Voice Of People

VOICE OF PEOPLE
Aram Abrahamian

Aravot.am
11 May 06

The reasons of air crash, which happened on 3 of May, haven’t been
officially declared yet. The truth will be appeared if the Russian
part wants it. But if the investigation is delayed and is so called
“died” we can say surely that the main guilty part is Russia.

The awful disaster was a shock for us, the citizens of Armenia. For
finding out how our society beared that shock “Aravot” ordered to
its APR Group company to make a Gallup poll from 6-8 of May among
652 Yerevan citizens.

First of all we were interesting from what sources our compatriots have
got information. 6,6% has got that information from the milieu. Only
a person from 652 members mentioned Internet as the source of
information, which is pitiful, of course. It is also pitiful that
radi? has 2,6% in this list. The main part has got information from
TV companies; 30,4% from “Armenia”, 10% from H1, 5,7% from ORT, 5,2%
from RTR Planeta, 3,2% from “Shant”, 2,6% from “Armnews”. The percent
of other TV companies is less than 1%. Nobody among 652 mentioned any
newspaper as a source of information. But TV Companies can’t be glad
because only 12,6% trusts in information given by mass media, 71%
“trusts partly”, 16,4% doesn’t trust at all.

And what or whom those 652 citizens consider guilty for the air
crashes. A part of Yerevan citizens are careful in their answers,
“find difficulty in answer”, it will become clear after finding the
black box. And the first place among certain answers is the ‘Russian
dispatchers” answer, 29,6% which I consider reasonable. Second is
“organized air crash” answer which is surprising for me a little
/10,6%/. Perhaps a part of people is inclined to believe in sensational
versions full of intrigues. Other versions are “use of weapon inside
the airplane” /4,3%/, “conspiracy of foreign countries against Armenia”
/3,8%/ , “terror” /1,8%/ Weather /8,4%/ and”Armavia” company 4,8%/
are also mentioned.

And finally a result of polling which inspires optimism; “Are you or
your family members going to use of air services during 2006”. 23,2%
answered to that question positively, 49,5% gave negative answer and
27,3% didn’t know. So people haven’t been frightened so much.

ANKARA: Turkish Delegation On French Bill: Objection Alone Not Enoug

TURKISH DELEGATION ON FRENCH BILL: OBJECTION ALONE NOT ENOUGH

Zaman, Turkey
May 11 2006

A Turkish Grand National Assembly (TBMM) delegation arrived in Paris
Tuesday to meet with members of the French Parliament over the new
legislative proposal to criminalize denial of the so-called Armenian
genocide.

The Turkish delegation, made up of Parliamentary Foreign Affairs
President Mahmet Dulger and parliamentarians Musa Sivacioglu, Onur
Oymen, Gulsun Bilgehan Token, met President of the French National
Parliament Jean-Louis Debre, leader of the People’s Movement Union
(UMP) Bernard Accoyer, and PS Group Leader Jean Marc Ayroult.

French politicians asserted that they are opposed to the bill,
officials reported.

Turkish parliamentary members then asked their French counterparts
to persuade other groups as well.

Known for his anti-Turkish viewpoints, former Prime Minister and
Parliamentary Foreign Affairs President Eduard Balladur said his
group also opposes the bill.

Moreover, the Turkish delegation also met some French members of the
parliament and Jacques Blanc, the Turkey-France Friendship Group Chair.

Communicating the Turkish people’s harsh criticism of the French
proposal, the delegation highlighted that history was the subject
area of historians.

As part of the latest developments, a declaration made by a group
in Turkey consisting of journalists, authors, and academics, known
for their controversial opinions on the so-called Armenian genocide,
was published in the French Liberation newspaper.

ANKARA: Bulgaria Parliament Rejects The Armenian Bill

BULGARIA PARLIAMENT REJECTS THE ARMENIAN BILL
Mary S. Garden (JTW) and Cihan News Agency

Journal of Turkish Weekly
May 10 2006

SOFIA – An Armenian (so-called) ‘genocide’ resolution, presented
by the racist and ultranationalist ATAKA party, was rejected by the
Bulgarian parliament on Wednesday.

The resolution which called on the Bulgarian parliament to recognize
the so-called Armenian genocide, were discussed today at the parliament
general assembly.

The Ruling Bulgarian Socialist Party and Movement of Rights and
Freedoms (HOH) opposed the resolution.

In today’s vote, 79 lawmakers rejected the resolution, 55 voted in
favor, while 40 lawmakers abstained.

The ultra-nationalist Armenians try to make parliaments to recognize
the Armenian historical accusations against the Turks as fact.

The United States and United Kingdom parliaments did not accept any
Armenian bill. The British Government openly declared that the 1915
Relocation Campaign was not genocide.

Turkish experts argue that the national parliaments should focus on
the present problems instead of the historical disputes. “All of us,
Turks, Armenians and Bulgarians experienced difficult times. However
we now should be united and work together” Dr. Sedat Laciner says.

According to Dr. Laciner, head of the USAK, the Bulgarian MPs have
vividly warned the Armenian lobbies that we should not sacrifice today
for the past. Dr. Laciner further continued: “If we open the past’s
dark pages, no Turkish man or woman would make co-operation with the
Armenians or other ethnic groups. More than 5 million Turkish people
were killed or died during the Balkan and First World War years. Many
were tortured or killed by their own neighbors.

However the Turks prefer to forget the bitter memoirs. They understood
that otherwise they could not establish a future. Turks do still
remember the past, but pretend the reverse. The Turks forgive the
Armenians and others. Armenians have to learn how to forget and
forgive. Otherwise they will have no future but sorrows forever.”

Turkey has never accepted the Armenian accusations and argued that the
armed Armenians had massacred more than 520,000 Turkish people during
the First World War. The Armenian groups in the Eastern provinces
joined the occupying powers against their own state.

Monument To Be Erected In Yerevan To Those Killed Last Week InArmeni

MONUMENT TO BE ERECTED IN YEREVAN TO THOSE KILLED LAST WEEK IN ARMENIAN AIRBUS CRASH

ARKA News Agency, Armenia
May 10 2006

YEREVAN, May 10. /ARKA/. A monument is to be erected in Yerevan to
those killed last week in Armenian airbus crash near Sochi.

Khachatur Vardanyan, member of governmental commission set up for
dealing with funeral procedure, said various proposals to erect a
monument are under consideration now as well as matters related to
the erection financing.

Earlier, on May 9, Armenian regional Administration Minister Hovik
Abramyan said about this intention.

Armavia Armenian Air Company’s jet A320 fell into the Black Sea as it
tried to land in Adler airport near Sochi. All 113 aboard the liner
died.

Festive Events On Occasion Of 61th Anniversary Of Victory In GreatPa

FESTIVE EVENTS ON OCCASION OF 61th ANNIVERSARY OF VICTORY IN GREAT PATRIOTIC WAR HELD IN HAKHTANAK PARK

Noyan Tapan
May 09 2006

YEREVAN, MAY 9, NOYAN TAPAN. On May 9, festive events on the occasion
of the 61th anniversary of the victory in the Great Patriotic War
were held in the Hakhtanak (Victory) Yerevan park. RA President Robert
Kocharian, members of RA government, diplomats accredited in Armenia,
representatives of the Russian military unit in the country, veterans
of the Second World War took part in the events. They laid a wreath to
the Memorial of the Unknown Soldier. Then a military parade was held,
which was followed by a festive concert. There also will be fireworks
in the Hakhtanak park in the evening. May is a month of victories for
the Armenian people. In May the Armenians won in the Avarayr battle,
in Bash-Aparan, in Shushi. The anniversary of liberation of Shushi
is also marked on May 9.

Pence meets with Turkish officials to discuss Iran

Congressional Press Releases
May 8, 2006 Monday

PENCE MEETS WITH TURKISH OFFICIALS TO DISCUSS IRAN TEN MINUTES AFTER
IRANIANS DEPART

by MIKE PENCE, REPRESENTATIVE, HOUSE

For Immediate Release

Pence Meets With Turkish Officials To Discuss Iran Ten Minutes After
Iranians Depart

Contact: Matt Lloyd (202) 226-4379

May 8, 2006

WASHINGTON, DC – Congressman Mike Pence, a member of the House
International Relations Committee, on a Congressional Delegation trip
to the Middle East, met with the Foreign Minister of Turkey today.
The following is his latest blog entry on the meeting:
<;

Turkey May 8, 2006

Months ago, when we planned to visit Ankara, the capitol city of
Turkey, on our way back from Iraq, little did we know that our visit
would take place in the midst of swirling international developments
regarding Iran.

I did not imagine that our meetings with the Foreign Minister of
Turkey, Abdullah Gul, would take place while the UN was debating
sanctions against Iran.

And I never imagined that our meeting with the General Secretary of
Turkey’s National Security Council would take place in the same
building and in the same conference room where the National Security
Advisor of Iran had just concluded a meeting ten minutes earlier. But
that’s just what happened.

Our day began with a short drive to the palatial residence of the
Foreign Minister of Turkey, Abdullah Gul. A pleasant and earnest man,
the Foreign Minister ushered us into a large conference room and
offered a perfunctory welcome.

After I thanked our host for receiving us, I opened the meeting with
reference to the fact that the United States values our relationship
with Turkey, despite recent differences over our policy in Iraq. I
reiterated the comments expressed by Secretary of State Rice in her
visit to this country just two weeks ago and invited his comments on
Iraq and Iran. Others expressed our concern over the recent meeting
with Hamas in Turkey and urged a just resolution of the question of
Armenian genocide.

The Foreign Minister leaned forward on his elbows and went to work
explaining the Turkish view of each of the issues in an intense but
friendly manner.

On Iraq, he expressed the long-standing position of Turkey that Iraq
must remain a single country. He said the new government should
“concentrate on Baghdad and should not think of separating the
country.” He urged a long view of the challenges we face in Iraq
saying, “I believe for a long time, Iraq will keep us busy.”

On the subject of withdrawal, he was equally blunt: “We should not
give up until we se a stable and democratic Iraq….a sudden or
immediate withdrawal from Iraq by the United States would be a
catastrophe.”

Of the root causes of the insurgency: “Iran’s influence is
deepening.”

On the subject of Iran’s nuclear enrichment program, the Foreign
Minister alluded to a meeting later in the day with a delegation from
Iran that included Iran’s National Security Advisor Larijani. He said
he expected the Iranians to argue that they needed nuclear power to
meet their energy needs but added, “They cannot convince us. They
have enough energy sources.” He assured us that he would deliver a
“strong message” that “nuclear program is wrong” and closed saying
that on the subject of Iran’s nuclear program, “our policies are the
same as United States.”

Later in the day we met with the civilian National Security Council
headed by Ambassador Yigit Alpogan. Until very recently, this agency
was the center of Turkey’s national security and is still housed in
an opulent building of long corridors, red carpets and ceremonial
military displays. We entered the conference room and sat at a long
table facing our Turkish counterparts and learned, to our surprise,
that the Iranian delegation left that room just ten minutes before we
arrived. The topic: Iran’s nuclear enrichment program. We got right
down to business.

I asked the Ambassador what insights he might share about the
situation in Iran since Turkey had shared a border with Iran and had
close dealings since about the 15th century.

That was the moment that he informed us that the Iranians had just
left and that he had been meeting with them for the past four hours.

He said that Iran had made its case: “they have complaints; they say
they have been misunderstood…that they would like the right to have
peaceful uses of nuclear energy.” Interestingly, he said that the
Iranians “are open to inspections and transparency” saying that they
assured him “they don’t have nothing to hide.”

When we asked how he had responded, flanked by two military generals,
the civilian head of Turkey’s national security said, “We are
disturbed that they are intending to acquire nuclear weapons
technology.” Much later in the discussion, he would use this same
phrase, “we told them we are disturbed.”

When one colleague asked, “What are they really up to?”, the Foreign
Minister replied in a nonchalant manner, “They want to develop a
nuclear weapon as soon as possible.”

The Iranians apparently didn’t make their case.

Of solutions, the Foreign Minister stated emphatically that “the only
way to solve the problem is through diplomatic matters.” But he said
he had made it clear to Iran that Turkey stand with the UN saying,
“Turkey will abide by all means to any Security Council Resolution.”
In all, it was an encouraging meeting with a friend who was willing
to speak truth to their neighbor.

As we prepared to end the meeting, I told the Foreign Minister how
grateful we were to be received on such a momentous day where he met
with Iranian and American officials in the same day. To lighten the
moment, I said, “I won’t ask you which meeting was more tedious!” Our
host burst into laughter adding, “And I will not answer this question
anyway!” A meeting among friends should always end in a spirit of
friendship.

As we fly across Europe enroute to visit soldiers at our hospital in
Germany, I am certain that while we are leaving Turkey behind, the
topic of our attention in these high level meetings will be front and
center for some time. I leave with a sense of the seriousness of this
moment in contemporary world history. I also leave with a sense that,
while we may differ from time to time with the government of Turkey,
we have in this ancient land a friend of freedom and of the United
States. And that will be an asset as the United States responds in
Iraq and to Iran in the uncertain days that lie ahead.

http://mikepence.house.gov/blog/&gt
http://mikepence.house.gov/blog/

Ottawa juge que le rappel de l’ambassadeur turc une affaire interne

Agence France Presse
8 mai 2006 lundi 8:38 PM GMT

Ottawa juge que le rappel de l’ambassadeur turc est une affaire
interne

Le gouvernement canadien a évité lundi de commenter le rappel en
consultations par Ankara de son ambassadeur à Ottawa, en raison de
désaccords sur l’appellation du “génocide” arménien, estimant que ces
consultations étaient une affaire intérieure turque.

“Ces consultations sont une affaire intérieure turque et nous ne
voulons pas nous livrer à des spéculations sur leur nature”, a
déclaré Kim Gurtel, une porte-parole du ministère des Affaires
étrangères.

“Nous avons été avisés par une note diplomatique le 4 mai que
l’ambassadeur turc quitterait le Canada le 6 mai pour des
consultations à Ankara”, a noté la porte-parole. Un porte-parole du
ministère turc a indiqué que les ambassadeurs à Paris et Ottawa “se
trouvaient à Ankara pour une brève période pour des consultations
liées à la question arménienne”, a-t-elle ajouté.

La Turquie a annoncé officiellement lundi le rappel en consultations
des deux diplomates, indiquant sans autre précision que celles-ci
concernaient “les derniers développements”.

Ankara avait averti la France la semaine dernière que les relations
bilatérales pourraient être gravement affectées si l’Assemblée
nationale française votait une loi permettant des poursuites contre
toute personne niant l’existence du “génocide” arménien. Et les
autorités turques s’étaient déclarées “consternées” par des propos du
Premier ministre canadien Stephen Harper.

Ce dernier avait salué le 21 avril la commémoration du génocide
arménien, reconnu par des résolutions du Parlement canadien.

Genocide term prompts Turkish snub

Al-Jazeera, Qatar
May 8 2006

Genocide term prompts Turkish snub

Monday 08 May 2006, 16:18 Makka Time, 13:18 GMT

Turkey has recalled its ambassadors to France and Canada for
consultations in a row over Armenian deaths during the first world
war.

Both France and Canada acknowledge the mass killings of Armenians was
a genocide.

The temporary recall of the diplomats was Turkey’s latest move
against increasing international pressure on the country to recognise
the killings as genocide.

Turks say the death count is inflated and insist that Armenians were
killed or displaced as the Ottoman Empire tried to secure its border
with Russia and stop attacks by Armenian militants.

Turkey recently criticised Stephen Harper, the Canadian prime
minister, for remarks he made in support of recognising the mass
killings as genocide, and said that such statements threatened
Turkish-Canadian relations.

Turkey has also warned French politicians not to approve a draft law
which would make the denial of the genocide a crime.

France’s parliament is set to consider next week a one-article bill,
which would make it a crime to deny the Armenian genocide of 1915. It
is already an offence in France to deny the Holocaust of the second
world war.

Armenians say 1.5 million of their people were killed as the Ottoman
Empire forced them from eastern Turkey between 1915 and 1923 – and
that this was a deliberate campaign of genocide by Turkey’s rulers at
that time.

Location Of A-320 Plane’s Black Boxes Clarified

LOCATION OF A-320 PLANE’S BLACK BOXES CLARIFIED

YEREVAN, MAY 8, NOYAN TAPAN. As of May 8, in spite of bad weather
conditions, searches are going on in the place of accident of A-320
plane. The location of black boxes was clarified the previous
day. According to the specialists, they are in a smaller, 400-450
meters, depth than it was supposed. At present the specialists are
working in the direction of lifting them from the bottom of the
sea. As the Russian side affirms, the searches will continue as long
as there is hope to find something connected with the plane.

Specialists from RF, Ukraine, France also take part in the
searches. Cyprus, Italy and Great Britain have also offered their
assistance. The last group of the relatives of the victims will return
to Armenia on May 8. According to the official data, no corpses of
those who died in the accident have been found in the recent days. At
present, 56 corpses out of those of 113 victims have been found and
only 48 of them have been indentified by now. 36 of them have been
moved to Armenia. At the request of the relatives, 48 jugs with the
sea sand and water from the territory of the accident were also moved
to Armenia. They will be committed to the earth instead of the
non-found corpses.

Genocide armenien: des historiens “choques” par la proposition de lo

Genocide armenien: des historiens “choques” par la proposition de loi socialiste

Agence France Presse
6 mai 2006 samedi 1:44 PM GMT

PARIS 6 mai 2006 — Plusieurs historiens de renom se declarent
“profondement choques” par la proposition de loi recemment deposee
par le groupe socialiste qui vise a sanctionner penalement la negation
du genocide armenien, dans un texte transmis samedi a l’AFP.

Dans ce texte, les signataires, qui avaient deja lance en decembre une
petition – “Liberte pour l’histoire!” – s’opposant au vote de “lois
memorielles”, se declarent “profondement choques par la proposition de
loi deposee par le groupe socialiste qui devrait venir en discussion
devant l’Assemblee nationale le 18 mai”.

Cette proposition de loi complètera, si elle est adoptee, la loi du
29 janvier 2001 par laquelle l’Etat francais reconnaît le genocide
armenien de 1915 mais qui ne prevoit pas de sanction en cas de
negationnisme.

“Nous avions naguère mis en garde contre le vote et la promulgation
de verites officielles indignes d’un regime democratique”, poursuit
le texte.

Selon la proposition de loi, la negation du genocide armenien devrait
“etre punie des memes peines que la negation de la Shoah”. “Pareille
disposition, poursuit le texte des historiens, aggraverait les
atteintes a la liberte d’expression. Elle prendrait une nouvelle fois
les enseignants en otage. C’est affligeant”.

Les signataires du texte se declarent d’autant plus choques qu’ils
avaient rencontre, en decembre 2005, des responsables de groupes
parlementaires de l’Assemblee nationale “qui leur avaient assure a
demi-mot qu’aucune nouvelle disposition ne viendrait aggraver les
lois memorielles”.

Outre l’historien Jean-Pierre Azema, on trouvait parmi les signataires
de la petition “Liberte pour l’histoire”, des universitaires comme
Elisabeth Badinter, Marc Ferro, Jacques Julliard, Pierre Nora, Mona
Ozouf, Jean-Pierre Vernant, Pierre Vidal-Naquet.

Le vice-president UMP de l’Assemblee nationale, Eric Raoult, a depose
une proposition de loi similaire.

Dans leur petition “Liberte pour l’histoire!”, plus de 400
universitaires se declaraient notamment “emus par les interventions
politiques de plus en plus frequentes dans l’appreciation des
evenements du passe”. Ils demandaient en outre l’abrogation d’un
certain nombre d’articles de loi “indignes d’un regime democratique”

En ce qui concerne le genocide armenien, la Turquie rejette
categoriquement la thèse d’un genocide, estimant qu’il s’agissait
d’une repression dans un contexte de guerre civile où les Armeniens
se sont allies aux troupes russes qui avaient envahi l’empire ottoman.

Ankara evalue a 300.000 le nombre d’Armeniens massacres et affirme
qu’au moins autant de Turcs ont ete tues.

Les Armeniens affirment pour leur part que le nombre de morts durant
des massacres ou des deportations avoisine 1,5 million.

Recemment, a Lyon, des inscriptions en francais et en turc niant le
genocide avaient ete decouvertes sur des stèles du memorial qui lui
est dedie, quelques jours avant son inauguration.

–Boundary_(ID_l8VEgd6t6T7oeYuEz8Q8 Gg)–