In Armen Bayburdian’s Words, Armenian-French Relations Are Not Accep

IN ARMEN BAYBURDIAN’S WORDS, ARMENIAN-FRENCH RELATIONS ARE NOT ACCEPTED UNEQUIVOCALLY, WHAT DOES NOT INFLUENCE POSITIVELY ON FRANCE

Noyan Tapan News Agency, Armenia
Nov 14 2006

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. The conference entitled "15 Years of
Independence of Armenia and France" taken place at the National Academy
of Sciences on November 14 on the initiative of the French Embassy to
Armenia and AOKS (Armenian Society for Cultural Links and Cooperation)
was dedicated to the Armenian-French historic-cultural ties.

Tsovinar Chaloyan-Hakobian, the AOKS "Armenia-France" company
chairwoman, mentioned that this conference organized by them is the
8th one and completely dedicated to the year of Armenia in France,
particularly to all the political and cultural developments and
achievements taken place after the independence of Armenia. The
speakers made speeches dedicated to the two countries’ political and
cultural cooperation and relations of 15 years, touching upon the
Armenian-French historic ties as well.

Armen Bayburdian, the RA Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs emphasized
that the Armenia-France interstate relations formed still from 1991
are much older and firmer in their basis. Those, according to historic
evidences, were formed still during the Crusades years.

And during the period of Napoleon Bonaparte’s ruling Armenians were
patronized just by the great conqueror.

Armen Bayburdian is sure that the peculiarity of the Armenian-French
relations is that those are built not only on bilateral state
interests: existence of the French Armenian powerful community of many
thousands was also attached importance here. Armenians, with their rich
cultural heritage, greatly assisted development of the French culture.

In the Deputy Minister’s words, France was among the first ones that
recognized the independence of Armenia on March 3, 1992. And the
French parliament recognized the 1915 Armenian Genocide in 2001. It
became a great spur for development of the process of recognizing the
genocide in other countries. "The Armenian-French relations are not
accepted unequivocally in the region and international political field,
what often does not have positive political or economic consequences
for France," A.Bayburdian mentioned. The latter also stated that
Azerbaijan does not take part in those regional programs in which
France is also involved.

A.Bayburdian also stated that France annually makes investment of 47
mln dollars in Armenia, and 118 companies implement economic joint
programs here. Besides, the French government annually allocates 540
thousand evros for implementation of cultural programs in Armenia.

Pelosi’s Rising Star A Beacon For California

PELOSI’S RISING STAR A BEACON FOR CALIFORNIA
By Michael Doyle, Bee Washington Bureau

Modesto Bee
Sacramento Bee
November 8, 2006 Wednesday

Parochially speaking, the Republicans’ Capitol Hill loss could be
California’s gain.

When the 110th Congress is sworn in in January, a Californian will
hold the most powerful position in the House of Representatives. At
least 17 other California House Democrats likewise are poised by dint
of seniority to lead committees or subcommittees.

"It’s always great to have people in leadership, from either party,
from your state," noted Rep. Dennis Cardoza, D-Merced.

The full impact of Tuesday’s election will unfold over time, as House
Democrats adjust to their newfound majority status. There will be
unforeseeable ripple effects, as one change begets another.

"There’s a lot of jockeying that’s going to happen before the end of
the year," Cardoza said.

Still, the ascension of Rep. Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco to House
speaker will give the Golden State considerable clout. She will be
the first Californian to take the House’s top job, as well as the
first woman.

As speaker, Pelosi will direct which bills reach the House floor.

She picks who gets plum assignments. She appoints House negotiators
who compromise with the Senate. She will be in earmark heaven,
shaping legislative bottom lines to her satisfaction.

"It’s a big step forward," said Vic Fazio, a Washington lobbyist who
formerly represented the Sacramento Valley in the House. "For the
region, it’s actually quite good."

Pelosi’s top lieutenants are likewise attuned to California’s
appetites. They include close advisers such as Rep. George Miller,
D-Concord, and Rep. Mike Thompson, D-Eureka. Pelosi’s chief of staff,
John Lawrence, holds a doctorate in history from the University of
California at Berkeley and cut his political teeth with Central Valley
water politics.

FIVE COMMITTEES LIKELY FOR STATE REPS.

Californians would lead at least five full committees, if seniority
prevails.

Miller would take over the House Education and the Workforce
Committee. Even the committee’s name might change. When Democrats
previously controlled Congress, they symbolically saluted their union
allies by calling the panel the Education and Labor Committee.

More substantively, Pelosi has promised that within the "first 100
hours" of the new Congress, Democrats will emphasize six priorities
that include increasing the national minimum wage to $7.25 an hour,
up from $5.15. California’s current minimum wage is $6.75 an hour.

The wage hike still could founder amid Senate and White House
resistance. So could other House Democratic priorities, like the
costly proposal to screen 100 percent of the 7-million-plus ocean
cargo containers that arrive annually in Oakland, Long Beach and
the nation’s other ports. Inspectors reach only about 5 percent of
seaborne containers entering the United States.

"It is realistic to set out an agenda," said Tim Ransdell, executive
director of the California Institute for Federal Policy Studies. "It
is less realistic to think that every item on a grand wish list can
be achieved."

Another Bay Area lawmaker, Rep. Tom Lantos of San Mateo, is the senior
Democrat on the House International Relations Committee. The panel
certainly would become a forum for critiquing Iraq policies.

More narrowly, fresh hearings are likely for ethnic political disputes,
such as an Armenian genocide resolution favored by San Joaquin Valley
lawmakers.

The House Government Reform Committee under Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Los
Angeles, would aggressively investigate the Bush administration.

Californians are likewise in line to run committees handling ethics
and House administration.

The state’s defense industry is watching whether Los Angeles Democrat
Jane Harman will head the House intelligence panel. She has the
seniority and is lobbying hard, but she’s at odds with Pelosi, who
hand-picks the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.

Besides committees, power will flow anew to certain coalitions.

BLUE DOGS SEEN AS KEY FOR VALLEY

Cardoza and Rep. Jim Costa, D-Fresno, are among 37 members of the
Blue Dog coalition. The centrist Democrats seek more influence,
bridging the gap between Democratic liberals and moderate Republicans.

"We will have to shift into defensive mode," said Rep. Devin Nunes,
R-Visalia. "This will mean working in a coalition with the Blue Dogs,
to stop bad things for the valley from coming through."

California also is losing some stature. The House water and power
subcommittee responsible for shepherding a San Joaquin River settlement
bill, for instance, is passing from the hands of Republican Rep. George
Radanovich of Mariposa.

"I think the valley agenda will be the same," predicted Rep. Richard
Pombo, R-Tracy, who held a slim lead in his race at press time "but
it will be much harder to get things done."

Landmark’s battle scars take on new meaning

Daily Star – Lebanon
Nov 11 2006

Landmark’s battle scars take on new meaning

Multimedia artist Marwan Rechmaoui’s captures history of a former
icon

By Kaelen Wilson-Goldie
Daily Star staff
Saturday, November 11, 2006

Interview

BEIRUT: Marwan Rechmaoui’s most recent work, entitled "Spectre," is
an exact, sculptural replica of a building that spreads across two
blocs in the neighborhood of Ras Beirut.

As an artist, Rechmaoui has nurtured an enduring interest in acts of
mapping and deconstructing city life. "A Monument for the Living,"
from 2002, dealt with the history of Bourj al-Murr, the concrete
tower in Kantari that continues to define the Beirut skyline despite
its uselessness (never finished, can’t be used, can’t be knocked
down, can’t be imploded, can’t shake a reputation as Civil War-era
sniper nest and torture center). "Beirut Caoutchouc," from 2003,
re-created a map of the capital in tough, interlocking black rubber.

For "Spectre," he tells The Daily Star, "I wanted to take a
cross-section of Lebanese society," but only by dealing with the
traces that society leaves behind, the marks that are imprinted on
Beirut’s urban fabric."

Plus, Rechmaoui used to live in this particular building, so whether
he’d be keen to acknowledge it or not, it must mean something to him.

The building, known as the Yacoubian, is named for the man who had it
built, says Rechmaoui, an Armenian originally from the Syrian city of
Aleppo who, according to rumor, once worked as a cake vendor but came
into great wealth when he moved to Beirut.

As Rechmaoui tells it, the Yacoubian was erected in the Nasserite
era, in the aftermath of Syria’s brief unification with Egypt, when
members of the Damascene elite were nervous about the potential
nationalization of their assets and shifted large amounts of capital
into banks in Beirut.

At the time, he continues, a group of five architects living in
Beirut pushed for new legislation to be passed in Lebanon, which
would allow the units of a particular building to be separated and
sold. Previously, such legislation had applied only to undeveloped
land.

As a result, he says,"people took advantage."

Huge structures went up in Beirut’s residential and commercial
quarters. The typical four- to six-floor apartment building gave way
to towering blocs like the Yacoubian’s.

A Lebanese architect named Rafik al-Muhib drafted the plans for the
building. Yacoubian had commissioned him to design a deluxe housing
complex for wealthy residents who would be living in close proximity
to the sea and Beirut’s upscale, cosmopolitan nightlife district.
Indeed, in the initial years of its existence, the building was used
for that very purpose. The legendary Venus nightclub was located
beneath the parking lot, and every night that parking lot was filled
with Rolls Royces and Ferraris.

But with the outbreak of the 1975-1990 Civil War in Lebanon, the
building’s original residents, whether they were from Lebanon or
elsewhere, began to leave in large numbers. They were rich, says
Rechmaoui, which meant they could afford to escape the fighting, and
they had other places to live anyway.

As the violence in Lebanon continued, new residents began to move in
– refugees from other parts of Beirut and from South Lebanon, seeking
to escape the first Israeli invasion of March 1978.

Some of the older residents stayed on throughout the 15-year war.
Some refugees from the South who decided to settle down in Beirut
after the war eventually bought their apartments and stayed as well.
Some refugees who had been squatting in their units moved out and
made way for another wave of new residents in the postwar period.

In the process, the Yacoubian Building lost its original luster. It
is no longer viewed by anyone as a glamorous address.

But for Rechmaoui, it is a telling piece of history.

For a few years, he says, he lived in there in a first-floor
apartment with a studio next door, his two windows located right
above the entrance. For Rechmaoui, what is interesting about this
sprawling, two-bloc concrete structure is the challenge it presents
to the central tenets of modernity.

It was designed to be clean, rational, sleek, and sophisticated, he
says, and for a time it was all these things. It resembled an
architect’s maquette.

But then everything broke down. Residents wrecked the unity of the
facade by enclosing their balconies or throwing up tough and colorful
curtains. Businesses moved in hung exterior placards advertising
their offices. The boy scouts established a base in the complex, as
did an Eritrean social club and a dive bar much loved for its Che
Guevara memorabilia.

The new inhabitants of the Yacoubian established their own ad hoc
barriers and gerrymandered boundaries between units. The spaces
imagined by planners gave way to realities of how those spaces were
used. New rules took hold. The rhythms of urban life were disrupted
by the conventions of rural residents who lived in the Yacoubian
Building as they had in their villages.

"Spectre" is a recreation of this building in miniature. Rechmaoui
was commissioned to create it by the Sao Paulo Biennale, which opened
last month. He planned to cast it in concrete and have it shipped by
boat from Lebanon to Brazil this past summer. With the outbreak of
another war with Israel, things didn’t pan out. Instead, Rechmaoui
traveled to Sao Paulo in late September and built the work there
ahead of the opening in early October. He had only two weeks time to
complete it, which meant he had to make sacrifices.

As it stands now, "Spectre" is constructed of wood and painted a pale
shade of beige.

Originally, Rechmaoui wanted each unit to be not only rendered in
concrete but also exploded out for emphasis, "a gentle rather than
violent explosion," he explains.

Pulling out each unit would call attention to the demarcation lines
between the apartments and highlight how they function, how they
allow a heterogeneous group of people to live together.

"Spectre" was meant to be a recreation of every detail along these
borderlines, examining the traces people leave behind and exploring
how urban life is impressed upon a city’s surface. At the same, the
artist wanted to make manifest his refusal to divulge what goes on in
those people’s lives inside.

"I don’t like to deal with people," Rechmaoui says. "It’s a hassle
for me. I work how I work. Plus I didn’t want the work to be
gimmicky. You can never know what’s inside [a building like the
Yacoubian.] You can only see what people allow you to see, even if
you’re a voyeur.

"For me, it’s important to work on the city," he continues.
"According to modernists, a place like this does not exist, because
to exist it has to follow a certain order. This place is chaos, but
it works and it works well. I don’t look at it as a case study on how
people are living and how they function," he adds. It’s more a
mediation on urban life, "throwing away traditions to live now in
this life."

Rechmaoui traveled to Sao Paulo with a suitcase packed full of
individually marked and ordered envelopes – the accessories
representing each of those borderlines.

The work currently on view in Sao Paulo is an approximation of the
work Rechmaoui originally wanted to do. Within a year’s time, he
intends to redo the work as planned.

The one lesson he learned in Brazil is this, he says: "I realize it
has to be bigger."

http://www.dailystar.com.lb

EU willing to build special relations with the South Caucasus

Public Radio, Armenia
Nov 10 2006

EU willing to build special relations with the South Caucasus
10.11.2006 12:23

The EU backs the OSCE Minsk Group mediation efforts, EU High
Commissioner for the Common Foreign and Security Policy Javier Solana
told `Trend’ agency. `We cannot say that the EU is passive. EU has
done much. The region faces problems rooted in the conflicts. I want
to emphasize the importance of continuing the negotiations between
Armenia and Azerbaijan for reaching an agreement as soon as possible.
EU backs the mediation efforts of the OSCE Minsk Group. I hope that
November 14th meeting of the Foreign Ministers of the two countries
in Brussels will help achieve further progress,’ declared Javier
Solana.
As for Georgia, EU considers that settlement of its internal
conflicts is of vital importance for the whole region. `EU Special
Envoy for the South Caucasus Peter Semneby helps Armenia, Azerbaijan
and Georgia to discuss the further political and economic reforms and
promote development of the region, making its contribution to the
peaceful settlement of conflicts and promoting further cooperation
between the countries of the region,’ EU High Commissioner reminded.
In response to the question about the importance the European Union
attaches to the cooperation with the countries of the South Caucasus,
Javier Solana noted that the fact that the three South Caucasian
countries are EU neighbors and are included in the European
Neighborhood Policy speaks about EU’s wish to build special relations
with the region.

Albert Torcomian

News of Delaware County, PA
Nov 10 2006

Albert Torcomian

By Phyllis Edwards, STAFF WRITER11/09/2006

Albert Torcomian served on many successful runs with the U.S. Navy
Submarine Corps during World War II but he recalls having three
problems to overcome.

"The first problem to overcome is fear," Torcomian said during an
interview at his Havertown home.

"It’s a very difficult thing to do. The second thing for me was the
noise of the gunfire. You cannot believe the noise. I never heard
noise like that in my life. I had a very pleasant childhood and to go
through that was just mind-boggling. The third thing was saying
goodbye. You never get used to that," he said.

Torcomian was 17 and living in Lowell, Mass. when he joined the Navy
in January 1942. "I was going to school at that time and the whole
class decided to go downtown and volunteer as a group. Of course I
went along," he recalls.

When he returned home, his parents objected to him enlisting because
he was their only son. An Armenian priest was visiting the house and
he convinced Torcomian’s parents to allow him to join up.

"So off I went," he says. "I wanted to join the Marine Corps but they
were only taking two that day for the Corps." He was one of the two
chosen but then a "much larger individual" walked in and Torcomian
was passed over. "The sergeant took me out and said you’re in the
Navy," he says.

He went to boot camp at Newport, R.I. Boot camp lasted 16 to 18
weeks. Torcomian recalls the company commander giving a speech and
asking if anyone had any questions. "I always asked questions. The
chief was Armenian and I asked him a question. I didn’t know you
weren’t allowed to talk to anybody. He put me on the midnight to 4
a.m. watch. I used to walk the shore line in Newport from midnight to
4 a.m.," he recalls.

He was in the Navy for two weeks when they had a recruiting drive for
the submarine service. The commander volunteered Torcomian’s whole
company.

"Only two of us passed the physical. I spoke with the recruiting
officer and he said it’s an entirely voluntary basis," he recalls. He
also remembers the officer told him if he signed up he would get out
of boot camp that same day.

He signed and was sent to the submarine base in New London, Conn. for
school. "You have to go into Chief Spritz’s Navy. All the new
recruits line in front of the administration building. Chief Spritz
walks up and down and gives you a real going over. I was told to make
sure my pea coat buttons are tight. I got my mother to reinforce
them. He would come down the line and pull you. If your button came
off you were in Spritz’s Navy. You weren’t allowed to go to school.
All you did was maintenance work until he decided you were to go into
submarine school," he recalls.

There were a lot of rules on the base and any infraction would cause
you to be sent to Chief Spritz. "He had authority over the whole
base," he recalls.

After submarine school he was sent to a submarine base at Mare
Island, Cal. "I was put on a boat. We called submarines boats," he
says.

"We went to Pearl Harbor and made a couple of patrols, a couple of
runs. The run averaged about two or three months. You do your
patrolling and fighting out there then you come in. I was assigned to
a boat in Freemantle, Australia," he says.

"I was out there for two and a half years. I had a lot of successful
runs. Runs are if you go out and have action and sink tonnage. I was
on seven different boats," he says.

His battle station was as a bow gunner with a dual 2 mm machine gun.

He recalls the decks were level with the water when they took their
battle stations. They would run down the deck holding onto rails. "I
was the first one up every time. When they opened the hatch it was 90
feet to my battle station. You stand there and shoot. It was spooky.
You had to be a kid to do it because you did what you were told. You
cannot think. The outstanding thing about the service was the
training. They kept training you all the time so no matter what your
personal thoughts were you did things instinctively. It’s not like in
the movies. You were out there in your underwear firing a gun because
it was so hot. You wore your underwear and a helmet," he says.

He recalls getting left behind a couple of times when the submarine
submerged. "You’re up there eight or nine hours. They teach you
floating. The thing that saved my tail was floating. When you give up
just before you die you float," he says. "All these God damn fish
came up. They’re curious. If you’re out and floating they’ll come up
and take a bite out of you. If they don’t like it they’ll spit it
out. These schools of fish come up. If each one takes a nip you’re
gone," he says.

When the submarine returned to base a chaplain would come out 10
miles to meet the boat. He would bring the mail and fresh fruit and
milk.

"When you come in and tie up they’d have a band there playing. The
squadron commanders came down and handed out medals. The commander’s
statement was ‘give me 10 submarine runs and I’ll give you recruiting
duty in your home town.’ So as soon as you came in off that boat you
would try to get another ride right away. You were a kid. You
believed everything," he says.

The sailors were sent to the hospital for a check up. Then they were
put up in a hotel in town for two weeks while the submarine was
refurbished.

He recalls there were beautiful parks in Freemantle and Perth. "I
would just go there and lie down in the grass and eat fruit – apples,
oranges, pears, tangerines. It was the best fruit I’d ever tasted. I
wasn’t a drinker. That’s what I did," he recalls.

They would take the submarine for a shake down cruise to be sure
everything was in working order. They’d put the ordinance back on and
load up on provisions and be out to sea again.

"After a couple of days the captain would open the orders. It was
difficult. Submarines operated on their own. You had naval
intelligence would give you certain information about ship movements
here and there. You’d fight in a lot of naval battles. We always
stood air sea rescue. You’d sit about 15 or 30 miles away from the
battle and pick up the pilots as they were ditching their aircraft
coming back," he says.

He recalls some of the hardships on the boat. "You can’t take a
shower on a submarine. All the water you manufacture was to water the
batteries and for cooking. No showers. We used to hang buckets up for
condensation from water to brush your teeth. The temperature in a
submarine averaged between 110 and 130 degrees all the time. That’s
why they called them pig boats. You smelled those boats. When you
went topside the fresh air stunk. You try to maintain no friends if
you can because you lose so many men. Every run you lose 10 to 15
men. First run, second run you have friends. All of a sudden you
don’t bother with anybody you just do your job," he says.

His base was moved to Subic Bay in the Philippines. "We were there
about a month or so and they dropped the atomic bomb on Japan. We
loaded our submarine to come from Subic Bay to Japan, drop off
whatever provisions we had to help some of those people," he says.

They were ordered back to San Diego. He called his mother. Because of
the time difference it was the middle of the night and she thought
she dreamed the phone call. The next morning his sister called the
telephone company and verified that he had indeed called from San
Diego.

He was sent to a naval hospital in Virginia. His boat came around and
up the East Coast. He picked it up in Norfolk. "We went to Navy Day
in New York City on Oct. 29. President Harry Truman was there. All
the ships and boats tied up on the East River," he says. His entire
family came down to New York. A cousin who lived in the city threw a
party on his roof for the entire crew.

"My mother and father went home. I decided to go home with them. I
figured that’s it. I was home about a month. I went to the movies
with my friends at the Strand Theater. All of a sudden the lights
came on. The shore patrol came in and they announced my name on the
speaker. They put me under arrest for desertion," he recalls.

They were going to have a formal court martial for Torcomian until
they examined his war record. "I had a terrific war record. Everybody
was getting out of the Navy. Instead they sent me to teach school at
Key West, Florida," he says. He had been injured twice during his
duty. One a shell hit him in the head. "It spun my helmet around," he
says. The helmet was compressed and had to be cut off his head.

"On May 3, 1946 they called me in and said you’re going to be
discharged," he recalls. On May 6 he was formally discharged and went
home.

He became ill following his discharge and was hospitalized in a naval
hospital in Maine for six months.

"That was the end of my experience with the U.S. Navy," he says.

One of his old commanders worked for International Harvester Co. He
got Torcomian a job as an engineer. He traveled up and down the East
Coast. He met his wife Veronica at an Armenian Christian Youth
Organization meeting in Philadelphia. The Torcomians have three
children: Lynn (Baboujian), Thomas and John and eight grandchildren.

"Submarine sailors had a certain arrogance about them," he recalls.
"We’ve been around, done a lot of things. It’s a pretty tough life
but you could get off anytime. Just tell them you had enough," he
says. "You got through things that are totally unnatural."

The EU Should Be Playing Iran And Russia Off Against Each Other

THE EU SHOULD BE PLAYING IRAN AND RUSSIA OFF AGAINST EACH OTHER
Julian Evans

Eurasian Home Analytical Resource, Russia
Nov 8 2006

The European Union is increasingly anxious about being over-reliant on
gas imports from Russia. The Kremlin, it is clear, intends to wield
its huge oil and gas reserves as its main bargaining chip in foreign
relations. The EU is concerned that its authoritarian neighbour to
the east has it "over a barrel", as one British MP put it. Or, as
the Daily Telegraph recently bewailed "The Russian bear could punch
our lights out!"

If the EU is serious about reducing its dependency on Russian gas,
then it needs to look quickly at Russia’s biggest gas rival – Iran.

Iran is the second-biggest source of gas in the world. It has 18%
of the world’s gas supplies, compared to Russia’s 25%, but experts
believe over 60% of Iran’s reserves are still undeveloped.

The EU should be doing everything it can to foster competition between
these two countries in the energy sphere. It should be striving to
strike bilateral deals for Iranian gas, offering financial support for
Iran’s planned pipelines to India and Pakistan and other projects,
and generally standing four-square with Iran over its global energy
expansion.

The argument the EU should make to Iran (and to America) is that
the country is fighting last century’s war by struggling to become a
nuclear power. If Iran really wants to become a great power again,
it should argue, it should seek to develop its energy markets and
make the rest of the world – the US included – reliant on it. Energy,
not nuclear missiles, is the new weapon of the twenty-first century
great power. The sooner Iran lets go of its outdated ambitions to
be a nuclear super-power, the quicker it can become a modern energy
super-power.

Iran should resist an energy alliance with Russia, the EU should argue,
because Russia will always be in the driving seat. Gazprom only ever
takes a controlling stake in projects, and it will involve itself
in Iranian projects precisely with the object of protecting itself
from Iranian competition and stymieing the development of Iran’s gas
resources. If Iran wants to develop its resources quickly, it should
look to a more efficient and technologically developed partner, such
as Total, OMV or Statoil. Western banks can bring far more capital
to support Iranian energy projects than Russian banks ever could.

But we are not seeing this energy alliance with Iran happen. Instead,
we are seeing the EU once again outmanoeuvred by Gazprom, because
Gazprom thinks two moves ahead, and the EU merely reacts, usually
with panic and indignation.

This weekend, Gazprom bought a controlling stake in its joint
venture with Armenia, ArmRosGas, which controls Armenia’s domestic
gas distribution network and a soon-to-be-completed gas pipeline with
Iran. That pipeline could have helped free both Armenia and Georgia
from dependence on Russian gas, and also have been a conduit for
Iranian gas into western Europe. But the Armenians, unwooed by the EU,
sold the controlling stake to their Russian masters for $119 million.

The same week that this deal was being signed in Moscow with Armenia’s
president, the petroleum minister of India, Murli Deorla, was also in
town. He announced yesterday that India had agreed to let Gazprom join
a planned pipeline from Iran to India and Pakistan. He said: "Russia
will join the Iran pipeline. I spoke to Pakistan minister for petroleum
and natural resources Amanullah Khan Jadoon (on Russian participation)
on Tuesday and will be speaking to the Iranian minister later".

So on the two most important new projects bringing Iranian gas to the
outside world, Gazprom is involved, and possibly even in control. A
good weekend’s work, fellows.

These appear to be the first decisive steps in a Kremlin initiative
to forge an energy alliance with Iran. Also last week, Valery Yazev,
head of the Duma energy committee and Gazprom’s top lobbyist in the
Duma, called for the creation of a gas cartel involving CIS countries,
and including Iran, to counter the ‘cartel’ of European consumers. The
plan was prompted, he said, by the refusal of France and Germany
to be played off against the rest of Europe by president Putin, who
offered Germany the chance to be a hub for Russian supplies to the
rest of Europe when he visited Germany in September.

Merkel refused, sensible lady.

Alexander Medvedev, deputy chairman of Gazprom, yesterday told me that
he viewed participation with Iran as "very profitable. We hope to use
the joint venture to become involved in extraction and development
[of Iranian gas], and possibly help supply gas through the joint
venture to Western Europe, as well as Pakistan and India".

So Russia is already a few steps ahead of the EU in this game. An
energy alliance with Iran would tie up around 45% of the world’s
gas supplies.

However, the game is not over yet. Luckily for us, the US and UK
governments thought slightly ahead in the early 1990s, and secured
both the BTC and Shah Deniz pipelines, which will bring oil and gas
from Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan to Europe, without going through Russia.

There is also a plan, now being put on the front-burner by the EU,
to build a new Nabucco pipeline from the Caspian region to Austria,
with OMV the main backer of the project. Gazprom has also asked to be
involved in the project. Of course – as soon as the Kremlin signs the
European Energy Charter. The project is intended to take Azeri gas,
but should also take Iranian gas too.

Am I being naïve, arguing for EU participation with Iran, for its
support for Iran’s gas industry, which will only enrich this dangerous
and authoritarian country?

Firstly, the lure of Iran becoming a global energy super-power might
possibly be sufficient to persuade it away from its path of becoming
a nuclear power, one of many all over the Middle East. It would never
be a dominant nuclear power, but it could be a dominant gas power,
one of the most powerful in the world.

Secondly, when it comes to energy supplies, it’s not a question of
whether to work with illiberal authoritarian regimes or not. It’s
a question of trying to balance one authoritarian regime against
another, so you’re not too dependent on any one. Every energy
power in the world, with the exception of Norway, is illiberal and
authoritarian. Dick Cheney, for all his evilness, at least realizes
this, and worked earlier than any EU bureaucrat to diversify CIS
countries away from Moscow’s control.

We should be doing the same with Iran, though unfortunately the US
seems to have decided on an altogether more direct method for securing
Iranian energy supplies – and it is their belligerent rhetoric, and
the EU’s typically slow and confused energy policy, that is helping
drive Iran and Russia together.

Julian Evans, a British freelance journalist based in Moscow.

November 8, 2006
?lang=en&nic=opinion&pid=558

–Boundary_( ID_IEsLAhhdop8tftogAcInsg)–

http://www.eurasianhome.org/xml/t/opinion.xml

Turkish Approach To Exhibition Of Armin Wegner’s Photos

TURKISH APPROACH TO EXHIBITION OF ARMIN WEGNER’S PHOTOS
By Susanna Margarian

AZG Armenian Daily #213
08/11/2006

Photographs of Armin Wegner that are considered documents of the
Armenian Genocide were exhibited in Vercelli, Italy, yesterday. An
unpleasant incident accompanied opening of the exhibition. A Turkish
resident of Italy attacked and tore down the exhibition bills, then
entered the gallery and broke and tore 5 exhibits. The Turk also
attacked the Italian female guide then toppled over a table with
literature for visitors. According to Azdak newspaper, the police
soon after detained the lawbreaker.

Reportedly, the Italian channel 5 covered the exhibition and the
incident. It also touched on Roman Popes who had contributed to the
recognition of the Armenian Genocide.

Senate Marshal: Armenia’s Isolation Hinders In Development Of Econom

SENATE MARSHAL: ARMENIA’S ISOLATION HINDERS IN DEVELOPMENT OF ECONOMIC RELATIONS WITH POLAND

Regnum, Russia
Nov 7 2006

Armenian-Polish economic relations are at lower level than political
ones; Polish Marshal Senate Bogdan Borusewicz is quoted by a REGNUM
correspondent as stating on November 6.

According to him, commodities turnover between Armenia and Poland
totals merely $15mln; the fact may be explained by continuing Armenia’s
blockade. "It is mainly connected with fact that Armenia is isolated
by Turkey, Azerbaijan, as well as, one might say, by Russia because
blocking Georgia Russia has blocked Armenia, too," he stated stressing
that "it negatively influences upon Armenia." "Investors invest mainly
in places, from which it is possible to get into other countries,
too. Armenia is isolated in such sense," Bogdan Borusewicz added.

Meanwhile, as the Polish Senate Marshal stressed, "Armenia and
Armenians has been positively reflected by Polish mass media. Poles
love and respect Armenians." "Big Armenian community functioned in
frames of Polish state as far back as the 16th century; Armenians
filled rather high posts: they were ambassadors in Turkey and Persia
speaking on behalf of Poland and defending its interests. A big group
of the Poles of Armenian origin there is in Poland, too.

Unfortunately, they do not speak their language; however, their
distinctive surnames remind them of their origin," Bogdan Borusewicz
said.

It is worth stressing; the Polish delegation headed by Senate Marshal
Bogdan Borusewicz is on its two-day official visit in Yerevan.

Want A Moldovan Wine? Sarkisov Delivers Spirits

WANT A MOLDOVAN WINE? SARKISOV DELIVERS SPIRITS
By Kathy Carlson, News Correspondent

Nashville City Paper, TN
Nov 6 2006

Care for a glass of wine? It’s light, crisp and clean, with good
body and a hint of peach, similar to a pinot grigio. By the way,
it’s from Moldova.

Nashville accountant turned entrepreneur Simon Sarkisov wants to
introduce Nashville – and the rest of the country – to Moldovan wines
plus others he says are well-known in Europe but not here, yet.

"I want to be basically some kind of ambassador of good quality wines
to United States," he said.

His South Nashville-based business, World Vintage LLC, currently
imports wines from Spain and Moldova, a landlocked country about the
size of Maryland in southeastern Europe, between Rumania and Ukraine.

Moldova, formerly part of the Soviet Union, is now independent.

Moldova’s economic future may hinge on its wines – and people like
Sarkisov.

Wines from Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union have gained much
interest recently, especially as land, labor and grapes become pricier
in other wine-growing regions, said Elise Loehr Solima, proprietor/
wine director at the Green Hills restaurant F. Scott’s.

Moldovans have produced wine for thousands of years, Sarkisov said,
and its climate and soil are well suited for grapes. Moldovan wineries
– including the one Sarkisov imports from – also have won honors in
recent international competitions. Nevertheless, the United States
imported less than $1 million in Moldovan wine last year, according
to U.S. Census Bureau trade data.

Sarkisov’s company imports wines from Moldova’s Dionysos-Mereni
winery, along with Man Quixot and Lopez Panach wines from Spain. The
businessman is planning trips to Spain and Italy this year to seek
additional wines.

Sarkisov is an American citizen of Armenian descent. He grew up in
Azerbaijan, another former Soviet republic, and came to Nashville in
1991 at age 24. After graduating from Belmont University in 2000 with
an accounting degree, he worked in the corporate world.

Oddly enough, breaking his leg in a racquetball game in 2003 was
a turning point for him. With time to think about his career, he
focused on a long-time passion for wines. He decided to invest in a
wine-importing venture and specialize in unusual vintages and products.

In 2004, Sarkisov started World Vintages, importing his first wines
in 2005. Sarkisov now has one employee and, while he declined to give
revenues, said business has grown by about 35 percent over last year.

He sells in six states besides Tennessee, his main state for sales.

World Vintages imports wines under annual agreements with producers.

Tennessee law allows him to sell only to distributors who sell to
restaurants and liquor stores, which in turn educate consumers by
suggesting wines for specific meals or occasions. One distributor
that handles Sarkisov’s products is Nashville-based Aleksey’s Imports,
which distributes several Russian brands.

Moldovan wines compete with "inexpensive wines that are easy to drink,
versatile and friendly," said Eric Nichols, director of sales with
Aleksey’s. "It’s not special occasion [wine] but it’s very good
quality. It’s still kind of a secret, too."

Perhaps the secret will not be kept long as the Moldovan wines World
Vintages imports are very reasonably priced. For example, a bottle
of Vino Vista Pinot Noir is currently selling for about $10 at one
local retailer.

Nashville’s Tin Angel restaurant is one of Aleksey’s Imports’
accounts. From time to time, Tin Angel owner Rick Bolsom has featured
wines – including a Moldovan variety from Alexsky’s – that aren’t on
the regular wine list so that patrons can sample something different.

"I love to be able to offer quality wines at a reasonable price that
[offer] something interesting," Bolsom said. Moldova is "way off the
beaten track," he added, but has a long history of winemaking.

Currently, Russia forbids the sale of Moldovan and Georgian wines,
claiming they don’t meet its sanitation standards, which the two
countries contest. Others see retaliation because Moldova and Georgia
oppose Russia’s bid to join them in the World Trade Organization. The
loss of the huge Russian market has forced layoffs at some Moldovan
wineries, but one European press report says Dionysos-Mereni still
is doing well because of the quality of its wines.

Sarkisov and his distributors are betting that the Moldovan wines’
mix of value and quality will win customers.

"Once people try them," Nichols said, "they’ll come back."

Pamuk: A Great Writer, A Worthy Nobel Laureate

PAMUK: A GREAT WRITER, A WORTHY NOBEL LAUREATE
Roy Voragen, Bandung

Jakarta Post, Indonesia
Nov 4 2006

Orhan Pamuk deserves the Nobel Prize for Literature; his books make
him a worthy laureate. But it is unfortunate that his success is now
being politicized.

Matt Moore and Karl Ritter wrote in The Jakarta Post (Oct. 13):
"With its selection, the Swedish academy stepped squarely into the
global clash of civilizations, honoring a Western-leaning Muslim whose
country lies on the strategic fault line between east and west and
whose people are increasingly unhappy with Europeans’ reluctance to
accept them as full members in the European Union."

Did Moore and Ritter take the effort to read any of Pamuk’s
brilliantly constructed books? From their article it does not seem
so. Why didn’t they write about the themes and literary qualities of
Pamuk’s books? Now it seems he is being condemned because he is not
Turkish enough (i.e. he is not a good Muslim, not a good Oriental).

Is Orhan Pamuk a European because he admires Dostoyevski? If one reads
a book written by Pamuk one will see that he does not choose between
east or west, between secularism or religion, between modernity or
tradition. Pamuk takes a close look at his surroundings and tries
to make sense of them by constructing a narrative with many layers
and voices.

As Margaret Atwood wrote in a review for The New York Review of Books
(Aug. 15, 2004): "Stories, Pamuk has hinted, create the world we
perceive: Instead of ‘I think, therefore I am’, a Pamuk character
might say, ‘I am because I narrate’".

Pamuk wants to show us that our world is not a black-and-white world,
and if we picture it as black and white, not only will it not make
sense to us but it can also become a rather unlivable place.

Pamuk is Dostoyevskian in the sense that he tries to go beyond simple
representations, his narrations are inhabited by subjects like the
honest thief, the tender murderer and the superstitious atheist;
people are never just this or that, they are both and neither.

In response to the bloody situation in Iraq, Pamuk says in an interview
with Alexander Star (The New York Times, Aug. 15, 2004): "In my books
I have always looked for a sort of harmony between the so-called east
and west. In short, what I wrote in my books for years was misquoted,
and used as a sort of apology for what had been done.

And what had been done was a cruel thing."

And in response to 9/11 he writes (The New York Review of Books, Nov.
15, 2001):"I am afraid that self-satisfied and self-righteous Western
nationalism will drive the rest of the world into defiantly contending
that two plus two equals five, like Dostoyevski’s underground man,
when he reacts against the ‘reasonable’ Western world.

"Nothing can fuel support for an ‘Islamist’ who throws nitric acid at
women’s faces so much as the West’s failure to understand the damned
of the world".

Pamuk’s position is subtle, for example his novel Now carries an
epigraph from Dostoyevski’s novel The Brothers Karamazov: "Well,
then, eliminate the people, curtail them, force them to be silent.

Because the European enlightenment is more important than people."

This quote not only criticizes Turkey’s top-down modernization since
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk (1881-1938), it also criticizes the way many
Europeans, for example the Somali-Dutch Ayaan Hirsi Ali, treat Muslims:
Modernization as such is more important than the lives of ordinary
people, but what is liberty without a life? Enlightenment cannot be
enforced, that is illiberal.

Pamuk infuriates Islamists and nationalists alike. Orhan Pamuk is
critical of Islamism, because it stifles freedom of thinking and
expression. Pamuk was also one of the first to speak up against the
Ayatollah Khomeini fatwa which ordered the murder of Salman Rushdie,
who was accused of blasphemy after publishing The Satanic Verses.

Pamuk was also recently one of the co-writers of an open letter to
the Iranian president, Ahmadinejad, urging the release of scholar and
public intellectual Ramin Jahanbegloo, who is being held for having
contacts with foreigners.

Pamuk is also critical of nationalists and for the same reasons. He
gave an interview to the Swiss newspaper Tages Anzeiger (Feb. 6, 2005)
in which he said that "thirty thousand Kurds and a million Armenians
were killed". Pamuk is referring to the killings by Ottoman Empire
forces of Armenians during World War I.

Turkey does not deny the deaths, but denies that it was genocide,
i.e. according to a premeditated plan. Pamuk’s reference to 30,000
Kurdish deaths refers to those killed during the past two decades
in the conflict between Turkish forces and Kurdish separatists. In
Turkey, debate about this issue is stifled by stringent laws; therefore
Turkish history and identity are frozen.

Turkey should become a full member of the European Union soon, says
Pamuk. This must be possible because Turkey has long been a member
of NATO. It must be possible if the European Union stands for humanism.

But it becomes impossible if Europeans, out of fear of globalization,
deep-freeze an European identity as, for example, Christian.

But once again, Pamuk is no politician, nor is he an activist, he is
foremost a luminous artist. His books enlighten us on the difficulty of
forming an essential identity, to be someone; we are like the countries
we inhabit, i.e. complex and difficult to read. And Pamuk’s novel The
Black Book shows that to make sense of the world and ourselves the
reader has to become a writer. The clash of civilizations is simply
not an interesting narrative, it is far too colorless, and it is
about time to change that record.

The writer teaches philosophy at Parahyangan Catholic University,
Bandung, West Java, and can be contacted at [email protected].

http://www.thejakartapost .com/detaileditorial.asp?fileid=20061104.E02&i rec=1