Friends and fans pay tribute to Tigran Levonyan

ArmeniaNow.com
July 2, 2004

Final Curtain: Friends and fans pay tribute to Tigran Levonyan

By Gayane Abrahamyan
ArmeniaNow arts reporter

The art of opera in Armenia suffered a sad loss this week with the death of
director and singer Tigran Levonyan.

Levonyan, People’s Artist of the Republic of Armenia and a state prize
laureate, died on June 25 aged 68. Thousands of admirers attended his
funeral service on June 29 at Yerevan’s Opera House to bid a last farewell
to the artist as the magnificent sounds of the Anush opera rang out.

Tigran Levonyan, People’s Artist .
His dramatic tenor vocals as a singer and his original way of thinking as a
stage director opened a new chapter in the history of National Opera
Theatre. Thanks to his tireless dedication, new directing style and fresh
staging he gave priceless service to the Armenian opera art.

Levonyan was born in Beirut, Lebanon, and repatriated as a child to Armenia
in 1946. He completed his musical education in singing and directing in
Yerevan and Moscow and aged just 28 he became a soloist at Yerevan’s
Spendiaryan Opera and Ballet National Academic Theatre. By 1977 he had
become the theatre’s artistic director.

His long repertoire as a singer and director included national and world
opera productions: he performed Canio (Pagliacci), Tirit (Arshak II), Saro
(Anush), Carlos (Don Carlos), Otello (Otello), Alfred (La Traviata),
Shahumyan (David Bek), Manrico (Trubadur), Cavaradossi (Toska) with great
depth of dramatic feeling, impressive acting and a delicate interpretation
of direction.

Levonyan was the first to create opera films in Armenia and thanks to his
unique directing approach he placed on screen Almast, Arshak II, and
Palmetto, which became symbols of his innovative art.

However, he suffered unfairness at the hands of government bureaucracy too.
In 1999, upon the order of the Ministry of Culture, Levonyan was dismissed
from the theatre and deprived of the right not only to stage performances
but also to sing there as well.

A letter of protest signed by 125 artists of the theatre, calling for
Levonyan to be restored as artistic director and director, was ignored. He
was subjected to a humiliating whispering campaign in the press, where
articles were printed suggesting that he had pressured people into signing
the letter.

Mourners pay their last respects to an honored artist
“Opera and stage are my life. I’m deprived of the stage so I’m deprived of
life,” said Levonyan. “Back in 1993, I declared from the stage that we need
a law on culture in order to protect the culture from the Ministry of
Culture.”

“Tigran was working and creating because ideas came like rain from his mind.
But we felt deeply insulted and the insult of ignoring us was not only ours
but of the whole art loving society,” says singer Gohar Gasparyan, who
Avetik Isahakyan described as “Armenian nightingale”.

“He left unvalued, denied. Moreover, the reason for his illness was the
unending sense of outrage he felt, which did not subside in his heart,” says
People’s Artist Sos Sargsyan, his voice quivering.

Even after he left the Opera House, Levonyan did not stop creating. On the
occasion of 1700 th anniversary of Christianity in Armenia in 2001, he
staged open air performances of Anush and Palmetto at Zvartnots temple.

Choreographer Vilen Galstyan says that instead of organizing a lavish
funeral service for him, the State should have better appreciated his talent
during his life.

“It’s the Armenian option – ‘go die and I’ll love you’,” says Galstyan.

BAKU: Azerbaijan urges drive to resolve Karabakh dispute

Azerbaijan urges drive to resolve Karabakh dispute

ISTANBUL, June 26 (Reuters) – Azerbaijan called on the international
community to help resolve its chronic dispute with Armenia over
Nagorno-Karabakh on Saturday, arguing that the region was a potential
hotbed for drug-running and terror.

Azeri President Ilham Aliyev clashed at a conference in Istanbul with
an Armenian official who described the territory as an “established
entity” with governing institutions and a ceasefire that has held for
a decade since a six-year conflict.

“Nagorno-Karabakh is an entity which is not recognised by anyone in
the world,” the president responded to a comment from Armenian foreign
ministry official Garen Nazarian.

“It is an unrecognised, self-proclaimed, illegal so-called entity.
Azerbaijan will never agree with the loss of its territory, we will
get these territories back.”

Nagorno-Karabakh is a territory wholly inside Azerbaijan, populated by
Christian ethnic Armenians, which broke away from Baku’s rule as the
Soviet Union collapsed. The Azeris, their country controlling large
oil resources, want it back.

The Minsk Group of 11 countries, led by France, the United States and
Russia under the mandate of the Organisation for Security and
Cooperation in Europe, has so far failed to settle the problem.

Aliyev said that “Armenian occupation” had left one million of
Azerbaijan’s population of eight million as either refugees or
internally displaced persons, and Nagorno-Karabakh had become one of
the southern Caucasus’s “uncontrolled lawless zones.”

“Nagorno-Karabakh poses a very serious threat for the region –there
is no international control, no international monitoring and no rule
of law,” he told the security conference which set the stage for a
NATO summit in the Turkish city next week.

“This is a very comfortable place for criminal elements. There
is…some very significant evidence of illegal drug trafficking in
Nagorno-Karabakh, of terrorism camps.”

Aliyev appealed for more active efforts to resolve the dispute from
the “broad international community,” including the European Union, the
Council of Europe and other international institutions.

Asked by Nazarian why he was not satisfied with the mediation efforts
of the Minsk Group, Aliyev replied: “Because there is no result.”

06/26/04 13:53 ET

Armenian Opposition To Change Strategy Soon, Premier Says

ARMENIAN OPPOSITION TO CHANGE STRATEGY SOON, PREMIER SAYS

Aykakan Zhamanak, Yerevan
19 Jun 04

An interview with Prime Minister Andranik Markaryan. He comments on
the opposition struggle.

(Aykakan Zhamanak correspondent) Mr Prime Minister, the opposition
thinks that the first stage of the struggle against the authorities
to come to power has finished. How do you assess the first round of
the opposition-authorities fight?

(Andranik Markaryan) I do not think there was a fight between the
authorities and the opposition. Simply the opposition put forward
some problems and during that period the authorities continued their
routine activity ensuring the settlement of internal and external
problems, naturally, paying attention to the problems put forward
by the opposition. I do not want to say that the opposition and the
authorities in our country were fighting each other, as a result of
which one of them won. Simply political processes took place, during
which one of the parties felt that the problems raised by them were
not politically realistic.

For this reason I think that by the end of the year the opposition will
try to change its strategy in order to be able to present its political
demands in a more favourable way. Naturally, the authorities should
also try to settle existing problems by implementing certain work
together with the opposition as well and ease possible tension. So,
here I do not want to see a winner and a loser. We should assess
what took place from the point of view of our country’s rating: has
the rating of our country surged or dropped in the course of these
processes? I think it has dropped a little.

(Correspondent) But the opposition does not think that its political
demands are not realistic. According to opposition leaders, they
failed to fulfil their programmes at this stage because the opposition
continued to fight using constitutional methods against the authorities
which were acting in an unconstitutional way.

(Markaryan) I cannot agree with this. Simply the authorities
were trying to bring the opposition’s actions into line with the
law. As for the opposition’s failure, I think they were acting
incorrectly from the very beginning. Because though there is objective
displeasure in the country, this displeasure should not be expressed
at extraordinary elections, especially in an illegal form such as a
vote of confidence. This is one of the opposition’s mistakes.

Another mistake of the opposition was that they were trying to liken
the situation in Armenia to the situation in Georgia and to come to
power in this way. Whereas it is clear that after any elections,
part of society is always displeased with the results. Simply
that displeasure should be expressed at the next elections and the
opposition should work in this direction. Otherwise we will be holding
extraordinary elections permanently.

(Correspondent) But if the opposition was unable to settle its problems
during this stage, the reason is not that all the existing problems
of the country have been settled and the demands of the opposition
are not realistic.

(Markaryan) But who says that all the existing problems of the country
have been settled? I can say with responsibility that nobody speaks
about our problems more than the government itself. You may open the
strategic programme for poverty reduction or the anti-corruption
programme, and I can assure you that in these two programmes the
situation in our country is presented more harshly than the opposition
was telling about it in the newspapers or in the streets. We do not
make a secret of it. At the same time, we say that we are trying to
settle these problems. The opposition says that our way is wrong, and
if we leave they will settle all the problems. If they can settle them,
let them se ttle the problems now, or tell us how to settle them. But
their proposal is: leave and we shall come and settle the problems.

(Passage omitted: minor details)

Thoroughly modern meze

Thoroughly modern meze
By Anya von Bremzen, Special to The Times

Los Angeles Times
June 9 2004

Istanbul

By 11 p.m., the street theater on Nevizade Street, a narrow lane
lined with outdoor restaurants around Istanbul’s fish market, works
up to a kind of Felliniesque mayhem. Flower sellers push big thorny
roses at passersby’s noses, while a Gypsy quartet cranks background
music for a parade of street peddlers.

Amid this carnival, waiters unload trays of small dishes on tables
and refill glasses with raki, Turkey’s favorite anise-based liquor.
Our own table, at an old Armenian restaurant called Boncuk, is
mosaicked with plates of dips, crisp fish croquettes redolent of
allspice and cinnamon, a chickpea pâté layered with dried currants
and pine nuts, and a majestic börek, a pastry oozing a tangy filling
of cheese and pastirma, or spiced cured beef.

These are meze, Turkey’s signature little dishes and the Middle
East’s answer to Spanish tapas, Venetian baccari or Mexican
antojitos.

On our own shores, meze offer yet another twist on the small-plates
trend. Entertaining at home? Meze could have been invented for
Southern California, where, much like in Istanbul, they can be
languidly savored al fresco on the patio. Less fussy than hors
d’oeuvres, a welcome break from Italian antipasti, infinitely more
varied than hummus and baba ghanouj, a few meze together make an
exciting light feast.

Meze — the name is derived from the Persian word maza, or flavor —
seem to flourish in Istanbul as an edible life force: from a plethora
of eggplant preparations to a veritable encyclopedia of dolma, or
stuffed vegetables; from multitudes of böreks, savory pastries, to a
vast roster of salads and dips. They can be cold or hot, light or
substantial, as humble as a wedge of salty white cheese or as chichi
as the langoustine salads dished out at the glamorous fish
restaurants along the Bosphorus shores. Though most travelers to
Turkey encounter meze at restaurants, they taste even better when
prepared at home. “Meze is all about socializing — nibbling,
drinking, laughing,” says Gökçan Adar, an Istanbul food writer. One
breezy night, under a sour cherry tree in his overgrown garden, he
treats us to a 19-dish meze marathon.

Spontaneity is essential

Typical of modern-day Istanbul, where the cuisine evolves with
lightning speed, his spread is both creative and classic: braised
eggplant topped with a flourish of walnut and sun-dried tomato paste,
langoustines with their roe resting atop lemony wild greens, fritters
of just-picked zucchini flowers on a vibrant red pepper purée. This
could almost be Catalonia — or California. Not to be outdone, my
friend Engin Akin, a food writer and radio host legendary in Istanbul
for her swank soirees, throws a bash on the lawn of her home
overlooking the Bosphorus. Ever willing to experiment, Akin
deep-fries paper-thin leaves of yufka (a phyllo-like dough) and
serves the crisps with shavings of Turkish cured mullet roe similar
to bottarga. She fashions nifty bruschetta from the ubiquitous fava
bean pâté, topping the toasts with fried almonds.

Grazing gets more cosmopolitan still when Akin and I move on to
Bodrum, a jet-set resort on the Aegean. Here, at a cocktail party at
the white-washed villa of a shipping tycoon, white-gloved waiters
pass such dainties as miniature French fry “kebabs,” Gruyère köfte
(meatballs), and spicy sucuk (soujuk) sausage wrapped in phyllo.

In Turkey, meze are intimately linked with the city’s history as a
cosmopolitan port and to drinking establishments called meyhane.

What — drinking in a Muslim culture, with its Koranic prohibitions on
alcohol? Well … sure.

Even before Kemal Atatürk secularized Turkey in the 1920s,
restrictions on alcohol were sporadic, a whim of one sultan or
another. Selling alcohol was taboo, though, entrusted to Istanbul’s
numerous non-Muslim minorities: Greeks, Armenians and Jews. It was
they who established the original meyhane, raucous dives packed with
foreign sailors, where meze was an excuse for another round of raki.
Dating back to early Ottoman times or even further, meyhane continue
to thrive.

To learn more, I rendezvous with Akin and Deniz Gursoy, an author of
books on raki and meze, at Safa, the city’s oldest meyhane. With
whirling fans, burnished mirrors and pictures of Atatürk striking
Hollywood poses, the place feels like a souvenir from another era.
When Safa opened some 125 ago, Gursoy explains, meze came free with
consumption, consisting of basics like anchovies, pickled cabbage, a
tiny börek and a bowl of leblebi, or dried chickpeas. Today, the
repertoire seems inexhaustible.

Akin explains that flavors Westerners usually associate with Middle
Eastern cuisines — bulgur, pomegranate molasses, lavish spicing,
hummus, kebabs — are rather new to Istanbul, a consequence of the
enormous influx of immigrants from eastern Turkey.

Other classic meze we sample reflect the city’s historical layers of
cultures. Delicious fried liver nuggets, with wisps of raw onion and
a dusting of sumac, hail from the Balkans. The plaki is Greek, Gursoy
notes, referring to a classic cold preparation in which beans or fish
are simmered in tomato sauce sweetened with onions and cinnamon. Jews
might have contributed zeytinyagli, an iconic cold meze of
vegetables, such as artichokes or leeks, braised slowly in water and
olive oil with a little sugar until they melt in the mouth.

And though raki still reigns, these days, younger Turks are just as
likely to sip a locally made Cabernet or a dry Muscat with their
meze.

It is actually on Istanbul’s Asian side, at a humble joint called
Çiya, that I discover the city’s most exciting small dishes. Little
surprise, because chef-owner Musa Dageviren hails from Gaziantep, a
city near the Syrian border renowned for Turkey’s finest cuisine.

Each of his dishes vibrates with flavor: A simple tomato and parsley
salad comes alive with a sprinkling of pungent orange-hued powder
made from dried curd cheese. Grape leaves are filled with dried
onions, bulgur and pomegranate syrup. Boiled wheat berries and
home-pickled green tomatoes sport a creamy cloak of dense, tart
yogurt.

“Gaziantep doesn’t have a meze tradition per se,” Dageviren explains,
“but small dishes are normally served at kebab houses. At home, cooks
often fashion light cold meals from leftovers.”

Lacking white-gloved waiters or a grandma from Gaziantep, a meze
spread is still easy to improvise. The rich thick Turkish yogurt
alone — which can be replicated in the United States by draining
good-quality yogurt in a cheesecloth-lined sieve — provides a dozen
simple ideas. Stir in some crushed garlic, minced herbs and grated
cucumbers and spread it on pita. Or fold it into shredded beets,
sautéed zucchini or the chopped smoky flesh of an eggplant that has
been grilled whole over charcoal (and why not sprinkle some toasted
almond on top?). Alternatively, a dollop of yogurt can top fried
eggplant or zucchini slices.

Bulgur also makes a fine meze, say as a salad tossed with chickpeas,
tomatoes, parsley and mint and drizzled with pomegranate molasses and
olive oil. The mandatory raki accompaniment of feta and honeydew
melon becomes elegant when cut into cubes and threaded on long wooden
skewers. Not to forget olives, pistachios, good, creamy feta and
roasted chickpeas. And unless you have a bottle of raki that’s been
burning a hole in your liquor cabinet, try Greek ouzo, Pernod, a
fruity, light red wine (slightly chilled) or a crisp, delicate white
(no oaky Chardonnay, please).

Still, raki is our drink as Akin and I prepare a meze feast on her
boat for an indolent Aegean voyage. As for the menu, our plan is to
test-run the best meze recipes we’ve collected from parties and
restaurants. From Tugra, the palatial Ottoman restaurant at
Istanbul’s Çiragan Palace hotel, we steal the idea of wrapping
haloumi cheese in grape leaves, grilling them and serving this
unusual dolma drizzled with pomegranate molasses. A hit.

A floating feast

>>From the shipping tycoon’s party we’ve emerged with a recipe for
müjver, crisp zucchini pancakes, which we make cocktail-sized, with
the addition of the nontraditional baking soda — for puffier
fritters. In Akin’s hands, the ubiquitous köfte, or meatballs, turn
out studded with nuts and laced with herbs.

Suddenly, Akin confesses that she’s never made topik, my favorite
Armenian chickpea pâté filled with caramelized onions, currants and
pine nuts and dusted with cinnamon. A flurry of phone calls to
Armenian matriarchs. Akin nods and scribbles furiously. She got it.
Except we are not shaping it by spreading the chickpea purée on a wet
muslin cloth with a rolling pin, as tradition dictates. A shortcut
will do.

The table is finally set on the deck under a vast starry sky. Akin’s
husband, Nuri, proffers a CD with fasil, the traditional meyhane
music.

“You pour, we drink,” the song blasts. We take the cue. A sip, a
nibble, a gulp — and luckily no one falls in the water. Luckier
still, we don’t have far to go. No need for a hamal, a porter who in
Ottoman times would wait by the meyhane doors to deliver the
inebriated back to their families.

*

Topik (layered garbanzo bean pâté )

Total time: 1½ hours, plus chilling time

Servings: Makes 9 squares

2/3cups dried Zante currants

1/4cup mild olive oil

4 cups chopped white onions (medium dice)

1 teaspoon cinnamon, plus more for sprinkling the pâté

3/4 teaspoon ground allspice

1/2 cup toasted pine nuts

3 cups canned garbanzo beans, well drained, liquid

reserved

3 tablespoons tahini paste, room temperature, well stirred

2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice

2 medium-sized yellow-fleshed potatoes, peeled and boiled

Salt

1. Place the currants in a medium bowl, add boiling water to a level
one-half inch above the currants and let them stand for 30 minutes.
Drain and reserve the soaking liquid.

2. In a large skillet, heat the oil over medium-high heat. Add onions
and cook, stirring, until they begin to soften, about 7 minutes.
Reduce heat to medium-low and continue cooking, stirring
occasionally, until onions are soft and very lightly browned, about
15 to 20 minutes, adding 2 to 3 tablespoons of the currant soaking
liquid when onions begin to look dry.

3. Add the currants and another 2 to 3 tablespoons of their soaking
liquid and cook for 5 more minutes, stirring. Stir in the cinnamon
and allspice and cook for 2 more minutes. Remove from heat and let
the mixture cool to room temperature. Stir in the pine nuts.

4. In a food processor, purée the garbanzo beans in 2 batches with
the tahini, lemon juice and 4 to 5 tablespoons of the bean liquid
until very smooth. Scrape the mixture into a large bowl.

5. Mash the potatoes until smooth with a potato masher or pass
through a ricer. Stir the mashed potatoes into the puréed mixture and
mix thoroughly. Season with salt.

6. Line an 8-inch square baking pan with plastic wrap, leaving 4 to 5
inches of overhang on all sides. Wet your hands with cold water and
use them to spread half of the garbanzo mixture evenly on the bottom.
Spread the onion mixture evenly on top; it will be a rather thick
layer. With wet hands, spread the other half of the garbanzo mixture
on top of that. Fold in the overhang to enclose the pâté. Weight the
pâté with a small cast-iron skillet, a plate topped with two 16-ounce
cans or something of similar weight, and refrigerate for 2 to 3
hours.

7. To serve, bring the pâté to room temperature, invert it onto a
serving plate and remove the plastic wrap. Sprinkle the top lightly
with cinnamon (you can do this decoratively through a doily). Cut
into squares.

Each serving: 306 calories; 9 grams protein; 41 grams carbohydrates;
7 grams fiber; 14 grams fat; 2 grams saturated fat; 0 cholesterol;
246 mg. sodium.

*

Herbed zucchini and feta fritters

Total time: 1 hour, 30 minutes, plus refrigerator time

Servings: 36 fritters

1 1/2 cups plain yogurt, preferably full-fat organic

1 large garlic clove, crushed through a garlic press

Salt

1 pound zucchini (about 2 large), shredded in a food processor using
a three-eighths-inch hole

4 ounces feta, grated

1/3cup minced dill

1/3cup minced parsley

1/4 cup thinly sliced mint leaves

2/3cup flour

3/4 teaspoon baking powder

2 large eggs, beaten

Mild olive oil for frying

1. Place yogurt in a small sieve lined with cheesecloth and set over
a bowl. Drain in the refrigerator for 2 hours or overnight.

2. Place drained yogurt in a bowl, stir in garlic and salt to taste
and let mixture stand at room temperature while preparing fritters.

3. Place shredded zucchini in a fine sieve and press hard against the
sieve to extract as much liquid as possible. In a large bowl, mix
zucchini, feta, dill, parsley and mint and stir until well combined.

4. Sift flour and baking powder into bowl. Add half of mixture to the
eggs and stir to form a smooth paste. Stir paste into zucchini and
combine thoroughly. Sprinkle in the rest of the flour mixture and
stir in well. Let stand for about 10 minutes. Stir again.

5. Line a cookie sheet with paper towels. In a 12-inch skillet, heat
1 inch of oil to 375 degrees, or until a drop of batter sizzles on
contact. Drop 3 (1-tablespoon) portions of batter into oil without
overcrowding and flatten lightly with the back of a spoon. Fry until
deep golden and crusty, about 1 1/2 minutes per side. With a slotted
spoon, transfer fritters to the paper towels to drain and continue to
fry remaining fritters. Serve hot or warm, with the yogurt dip.

Each fritter: 50 calories; 2 grams protein; 3 grams carbohydrates;

0 fiber; 4 grams fat; 1 gram saturated fat; 16 mg. cholesterol; 52
mg. sodium.

*

Herbed köfte with tahini sauce

Total time: 45 minutes plus 1 hour chilling time

Servings: 42 meatballs

Note: Sumac is available at Middle Eastern markets.

Tahini sauce

1/2 cup tahini paste, well stirred

1/2 cup chicken broth

1/4 cup fresh lemon juice

1 teaspoon ground cumin

1 teaspoon mild paprika

1. Combine tahini, chicken broth, lemon juice, cumin and paprika,
stirring well.

Meatballs

2 slices white sandwich bread, crusts removed

1/2 pound ground beef

1/2 pound ground lamb

1 medium onion, grated

1 heaping teaspoon salt

1 1/2 teaspoons ground cumin

Large pinch ground allspice

1 teaspoon crushed red pepper

3/4 teaspoon black pepper

3/4 cup minced parsley

1/2 cup finely chopped mint

1 cup toasted walnut pieces

2 tablespoons mild olive oil

1/2 red onion, very thinly sliced

Minced parsley or sumac for garnish

Tahini sauce

1. Dip the bread in cold water and squeeze dry against the bottom of
a fine sieve. In a large bowl, mix bread with beef, lamb, onion,
salt, cumin, allspice, red pepper and black pepper. Mix thoroughly,
but avoid overhandling. Refrigerate for 1 hour.

2. Mix in parsley, mint and walnuts with your hands and shape mixture
into balls.

3. Heat 1 tablespoon oil over medium heat in a large skillet. Add
half the meatballs and sauté until browned and cooked through, about
7 minutes. Regulate heat so meatballs don’t burn, and shake pan
vigorously to turn them. Transfer to paper towels. Wipe skillet and
repeat with remaining oil and meatballs.

4. Top with onions. Garnish and serve hot or warm, with tahini sauce.

Each meatball: 69 calories;

3 grams protein; 2 grams carbohydrates; 0 fiber; 6 grams fat; 1 gram
saturated fat; 7 mg. cholesterol; 78 mg. sodium.

*

Grilled haloumi-stuffed grape leaves with pomegranate sauce

Total time: 25 minutes

Servings: Makes 12 dolmas

Note: Haloumi cheese is available at Bristol Farms and at Middle
Eastern markets. Haloumi and grape leaves can both be quite salty; if
your brand of leaves is too briny, soak them longer or blanch in
boiling water for 1 minute.

12 grape leaves preserved in brine

12 (3-inch by one-half-inch) logs haloumi cheese, one-half-inch thick
(queso blanco can be substituted)

2 1/2 tablespoons mild olive oil,

divided

2 tablespoons pomegranate molasses

1 tablespoon water

1/4 teaspoon sugar

1. Place the grape leaves in a bowl. Add boiling water to cover and
soak for about 2 minutes. Taste, and if the leaves still taste
assertively briny, soak for few minutes more. Rinse under cold water,
drain and pat dry with paper towels. Heat the grill to medium.

2. Place a grape leaf shiny side down on a work surface with the stem
facing you. Trim off the stem. Place a log of haloumi across the
bottom end of the leaf and fold the bottom over it. Fold in the sides
and roll up like a cigar to make a dolma. Make sure there are no
tears in the leaf, or the cheese will ooze out. Continue until you
have used all the grape leaves.

3. Brush the dolmas lightly with one-half tablespoon olive oil. Grill
them until they are lightly charred and the cheese is beginning to
soften but is not oozing out, about 1½ minutes per side. Transfer the
dolmas to a plate and let them cool for about 10 minutes.

4. Meanwhile, whisk the remaining oil with the pomegranate molasses,
water and sugar.

5. To serve, drizzle a white serving plate with the pomegranate
mixture and arrange the dolmas on top, drizzling with some extra
sauce if desired.

Each dolma: 246 calories; 14 grams protein; 3 grams carbohydrates;

0 fiber; 20 grams fat; 11 grams saturated fat; 50 mg. cholesterol;
418 mg. sodium.

Which Of Two TV Channels To Be Retransmitted?

WHICH OF TWO TV CHANNELS TO BE RETRANSMITTED?

A1 Plus | 16:22:11 | 08-06-2004 | Social |

After months of being turned off, the 23 UHF transmitter was
unexpectedly turned on today.

Testing signal appeared on the screen although no programs are being
broadcast.

The head of Radio and Television National Commission Grigor Amalyan
said recently in his interview with our correspondent that the
Commission won’t decide programs of which of the two Russian channels –
NTV or Culture – will be retransmitted on that broadcasting frequency.

NTV channel’s programs retransmitted before that. Some sources say
Armenian government gave an instruction to the Commission not to
announce tender for the frequency until negotiations with Culture
channel are completed. And what is the reason for today’s switching
on? Our correspondent tried to get the answer from NTV-retransmitting
Paradise Company, called there and had “an interesting talk” with
one of the company staff.

Question: Which TV channel will be retransmitted?

Answer: I don’t know.

Q.: What programs will be retransmitted?
A.: Don’t know.

Q.: If so, then why was the signal switched on?
A.: Don’t know.

Q.: Could we talk to the head of the company?
A.: He’s absent.

Q.: Maybe his deputy is present?
A.: He isn’t empowered to answer questions.

Q.: And maybe you are empowered?
A.: Call to Radio and Television National Commission.

So, the retransmission fate is still obscure and Paradise seems to
be absolutely not involved in decision-making process. At least the
conversation with the company employee is quite puzzling.

Partis =?UNKNOWN?B?4A==?= 44, nous revenons =?UNKNOWN?Q?=E0_18?=

Référence: Le Figaro, spécial 6 juin 1944

Ce parachutiste américain avait 19 ans quand il sauta sur Sainte-Mère-Eglise

Howard Manaoian.
(Photo J.- C. Marmara/Le Figaro.)

Howard Manaoian : «Partis à 44, nous revenons à 18»

Propos recueillis par Thiébault Dromard
[02 juin 2004]

Il a choisi la France. Caporal chef de l’infanterie parachutiste,
Howard Manoian a 19 ans quand il est parachuté au-dessus du petit
village normand de Sainte-Mère-Eglise. Le Figaro l’a retrouvé
soixante ans après dans cette bourgade du Cotentin, où il a établi sa
résidence principale depuis 1992. D’origine arménienne, cet enfant du
Massachusetts avoue apprécier le calme de la campagne normande, sauf
à la veille de chaque anniversaire du débarquement. Ses souvenirs de
la bataille de Normandie sont intacts. Il nous livre ici le journal
de ces heures et de ces jours historiques.

4 et 5 juin

«La tempête fait rage. Le vent et la pluie balayent le tarmac du camp
d’aviation située à quelques encablures de Leicester, en Angleterre. La
météo n’est pas de la partie. Ce n’est pas tant la pluie qui nous
inquiète, que les bourrasques de vent qui s’amplifient au fur et à
mesure de la journée du 4 juin. Le vent, c’est sans doute le pire
ennemi des parachutistes. Nous sommes pourtant prêts à y aller. Les
manœuvres, nous les connaissons par cœur pour les avoir répétées de
longs mois, ici, de l’autre côté du Channel. Mais la décision tombe, le
Débarquement est reporté de 24 heures. Une journée de plus à attendre,
à imaginer le pire, à ressasser les consignes dans notre tête, à
feuilleter, sans réelle motivation, le dictionnaire anglais-français
que la logistique nous a remis dans notre paquetage. La peur est
là. Nous connaissons tous les statistiques, un parachutiste sur
deux meurt avant d’avoir foulé le sol. Dans sa grande «générosité»,
l’Etat américain nous accorde d’ailleurs une sorte de prime de risque
mensuelle de 50 dollars.

Le 5 juin au soir, comme prévu, une légère amélioration se
dessine. Cette fois-ci, c’est la bonne. Dans quelques heures, nous
survolerons la Manche, puis les côtes normandes. Dans mon esprit,
dans celui de tous mes camarades, cette opération doit être de courte
durée. Pas question de s’attarder en France. Le débarquement achevé,
nous foncerons sur Berlin, notre ultime objectif.

Nuit du 5 au 6 juin

L’avion décolle vers 1 heure du matin et gagne rapidement le Cotentin,
distant d’à peine 200 kilomètres de notre base. Mon bataillon, le 505e
régiment, a pour objectif principal de prendre un pont qui enjambe
la petite rivière de Merderet, un affluent de la Douve, située à 3
ou 4 kilomètres de Sainte-Mère-Eglise. L’avion entame sa descente,
il a prévu de nous faire sauter au plus bas, c’est-à-dire à 200 mètres
d’altitude maximum.

Je saute parmi les derniers. Mauvais présage, ou hasard d’un
pilotage imprécis, j’atterris au beau milieu du cimetière de
l’église du village. Je ramasse rapidement mon paquetage et décampe
de ce lieu inhospitalier. Je retrouve avec bonheur trois de mes
camarades. Mais la joie des retrouvailles est vite effacée par la
riposte allemande. L’alerte a été donnée, les batteries de la Werhmacht
s’exécutent. J’essaye de prendre contact avec le reste de ma compagnie,
mais la connexion de ma radio est défectueuse.

Le combat de position fait rage dans les rues de Sainte-Mère-Eglise. On
progresse très lentement, rue après rue, quartier par quartier.

6 juin

Le jour se lève et la lumière expose à nu les dures réalités de la
guerre. Les corps s’amoncellent déjà dans les rues, les blessés se
comptent par dizaines. Des fermes transformées en hôpitaux de fortune
accueillent les éclopés.

Un officier américain vient me trouver. Il a besoin de renfort
pour prendre le château de Fauville, quartier général des
officiers allemands. Cette solide bâtisse est située à la sortie de
Sainte-Mère-Eglise, sur la route de Carentan. Pris par surprise, dans
son sommeil, l’ennemi oppose une résistance passive à notre assaut. En
une demi-heure, l’affaire est bouclée, et les 40 officiers sont sous
notre contrôle. Six parachutistes sont affectés à la surveillance
du château.

Pour ma part, je regagne le nord de Sainte-Mère-Eglise, où une poche
de résistance sévit. Nous partons à 44, nous revenons, le 7 au matin,
à 18 de cette sanglante boucherie. Le commandant du bataillon, le
sergent Robert Nyland, qui avait débarqué quelques heures plus tôt
à Utah Beach, est mort.

7 juin

La journée entière est consacrée à la libération de
Sainte-Mère-Eglise. Le combat de rue est intense.

Bientôt, la ville ressemble à un champ de ruines. Cela fait maintenant
près de deux jours que j’ai été parachuté. Deux jours sans aucune
nouvelle du reste de ma compagnie, basée à 4 kilomètres d’ici, en rase
campagne. Nous tentons pourtant d’établir une communication mais nos
radios ont été mal montées et rien ne fonctionne. Il faut attendre la
fin de la journée du 7 juin pour que nous puissions enfin réaliser que
nous maîtrisons la situation. La résistance allemande est bien plus
forte que nous l’imaginions. Demain, nous pourrons enfin rejoindre
nos camarades.

8 juin

Nous quittons Sainte-Mère-Eglise au petit matin. Mais avant de laisser
cette bourgade derrière nous, il nous faut absolument trouver un point
d’eau. Plus que faim, nous avons terriblement soif. Je n’ai pas bu
depuis trois jours. Je frappe à une porte. Je ne parle pas un mot
de français. Un homme m’ouvre. Je lui montre mon drapeau américain
à l’épaule pour le rassurer. Je tourne fébrilement les pages de mon
dictionnaire pour trouver les mots qui me donneront à boire. «Je
veux boire…», je n’ai pas le temps de dire de l’eau que l’homme
apporte une bouteille enveloppée d’un papier journal de sorte que
je ne parviens pas bien à en distinguer le contenu. Il me sert alors
généreusement de son liquide, qui a une couleur bien jaunâtre. Je me
souviens alors que la logistique nous avait mis en garde sur le fait
que l’eau, dans la plupart des villages de France, n’est pas potable.

Je sors alors deux comprimés purificateurs. J’attends qu’ils fassent
leur effet, et avale à grandes gorgées ce breuvage. J’ai à peine le
temps de réaliser qu’il s’agissait d’un alcool fort que je suffoque
et manque de m’étouffer. Je comprends que cet homme a cherché à
m’empoisonner. Je pointe ma mitraillette sur lui, mais il m’explique
tant bien que mal qu’il m’a servi une sorte de brandy à la pomme
appelé calvados. Pour m’excuser, je lui offre mes cigarettes.

Nous arrivons en début d’après-midi à destination et retrouvons avec
joie le reste de mes camarades. Mais rapidement, je constate que notre
compagnie accuse de lourdes pertes. Le bilan est effroyable. Deux
cents soldats ont sauté sur le pont le 6 juin. Deux jours après, il
n’en reste que 60 debout. 80 sont gravement blessés, 60 ont péri au
combat. Postés sur l’autre rive de la rivière, trois chars allemands
ont riposté pendant deux jours sans discontinuer. Il s’agit d’engins
français de la marque Renault, que les Allemands se sont procurés dès
1940. Deux d’entre eux ont explosé à la suite de tirs de bazooka,
le troisième a pris la fuite pour contourner notre front et nous
attaquer par-derrière. Il n’a pas eu le temps de faire de dégâts
car nous l’avons intercepté et anéanti avant même qu’il ne tire sa
première salve.

9 juin

Première grande victoire, nous parvenons enfin à traverser ce
petit pont de pierre et à gagner l’autre rive de cette rivière,
la Merderet. Nous pouvons maintenant poursuivre notre avancée plein
ouest et contrôler une partie non négligeable de la presqu’île du
Cotentin. Nous gagnons enfin concrètement du terrain. Nous pouvons
désormais considérer que le Débarquement s’est achevé pour laisser
la place à la bataille de Normandie».

Howard Manoian est blessé gravement pour la première fois le 17 juin,
à Saint-Sauveur-le-Vicomte. Une balle lui traverse la paume de la main,
de sorte «qu’on pouvait voir à travers». Il est également touché aux
deux jambes. Il est transféré dans un hôpital de campagne aménagé
sur la plage d’Utah Beach. Le sort s’abat une nouvelle fois sur lui
à sa sortie de l’hôpital. Un chasseur allemand mitraille la plage
en rase-mottes et le blesse à l’autre main. Pendant que le 505e
régiment libère le sud de la Manche, et notamment la Haye-du-Puit,
Howard Manoian est transféré en Angleterre par navire-hôpital, et
placé en convalescence jusqu’au 13 septembre. Il participe ensuite à
la campagne de Hollande, puis à celle des Ardennes, particulièrement
éprouvante. «Je n’ai jamais eu aussi froid», confie-t-il.

Howard Manoian ne marchera pas sur Berlin, il sera arrêté de nouveau
dans sa course par une grave blessure en mars 1945, qui l’oblige à
regagner définitivement les Etats-Unis. Il foule le sol américain le
10 mai, et savoure six semaines de permission.

Au lendemain de la guerre, Howard Manoian quitte l’armée. Il devient
gardien de prison, fonction dans laquelle il «s’ennuie à mourir». Il
quitte l’administration pénitentiaire pour exercer le métier de
policier pendant 32 ans.

http://www.lefigaro.fr/6juin/20040602.FIG0382.html

School to welcome new principal

School to welcome new principal

Metz to take reins at SoPas Middle

By Mary Bender , Staff Writer

Friday, June 04, 2004
Pasadena Star News

SOUTH PASADENA — A school that has become the district’s focal
point will get a new principal this summer, as the board of
education Thursday night unanimously hired a Glendale assistant
principal. Mercedes Metz, who works at Woodrow Wilson Middle School in
Glendale, will take the reins of South Pasadena Middle School, perhaps
as early as July 1. Her salary will range from $85,344 to $92,379.

“Her students describe her as ‘cool,’ ‘ Superintendent Mike Hendricks
said, introducing Metz to the five-member board, also noting that
she is “highly organized.’ Metz was one of 25 candidates.

“Thank you for this vote of confidence. I’m thrilled to be here,’
Metz told the board.

“The future is going to be bright,’ she said, pledging to uphold
“rigorous standards’ at the middle school, “in an environment that’s
going to be truly nurturing.’

About 1,000 sixth- , seventh- and eighth-graders are enrolled at South
Pasadena Middle School. The campus will undergo a major expansion
and renovation in the coming years, a project to be paid for with a
$29 million bond approved by voters in 2002.

The school board and district staff are in the thick of planning and
environmental review for the project.

Metz is a 10-year veteran of Glendale Unified, where she began her
career as a substitute teacher. She then won a permanent teaching
post at John Muir Elementary School in 1995.

She began transitioning into administrative work in 1999, with posts at
Eleanor Toll Middle School, before moving to the assistant principal’s
office at Wilson in 2001.

“She’s a very hard worker (and) she’s very bright. I’m losing a very
good person. She’ll certainly be missed here,’ said Richard Lucas,
principal at Wilson.

“I’ve seen her grow in three years quite a bit, and I think she’ll
be a wonderful principal there.’

Wilson has 1,286 students, mostly seventh- and eighth-graders, with
just a smattering of sixth- graders who win the right to enroll under
a district lottery, Lucas said.

The Glendale campus is racially diverse, with Armenian students
accounting for 34 percent of the enrollment, Latinos 24 percent, Asians
predominantly Korean 12 percent, and Filipinos 7 percent, Lucas said.

It’s not clear when Metz’s duties will be complete at Wilson, because
she had been named principal of the summer school, which runs June
30 to Aug. 6.

The principal’s post at South Pasadena Middle School had been
the center of controversy as the April 28 application deadline
approached. Parents and a open-meeting watchdog criticized the work
of an eight- member committee, appointed by school board President
Tammy Godley to help encourage qualified candidates to apply.

In recent years, there has been considerable turnover among the
middle school’s principals: Rich Boccia served one year before
returning to the Pasadena Unified School District, and Katy Schneider,
his successor, won the job two years ago. Schneider submitted her
resignation in March.

Meanwhile, 28 people applied to become South Pasadena Unified School
District’s next superintendent. The application deadline was May 27.

Hendricks’ last day is June 30; in a closed-door meeting in February,
the school board decided not to renew his contract. Godley said
Thursday night that the field will be whittled to 10 superintendent
candidates, who will be interviewed next week.

— Mary Bender can be reached at (626) 578-6300, Ext. 4456 or by
e-mail at [email protected] .

Counter Charges: Sentencing in April 13 case evokes anger and action

Counter Charges: Sentencing in April 13 case evokes anger and action
By Vahan Ishkhanyan, ArmeniaNow reporter

ArmeniaNow.com, 4 June 2004

The conviction of a man charged with hitting police with a plastic
bottle has sparked action from human rights agencies, has led to two
activists’ arrests for putting up leaflets calling for his release,
and has even led some individuals to write confessions that they are
guilty of the same crime.

Protestors outside court brought symbolic Jermuk bottles…

Last week an Armenian court sentenced Edgar Arakelyan, 24, to 18
months in prison for striking police with a plastic Jermuk water
bottle while police were breaking up a political demonstration in
the early hours of April 13.

Arakelyan pled guilty to charges (which originally called for a two
and a half year sentence), but argued that he used the bottle for
defense only after police had sprayed the crowd with tear gas and
had hit him with a baton, breaking out his front teeth.

In protest of Arakelyan’s arrest and conviction, about 2 a.m. Sunday,
25-year old Harut Alaverdyan and 24-year old Hakob Hakobyan went
along Mashtots Avenue pasting posters saying “Freedom for Edgar”
onto utility poles.

The young men were arrested, held in jail overnight, and on Tuesday
charged in court with malicious disobedience of a legal order or
demand made by police, and with “blasphemy”.

The men, one a university student and the other a post-graduate, say
they became nervous when police approached them, and offered to remove
the posters they’d pasted. Instead, they were taken into custody.

“We were attaching the last leaflet when two policemen approached
us and asked why we were attaching them,” Alaverdyan said. “I said,
‘If it goes against the law then I can tear them off’. Then a third
policeman came up to us. He had already torn a leaflet off. They
demanded us to follow them to a police station. I asked, ‘What we
are accused of?’ But they said, ‘Follow us, you will find out there.'”

According to the men, they were told not to hire a lawyer as police
would appoint one anyway and hiring a lawyer would cost too much. They
signed a document saying they refused hiring an attorney.

The following day a lawyer and the chairman of the Helsinki Committee
of Armenia visited the men and arranged for their release, after
Alaverdyan and Hakobyan signed a statement saying they would return
for a hearing.

In a courtroom that, three hours before trial, was already filled
to standing, attorney Argshti Kiviryan (who took the case for free)
argued that the men were exercising their rights to freedom of
speech. Kiviryan asked policeman Karapet Barseghyan why the men
were charged.

The lawyer reminded that, according to constitution, a person has a
right to freely spread his or her points of view and then asked why
the policeman’s demand to tear off the leaflets was legal. Policeman
Barseghyan kept silent for a long time and never answered the
question. Judge Saribek Aramyan helped him. The judge withdrew
the question and said attaching leaflets was not an illegal act and
therefore it was not an offense. The lawyer made a motion to close the
case based on the conclusion that the police had acted without cause.

The judge agreed, but did, however, impose a 1500 dram (about $2.70)
fine on Alaverdyan (he printed the leaflets) and a 1000 dram fine
(about $1.80) on Hakobyan, saying that the defendants “demonstrated
disobedience of the legal demand made by policemen”.

The court hearing was attended by several protestors who held signs
saying “No to police-ridden state”, “Don’t be afraid”, “No to state
terrorism”. Some held Jermuk bottles.

Human rights’ activists say the young men’s arrests is an example of
police abuse of power and an overall effort by authorities to silence
criticism of the Government by the political opposition.

“It became clear to all parties of the case and to police and to the
judge that the boys hadn’t committed any crime,” says chairman of
the Helsinki Committee Avetik Ishkhanyan. “However, the court would
have never closed the case as it would have meant that policemen had
made a mistake and in its turn it would have immobilized police in
conducting political persecutions.”

Ishkhanyan says that the court imposing even a symbolic fine (for a
charge that the court itself ruled to be unfounded) is evidence that
“police has more power than the court.”

***

Tigran Ter-Yesayan, head of the International Union of Armenian
Lawyers, says that official data shows that this year more than
400 people have been subjected by court verdicts to administrative
imprisonments and penalties for participating at oppositional
demonstrations. Ter-Yesayan says the true number is higher, but that
court records were not kept in all cases.

ArmeniaNow asked the Ministry of Justice for a list of the
convictions. “We have no resources and possibilities for preparing
such lists,” says Press Secretary of the Ministry of Justice Ara
Saghatelyan.

Hakobyan and Alaverdyan’s trial was an exception to the normal hearings
of those accused of similar politically-motivated misdemeanors.

Ter-Yesayan said he knows of only one case in which the accused was
represented by an attorney and that most of the hearings have been
held with only court administrators and police present.

“Hearings are private, as people don’t know where their relatives
are so that they could go and at least be present at hearings,”
Ter-Yesayan says.

Besides being subjected to administrative imprisonments and penalties
criminal cases have been started against 12 people – seven have been
released, four are in jail (including Arakelyan).

A number of non-governmental organizations were conducting mass
meetings every day in front of the building of Prosecutor General
Office of Armenia demanding that they are set free. Alaverdyan
participated in the demonstrations.

“It seemed to police that I was from the opposition,” he says. “But
I’m not engaged in any political party. The verdict against Edgar was
simply unjust and it didn’t correspond to what he had done. That’s
why I decided to begin attaching leaflets.”

After Arakelyan’s verdict and sentencing was announced, three people
who had helped organize the demonstration that turned violent April
13 sent declarations to police, stating their own guilt at having
committed such acts.

“I decided to own to the following: On April 12-13 I also took
part in a peaceful demonstration taken place on Baghramyan Avenue,
during which police of the free and independent Republic of Armenia
in subjected us, demonstrators, to beatings. I also hit law-abiding
officer with an empty Jermuk bottle (plastic).”

The statement is intended to express solidarity for the convicted.

“I made this statement because I was present at hearings and recalled
that I had also a hit policeman,” says Lala Aslikyan, who works for
World Study Organization.

“It is absurd when police break teeth and beat peaceful demonstrators,
who came only for expressing their opinions,” Aslikayan says. “And
after that, police remain unpunished while the demonstrator with
broken teeth is sentenced to one and a half years of imprisonment
for hitting one of those policemen with an empty plastic bottle.”

The world wars that time forgot

The Observer/Guardian (UK)
May 23 2004

The world wars that time forgot

BBC director of news Richard Sambrook on a documentary series that
features people for whom war is part of daily life

Sunday May 23, 2004
The Observer

Every minute of the day two people die somewhere in the world as a
result of war. Not only do most of us not know who dies, we hardly
know the wars that claim their lives. For many of those caught up in
conflict it is because of a decision they have made: to join the army
or a rebel group. For many others, there is no choice and little
hope.
Take the Hmong fighters deep in the jungles of Laos and still
persecuted for helping the Americans in the Secret War. The father of
a young family surviving on sawdust noodles and moving daily to
escape attack says: ‘One day the leaders of the international
community will come and rescue us. If they don’t nothing will
change.’ As I say, faint hope.

Television often portrays wars as exceptional and highly charged
events. The reality for hundreds of thousands of ordinary people is
anything but exceptional – it is part of how they live their daily
lives and encompasses boredom and drudgery alongside death.

How as journalists and broadcasters can we help people to understand
these conflicts and how they affect ordinary lives? One Day of War,
the first programme in the new series of BBC2’s This World, follows
individual fighters in 16 conflicts over the same 24-hour period. It
is a new approach, intended to be less remote than conventional
foreign affairs coverage, allowing viewers to get to know, if only
slightly, the individuals at war and their hopes, fears and
motivation. Of paramount importance to This World editor Karen
O’Connor and series producer Will Daws is to convey the fighters’
stories in their own words and to show the full 360 degrees of their
lives; the struggles but also their concerns for family, trying to
feed themselves and their sense of humour.

The day chosen was 22 March, when Hamas leader Sheikh Yassin was
killed by the Israelis. That made the day’s headlines, but much else
didn’t.

We meet Grace, an 18-year-old fighter with the New People’s Army in
the Philippines. She wanted to be a teacher, but couldn’t afford the
fees. She joined the rebels on New Year’s Day and now has two
choices: kill or be killed.

On the Black Sea a Georgian navy captain is trying to cadge fish off
passing ships to feed his crew as they sail an improbable rustbucket
to blockade the Abkhazian rebels. ‘I love work, I love women, I love
beer,’ he declares, but as night falls his discomfort and the danger
grow. In Nepal we accompany a 24-year-old woman Maoist rebel on her
first active mission armed with a flintlock rifle more suited to the
Napoleonic wars. ‘Ideology is our weapon,’ she suggests, but in a
quieter moment talks lovingly of the grandmother who raised her and
who she misses at night.

And in Somalia we follow a child soldier collecting money at
roadblocks to fund his militia. He takes us to the house where his
parents were killed by a mortar. It was better when they were alive,
he tells us. He could play football and go to school. He longs to do
something positive for his country, but charm and aspiration are not
enough to survive in Somalia.

In Chechnya, Russian troops on mine-sweeping duty used to put wooden
crosses at the side of the road where a colleague had fallen. ‘Now no
one bothers. We have to have a collection to buy a coffin to send
them back to Moscow,’ says one. Nine hundred Russian troops have died
in Chechnya, plus, it is estimated, 15,000 rebels and 100,000
civilians.

Last February I met the 16 teams who were going out to film One Day
of War as they gathered in London for safety briefings and final
logistics. They comprised a highly experienced group of cameramen and
producers, all motivated by the idea of contributing to a unique
film, a snapshot of the world in a way that had never been attempted
before. They are largely unknown to the audiences who benefit from
their work. The risks to them were considerable, and I salute their
courage and professionalism.

This project and its approach are the latest extension of what the
BBC has seen as part of its core mission since it began broadcasting
in 1922. ‘Let nation speak unto nation’ is emblazoned on the BBC
crest. ‘Making sense of the world’ is how BBC News has more recently
defined its purpose. Once a team of seven or eight people would be
needed to film overseas and ship – literally – the film back to
London for developing and printing. Today we can broadcast live from
anywhere on the planet. Last year we saw live coverage of fighting in
Iraq. But it doesn’t follow that instant communication in a
globalised world makes our understanding any deeper.

Napoleon is said to have once declared: ‘If you had seen one day of
war, you would pray to God that you would never see another.’ Two
hundred years later, there are some corners of the world, little
discussed and under-reported, where that still holds true.

I believe the BBC’s commitment to world affairs, and its scale, make
it the only broadcaster that could attempt a project as ambitious as
this – venturing deep into the jungles, deserts and mountains of the
world, finding the most remote and dangerous conflicts, and allowing
the people there to speak for themselves. The film reminds us of half
forgotten names: Nagorno Karabakh, the FARC, the Hmong. While we
carry on with our lives, jobs, children, moving house, they carry on
fighting, sometimes for 40 or 50 years. If it sometimes seems
pointless we should make a little effort to get to know them and to
understand. There is a reason they go on – and in One Day of War they
tell us why.

thisworld

· ‘One Day of War’ will be shown on BBC2 at 9pm on Thursday

www.bbc.co.uk/

The bones talk, and she listens: Koff writes a sobering account of h

The Vancouver Sun (British Columbia)
May 22, 2004 Saturday Final Edition

The bones talk, and she listens: Clea Koff writes a sobering account
of her encounters with mass murder

by: Tom Hawthorn

One murder is a crime. One hundred murders, or one thousand, or ten
thousand, or tens of thousands are also crimes, although the enormity
of the wrongdoing is so great, so unbelievable, that it becomes
possible for the perpetrators to lie and cover up, making accomplices
of many others.

Hitler, the mass murderer against whom other monsters are measured,
knew this well. Preparing plans for the extermination of the European
Jews, he notoriously dismissed concerns about future world opinion.
“Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?”
he said. Indeed, when recently Canada’s House of Commons belatedly
condemned those deaths more than eight decades after the fact, the
vote was denounced by the Turkish government and its supporters as
being misinformed and unhelpful.

For survivors and grieving relatives, the horror of murder is
compounded by denying the fact.

Bearing witness is an antidote to such sickness. So, the Holocaust
memoir becomes a genre because it is necessary to count as many
survivors and name as many victims as possible, if we are to take
seriously the solemn promise of “never again.”

Yet the past decade has provided a brutal wake-up for those of us
under age 65 who have wondered how the world could ignore the
deliberate and organized slaughter of so many people.

In Rwanda, political leaders squawked orders for mass murder over the
radio. In Serbia, otherwise decent people suspended disbelief and
accepted government propaganda denying the existence of mass graves.
In Canada, we tsk-tsked over news of the latest atrocities, our sense
of moral superiority once again affirmed.

Even as a teenager, Clea Koff knew the world’s atrocities demanded a
response from her. Raised in Africa, England and the United States,
this daughter of a Tanzanian mother and an American father, both
documentary filmmakers, quips that she learned about the
lumpenproletariat at the supper table before she knew about Bert and
Ernie on television. Fascinated by the nature of death even as a
girl, she collected dead birds and studied them as a prelude to
backyard burial.

Koff found inspiration for a career as a forensic anthropologist from
two sources: a TV documentary on bodies preserved in the ash from an
eruption of Mount Vesuvius, and Clyde Snow’s book Witnesses from the
Grave: The Stories Bones Tell, which describes efforts to find the
remains of the “disappeared” victims of Argentina’s bloody military
junta of the 1970s and ’80s.

“I had known for years that my goal was to help end human rights
abuses by proving to would-be killers that bones can talk,” she
writes in The Bone Woman, a compelling personal chronicle of months
spent rooting around in mass graves.

Koff was sent to Africa in 1996 with the International Criminal
Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR), a United Nations organization formed to
bring the killers to justice. (She also worked for ICTY, the tribunal
for the former Yugoslavia.) She works with the remains of murder
victims, of which there is no shortage. The violence in Rwanda was so
widespread that it quickly claimed some 800,000 victims, the vast
majority killed by hand, usually by machete. Imagine every man, woman
and child in Vancouver and Burnaby hacked to death, some left to rot
where they fell, others thrown into pits and covered with dirt.

Koff finds Rwanda a beautiful, verdant land, where the serene setting
of the church at Kibuye masks the horror inflicted and a menace still
not dissipated.

While some skeletons display wounds to the arms and hands, others
bear only the fatal blows.

“The absence of defence wounds gave my image of that massacre an
eerie calmness; did people take the blows as though taking the
sacrament?”

She finds herself smiling a lot in Rwanda, an incongruous reaction to
so horrid a killing field. “It is because I see not just death —
about which I can do nothing — but bones and teeth and hair, which I
can do something about …”

Bones offer clues as to age, sex, height, ancestry and cause of
death. Koff and her colleagues scrape away dirt until they uncover
remains, exchanging a pickaxe for a trowel for a pair of chopsticks
for the delicate task of flicking dirt from between finger joints.

A rational scientist, Koff uses a poet’s eye in describing her
discoveries, noting in one case how “the big toe phalange [is] chunky
like a baby carrot, the other phalanges more like small licorice
pieces, held in anatomical position by a sock because the flesh of
the foot has decomposed.”

Descriptions of much of her work are not for the faint of heart, so
those of you now eating breakfast may wish to skip a few paragraphs.
Koff copes daily with ammonia fumes from intestines, as well as
saponified remains, a state of decomposition in which skin remains
tender. “If you puncture it, something not dissimilar to cottage
cheese came foaming out …”

The smells of decomposition — “one being sharp and ripe, the other
thick and ‘hairy'” — permeate her clothing, scents she cannot avoid
even while eating lunch.

These horrors fuel the nightmares she duly records, yet an event she
witnesses causes her greater distress.

One fine evening, Koff dines al fresco on the shores of Lake Kivu
when her reverie is disturbed by a sickening sight: two desperate men
in the water being shot to death by uniformed Rwandan soldiers. “I
couldn’t conceive of which ‘side’ they were on, or which side we were
thought to be on, or, indeed, if there were any sides.”

Seeking explanation, she is told the dead men were insurgents from
Zaire. The information is useless, for she has no means of judging
its accuracy.

“I hated the impotence of not being able to do more than just report
the killings and I hated the fear I now felt for my own life, even
though the bullets hadn’t been directed at me or my teammates. And,
insult upon insult, I hated the fact I got to leave this place so
easily.”

The Bone Woman was written from Koff’s journal entries — a strength
in retelling the small incidents of her labours, a weakness when
recounting the petty disputes one expects among colleagues working in
such hostile and unpalatable circumstances. She dislikes the teasing
she endures from teammates after telling a Reuters reporter that she
says to the uncovered skeletons: “We’re coming. We’re coming to take
you out.”

Her complaint is so overshadowed by the enormity of these crimes
against humanity as to seem callow and naive. And yet her reaction
may be understandable, given that she’s someone who spends her 24th
birthday up to her elbows in viscera.

Koff also exhumes bodies from mass graves in the former Yugoslavia
(“where the people who committed the crimes we would be uncovering
were still at large”) at Cerska, Nova Kasaba and a rubbish pit at
Ovcara, where missing men from the hospital at Vukovar had been
dumped.

“These bodies, by their very presence, were dismantling years of the
perpetrators’ propaganda that the grave didn’t exist, that the
missing men were probably larking about in Italy, that a crime
against humanity hadn’t taken place five years earlier,” she writes.

Her work does not so much bring resolution to the crimes, by
uncovering the assailants and having them punished, as restore
humanity to those whose lives were taken. Long after the book is
closed, a reader remembers the woman in Rwanda with pink plastic
necklaces; the hospital patient who secreted his X-rays in his
clothing (for identification after death? because he believed he was
going to another hospital?); the boy in Kosovo whose grave held
marbles — child’s playthings and a reminder of our necessary outrage
at his murder.

Tom Hawthorn is a Victoria reporter who last reviewed Lloyd
Axworthy’s book, Navigating a New World.

GRAPHIC: Photo: Pierre Heuts, From the book the bone woman; Clea Koff
(right) in Kigali, Rwanda, with UN scientific expert Bill Haglund.;
Photo: THE BONE WOMAN: A Forensic Anthropologist’s Search for Truth
in Rwanda, Bosnia, Croatia, and Kosovo BY CLEA KOFF, Knopf Canada,
271 pages ($34.95)