. Even though opposition to the regime was highly dangerous, Hans and Sophie Scholl, along with others at the University of Munich, formed the White Rose Movement and called on Germans to recognize their moral duty and overthrow the government. Their resistance led to their arrest and murder in 1943, but their resistance and courage is recognized and honored to this day. Barsamian will attempt to answer just when enough really becomes enough and people are deemed to take certain risks.

The event is free and open to the public, and is cosponsored by the Armenian Youth Federation – Western United States, and the ARF Shant Student Association.

As a tireless and wide-ranging investigative journalist, David Barsamian has altered the independent media landscape, both with his weekly radio show “Alternative Radio” and his books with Noam Chomsky, Eqbal Ahmad, Howard Zinn, Tariq Ali, Richard Wolff, Arundhati Roy, and Edward Said. In his work, he covers world affairs, imperialism, capitalism, propaganda, the media, the economic crisis, and global rebellions. Barsamian is the recipient of the Media Education Award, the ACLU’s Upton Sinclair Award for independent journalism, and the Cultural Freedom Fellowship from the Lannan Foundation. He has been named by the Institute of Alternative Journalism as one of its “Top Ten media Heroes.” Barsamian has a forthcoming book with Noam Chomsky titled, “Global Discontents: Conversations on the Rising Threats to Democracy.”

The Mariam and Kirkor Karamanougian Youth Center is located at 211 West Chestnut Street, Glendale, CA 91204. Additional parking is available in the adjacent St Mary’s Armenian Church parking lot. For questions please


Contact:
Razmig Sarkissian | Ռազմիկ Սարգիսեան 
(323) 236-4399


Armenians and Progressive Politics to Host David Barsamian .docx

Binary data


AAPP David Barsamian Lecture.jpg

JPEG image

Vartan Gregorian Scholarship Program Announces Call for Applications

ArmenPress, Armenia
Oct 12 2018


 Vartan Gregorian Scholarship Program Announces Call for Applications


YEREVAN, OCTOBER 12, ARMENPRESS. The Aurora Humanitarian Initiative
announces a call for applications for new research grants, IDeAsaid in
a press release.

The Vartan Gregorian Scholarship (Research Grants) Program will
support exceptional early-career scholars and researchers, with a
specific focus on historians and social scientists, in their efforts
to study the unexplored questions of the 20th century history of
Armenia.

The first phase of the five-year scholarship program will focus on
Armenian scholars and researchers from Armenia under the age of 35.
The second and third phases of the scholarship program will be
expanded to include scholars and researchers in the global Armenian
diaspora and beyond. The scholarship program will award two $30,000
grants per year. “Universities and scholars play a critical role in
asking and answering the questions that concern mankind. The Vartan
Gregorian Scholarship supports the spirit of inquiry and study that
Vartan himself embodies. We are proud that the scholarship will enrich
the body of knowledge about Armenia and will augment the contributions
of Armenian scholarship”, said Ruben Vardanyan, Co-founder of the
Aurora Humanitarian Initiative. “We are making this announcement
today, on Holy Translators Day, in the spirit of commitment to the
foundational, cross-cultural exchange that the 5th century Translators
introduced to the Armenian world. The Vartan Gregorian Scholarship
will celebrate this man and this tradition.” The Vartan Gregorian
Scholarship (Research Grants) Program was created to strengthen
connections between Armenian and international research institutions,
building on the deep and rich scholarly tradition of Armenia. With the
support of the Aurora Humanitarian Initiative and experts in the field
of Armenian Studies, the Scholae Mundi education platform will play a
key role in the implementation of the program. The scholarship program
was created by the Aurora Humanitarian Initiative in consultation with
experts in the field of Armenian Studies, to advance scholarly
research in Armenia and on Armenian topics internationally. The
experts who were consulted by the Initiative have included: Hratch
Tchilingirian, Associate Faculty Member of Faculty of Oriental
Studies, University of Oxford; Hayk Demoyan, Doctor of Historical
Sciences and former Director of the Armenian Genocide
Museum-Institute; and Levon Chookaszian, Head of Chair of History and
Theory of Armenian Art, Yerevan State University. Each application
will be reviewed by a five-member international Selection Board
comprised of prominent scholars: • Ronald G. Suny, the William H.
Sewell Jr. Distinguished University Professor of History, University
of Michigan and Emeritus Professor of Political Science and History,
the University of Chicago • George Bournoutian, Senior Professor of
History, Iona College • Hratch Tchilingirian, Associate Faculty Member
of Faculty of Oriental Studies, University of Oxford • Levon
Chookaszian, Head of Chair of History and Theory of Armenian Art,
Yerevan State University • Hayk Demoyan, Doctor of Historical Sciences
and former Director of the Armenian Genocide Museum-Institute
Welcoming the call for applications, Ronald G. Suny said, “A small
investment in a promising scholar at the beginning of her or his
career rebounds many fold as that researcher continues through time to
contribute to our knowledge of the world. The Vartan Gregorian
Scholarship will bear fruit many decades after its first seeds are
planted.” The application process will be conducted online and will be
open until December 1, 2018. All applicants will be requested to
submit: • A research proposal in English (maximum of 2,000 words,
double spaced, 12pt font) • A CV with a list of publications • A cover
letter • At least one academic letter of recommendation. ### Dr.
Vartan Gregorian is a co-Founder of the Aurora Humanitarian Initiative
and President of Carnegie Corporation of New York. Born in Tabriz,
Iran, of Armenian parents, Dr. Gregorian received his elementary
education in Iran and his secondary education in Lebanon. In 1956 he
entered Stanford University, where he majored in history and the
humanities, graduating with honors in 1958. He was awarded a PhD in
history and humanities from Stanford in 1964. He was founding dean of
the Faculty of Arts and Sciences at the University of Pennsylvania in
1974 and four years later became its twenty-third provost until 1981.
Following an academic career spanning two decades, Dr. Gregorian
served as President of The New York Public Library. He is widely
credited with restoring the status of the library as a cultural
landmark. In 1989 he was appointed president of Brown University. Dr.
Gregorian is the recipient of numerous fellowships, including from the
John Simon Guggenheim Foundation, the American Council of Learned
Societies, the Social Science Research Council, and the American
Philosophical Society.

President seeks ‘transition to once again happen within law and Constitution’

Category
Politics

The only way for resolving the Armenian domestic political developments is the path of dialogue, negotiations and agreements, in conditions of law, rule of law and the Constitution, President Armen Sarkissian told reporters during a visit today to the Charles Aznavour Home in Yerevan.

Reporters asked whether the president plans to sign the controversial bill into law. “After returning [from abroad] I began meetings with the prime minister, the Speaker of Parliament, and political parties, with the goal to achieve what we are speaking about, in order for the transition to once again happen within the framework of the Constitution and law,” he said.

The controversial bill is an amendment to the Rules of Procedure law of the parliament, whereby in the event of a parliament session being unable to be held because of lack of quorum, or if lawmakers are anyhow prevented from participating, it will be considered interrupted rather than failed, with a possibility of resuming at a later date. The aim of the bill is apparently a limitation of possible circumstances of dissolution of parliament. The bill was adopted on October 2 by the parliament which is dominated by Republicans [HHK], which sparked demonstrations. Adopted bills should be signed into law by the president to come into effect.

Armenian government upholds draft government budget for 2019

ARKA, Armenia
Sept 27 2018

YEREVAN, September 27. /ARKA/. The Armenian government upheld Thursday the draft government budget for 2019.

The budget revenue is projected here at AMD 1.5 trillion, spending at AMD 1.6 trillion, economic growth at 4.9% and inflation at 2.7%.  

On Monday, the budget will be sent to the National Assembly. 

For comparison, the 2018 government budget revenue was planned at AMD 1 trillion 208 billion and spending at AMD 1 trillion 307 billion. Deficit was projected at 156.9 billion, economic growth at 4.5% and inflation at 4% (±1.5%). ($1 – AMD 480.37). -0— 

Yerevan elections to express people’s will, says NSS chief

Category
Politics

National Security Service director Arthur Vanetsyan cast his ballot in the Yerevan City Council election.

Talking to reporters after voting, the intelligence chief said that he expects this election to express the will of the people and that a mayor of Yerevan will be elected by the vote of the people.

“No one will have any doubts in this regard,” he said.