ANKARA: Poll: Yerevan Visit Applauded By Majority

POLL: YEREVAN VISIT APPLAUDED BY MAJORITY

Today’s Zaman
o?load=detay&link=152595&bolum=100
Sept 9 2008
Turkey

A brief visit by President Abdullah Gul to Yerevan to attend a soccer
match between the Turkish and Armenian national teams was welcomed
by an overwhelming majority of Turkish society, as it was considered
a landmark step to thaw relations between the two countries, a new
opinion poll has found.

The Ankara-based MetroPOLL Strategic & Social Research Center
conducted a survey on Gul’s visit to Yerevan to learn Turks’ views
on the visit. According to the survey, 69.6 percent of those polled
found Gul’s visit to Armenia successful, a figure suggesting that Turks
are hopeful the visit may be a turning point in the relations between
Turkey and Armenia. Armenian President Serzh Sarksyan invited Gul to
watch a World Cup qualifying match between the Turkish and Armenian
national teams in Yerevan. Gul’s acceptance of the invitation raised
hopes for dialogue that could eventually restore relations between the
two estranged neighbors and help bury an almost century-old hostility.

Gul was the first Turkish president to set foot in Armenia since it
declared independence from the Soviet Union in 1991. Though Turkey
was among the first countries to recognize Armenia’s independence,
it closed its border with the country and severed formal ties
with Yerevan after Armenia occupied the Azerbaijani territory of
Nagorno-Karabakh. But the origins of the dispute between Turkey and
Armenia go further back in history.

Armenia claims the Ottoman Turks killed 1.5 million Armenians in
eastern Anatolia during World War I as part of a systematic campaign
of genocide.

The major question of the survey was whether Gul’s visit to Armenia
was successful or not. An overwhelming 69.6 percent of respondents said
the visit was successful, whereas 15 percent said it was unsuccessful
and 15.4 percent said they had no idea.

"Turkey and Armenia took a step to normalize relations after long years
of dispute. Though some political parties and politicians strongly
opposed Gul traveling to Yerevan, both the government and the president
did the best to thaw the ice between the two countries. Gul’s visit
to Armenia was met with satisfaction by the Turkish nation. To me,
this visit may be a turning point in Turkish-Armenian relations,"
said Professor Ozer Sencar, one of the administrators of the poll.

Professor Eser KarakaÅ~_, a columnist for the Star daily, said the
visit was a huge step for the settlement of problems between the
two neighbors.

"This is a significant step of goodwill. It would be great if both
countries reinforced this step with similar ones in the future. It
may not solve all problems between Turkey and Armenia but may at
least help Turkey open its border with its neighbor," he stated.

Another question directed to respondents in the poll was on the tough
stance of the main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) and
the opposition Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) toward Gul’s visit to
Yerevan. When asked whether the CHP and the MHP were right to react
negatively to Gul’s visit, 65.6 percent of those polled said the two
opposition parties were wrong to harshly criticize the visit. Only
24.9 percent of respondents said the two parties were right to do so
and 9.5 percent said they had no idea.

Officials from the CHP and the MHP were extremely critical of the visit
to Armenia by Gul. They said a visit to Yerevan would mean alienating
Azerbaijan, which is of vital importance to Turkey in many respects.

Sencar emphasized that the Turkish nation was troubled by the CHP and
MHP’s harsh reaction against the visit. "Our people don’t deem such
reactions as democratic behavior. A considerable majority of society
is aware that these two parties strive to create an atmosphere of
chaos in the country. However, society doesn’t want to experience
any other crises," he stated.

KarakaÅ~_ agreed, adding that the dispute between Turkey and Armenia
stems from political disaccord and that the two nations are not
parties to this conflict.

"People of the two countries say at every opportunity that they
don’t have any problems with each other. It is the states which have
problems," he noted.

Sencar also stated that the Turkish nation will give the best response
to the rash behavior of the CHP and the MHP at the ballot box. "Both
of the opposition parties displayed stances indicating that they
want to maintain the crisis between Turkey and Armenia. However,
people here want to have neighborly relations with Armenia. I think
both the CHP and the MHP will suffer from their tough stance against
the normalization of relations with Armenia," he remarked.

A previous survey by MetroPOLL had revealed that the opposition
parties in Turkey continue to suffer from declining popularity with
the public. It showed that the CHP and the MHP would remain below
the election threshold should general elections be held on the poll
date. Only 9.5 percent of respondents said they would vote for the CHP,
while 6.6 percent said they would favor the MHP.

Another topic of the new poll was future relations with Armenia. In
response to a question over what kind of policy Turkey should pursue in
relations with its neighbor, 62.8 percent of those polled said Turkey
should develop diplomatic and economic relations with Armenia, whereas
25.9 percent said it should maintain the existing policies. Another
11.3 percent said they had no idea.

"Our people are tired of disputes with Armenia, which are of no
benefit to Turkey. We have had an ongoing debate with Armenia for
80 years. People don’t want events dating back to the Ottoman times
to affect their lives any longer. This is why they attach such great
importance to Gul’s visit to Yerevan," concluded Sencar.

The telephone poll was conducted Sept. 7 among a random national
sampling of 1,019 adults residing in cities, towns and villages. The
margin of error for the full poll is 2.5 percentage points, at a 95
percent confidence level.

–Boundary_(ID_MNAg1IffCYY0dP37iTASwQ)–

http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/detaylar.d

ANKARA: Turkish, Armenian FMs discuss relations, Caucasus

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Sept 7 2008

TURKISH, ARMENIAN FOREIGN MINISTERS DISCUSS RELATIONS, CAUCASUS

Ankara, 7 September: Turkish President Abdullah Gul returned from
Armenia to Turkey late on Saturday [6 September].

He watched a 2010 World Cup qualifying game between the national
soccer teams of Turkey and Armenia, and also held a meeting with
Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan.

Turkish Foreign Minister Ali Babacan, who also visited Yerevan with
Gul, held a meeting with Armenian Foreign Minister Edvard Nalbandyan.

Babacan-Nalbandyan meeting was positive and productive; the target of
the both parties was to provide full normalization in relations. They
also discussed situation in Caucasus, recent developments in Georgia
and Upper Karabakh issue.

Babacan and Karabakh agreed that the two countries would meet again
during general assembly meeting of UN which will take place in New
York.

After completing his meeting, Babacan returned to Turkey.

ANKARA: Turkey beats Armenia in historic game attended by both leade

Hürriyet, Turkey
Sept 6 2008

Turkey beats Armenia in a historic game attended by both leaders

The national teams of Armenia and Turkey came together on Saturday in
a World Cup qualifying match in Yerevan. However this game had greater
significance than regular sporting competitions given the attendance
of the presidents of both countries, who do not have any diplomatic
relations. Turkey won the match 2-0. (UPDATED)

Expectations were low for a major breakthrough in the frozen relations
between the two countries during the football diplomacy, but it was
seen as an opportunity to start taking steps toward the normalization
of relations.

Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan has invited his Turkish counterpart
Abdullah Gul to watch the game together in Yerevan to mark "a new
symbolic start in the countries’ relations". Gul had accepted the
invitation.

Gul met Saturday Sargsyan at the Armenian president’s office for talks
during the Turkish president’s historical visit to the Caucasus
nation.

The two leaders said there now is a "political will" to resolve
decades of animosity, following landmark talks in Yerevan.

"I hope that this visit will create the possiblity to improve
bilateral relations," Gul was quoted by AFP as saying at a joint press
conference with Sargsyan.

Sargsyan declared there now is a "political will to decide the
questions between our countries, so that these problems are not passed
on to the next generation".

The Armenian president also said he had been invited by Gul to attend
a return football match between the two nations in Turkey next year.

"Today the president of Turkey invited me for a reciprocal visit to
Turkey to watch the next match. I think this is a good start,"
Sargsyan said.

Gul also said the two "shared opinions on how to bring stability and
cooperation to the Caucasus region" and thanked Sargsyan for welcoming
a Turkish proposal for a new regional forum in the volatile zone.

NATO member Turkey has called for the establishment of a forum to
boost cooperation in the Caucasus, involving regional countries and
Moscow, after tensions between Georgia and Russia erupted in a
military conflict last month.

Sargsyan, for his part, said he was "very pleased" to see from Turkey
"a readiness to create stability and cooperation in the region."

TURKEY WINS THE GAME The leaders went to the stadium to watch the
World Cup qualifier between Armenia and Turkey that began at 1600 GMT,
after the meeting.

Armenian fans booed and hissed as Gul took his seat at the stadium and
as the Turkish national anthem played, AFP reported.

Turkey won the match 2-0.

Tuncay Sanli scored in the 60th minute of the match to give Turkey a
1-0 lead. The second goal came from Semih Senturk in the 78. minute.

Security was tight for the two presidents, who sat together with their
delegations in a special bullet-proof area. At the final whistle the
groups exchanged handshakes and applauded as the players on the pitch
traded shirts.

LIFTING BARRIERS Before his departure for Yerevan, Gul said he hoped
his trip would not only draw the two countries together, but also
contribute to regional peace.

"It is my wish that this match will help lift the barriers dividing
two people who share a common history and will contribute to regional
friendship and peace," Gul said.

"We have noticed a month ago how disputes in the Caucasus region pose
a threat to stability and peace in the region. The war between the
Russian Federation and Georgia had an impact not only on the regional
countries but the whole globe," he said.

Gul said Sargsyan and he would have an opportunity to discuss the
developments in the region, adding his visit to Yerevan took place at
an important period.

"As you know, we developed an initiative titled ‘Caucasus Stability
and Cooperation Platform’ to facilitate permanent stability and peace
in the Caucasus. We held discussions with the prospective members of
this platform except with Armenia. During my visit to Yerevan, I will
have a chance to exchange viewpoints on this platform with the
Armenian President Sargsyan," Turkish president said.

"I wish that the match to be played today will help the lifting of
obstacles that prohibit closeness between the two peoples that share
common history and will contribute to regional friendship and peace,"
Gul said. "With these feelings and thoughts, I wish our national team
success," Gul added.

Gul was welcomed by Armenian Foreign Minister Eduard Nalbandian at
Yerevan’s Zvartnots airport. The airport has been decorated with
Turkish and Armenian flags.

Armenian officials have implemented tight security measures in
Yerevan. Streets around the stadium and the presidential office were
closed to traffic.

FIRST PRESIDENT VISITING ARMENIA
Gul became the first Turkish leader ever to set foot in neighboring
Armenia.

Turkey is among the first countries that recognized Armenia when it
declared its independency in the early 1990s.

However there is no diplomatic relations between two countries, as
Armenia presses the international community to admit the so-called
"genocide" claims instead of accepting Turkey’s call to investigate
the allegations, and its invasion of 20 percent of Azerbaijani
territory despite U.N. Security Council resolutions on the issue.

Turkey hopes an enhancement of mutual relations would eventually help
to bring an end to the so-called genocide claims with the
establishment of a commission to investigate the true history and the
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

In 2005, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan took a tentative first
step towards resolving the thorny genocide issue by proposing that a
joint commission of historians launch an investigation and publish
their conclusions.

The proposal was rejected by Yerevan and expectations are high in
Turkey that the warming relations would help Armenia to accept this
proposal.

Armenia, with the backing of the Diaspora, claims up to 1.5 million of
their kin were slaughtered in orchestrated killings in 1915. Turkey
rejects the claims, saying that 300,000 Armenians along with at least
as many Turks died in civil strife that emerged when Armenians took up
arms for independence in eastern Anatolia.

Des relations bilaterales difficiles

Le Figaro, France
Jeudi 4 Septembre 2008

Des relations bilatérales difficiles

1991 : l’Arménie, ancienne république soviétique, devient
indépendante.

1993 : la Turquie ferme sa frontière commune avec l’Arménie pour
protester contre la guerre au Haut-Karabakh, une enclave en
Azerbaïdjan que revendiquent les Arméniens.

1994 : un cessez-le-feu entre Erevan et Bakou met fin aux opérations
militaires dans la province séparatiste, sans régler le conflit qui a
fait 30 000 morts.

19 février 2008 : le premier ministre arménien Serge Sarkissian,
originaire du Haut-Karabakh, est élu président de l’Arménie dès le
premier tour de scrutin.

Mai-juillet 2008 : rencontres secrètes de délégations turque et
arménienne.

6 septembre 2008 : visite prévue du président de la République turque,
Abdullah Gül, à Erevan pour assister au match de football
Turquie-Arménie.

Time for opening Armenian-Turkish border hasn’t come yet

PanARMENIAN.Net

Time for opening Armenian-Turkish border hasn’t come yet
05.09.2008 15:53 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ A visit is not beginning of talks, said Svante
Cornell, research director of the Stockholm Central Asia-Caucasus
Institute.

It should be taken as a gesture, according to him.

`Turkey will not change its tough policy toward Armenia and the time
to open the border with Armenia hasn’t come yet. Turkey made this move
not on its own accord, but under U.S. pressure, as the war in Abkhazia
and South Ossetia seriously affected Armenia’s economy,’ Cornell said.

`West understands that only restoration of relations with Turkey can
help to revive economy in Armenia,’ he added, Trend Azeri news agency
reports.

Gul’s visiting Armenian genocide memorial would be a leap forward

PanARMENIAN.Net

Turkish Daily News: Gul’s visiting Armenian genocide memorial would be
a leap forward
05.09.2008 18:36 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ `By visiting Yerevan on Saturday, Gul will in fact
take a giant step for the future. I don’t think that Gul will visit
the genocide monument, but if he were to, history could have opened
the doors wide. Turkey could have made a leap forward, let alone just
a few steps,’ Turkish Daily News observer Cengiz Candar writes.

`Such a gesture has nothing to do with acceptance of genocide. Such a
gesture only means `Gul is cognizant to tragic memories of our common
past. And I, as the president of Turkey, do have respect to all,’ he
writes.

Gul will be in Yerevan on Sept. 6 for a qualifying World Cup game
between the Armenian and Turkish national teams.

Armenia, Turkey Put Differences Aside For Soccer

EurasiaNet, NY
Sept 5 2008

ARMENIA, TURKEY PUT DIFFERENCES ASIDE FOR SOCCER
Marianna Grigoryan 9/05/08

A football match could possibly give a kick-start to efforts by
Armenia and Turkey to normalize relations. On September 6, Turkish
President Abdullah Gul will travel to Yerevan to watch a 2010 World
Cup qualifying soccer match between Armenia and Turkey, thus becoming
the first Turkish leader to visit Armenia.

Scheduled to arrive in Yerevan two hours before the game starts at
9.00 pm local time, President Gul is slated to dine with Armenian
President Serzh Sargsyan before the two attend the game at Yerevan’s
reconstructed Hrazdan football stadium. Gul will return to Turkey
following the end of the match. Gul’s visit will take place amid high
security, and he will watch the qualifying match from behind
bullet-proof glass.

After months of speculation, confirmation that Gul had accepted
President Sarkisian’s invitation only came on September 3. Opposition
politicians and government officials alike in Yerevan voiced hope that
the football game could create a long-awaited diplomatic breakthrough
in relations, which have been marked by enmity since Armenia gained
independence amid the 1991 Soviet collapse. Turkey closed its border
with Armenia and broke off diplomatic ties following Armenia’s
1988-1994 war with Azerbaijan, a strong Turkish ally, over the
breakaway enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh.

"The visit of the Turkish president is the most important political
event for Armenia," commented senior Republic Party member Suren
Sureniants. "The visit will have an indirect influence not only on our
foreign, but also on domestic policy and will lead to the start of new
relations."

As a sign of that outlook, the opposition movement led by ex-President
Levon Ter-Petrosian postponed for a week a rally that had been planned
for September 5 in Yerevan. "We should establish normal,
good-neighborly relations with Turkey without preconditions,"
Ter-Petrosian said at a recent press conference. "When I said this
[earlier], they would say what treachery it is. And now, they keep
repeating it night and day," he said in reference to government
officials. Not all Armenian politicians feel the same, however. The
Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutiun), a traditional
nationalist party, has vowed to mount protests against Gul’s
visit. Similar demonstrations have been threatened in Turkey, too.

Centrist Turkish media outlets have been generally supportive of Gul’s
pending visit. Meanwhile, Azerbaijan — a close Turkish ally, as well
as a bitter enemy of Armenia — has given its official blessing to the
trip. On September 4, Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov said that
Azerbaijani leaders "welcome this initiative positively," the Turkish
daily Hurriyet reported.

A September 3 statement from Gul’s office noted that the Turkish
president had accepted Sarkisian’s invitation to "create a new climate
of friendship in the region" and to "lift the obstacles preventing the
coming together of two peoples who share a common history."

The statement echoes sentiments expressed by Sargsyan, who in a July 8
Wall St. Journal commentary, entitled "We Are Ready to Talk to
Turkey," expressed a desire for "a new phase of dialogue with the
government and people of Turkey, with the goal of normalizing
relations and opening our common border."

Although officials in both countries seem eager to explore a
rapprochement, there are many on both sides who remain
suspicious. Ruben Safrastian, director of the Institute of Oriental
Studies at the Armenian National Academy of Sciences, is among the
skeptics in Yerevan who do not believe the visit will live up to its
hype. Safrastian argues that Turkey is not prepared to deviate
dramatically from its current policy on Armenia. Gul’s last-minute
decision to accept Sarkisian’s invitation was more likely dictated
both by regional tensions linked to Russia’s war with Georgia, and by
an upcoming debate in the US Congress about Ottoman Turkey’s 1915
slaughter of thousands of ethnic Armenians, Safrastian suggested.

"There may be some small change that will result in some thaw between
the two countries, however, Gul will try to use the visit to
strengthen his positions in the region," Safrastian said. "The Turks
will use this visit to prove their goodwill. However, in reality, they
will do everything to use it in their interest."

As for the actual football qualifying match, coaches and players are
not trying to allow politics to intrude on the competition. "We
footballers think quickly and we like to play quickly. But it would
slow us down if we tried to take history’s weight on our
shoulders. That would ruin our game," the Turkish Daily News quoted
Turkey’s head coach, Fatih Terim as saying. Added Armenia’s head
coach, Jan Poulsen, a longtime Danish soccer manager, at a September 4
press conference: "We are in a good form at this moment. We feel
determined and will do our best."

Editor’s Note: Marianna Grigoryan is a reporter for the ArmeniaNow.com
weekly in Yerevan.

Azerbaijan Supports Initiative On Creation Of Platform Of Cooperatio

AZERBAIJAN SUPPORTS INITIATIVE ON CREATION OF PLATFORM OF COOPERATION IN CAUCASUS – FM

arminfo
2008-09-05 11:18:00

ArmInfo. Azerbaijan considers Turkey’s initiative on creation of
a Platform of cooperation and security in the Caucasus positive,
Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov told journalists the day
before. On August 11, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan proposed
an initiative of creation of a "Platform of Stability and Cooperation
in the Caucasus". It is aimed at stabilization of the situation in the
region and envisages participation of five countries of the region in
the Platform. "Azerbaijan considers Turkey’s initiative on creation
of such a Platform positive. It will be a very positive fact for the
region countries in case stability is established in the Caucasus",
Mammadyarov said. As the minister said, "we must keep on consulting
in this direction". "You know that the Georgian and Russian foreign
ministers have already been in Turkey and held negotiations there.

Azerbaijan will also continue these discussions with Russia, Georgia
and other countries", he said. Along with it, the minister said that
"it is still early to say in which form this Platform will be taken",
the Azerbaijani mass media report.

Russia Accuses Cheney Of Ulterior Motives In Visit

RUSSIA ACCUSES CHENEY OF ULTERIOR MOTIVES IN VISIT

Associated Press Worldstream
September 3, 2008 Wednesday 11:04 AM GMT

A Russian security official says U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney is
seeking U.S. access to oil and gas during a trip to the resource-rich
Caucasus.

Nikolai Patrushev says the goal of Cheney’s visit to Azerbaijan,
Georgia and Ukraine is to trade U.S. support for energy supplies.

He says the U.S. had to ensure these countries had "corresponding
regimes" in order to make that happen.

Patrushev is the head of Russia’s powerful presidential Security
Council, and is in the Armenian capital of Yerevan for a meeting of
a Moscow-led bloc called the Collective Security Treaty Organization.

Patrushev said Wednesday that the seven-member bloc had unanimously
backed Russia’s actions in its short war with Georgia last month.

CSTO Security Councils Chiefs To Discuss NCaucasus Situation

CSTO SECURITY COUNCILS CHIEFS TO DISCUSS NCAUCASUS SITUATION

ITAR-TASS
Aug 31 2008
Russia

MOSCOW, September 3 (Itar-Tass) – The Secretaries of the Security
Councils of the Collective Security Treaty Organisation (CSTO)
member-countries meet in Yerevan on Wednesday to discuss the situation
in the North Caucasus area following Georgia’s aggression against
South Ossetia.

An official in the press service of the CSTO Secretariat has told
Itar-Tass that participants in the meeting are to discuss tendencies
in the development of the military-and-political situation within the
CSTO zone of responsibility and adjacent areas as well as measures
to neutralise arising challenges and threats to collective security.

Those present at the meeting are also to consider a draft agreement on
the training of personnel for law enforcement, firefighting, emergency
rescue agencies and specials services of the CSTO member-countries.

The chiefs of the CSTO security councils are to examine drafts of a
decision of the CSTO Collective Security Council about stepping up
activities against the trafficking of narcotics, a programme for the
formation of an information security system, a plan for collective
actions aimed at implementing the 2008-2012 UN Global Counterterrorist
Strategy.