RFE/RL Armenian Report – 09/20/2019

                                        Thursday, 

Pashinian Demands ‘New Impetus’ To Fight Against Corruption


Armenia - Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian discusses with the heads of 
law-enforcement agencies the fight against corruption, Yerevan, September 20, 
2019.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian on Friday ordered Armenian law-enforcement 
authorities to step up their anti-corruption efforts and, in particular, 
recover more public funds embezzled or wasted by former officials.

Pashinian met with the heads of Armenia’s law-enforcement agencies and State 
Oversight Service to discuss what his press office described as further 
“measures planned in the fight against corruption.”

“I believe that we need to give new impetus to the fight against corruption 
and, if I can put it this way, restart this process,” he said in his opening 
remarks publicized by the office. “I find that extremely important not only in 
terms of solving corruption-related crimes committed in the past. I am also 
convinced that if we are not principled enough on this issue corruption is a 
phenomenon which will find ways of adapting to the new conditions and showing 
the ability to come back in a phased, slow, creeping fashion.”

The meeting came just days after Pashinian forced the resignations of the chief 
of the Armenian police, Valeri Osipian, and the director of the National 
Security Service (NSS), Artur Vanetsian, for still unclear reasons.

Vanetsian had overseen some of the most high-profile corruption investigations 
launched in Armenia since last year’s “Velvet Revolution.” He criticized 
Pashinian’s “spontaneous” leadership style in a September 16 statement that 
announced his resignation.

Pashinian said on Wednesday that Vanetsian’s exit will not reflect negatively 
on his administration’s anti-graft drive. “In the new Armenia the NSS is not a 
[single] individual, the NSS is a system and it will go after all current and 
former corrupt individuals, spies and other elements of this kind,” he wrote on 
Facebook.

Vanetsian and Osipian were replaced on a temporary basis by their respective 
deputies: Eduard Martirosian and Arman Sargsian. Both men attended the 
corruption-related meeting held by Pashinian.


Armenia - Vachagan Ghazarian, ex-President Serzh Sarkisian's former chief 
bodyguard, empties his bag filled with cash after being arrested by the 
National Security Service in Yerevan, 25 June 2018.

The 44-year-old prime minister has repeatedly claimed to have eliminated 
“systemic corruption” in the country since he swept to power in May 2018. 
During his 16-month rule, law-enforcement authorities have brought serious 
corruption charges against dozens of persons, including close relatives and 
cronies of former President Serzh Sarkisian.

Pashinian said on Friday that the state has recovered a total of 51 billion 
drams ($107 million) in lost public publics as a result of those criminal 
cases. He said that while this is “not a small sum” the law-enforcement bodies 
can do “much more.” He stressed at the same time that they must avoid 
“repressions” or other violations of the due process in that endeavor.

Pashinian already said on August 30 that Armenians expect a tougher 
anti-corruption fight from the authorities and that the latter are creating 
“new institutional structures” for that purpose. He praised an anti-graft 
strategy and a three-year action plan drafted by the Armenian Justice Ministry 
in June.

The documents call, among other things, for the creation of anti-corruption 
courts and a special law-enforcement agency empowered to prosecute state 
officials suspected of bribery, fraud and other corrupt practices.



Kocharian Again Denied Bail

        • Naira Bulghadarian

Armenia -- Former President Robert Kocharian waves to supporters during his 
trial, Yerevan, .

Three days after deciding not to recognize Robert Kocharian’s arrest and 
prosecution as unconstitutional, a court in Yerevan also refused on Friday to 
release the former Armenian president from prison on bail.

Anna Danibekian, the judge presiding over the trial of Kocharian and three 
other former senior officials, thus dismissed defense lawyers’ assertions that 
he never attempted to hide from justice or obstruct the criminal investigation 
into the 2008 post-election violence in Yerevan.

The lawyers requested bail for their client on Tuesday immediately after 
Danibekian rejected their interpretation of a recent ruling handed down by 
Armenia’s Constitutional Court. The trial prosecutors objected to the bail 
request. One of them spoke of a “very high risk” of Kocharian going into hiding 
and/or exerting “illegal influence” on witnesses in the event of his release.

The Constitutional Court ruled on September 4 that an article of the Armenian 
Code of Procedural Justice used against Kocharian is unconstitutional because 
it does not take account of current and former senior Armenian officials’ legal 
immunity from prosecution. According to the ex-president’s attorneys, this 
means that he must be set free and cleared of coup charges.


Armenia -- Judge Anna Danibekian presides over the trial of former President 
Robert Kocharian, Yerevan, .

The lawyers said on Tuesday that Danibekian bowed to what they called strong 
pressure exerted on her by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and his political 
allies. One of them, Hayk Alumian, condemned the judge in even stronger terms 
after she refused to grant Kocharian bail.

“The court has thus become a tool for Mr. Kocharian’s political persecution,” 
Alumian charged in the courtroom. The court is now acting like a government 
tool.”

Alumian went on to demand that Danibekian recuse herself from the case. “You 
are unable to administer justice in this case because you are under the 
influence of the force persecuting Mr. Kocharian for political purposes,” the 
lawyer told her.

The 41-year-old judge said she will respond to the demand at the next court 
hearing which she scheduled for October 7.

The high-profile case was assigned to Danibekian less than a month ago. 
Kocharian’s trial was previously presided over by another judge, Davit 
Grigorian. The latter ordered Kocharian freed from custody on May 18. He also 
suspended the trial, questioning the legality of the coup charges leveled 
against the man who ruled Armenia from 1998-2008.

Grigorian was suspended by judicial authorities in July after a law-enforcement 
agency charged him with forgery. The judge denies the accusation.


Armenia -- District court judge Davit Grigorian leaves the courtroom after 
ordering former President Robert Kocharian's release from prison, May 18, 2019.

The Constitutional Court ruling on the case also angered the authorities. 
Pashinian denounced it as “illegal,” while the pro-government majority in the 
Armenian parliament decided to appeal to the high court to replace its 
chairman, Hrayr Tovmasian. Majority leaders accused Tovmasian of serious 
procedural violations and conflict of interest.

Kocharian, his former chief of staff Armen Gevorgian and retired army Generals 
Seyran Ohanian and Yuri Khachaturov stand accused of overthrowing the 
constitutional order in the wake of a disputed presidential election held in 
February 2008. The prosecution says that they illegally used the Armenian 
military against opposition protesters that demanded the rerun of the ballot.

All four defendants deny the accusations. Kocharian, who was also charged with 
bribery early this year, has repeatedly accused Pashinian of waging a 
“political vendetta” against him. The authorities deny political any motives 
behind the case.

Kocharian declared a state of emergency and ordered army units into Yerevan 
late on March 1, 2008 amid violent clashes between protesters and security 
forces which left ten people dead. He handed over power to Serzh Sarkisian, his 
preferred successor and official election winner, in April 2008.



Fugitive Ex-Official Faces More Corruption Charges

        • Susan Badalian

Armenia - Mihran Poghosian, head of the Service for the Mandatory Execution of 
Judicial Acts, at a news conference in Yerevan, January 25, 2013.

Investigators have brought fresh corruption charges against Mihran Poghosian, a 
former senior Armenian official who fled to Russia after being first indicted 
in Armenia early this year.

The Special Investigative Service (SIS) alleged on Friday that Poghosian 
laundered in 2015 $1.2 million in cash acquired through illegal 
entrepreneurship and tax evasion. It said the money was channeled into an 
Armenian company belonging to him in the form of interest-free loans.

According to an SIS statement, one of those “loans” worth $690,000 was 
transferred from the bank account of a firm registered in Panama.

“We can’t give other details at the moment,” a spokeswoman for the 
law-enforcement agency, Marina Ohanjanian, told RFE/RL’s Armenian service. “The 
investigation is continuing.”

Citing leaked documents known as the Panama Papers, an Armenian investigative 
website reported in April 2016 that Poghosian controls three shadowy firms 
registered in the Central American state. Poghosian dismissed the report at the 
time. Nevertheless, he resigned as head of Armenia’s Service for the Mandatory 
Execution of Judicial Acts (SMEJA) shortly afterwards.

A year later, Poghosian was elected to the Armenian parliament on the ticket of 
then President Serzh Sarkisian’s Republican Party. He was widely regarded as an 
influential figure in Armenia’s former leadership toppled during the 2018 
“Velvet Revolution.”

The 43-year-old was already charged in April this year with embezzling at least 
64.2 million drams ($135,000) in public funds while in office. He dismissed the 
charges as politically motivated.

Later in April, Poghosian was detained in Russia on an Armenian arrest warrant. 
However, Russian prosecutors subsequently refused to extradite him to Armenia.

The Russian ambassador in Yerevan, Sergey Kopyrkin, insisted last week that 
Poghosian was not granted political asylum in Russia. “According to my 
information, we are talking about a legal process, about the provision of 
necessary documents [to the Russian authorities,]” he said.



Biden Calls For U.S. Recognition Of Armenian Genocide

        • Heghine Buniatian

U.S. -- Democratic 2020 U.S. presidential candidate and former Vice President 
Joe Biden walks with supporters at the Independence Day parade in Independence, 
Iowa, July 4, 2019.

U.S. Democratic presidential frontrunner and former Vice President Joe Biden 
has called for an official U.S. recognition of the 1915 Armenian genocide in 
Ottoman Turkey.

“The United States must reaffirm, once and for all, our record on the Armenian 
Genocide,” Biden said in a letter to the Armenian National Committee of America 
(ANCA) released by the lobby group on Friday.

“We must never forget or remain silent about this horrific and systematic 
campaign of extermination that resulted in the deaths of 1.5 million Armenian 
men, women, and children and the mass deportation of 2 million Armenians from 
their homes,” he wrote. “If we do not fully acknowledge, commemorate, and teach 
our children about genocide, the words “never again” lose their meaning.”

“Failing to remember or acknowledge the fact of a genocide only paves the way 
for future mass atrocities,” he added.

Biden, who is seeking the Democratic Party’s nomination for the 2020 
presidential election, was a strong backer of Armenian genocide recognition as 
a member the U.S. Senate. In particular, he co-sponsored in 2007 a relevant 
resolution that never reached the Senate floor.

The ANCA noted this fact in a statement. But it also pointed out that former 
President Barack Obama failed to honor his campaign pledges to reaffirm his 
recognition of the genocide if elected.

“The Obama-Biden Administration … pivoted hard against the spirit and letter of 
its high-profile campaign pledge to recognize the Armenian Genocide, deepening 
official U.S. complicity in Turkey’s genocide denials and ongoing obstruction 
of justice for this crime,” read the ANCA statement.


U.S. - U.S. Vice President Joseph Biden, U.S. Ambassador to UN Samantha Power, 
Armenian President Serzh Sarkisian and Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian 
attend a ceremony at the Washington National Cathedral to mark the centennial 
of the Armenian genocide, 7May2015.

In 2010, Biden controversially claimed that then Armenian President Serzh 
Sarkisian had asked Washington not to “force” the issue of genocide recognition 
while Turkish-Armenian negotiations are in progress. Sarkisian denied the claim.

In May 2015, Biden joined Sarkisian and over two thousand Armenian Americans in 
attending a ceremony to mark the 100th anniversary of the Armenian genocide 
held at Washington’s National Cathedral.

In an April 2015 statement, Obama again avoided using the word “genocide” in 
reference to the mass killings. He at the same time implicitly praised Pope 
Francis for honoring the victims of what the pontiff called “the first genocide 
of the 20th century” in a Vatican Mass. Obama also paid tribute to Henry 
Morgenthau, America’s First World War-era ambassador in Constantinople who 
tried to stop what he saw as a “campaign of race extermination” by the Ottoman 
Turks.



Press Review


Lragir.am says that “circles close to Armenia’s former regime” and like-minded 
commentators in Russia are spreading claims about a deterioration of 
Russian-Armenian relations. “Armenia continues to participate in Russian-led 
blocs, vote in Russia’s favor in international structures and fulfill all of 
its contractual obligations,” counters the pro-Western publication. “There have 
been no official statements [by Armenian leaders] on their revision.” In this 
regard, it quotes a Russian analyst, Modest Kolerov, as saying that Moscow is 
unhappy with the continuing imprisonment of former President Robert Kocharian 
and Yerevan’s stated efforts to strike arms deals with third countries. The 
publication argues that not only Nikol Pashinian but also Serzh Sarkisian vowed 
to develop Armenia’s defense industry.

“Zhamanak” is puzzled by Pashinian’s decision to appoint Valeri Osipian as his 
chief adviser right after removing him from the post of chief of the Armenian 
police. “Valeri Osipian is a policeman by profession and supposedly cannot give 
the prime minister professional advice on any other field,” writes the paper. 
“It must therefore be noted that his appointment [as chief adviser] is a 
political act. Is Nikol Pashinian thereby stopping Valeri Osipian from talking 
about the reasons for his resignation?” Osipian promised to give those reasons 
“later on” at a farewell meeting with senior police officials held on September 
18. The paper speculates that he thus threatened to “speak up if something is 
not done” by Pashinian.

“Aravot” weighs in on an unfolding debate over whether Armenia’s police and 
National Security Service (NSS) should be headed by career officers or 
political appointees. “There is no definitive answer to this question,” 
editorializes the paper. It points out that both security agencies were already 
run by political figures in the 1990s. It believes that the government should 
curtail the NSS’s powers, saying that the Armenian successor to the Soviet KGB 
should not deal with crimes like corruption and tax evasion.

(Lilit Harutiunian)


Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2019 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org



ACNIS reView #30, 2019_Editorial_Some election lessons from Artsakh

Editorial   

 

13 SEPTEMBER 2019    

During the September 8 municipal elections in Artsakh, one important circumstance emerged, which is worth discussing in detail. Political changes in Armenia, as can already be argued, have significantly changed the logic of internal political processes in Artsakh. The machine of centralized influence on voters, which has been practiced for more than two decades, has failed. Many observers note that for the first time, people were given the opportunity to make free choices. None of the previous factors suppressing the will of the majority of voters showed their effectiveness. Neither the pro-government parties, nor the bureaucratic corps became the "heroes" of these elections. And the fact that in one of the settlements – Kovsakan – voters showed a massive protest against the announced election results, shows even more clearly that this time only the voters decided the fate of the elections.

Times have clearly changed. Initially, it was clear that for the political forces of Artsakh these elections were a measure of public sentiment with an eye to the upcoming presidential and parliamentary elections next year. This can explain the fact that not one of the existing parties nominated their candidates for key posts in Stepanakert and regional centers. Nobody wanted to see their candidate defeated, as this would mean that a particular party has no influence on voters. Preference was given to the tactics of shadow support of self-nominated people who have authority in society.

However, the election situation was more complex than expected. Nobody managed to hide behind independent candidates. Voters behaved quite unexpectedly. Despite the fact that almost every candidate was initially attached with a cliché “a man of such and such,” “a man of power,” etc., society ignored this circumstance. Mostly, a personal choice proved itself, which is already evident from the percentage of votes cast for each candidate. This is clearly seen from the voting results in Stepanakert, where not one of the candidates received a “breakthrough package” of votes. And only the fact that the law does not provide for a second round of voting allowed one of the candidates to win with a minimum of votes.

Thus, according to preliminary data, David Sargsyan, the non-partisan businessman who won in Stepanakert, received 7787 votes, and reserve officer Grigory Sahakyan came in second place with 4765 votes. In the third place Areg Avagyan garnered 3125 votes. Even the current deputy mayor, Armen Hakobyan, received only 3059 votes, while Araik Avanesyan, who received the least number of votes, still got 2108 votes. Given the fact that in Stepanakert, out of the 39 thousand registered voters, 21,543 voters participated in the vote, the victory could be ensured by receiving all the votes of one fifth of the voters. As you can see, none of the candidates showed a serious influence on the opinions of the majority of residents of the Artsakh capital. Almost half of the voters simply showed no interest in the election.

Voting results in some district centers also demonstrate that the factor of administrative resources and the factor of parties did not have a significant effect on the mood of voters. Preference in many places was given to non-partisan self-nominees.

One can only hope that no one will be able to reverse the wheel of the noted positive process.

  

Զոհրաբ Մնացականյանը կայցելի Լիտվա, Լատվիա և ԱՄՆ

  • 13.09.2019
  •  

  • Հայաստան
  •  

     

 62

ՀՀ արտաքին գործերի նախարար Զոհրաբ Մնացականյանը կայցելի Լիտվա, Լատվիա և ԱՄՆ: Այս մասին ճեպազրույցի ժամանակ այսօր տեղեկացրեց ԱԳՆ խոսնակ Աննա Նաղդալյանը:


«Զոհրաբ Մնացականյանի այցը Վիլնյուս նախատեսված է սեպտեմբերի 16-17-ին, այնուհետ  նա կմեկնի Ռիգա», – նշեց խոսնակը՝ ավելացնելով, որ երկու երկրներում էլ նախատեսված են հանդիպումներ վարչապետերի, ԱԳ նախարարների հետ և խորհրդարաններում:  


Իսկ սեպտեմբերի վերջին նախարար Մնացականյանը կմեկնի ԱՄՆ, որտեղ կմասնակցի ՄԱԿ Գլխավոր ասամբլեայի աշխատանքներին:

4.8 magnitude earthquake recorded in Armenia

4.8 magnitude earthquake recorded in Armenia

Save

Share

 20:37,

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 10, ARMENPRESS. According to the Mediterranean Seismological Center a 4.8 magnitude earthquake was recorded in the territory of Armenia at 20:22 local time. The epicenter was 11 km north from Amasia region, hypocenter – 3 km.

ARMENPRESS reports underground shocks were recorded in Vanadzor, Gyumri and Yerevan.

Edited and translated by Tigran Sirekanyan




Sports: Pellegrini after Italy victory over Armenia: “Mkhitaryan played well. We look forward to seeing him in Rome”.

The Roma Press, Italy
Sept 5 2019

<img width="710" height="495" src=”"https://i1.wp.com/romapress.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Capture3-1.jpg?fit=710%2C495&ssl=1" class="attachment-newsphere-featured size-newsphere-featured wp-post-image" alt="" srcset="https://i1.wp.com/romapress.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Capture3-1.jpg?w=710&ssl=1 710w, https://i1.wp.com/romapress.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Capture3-1.jpg?resize=300%2C209&ssl=1 300w" sizes="(max-width: 710px) 100vw, 710px" />


Roma midfielder Lorenzo Pellegrini scored a goal in Italy’s 3-1 victory over Armenia in the Azzurri’s Euro 2020 qualifier match and spoke to Rai Sport following the clash:

“It was a good night for us, we won a difficult match. They’re a very tough team and we played at a difficult place. Mkhitaryan? He played a good game, we look forward to seeing him in Rome. He’s a great player”.

Turkey and Azerbaijan begin TurAz Falcon joint annual air force exercises

Turkey and Azerbaijan begin TurAz Falcon joint annual air force exercises

Save

Share

17:22, 3 September, 2019

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 3, ARMENPRESS. The 2019 TurAz Falcon Turkish-Azerbaijani joint Air Force military exercises have commenced in Azerbaijan, Anadolu news agency reported.

Around 30 military aircraft are involved in the drills which will take place until September 16.

Turkey has sent its F-16 fighter jets to Azerbaijan for the annual drills.

Edited and translated by Stepan Kocharyan

3 more Armenian citizens injured in Georgia passenger van crash discharged from hospital

3 more Armenian citizens injured in Georgia passenger van crash discharged from hospital

Save

Share

13:38,

YEREVAN, AUGUST 31, ARMENPRESS. 3 out of 7 Armenian citizens hospitalized following a passenger van crash near Tbilisi were discharged from a Georgian hospital, the Armenian Embassy in Georgia told Armenpress.

16 Armenian citizens were hospitalized with various degree injuries following the crash. 9 of them have already been discharged.

“Currently there are 4 Armenian citizens in Georgian hospitals, two of them are in critical condition, one is in serious condition and the other is in stable condition.

A passenger van traveling from Armenia’s capital of Yerevan to Georgia’s Batumi crashed on August 31 near Georgian capital city of Tbilisi at around 02:00-03:00. 2 citizens of Armenia have been killed.

Edited and translated by Aneta Harutyunyan




Newspaper: Why Armenia put off Istanbul Convention ratification matter?

News.am, Armenia
Aug 31 2019
Newspaper: Why Armenia put off Istanbul Convention ratification matter? Newspaper: Why Armenia put off Istanbul Convention ratification matter?

11:01, 31.08.2019
                  

YEREVAN. – A few days ago it became known that the ratification of the Istanbul Convention will not be debated on in the parliament of Armenia this year, and that this document will undergo a thorough examination by the expert and professional circles. Interesting details have become known to Past (Fact) newspaper in this regard, the paper reported.

“According to a source close to the government, [PM] Nikol Pashinyan has held a closed meeting in connection with this matter.

“According to the same source, [at the meeting] Pashinyan said that unless the general situation of the CC [Constitutional Court] is clarified, it is still senseless to make the Istanbul Convention a priority agenda. Pashinyan explained that it may be challenged at the CC, and they will face the fact.

“In fact, aside from the overall heated dissatisfaction [over the Istanbul Convention], this also has been the reason that the discussions on the convention have been temporarily suspended [in Armenia],” Past wrote.

Azerbaijani press: MFA: Armenia’s attempts to present “elections” in Azerbaijan’s occupied territories as indicator of democracy do not stand up to criticism

22 August 2019 22:26 (UTC+04:00)

Baku, Azerbaijan, Aug. 22

Trend:

Armenia, instead of trying to create a false appearance of "exporting democracy" in Karabakh, should think about the pressing problems of its own citizens, Spokesperson of the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry Leyla Abdullayeva told Trend.

She was commenting on the Armenian media reports that on August 22 the Armenian government "for the first time allocated funds to foreign NGOs to monitor the elections in unrecognized Karabakh".

"Regarding this information of the Armenian media, it should be recalled that Armenia, which has occupied the territories of Azerbaijan, is not the first time organizing various kinds of shows there, which it calls "elections" or "referendum". According to their results, the entire international community invariably declares its principled position regarding support for the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Azerbaijan, non-recognition of the illegal regime, as well as any "elections" held by it", she said.

Abdullayeva noted that allocating funds for monitoring the “elections” in the occupied territories of Azerbaijan, the Armenian government once again acknowledges its effective control over the Nagorno-Karabakh region and the surrounding districts, thus confirming the relevant conclusion of the ECHR contained in its 2015 judgement in the case of "Chiragov and Others v. Armenia".

"And finally, attempts to present the so-called "local government elections" in the occupied territories of Azerbaijan as an indicator of democracy do not stand up to criticism. The entire international community condemns the acts of mass destruction of the Azerbaijani population, ethnic cleansing and violation of the fundamental rights of hundreds of thousands of internally displaced persons. Armenia, which is responsible for all these international torts, can in no way claim the status of an exporter of democracy", Abdullayeva said.

She noted that the Armenian government, instead of hopeless attempts to create a false appearance of "exporting democracy" to Karabakh occupied by it, should think about the urgent problems of their own citizens.

"In addition, its actions should not run counter to the logic of advancing the negotiation process to resolve the Armenia-Azerbaijan Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and serve to preserve the status quo based on the illegal occupation of internationally recognized territories of Azerbaijan," she added.

The conflict between the two South Caucasus countries began in 1988 when Armenia made territorial claims against Azerbaijan. As a result of the ensuing war, in 1992 Armenian armed forces occupied 20 percent of Azerbaijan, including the Nagorno-Karabakh region and seven surrounding districts.

The 1994 ceasefire agreement was followed by peace negotiations. Armenia has not yet implemented four UN Security Council resolutions on withdrawal of its armed forces from the Nagorno Karabakh and the surrounding districts.