No unsolved problems standing between Russia and Armenia: Putin

No unsolved problems standing between Russia and Armenia: Putin

Focus News, Bulgaria
Jan 24 2007

24 January 2007 | 15:41 | FOCUS News Agency

Sochi. Armenian President Robert Kocharyan arrived Wednesday in the
Russian resort town of Sochi on the Black Sea for talks with President
Vladimir Putin, the Russian RIA Novosti reports.

Putin said at the meeting that he and Kocharyan are satisfied with
bilateral relations, and that there is "not a single unsolved problem,
not a single difficult issue being discussed."

BAKU: Rene van der Linden: PACE on firm position of liberation of Az

Azeri Press Agency
Jan 22 2007

Rene van der Linden: PACE on firm position of liberation of
Azerbaijani lands

[ 22 Jan. 2007 15:06 ]

Today PACE President Rene van der Linden has held press conference on
the commencing of PACE winter session, APA correspondent in
Strasbourg reports.

PACE President mainly touched on the issues that are on the agenda of
the session and gave information about his recent visits to Russia
and Belarus. He also expressed his opinion to death of Armenian
Turkish journalist. PACE President said that he is not pessimistic
about non-ratification the 14th protocol of the European Court on
Human Rights by Russia and noted that he had met with the chief of
the Duma. Rene van der Linden stated that Duma still considers the
issue.

"We will try to inspire Russia to ratify the 14th protocol," he said.

He also touched on the problem exisiting between Russia and Belarus
and stressed about possibility that the tenseness happened because of
Belarus’s approach to the European structures. He wished that Hrant
Dink’s assassination will not influence the relations of the
organization and Turkey.

"It should not influence Turkey EU membership process either," he
said.

The PACE president said that Armenian PACE commitments will be
discussed in the plenary meeting to be held tomorrow and noted that
Karabakh issue will also be in the focus of the meeting.

"We inspire the sides in the negotiations on Karabakh. Of course CE
can show its position in the negotiations; simply, we are waiting for
the results of the negotiations. As you know, PACE adopted
resolution, showing its firm position that Armenia occupied
Azerbaijani territories," he said. /APA/

Murder of Journalist in Turkey Threatens Democracy

Murder of Journalist in Turkey Threatens Democracy

Toronto Daily News, Canada
Jan 22 2007

Armenian Genocide expert Peter Balakian says that the assassination
of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink in Istanbul was more than
a senseless murder.

The assassination of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink in
Istanbul was more than a senseless murder, according to Colgate
University professor and Armenian Genocide expert Peter Balakian –
it was yet another example of how far Turkey is from being a democracy.

Balakian, author of New York Times bestseller and Raphael Lemkin
Prize winner The Burning Tigris; the Armenian Genocide and America’s
Response, is available to comment on Dink’s death.

"As editor of Agos, a weekly Armenian newspaper, Dink held a uniquely
important place in Turkish society, so his slaying was particularly
significant," said Balakian. "If Turkey wishes to go forward as a
democracy, it must find a way to embrace Dink’s legacy."

Eighteen journalists have been killed in Turkey in the last six years,
and 77 are on trial now, he said, but violence toward intellectuals
begins, in the modern period, for Turkey with genocide of the Armenians
in 1915.

"Turkey has a long history of punishing its writers, thinkers,
artists, and ethnic minorities," he explained. "On April 24, 1915,
at the beginning of the Armenian Genocide which claimed more than a
million lives, the Ottoman government rounded up more than 250 Armenian
leaders in Constantinople (Istanbul) and transported them out of the
city. Most of them were killed, making it easier for the government
at that time to carry out its planned extermination and exile of the
rest of the Armenian population. Dink now joins those martyrs."

Political violence of this nature increased when Turkey began its
accession to the European Union in recent years, said Balakian,
and it is definitely not random. "The ruling party’s attempts to
meet the EU’s conditions – among them, more freedom of expression,
equal treatment of minorities, and an end to official government
denial of the Armenian Genocide – amplified the resistance of extreme
nationalists and the military to such reforms," he said.

Because of Dink’s standing, Balakian believes the slaying will
reverberate beyond Turkey. "His death is emblematic of the struggle
for freedom of thought and expression people face under violent and
repressive societies and governments all over the world."

Of Dink himself, Balakian commented: "Despite Turkey’s penal code –
which mandates prison sentences for a long list of offenses that
constitute the crime of ‘insulting Turkishness’ – Dink persisted in
publishing articles and speaking openly about subjects that are taboo
in Turkey, most notably the Armenian Genocide of 1915 committed by
the government of the Ottoman Empire. For doing so he was put on trial
last year, and threats against his life had increased dramatically in
the last few weeks. Yet no amount of brutality and danger diminished
his courage; he continued to work toward his goal, which was to help
achieve a peaceful reconciliation between ethnically Armenian and
Turkish society."

Turkey far from democracy and freedom of speech

Turkey far from democracy and freedom of speech

ArmRadio.am
20.01.2007 16:05

Hrant Dink’s assassination will further strain the internal political
situation in Turkey, Director of the Institute of Oriental Studies of
the Armenian National Academy of Sciences Ruben Safrastyan said in a
press conference today.

According to him, in May 2007 presidential elections are due in
Turkey, and the main struggle launches between the President in office
Ahmet Nejdet Sezer, representative of the so-called Kemalist of
European course, and adherents of the Islamist position headed by
Prime Minister Rejeb Tayyip Erdogan.

The two opposing camps aspire to attract the army, and the one who
manages this will come out victor. However, one should not forget
about the factor of the `state inside state’ factor permanently
existing in Turkey, that is to say about the group of senior officials
who prefer to stay in the shadow, who resolve important state
questions and accomplish this with the help of radical groups like the
`Grey wolves’ terrorist organization. It’s quite possible that they
could have ordered ad perpetrated the murder of Hrant Dink in order
`to show everyone that real Turkey is not the central districts of
Istanbul but the rest of areas with pro-Islamic position,’ Safrastyan
considers.

He noted also that the accident will further delay the opening of the
Armenian-Turkish border, which seemed extremely unrealistic and far
even before. Hrant Dink was a dreamer, who sincerely believed that it
is possible and necessary to change Turkey from inside staying in the
country. However, his death showed how far Turkey is from democracy
and freedom of speech, noted Ruben Safrastyan.

Director of the Caucasus Institute of Mass Media Alexander Iskandaryan
also declared that Istanbul should be differentiated from the rest of
Turkey. `The population of central parts of Istanbul, which is
aspiring to Europe and which organized an act of protest connected
with Dink’s death, is one thing, but if you go 20 km away from
Istanbul you will find yourself in quite a different pro-Islamic
Turkey, the population of which cannot comprehend why it should
organize an act of protest for the murder of some Armenia,’ noted
Iskandaryan.

As for the Armenian-Turkish relations in light of yesterday’s murder,
Alexander Iskandaryan considers nothing special will occur here. Those
who believed establishment of relations is unnecessary will keep to
their conviction. Those who supported the idea will say nothing
extraordinary has happened, murders happen indifferent countries of
the world.

Participants of the press conference agreed on one thing: there is no
need to search for thid countries behind Hrant Dink’s assassination,
since it is the result of the current internal political situation in
Turkey.

Turkey reeling from death of Armenian journalist

CTV.ca, Canada
Jan 20 2007

Turkey reeling from death of Armenian journalist
Updated Sat. Jan. 20 2007 7:51 AM ET

Associated Press

ISTANBUL, Turkey — Turkey’s prime minister on Saturday conveyed his
nation’s sense of shock a day after a journalist and Armenian
community leader was assassinated at the entrance to his bilingual
Turkish-Armenian newspaper.

Officials released a photo of the young man they suspect killed Hrant
Dink, who received numerous death threats for his views that Turks
carried out a genocide against the minority Armenians early in the
20th century.

"The bullets aimed at Hrant Dink were shot into all of us," Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said. Within hours of Dink’s murder, he
had sent his interior minister and justice minister to Istanbul to
lead the investigation.

Dink, who had faced trials for the genocide claims, was shot and
killed Friday in broad daylight. No suspects are in custody.

He wrote in his last newspaper column that he was so worried about
attacks that his head swiveled like a pigeon’s as he moved around
Istanbul.

Most Turks assumed the shooting was a reaction to Dink’s public
statements that the mass killings of Armenians around the time of
World War I constituted genocide. Nationalists see such statements as
insults to the honor of Turks and as threats to national unity.

Whatever the motivation, the killing made it clear that Turkey
remains a place where people speak freely at their own peril, despite
generations of Western-looking liberal reforms and the nation’s
commitment to joining the European Union.

The New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists said Turkey was
the eighth deadliest country in the world for journalist, with 18
killed in the past 15 years for their work. Turkey’s Zaman newspaper
said 62 journalists have been assassinated in the nation’s 84-year
history.

Dink, 52, was often subjected to more subtle attempts to silence him.
He was one of dozens of journalists, writers and academics who have
gone on trial for expressing their opinions here, most under the
infamous article 301 of the penal code, which makes it a crime to
insult Turkey, its government or the national character.

In the most famous case, Nobel Prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk
faced jail time last year for insulting Turkey by saying Turks had
killed a million Armenians. His case was dropped on a technicality.

Dink clearly sensed his life was in danger.

"My computer’s memory is loaded with sentences full of anger and
threats," he wrote on Jan. 10 in his last newspaper column. "I am
just like a pigeon. … I look around to my left and right, in front
and behind me as much as it does. My head is just as active."

In the past few years, Turks had come to know Dink well, mostly
because of the high-profile cases opened against him. In late 2005,
Turks saw him lose his composure, crying on television as he
discussed his latest court case and what it was like to live amid
people who hated him.

A Turkish citizen, Dink said he would stay here, however, in the
hopes that cases he opened at the European Court of Human Rights
would be resolved in his favor, and do something to improve his
country.

Turkey’s relationship with its Armenian community has long been
fraught with tension, controversy and painful memories of a brutal
past.

Much of Turkey’s once-sizeable Armenian population was killed or
driven out beginning around 1915 in what an increasing number of
countries are recognizing as the first genocide of the 20th century.

Turks vehemently deny that their ancestors committed genocide,
however, and saying so is tantamount to treason. In the 1970s and
1980s, tensions were further inflamed as dozens of Turkish diplomats
were killed by Armenian assassins seeking revenge.

Turkey, which is 99 percent Muslim, and Armenia, which claims to be
the first country to officially adopt Christianity, share a border.
But the border is closed, and the two countries have no formal
diplomatic relations.

Greece: Journalist killed by gunman in Istanbul

Euro2day, Greece
Jan 19 2007

Journalist killed by gunman in Istanbul

FT.com

A high-profile Turkish-Armenian editor, convicted of insulting
Turkey’s identity, was shot dead outside his newspaper office in
Istanbul on Friday.

Hrant Dink, a writer and journalist and a frequent target of
nationalist anger, was shot by an unknown assailant as he left his
newspaper Agos around 1 p.m. British time in central Istanbul, the
paper said.

"Hrant was a perfect target for those who want to obstruct Turkey’s
democratisation and its path towards the European Union," Agos writer
Aydin Engin told Reuters.

Broadcaster NTV said Dink been shot three times in the neck and
police were now looking for a 18 or 19-year-old man.

CNN Turk television said two men had been detained in connection with
the shooting.

The attack is bound to raise political tensions in would-be EU member
Turkey, where politicians of all parties have been courting the
nationalist vote ahead of presidential elections in May and
parliamentary polls due by November.

Protesters at the scene chanted "the murderer government will pay"
and "shoulder-to-shoulder against fascism".

Television footage showed his body lying in the street covered by a
white sheet, with hundreds of bystanders gathering behind a police
cordon.

"This bullet was fired against Turkey … an image has been created
about Turkey that its Armenian citizens have no safety," said CNN
Turk editor Taha Akyol.

Turkey’s Foreign Ministry said in a statement it "forcefully
condemned" the "loathsome attack".

Last year Turkey’s appeals court upheld a six-month suspended jail
sentence against Dink, a Turkish-born Armenian, for referring in an
article to an Armenian nationalist idea of ethnic purity without
Turkish blood.

The court said the comments went against an article of Turkey’s
revised penal code which lets prosecutors pursue cases against
writers and scholars for "insulting Turkish identity".

The ruling was sharply criticised by the EU.

INSULTING TURKISHNESS

Dink was one of dozens of writers who have been charged under laws
against insulting Turkishness, particularly over the alleged genocide
of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War One.

Turkey denies allegations that 1.5 million Armenians were killed in a
systematic genocide. It says both Christian Armenians and Muslim
Turks were killed in a partisan conflict that raged on Ottoman
territory.

But the government has promised to revise the much criticised article
of the penal code amid EU pressure.

Dink was editor-in-chief of the bilingual Turkish and Armenian
newspaper and one of the most prominent Armenian voices in Turkey.

"I will not leave this country. If I go I would feel I was leaving
alone the people struggling for democracy in this country. It would
be a betrayal of them. I could never do this," Dink said in an
interview with Reuters last July.

Tensions have been growing ahead of presidential elections amid a
rise in nationalism.

Turkey’s powerful secularist establishment fears the ruling AK Party,
which controls parliament and has roots in political Islam, will
elect Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan as president.

Secularists, including powerful army generals and judges, fear
Erdogan — a former Islamist — would try to erode Turkey’s strict
division between state and religion if elected president.

Erdogan denies he or his party have an Islamist agenda.

Kocharian and Putin to Meet Jan 24 to Discuss Priorities

Armenpress

KOCHARIAN AND PUTIN TO MEET JANUARY 24 TO DISCUSS
PRIORITIES

YEREVAN, JANUARY 19, ARMENPRESS: President Robert
Kocharian will travel to Russia next week for talks
with his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin,
Kocharian’s press office said today. It said the
meeting will be held on January 24 in Sochi, a resort
town on the Russian Black Sea coast.
President Kocharian flew to Moscow on Wednesday for
what his press office said was a ‘private’ visit. The
two leaders will discuss a wide scope of economic and
political issues, Kocharian’s press office said,
adding that the focus will be on energy, ways on
expanding Russian-Armenian trade and Russian
investments in Armenia.
It said they will also discuss regional issues and
international efforts to resolve the Nagorno-Karabakh
conflict. The Sochi talks will take place a day after
the January 23 planned meeting in Moscow of the
foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan that will
be attended by French, Russian and U.S. mediators from
the OSCE Minsk Group.

Prosecutors Press Charges Against Controversial MP

PROSECUTORS PRESS CHARGES AGAINST CONTROVERSIAL MP
By Karine Kalantarian

Radio Liberty, Czech Republic
Jan 18 2007

Hakob Hakobian, a controversial businessman and parliament deputy,
looks set to stand trial on charges partly stemming from his role in
a recent mass brawl at a gas distribution station near Yerevan.

Armenia’s Office of the Prosecutor-General said on Thursday that it
has completed a criminal investigation into the incident and Hakobian’s
economic activities and will soon forward the case to the court.

The 43-year-old, who joined the governing Republican Party of Armenia
(HHK) last year, was charged with "hooliganism," tax evasion and
other financial irregularities in October immediately after fellow
lawmakers agreed to lift his legal immunity from prosecution.

Addressing the Armenian parliament at the time, Prosecutor-General
Aghvan Hovsepian accused him of organizing an armed assault on the
gas facility in the village of Hayanist after security guards there
refused to allow him to enter its premises.

Hakobian reportedly visited it to demand that the ARG national gas
distributor resume supplies to nearby liquefied gas stations owned
by him. He was arrested on the spot and kept in custody for three days.

The National Assembly gave the green light for his prosecution despite
his assurances that he arrived at the scene stop a "manly fight"
between the security guards and local residents.

The pro-government businessman, who holds sway in the area south of
Yerevan, continues to protest his innocence. "I am not guilty on any
of the counts," he told RFE/RL. "Only incidents taking place in public
places are hooliganism. In my case, the fight happened in a field."

Hakobian also denied the other charges relating to his business
activities of the past 15 years. "I keep doing what I have done for
years," he said.

Hakobian implicitly alleged in parliament that he was not prosecuted
earlier because he has for years bribed law-enforcement and tax
officials inspecting his businesses. The claim was picked up by
opposition parliamentarians. They also denounced as illegal the fact
that Hakobian was arrested not by the Armenian police but President
Robert Kocharian’s personal security service.

Together Against Negationism

TOGETHER AGAINST NEGATIONISM

ArmRadio.am
18.01.2007 12:53

January 17, 2007, France of Justice, Arts, Literature and Politics,
joined their forces to make the French Senate adopt the bill against
the negation of Armenian Genocide voted by the Parliament on October
12, 2006.

"Together against negationism!" is the formula call launched by
Co-ordination Council of Armenian Organizations of France (CCAF)
presented by its president Alexis Govciyan and also by Jewish
organizations of France, Jean Eckian informs from France.

More than 1500 people joined together in front of the "Palais de la
Mutualite" in Paris. The gathering was attended by singer Charles
Aznavour, Serge Klarsfeld, "hunter of Nazis", father of teaching of
Shoa, president of "Sons and Girls of Jewish Deportees Association
of France", writer philosopher Bernard Henri Levy and several others.

Deputy Patrick Devedjian, adviser to presidential candidate of the
French Republic, Nicolas Sarkozy, and Francois Holland, secretary
general of the French Socialist Party, followed each other on the
platform to denounce the Turkish State negationism.

In a very impressive speech condemning Turkish negationism, philosopher
Bernard-Henri Levy concluded with this formula: "solidarity of the
shipwrecked" to associate Jewish and Armenian destinies.

If this law is endorsed soon by the French Senate, the dispute of
the Armenian Genocide will be punished by one year of prison and
45.000 euros ($39.000) of fine, same judgment as that planned for
the negation of Jews genocide by the Nazis.

OSCE/ODIHR Director Expresses Willingness To Cooperate With RA Centr

OSCE/ODIHR DIRECTOR EXPRESSES WILLINGNESS TO COOPERATE WITH RA CENTRAL ELECTORAL COMMISSION

Noyan Tapan
Jan 16 2007

YEREVAN, JANUARY 16, NOYAN TAPAN. The Chairman of the RA Central
Electoral Commission (CEC) Garegin Azarian on January 16 received
Director of the OSCE/ODIHR (Office for Democratic Institutions
and Human Rights) Christian Strohal, who is on a two-day visit to
Armenia. During the meeting, the sides spoke about the amendments
and additions recently made in the RA Electoral Code, attaching
special importance to reforms of the vote and result summarizing
orders. Spokeswoman for the RA CEC Tsovinar Khachatrian told NT
correspondent that C. Strohal expressed confidence that the amendments
of the RA Electoral Code will ensure some progress in the electoral
system of Armenia. He also stated a willingness to cooperate with
the RA CEC during the upcoming elections.

The CEC Chairman informed the guest about the professional courses for
candidates for electoral commissions’ membership, which were organized
in 2006, as well as about technical re-equipment of the RA CEC.