From Scratch: The Forced Displacement and New Lives of Artsakh Refugees

Note: On January 1, 2024, the Republic of Artsakh was officially dissolved per the decree signed by Artsakh President Samvel Shahramanyan on September 28, 2023, following Azerbaijan’s full throttle military assault that resulted in the fall of Artsakh and the ethnic cleansing of its Armenian population. According to the decree, all Artsakh state institutions have been dissolved, and the republic has ceased to exist. Siranush Sargsyan’s report highlights the ongoing humanitarian crisis arising from the genocide carried out by Azerbaijan against Artsakh and the profound needs of the forcibly displaced Armenians of Artsakh.

One year ago, the depopulation of Artsakh began with a blockade imposed by Azerbaijan on December 13, 2022. It was completed on September 19, 2023, when Azerbaijan launched a military assault on Artsakh to seize the territory and forcibly displace its population. In the past year, the people of Artsakh have endured a nine-month siege, a two-day war, forced displacement and the loss of their homeland. Now 100,000 Armenians from Artsakh are living as refugees in Armenia.

The stories of displaced families are all unique, yet they share a common harsh reality. Families grapple with a spectrum of challenges—social, psychological, economic and cultural—and carry stories of survival and strength amid the uncertainties of their circumstances far away from their homes. Armenian municipalities, diaspora Armenians and international organizations have been working together to address the immediate needs of the displaced, including food, hygiene and household items. But the problems are diverse and difficult, especially the issues of finding affordable apartments for rent, providing necessary household appliances and furniture and securing employment.

Lilit Sargsyan, a single mother from Askeran, Artsakh, with her six-year-old daughter and parents now call Khachpar village in the Masis municipality of Armenia their home. Unable to afford rent, Sargsyan, with the help of friends, acquired a makeshift cabin, or a domik. Her father is working hard to renovate the cabin, hoping to shield the family from the winter cold. Her grandmother’s old carpet, the most precious thing she brought with her from Artsakh, makes the home a bit warmer.

Lilit Sargsyan in front of the makeshift house (or domik), which she bought with the help of friends and will become her new house

Currently teaching at Khachpar Secondary School, Sargsyan regards her teaching years in Artsakh as the most meaningful and cherished period of her life.

Sargsyan has experienced four wars in her lifetime. She says the most challenging was the recent two-day war in September. Facing a military attack after nine months of blockade, the family had no access to hiding places, food or transportation. Organizing care for her disabled daughter during the siege was especially tough. She could not take her daughter to the rehabilitation center twice a week like she used to due to the lack of fuel. She did not know how to explain the daily struggle for food to her daughter.

“Everyday after 6 o’clock was the hardest moment for me. Although I missed my daughter during the day, I didn’t want to go home, because I had nothing to give her,” Sargsyan said. “When there was nothing, she ate spaghetti, which until the blockade I used to cook a lot for her with oil and salt. But I couldn’t buy it. Then a friend of mine gave me three kilograms of real white flour, which was a miracle for me at that time. I tried to make spaghetti with salt, water and flour, and it worked. She loved eating it. There was no oil, so I added lard, but she didn’t understand and ate it with pleasure.” 

Until her domik is repaired, Lilit Sargsyan is staying with her daughter and parents in Khachpar in her aunt’s house

In Khachpar, Sargsyan’s family found a warm welcome. “Perhaps it’s because many here are refugees from Azerbaijan due to the 1990s Artsakh War and those who settled after the 2020 war. They understand us better,” she reflected. However, challenges persist. The Armenian government has issued a temporary protection status to forcibly displaced people from Artsakh. Like most families, Sargsyan is still waiting to receive documents confirming their status and cannot access child benefits, while her parents cannot receive their pension.

“We just don’t feel safe living with Azerbaijanis. Talking about security is absurd, especially if we aren’t going to have an army or any other way to defend ourselves.”

According to the decision adopted by the Armenian government, people forcibly displaced from Artsakh have been granted the status of temporary protection, rather than citizenship or refugee status. Only after receiving a document confirming this status along with temporary registration can forcibly displaced people receive their pensions or child benefits.

Tens of thousands of forcibly displaced people are still waiting to receive the document confirming their temporary protection status and have not received their pensions for three months. They are also unable to benefit from a number of state subsidy programs and benefits due to the lack of timely registration.

While residing in Artsakh, residents had used passports of the Republic of Armenia. It is insulting and incomprehensible to Sargsyan, and many other displaced people from Artsakh, why she should now choose between giving up her passport in exchange for another one or being considered a refugee in her own homeland.

Sargsyan yearns to return to Artsakh yet struggles to envision coexistence with Azerbaijanis. “We just don’t feel safe living with Azerbaijanis. Talking about security is absurd, especially if we aren’t going to have an army or any other way to defend ourselves,” she said. Asked what she would bring with her from Artsakh to Armenia if given the chance, she said, “Perhaps our pineapple and pomegranate crops have turned into bird feed or rotted.” She would bring saplings from those trees and open the window of their house to prevent mold.

According to the deputy mayor of Masis, Khoren Aroyan, in the first days of the mass displacement, about 12,000 people from Artsakh settled in the town of Masis and neighboring villages. Some of them have since moved to other regions of Armenia, and about 8,500 displaced people remain. 

After the Baku and Sumgait pogroms against Armenians during the first Artsakh War, many people with roots in Artsakh fled to Masis. After the 2020 war, many people from Artsakh once again sought refuge in Masis among their relatives and friends.

Sarushen is one of many villages in Artsakh that was fired on by Azerbaijani forces throughout the blockade, restricting agricultural work and garden cultivation. When the war started on September 19, Ivan Harutyunyan from Sarushen could only save his family members, leaving behind everything else he cherished. 

Ivan Harutyunyan and Alina Harutyunyan both live in the corridor of a non-functioning library, which serves as both a kitchen and a living room

“We left our lands, our livestock and our ancestors’ graves,” Harutyunyan said with a heavy heart. “We had no choice but to abandon everything and escape through the forests.” His journey of forced displacement from the Artsakh capital Stepanakert, lasting almost three days, led him to the town of Goris in southern Armenia and then to Masis.

“I regret losing the four tractors I used not only for our gardens and arable lands but also for the entire village. We can rebuild houses, but how do we work without equipment?” Harutyunyan said. 

Today, he shares a room in a former, dilapidated library building with several families, including those of his three brothers, totaling 31 people. Despite efforts by the municipal administration to provide beds and essentials, living conditions are challenging. Families share a single toilet-bathroom, and there is no kitchen. The struggle for normalcy persists, a common thread in the lives of the displaced.

Alina Harutyunyan, a mother of four children, was displaced from the village of Harutyunagomer in the Martakert region of Artsakh. Her family was involved in pig breeding, poultry farming and cultivating buckwheat. When Azerbaijan attacked, she had to leave behind the unfinished corn harvest and embark on a migration journey with her family.

They found temporary refuge in a room of the same library where Ivan Harutyunyan and his family are staying. Since there is no kitchen, Harutyunyan and other displaced women cook dinner on a small gas stove in the hallway.

Harutyunyan was only able to bring essential documents with her. With the assistance of the community administration and diaspora Armenians, her family has received beds and a small refrigerator, which are still insufficient to meet the needs of the families sharing the tight space.

Alina Harutyunyan in her makeshift kitchen

Harutyunyan hopes that, with continued support from benefactors, she can secure a refrigerator, dishes, household items, a television and computer for her two children, who are in school. “We all get together in the evenings and try to watch something on my daughter’s phone. It’s our only source of entertainment,” Harutyunyan said. Just like Ivan, Harutyunyan faces the challenges of making a home in the confines of a library, hoping for a brighter future with the kindness of those willing to help.

“Every time we start again from scratch,” began a conversation with 44-year-old Svetlana Mamunts, a mother of four children. 

Mamunts’s family was forcibly displaced from the village of Aghabekalandj in the Martakert region of Artsakh. “When the explosions started, I was kneading dough. I left it unfinished, took my children and went into the basement,” Mamunts recalled.

The dilapidated bathroom in Svetlana Mamunts’s rented house

Mamunts and her family managed to escape and reach Stepanakert with a neighbor’s car. The Azerbaijani checkpoint that every car passed through while exiting Artsakh was particularly terrifying for Mamunts. “All those who had a man in their house went through that fear and mentally said goodbye to their relatives,” she said. They spent several days sleeping in cars, and after a three-day journey, they arrived in Armenia. The rented house they now occupy has almost nothing. 

The family left behind two cars, and if they had fuel, they would have brought at least their household items with them. “But the most difficult thing is that we left our land, our house, our cattle,” Mamunts lamented. She regrets not bringing her sewing machine, which she used not only for herself but also to fulfill orders from villagers.

“Everyone wants to go back, but at what cost? If we have to live with Azerbaijanis, I will not dare to take my children there under any circumstances,” Mamunts shared.

Svetlana Mamunts, her husband Garik and their children in their new house

“It is the third time we have become refugees and lost our home, and we seem to have adapted to it, but for those who lost their home for the first time, it is very difficult. I try to calm them down,” said Ellada Harutyunyan.

When the Artsakh independence movement started in the 1980s, Harutyunyan lived with her family in Baku, Azerbaijan. During the Sumgait and Baku pogroms directed against Armenians, Azerbaijanis stabbed and killed Harutyunyan’s father. Her family arrived in Yerevan on December 7, 1988, the day of the devastating Armenian earthquake, then left for Artsakh. 

After the end of the first Artsakh War, her family settled in Aknaghbyur village in Artsakh. “As bees return to their nest, so we returned. The call of the motherland is inexplicable,” Harutyunyan said. With that call, after the 2020 Artsakh War, even though Aknaghbyur was occupied by Azerbaijanis, Harutyunyan’s family returned to Artsakh and lived in Stepanakert with rent. “If there is an opportunity, we will all return. It is our centuries-old homeland. We left our history and our sanctities there,” Harutyunyan said.

After Azerbaijan’s military assault on Artsakh in September 2023, it was difficult for the Harutyunyan family to make the decision to leave the homeland. Throughout the blockade, Harutyunyan’s husband guarded the border with other soldiers. Yet seeing that everyone was leaving, the family also took the path of migration. 

Ellada Harutyunyan

Harutyunyan finds it difficult to describe the two-day journey from Artsakh to Armenia. “People died on the road, and new ones were born. People were getting sick all the time,” she recalled.

“Even now, we seem to be waiting for something to happen. And you wonder, where are we going next? Is this ever going to end?”

Now Harutyunyan lives with her husband in the non-functioning Kindergarten No. 4 in Masis, Armenia. Another 67 displaced people from different villages of Artsakh live in the kindergarten building. There are no supplies or proper living conditions, but the families cannot afford to rent a house. “Even now, we seem to be waiting for something to happen. And you wonder, where are we going next? Is this ever going to end?” Harutyunyan posed.

Anahit Tamrazyan, a 37-year-old mother of six children, was displaced from Haterk village in the Martakert region of Artsakh. Her family worked in gardening and animal husbandry. Following Azerbaijan’s attack, they fled in a truck and drove to Armenia. “When we left the village, I managed to let the cattle go so that at least they wouldn’t die of hunger,” said Tamrazyan.

Anahit Tamrazyan and her family

When the fighting started, Tamrazyan’s eight-year-old son Davit initially thought he was hearing the sounds of construction, but he quickly composed himself and ran to the basement. He misses his friends, who he last saw during the deportation, but he could not approach them to say goodbye. Davit dreams of becoming an artist, but in his letter to Santa Claus, he asked for a toy weapon. “To return to our village and protect the village,” he explained.

“Although we were close to the border and it was dangerous, we were home. All my children find it very difficult to adapt here,” Tamrazyan said. Despite the difficulties of the blockade, Davit believes life is better in their village in Artsakh. He hopes to return to see his friends, Hansel and David.

Anahit Tamrazyan’s eight-year-old son Davit

Siranush Sargsyan is a freelance journalist based in Stepanakert.


Rooted In the Valley: The Hagopians Escaped the Armenian Genocide and Thrived

Jan 3 2024

Published

  

on

 

By

 SJV Water

Richard Hagopian’s family was one of thousands who escaped the Armenian Genocide in the early 1900s and forged a new path in the fertile San Joaquin Valley.

It wasn’t an easy life, especially after his father died, leaving Richard the man of the family while still in his teens. But hard work, a successful music career, and a beloved family restaurant in Visalia sustained the family and built a future for new generations.
Now in his 80s, Richard has come back to farming. Whether his sons will keep it going is up to them.
“I can’t tell the future,” he says.

SJV Water donors and the James B. McClatchy Foundation provided funding for the Rooted in the Valley series.

— Jesse Vad, SJV Water

Watch the video at

https://gvwire.com/2024/01/03/rooted-in-the-valley-the-hagopians-escaped-the-armenian-genocide-and-thrived/

ALSO AT:  

RFE/RL Armenian Service – 12/15/2023

                                        Fridayt, 


Baku Again Rejects Armenian-Azeri Troop Disengagement

        • Shoghik Galstian

ARMENIA -- A view of Azerbaijani (L) and Armenian army posts on the on the 
Armenian-Azerbaijani border, June 18, 2021


Azerbaijan has rejected Armenia’s renewed calls for a mutual withdrawal of the 
two countries’ troops from their long and volatile border.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian first came up with the idea of troop 
disengagement in May 2021 shortly after Azerbaijani forces advanced into 
Armenian territory at several sections of the border. The idea was subsequently 
backed by the European Union and the United States but not Azerbaijan.

Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan said earlier this week that Yerevan 
still hopes that Baku will agree to the mutual troop withdrawal. He said it 
would be a fresh confidence-building measure following the latest exchange of 
Armenian and Azerbaijani prisoners welcomed by the international community.

Azerbaijan’s Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov dismissed Mirzoyan’s calls during 
a joint news conference with his Turkish counterpart Hakan Fidan held in Baku on 
Thursday.

“The Armenian-Azerbaijani border has not been delimited,” said Bayramov. “It’s a 
complex issue. If the troops are withdrawn without a comprehensive agreement who 
can guarantee that one of the parties will not seize [border] positions.”

Arsen Torosian, an Armenian lawmaker representing the ruling Civil Contract 
party, criticized this stance on Friday, saying that Baku wants to keep up 
pressure on the Armenian side in ongoing talks on a bilateral peace treaty and 
border delimitation. Torosian also questioned Baku’s commitment to a “genuine 
peace.”




Armenian Speaker Won’t Rule Out CSTO Exit

        • Satenik Kaghzvantsian

Armenia - Parliament speaker Alen Simonian speaks to journalists, Yerevan, 
November 28, 2023.


Parliament speaker Alen Simonian on Friday accused the Collective Security 
Treaty Organization (CSTO) of “criminal inaction” and did not rule out the 
possibility of Armenia’s exit from the Russian-led military alliance.

“If Armenia’s interests require any [foreign policy] U-turn, there will be such 
a U-turn,” Simonian told reporters in Gyumri. “If such a decision is made the 
people of Armenia will know about it.”

“On a number of occasions, the CSTO has demonstrated criminal inaction, to say 
the least, towards Armenia,” he charged. “Let nobody think that we expected or 
expect soldiers of [other] CSTO countries to come here and shoot at 
Azerbaijanis. But we should have at least seen a political evaluation [of 
Azerbaijan’s actions,] and we haven’t seen it.”

Simonian, who is a leading political ally of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian, 
referred to the CSTO’s and Russia’s failure to condemn Azerbaijan’s offensive 
military operations launched along the Armenian-Azerbaijani border last year and 
in 2021. Armenia officially requested military aid from its ex-Soviet allies in 
September 2022.

Pashinian subsequently pledged to “diversify” his Armenia’s foreign and security 
policy, saying that Russia is “unable or unwilling” to honor its security 
commitments to his country. He and other Armenian officials have boycotted 
high-level CSTO meetings held in recent months, raising growing questions about 
Armenia’s continued membership in the alliance.

It contrast to his harsh criticism of the CSTO, Simonian said Armenia should 
remain a member of the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU), a Russian-led trade bloc, 
and the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), a larger and looser grouping 
of former Soviet republics. He pointed to its economic dependence on Russia and 
described the CIS as a “platform for cooperation that benefits our country.”

Russian President Vladimir Putin suggested on Thursday that Yerevan is not 
planning to leave any of the three organizations.

“I don’t think that it is in Armenia’s interests to end its membership in the 
CIS, the EEU and the CSTO,” Putin told a year-end news conference in Moscow.




Moscow Warns Yerevan Against Scrapping Russian-Brokered Deals


Armenia - Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian meets Russia's Deputy Prime 
Minister Alexei Overchuk, Yerevan, .


Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian met with Russia’s visiting Deputy Prime Minister 
Alexei Overchuk on Friday one day after Moscow accused Yerevan of not complying 
with a Russian-brokered agreement to open the Armenian-Azerbaijani border to 
travel and commerce.

The Russian Foreign Ministry on Thursday also warned Pashinian’s administration 
against walking away from this and other agreements that were brokered by 
Russian President Vladimir Putin during and after the 2020 war in 
Nagorno-Karabakh.

“In the absence of a peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan, we consider 
attempts to revoke these important documents extremely dangerous,” the ministry 
spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, said in a statement. “Such a step would inevitably 
result in serious risks, primarily for Armenia itself.”

Yerevan cannot manage those risks “with the help of Western 
pseudo-intermediaries,” Zakharova warned. She went on to deplore “a whole series 
of actions by Yerevan due to which it was not possible to fully implement the 
trilateral agreements.”

“In particular, for many months the Armenian side has been blocking the start of 
work to restore railway communication between Azerbaijan and Armenia, refusing 
to comply with the provisions of paragraph 9 of the high-level statement of 
November 9, 2020,” she said.

The paragraph stipulates that Russian border guards stationed in Armenia will 
“control” the movement of people, vehicles and goods between Azerbaijan and its 
Nakhichevan exclave through Armenian territory. A senior Armenian official said 
earlier this year that this only allows them to “monitor” the commercial 
traffic, rather than escort it, let alone be involved in border controls.

Russian President Vladimir Putin, center, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, 
left, and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan attend a trilateral meeting in 
Moscow, May 25, 2023.

The Azerbaijani government is understood to have demanded that the special 
transport link for Nakhichevan be exempt from Armenian border controls. Armenia 
has repeatedly ruled out that.

The issue was high on the agenda of Pashinian’s meeting with Overchuk, who is 
also a co-chair of a Russian-Armenian-Azerbaijani task force dealing with 
planned transport links. The Armenian premier was cited by his press office as 
telling Overchuk that Yerevan remains committed to “unblocking regional 
transport infrastructure based on the principles of sovereignty, jurisdiction, 
equality and reciprocity.”

A statement by the office gave no other details of their talks. Mher Grigorian, 
an Armenian deputy premier and another co-chair of the trilateral commission, 
was also in attendance.

The Sputnik news agency quoted Overchuk as saying later on Friday that the 
commission has worked out a “document” on the Armenian-Azerbaijani rail link 
which is “in a high degree of readiness" for signing. He did not say what 
exactly keeps the sides from signing it and whether that could happen anytime 
soon. Nor did he criticize Yerevan in that regard.

Overchuk spoke after co-chairing with Grigorian a regular session of a separate 
Russian-Armenian intergovernmental commission on economic cooperation.

The main purpose of the 2020 agreement cited by Zakharova was to stop fighting 
in Karabakh and prevent new hostilities. The deal also called for the deployment 
of Russian peacekeepers in Karabakh and gave them control over the Lachin 
corridor connecting the region to Armenia.

The peacekeepers did not push back when Baku disrupted commercial and 
humanitarian traffic through the corridor in December 2022 and set up a 
checkpoint there in April in breach of the ceasefire. Nor did they intervene 
when the Azerbaijani army went on the offensive in Karabakh on September 19, 
forcing its practically entire population to flee to Armenia.

Nagorno-Karabakh - Ethnic Armenians pass through a Russian checkpooint as they 
flee Karabakh for Armenia, 26 September 2023.

Unlike the European Union and the United States, Russia did not even denounce 
the offensive. Pashinian and other Armenian leaders have said that Moscow’s 
stance constituted an even more serious violation of the truce accord.

Zakharova’s statement essentially blamed Armenia for the assault, backing 
Azerbaijani allegations that it supplied weapons to Karabakh through Lachin and 
did not withdraw all Armenian troops from the disputed territory. Yerevan has 
strongly denied the allegations that were never publicly echoed by the Russian 
peacekeepers.

Zakharova also repeated Russian claims that Pashinian sealed the fate of the 
Karabakh Armenians by recognizing Azerbaijani sovereignty over Karabakh during 
talks with Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev organized by the EU in October 
2022 and May 2022. Putin likewise said on Thursday Karabakh was “abandoned” by 
Armenia, not Russia.

Moscow’s latest warning to Yerevan came amid unprecedented tensions between the 
two longtime allies and ongoing Western efforts to broker an 
Armenian-Azerbaijani peace treaty. In particular, the U.S. is now trying to 
agree a new date for a meeting between the Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign 
ministers which was due to take place in Washington on November 20. Baku 
cancelled the meeting, citing what it called pro-Armenian statements made by a 
senior U.S. official.




Conflicting Claims On Russian TV Coverage Of Armenia

        • Nane Sahakian

Armenia - Armenia's Deputy Minsiter of High-Technology Avet Poghosian and 
Russia's Deputy Minister of Mass Communication Bella Cherkesova sign a joint 
statement in Yerevan.


Russia has denied admitting that its leading state-owned TV channels have 
violated terms of their retransmission in Armenia agreed by the governments of 
the two countries three years ago.

A relevant Russian-Armenian agreement signed in December 2020 allowed the two 
channels as well as the Kultura TV station affiliated with one of them to retain 
their slots in Armenia’s national digital package accessible to TV viewers 
across the country. The agreement bars them from commenting on domestic Armenian 
politics and spreading “hate speech.”

Armenia’s National Commission on Television and Radio has recently accused the 
Kremlin-controlled broadcasters of violating this provision amid a further 
deterioration of Russian-Armenian relations. In September, an Armenian 
pro-government lawmaker called for a ban on their retransmission, saying that 
the Russian broadcasts pose a threat to the South Caucasus nation’s security. 
She appeared to allude to their reports critical of Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian.

The Armenian Ministry of High-Technology pledged to raise the matter with the 
Russian government. In a statement released on Thursday, the ministry said 
senior officials from the Russian Ministry of Digital Development and Mass 
Communication acknowledged violations of the retransmission agreement during 
talks held with its representatives.

“An agreement was reached to take steps towards proper compliance with all 
points of the agreement,” it said.

The Russian ministry was quick to deny this in a statement cited by Russian news 
agencies, however.

“The Russian side took note of the concerns of the Armenian side. However, no 
specific documentary evidence of these facts was provided by [Armenian] 
colleagues,” read the statement.

It added that the two sides agreed to “ensure full implementation of the 
agreement” and “maintain close cooperation.”

The Armenian ministry insisted on Friday that the Russian side the “accepted the 
fact of violations” in a joint communiqué adopted by them. It noted at the same 
time that the Armenian side avoided holding a “substantive discussion” of those 
violations during the talks.

RUSSIA -- The flag of Channel One at the Ostankino TV Center in Moscow, October 
28, 2019

The Armenian government faced more calls from its supporters and Western-funded 
groups to ban the retransmission after Russia’s leading state broadcaster, 
Channel One, derided and lambasted Pashinian during an hour-long program aired 
in October. The program featured pro-Kremlin panelists who denounced Pashinian’s 
track record and portrayed him as a Western puppet tasked with ending Armenia’s 
close relationship with Russia.

The Armenian Foreign Ministry summoned the Russian ambassador to protest against 
“offensive and absolutely unacceptable statements” made during the show.

The Armenian charge d’affaires in Moscow was summoned to the Russian Foreign 
Ministry the following day. Ministry officials condemned what they called 
anti-Russian propaganda spread by Armenia’s government-controlled media.

In the last few years, Armenian Public Television has regularly interviewed and 
invited politicians and commentators highly critical of Moscow to its political 
talk shows. Their appearances in prime-time programs of the TV channel run by 
Pashinian’s loyalists have become even more frequent lately.



Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.

 

Rep. Schiff leads letter to Comptroller HSU demanding accountability from Citibank for discriminating against Armenian Customers

Dec 12 2023

CitiBank Recently Ordered to Pay $26 Million Fine by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, But Members Pushing for Further Accountability

Washington, D.C.— Today, Representative Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) led a letter to the Office of the Comptroller of Currency’s Acting Comptroller Michael J. Hsu to demand answers and further accountability from CitiBank for their recent discrimination against Armenian credit card customers.

“We write today regarding disturbing reports of Citigroup Inc. (Citi)’s discriminatory lending practices against Armenian Americans. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Citi deliberately targeted and denied Armenian American credit card applicants based on their surnames and city of residence over a six-year period. According to reports, from 2015 through 2021, Citi singled out credit card applicants with surnames that Citi employees associated with Armenian origin as well as applicants whose addresses were in or near Glendale, California, home to a large and vibrant Armenian community,” the lawmakers wrote.

“Citi is the fourth-largest bank by U.S. customer deposits, according to the Federal Reserve. As one of the largest banks in the nation, their institution plays a key role in determining which individuals and communities have access to economic opportunity. No American should fear that their access to financial services or financial stability will be impacted by their race, ethnicity, nation of origin, or any other protected trait and it is our job to continue to dismantle the ongoing patterns of discrimination in the financial sector, and across our broader society,” the lawmakers continued.

Finally, the lawmakers demanded answers to these key questions.

  1. Has the OCC launched its own investigation into this case and considered taking additional actions to hold Citi accountable?
  2. Have any other financial institutions engaged in similar discriminatory actions against the Armenian community or other ethnic communities?
  3. Do any of the employees responsible for participating in this discriminatory practice still hold employment with Citi and what disciplinary actions have taken place?
  4. What actions has Citi taken to ensure this does not happen again?
  5. What additional regulatory tools are necessary to make sure this does not happen again at Citi or any other institution? 
  6. What proactive steps has or will OCC take to investigate this instance or similar instances of discrimination at other banking institutions under its jurisdiction?

Schiff’s 30th Congressional District, which includes the cities of Burbank and Glendale, is home to the largest Armenian diaspora outside of Armenia. He serves as Vice Chair of the Congressional Armenian Caucus. 

This letter was signed by Representatives Salud Carbajal (D-Calif.), Tony Cárdenas (D-Calif.), Judy Chu (D-Calif.), Jim Costa (D-Calif.), Anna Eshoo (D-Calif.), Raja Krishnamoorth (D-Ill.), Barbara Lee (D-Calif.), Mike Levin (D-Calif.), Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), Seth Magaziner (D-R.I.), Katie Porter (D-Calif.), and Haley Stevens (D-Mich.).

The full letter text can be found HERE and below:

Acting Comptroller Michael J. Hsu
Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
400 7th Street SW
Washington, DC 20219

Dear Acting Comptroller Hsu,

We write today regarding disturbing reports of Citigroup Inc. (Citi)’s discriminatory lending practices against Armenian Americans. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Citi deliberately targeted and denied Armenian American credit card applicants based on their surnames and city of residence over a six-year period.[1] According to reports, from 2015 through 2021, Citi singled out credit card applicants with surnames that Citi employees associated with Armenian origin as well as applicants whose addresses were in or near Glendale, California, home to a large and vibrant Armenian community. Given the harm done to our constituency and the seriousness of these allegations, we request that the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) investigate this lengthy and discriminatory lending practice at Citi and any other financial institutions that may have engaged in similar practices. 

As detailed in CFPB findings, Citi allegedly targeted applicants in the state of California whose last names ended in “-ian” and “-yan”— common components of surnames of Armenian origin. Citi’s practices included applying extra scrutiny to, negatively assessing, and denying credit card applications and credit line increases to consumers they identified as Armenian American. Of the most alarming allegations, some of the employees in question referred to these applicants as “Armenian bad guys” or the “Southern California Armenian Mafia.”

According to the CFPB, over this timeframe, Citi employees lied to consumers about the basis of their credit denials, providing false reasons why applicants were denied. Furthermore, supervisors conspired to hide the discrimination by instructing employees not to discuss the discriminatory practices in writing or on recorded phone lines.

While disturbing in scope with nearly 600 consumers who were impacted, this revelation also repeats a toxic history of banks preventing equal and equitable access to credit, targeting and preventing specific communities from accessing credit and loans to purchase homes or build businesses. While the CFPB has ordered Citigroup to pay $24.5 million in fines and $1.4 million in direct restitution that will be given back to impacted consumers, we must make sure that there are sufficient regulatory tools in place that can prevent this kind of discrimination from happening again.

Citi is the fourth-largest bank by U.S. customer deposits, according to the Federal Reserve.[2] As one of the largest banks in the nation, their institution plays a key role in determining which individuals and communities have access to economic opportunity. No American should fear that their access to financial services or financial stability will be impacted by their race, ethnicity, nation of origin, or any other protected trait and it is our job to continue to dismantle the ongoing patterns of discrimination in the financial sector, and across our broader society. 
Accordingly, we ask that you provide written answers to these questions. 

  1. Has the OCC launched its own investigation into this case and considered taking additional actions to hold Citi accountable?
  2.  Have any other financial institutions engaged in similar discriminatory actions against the Armenian community or other ethnic communities?
  3. Do any of the employees responsible for participating in this discriminatory practice still hold employment with Citi and what disciplinary actions have taken place?
  4. What actions has Citi taken to ensure this does not happen again?
  5. What additional regulatory tools are necessary to make sure this does not happen again at Citi or any other institution? 
  6. What proactive steps has or will OCC take to investigate this instance or similar instances of discrimination at other banking institutions under its jurisdiction?

We urge your office to investigate this situation further, including any other institutions that engaged in similar behavior, to ensure they do not engage in further discriminatory practices, as well as ensure impacted communities receive their compensation.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter. We look forward to your response and to working together to continue to take action to protect consumers. 

https://schiff.house.gov/news/press-releases/rep-schiff-leads-letter-to-comptroller-hsu-demanding-accountability-from-citibank-for-discriminating-against-armenian-customers

EU and partners to step up efforts to implement Eastern Partnership’s agenda for recovery, resilience and reform

 09:37,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 12, ARMENPRESS. Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan has participated in the EU Eastern Partnership ministerial meeting in Brussels.

The EU Eastern Partnership (EaP) ministerial meeting brought together EU foreign ministers and their counterparts from five of the six Eastern Partnership countries (Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, the Republic of Moldova and Ukraine), under the chairmanship of the High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Josep Borrell. EU Commissioner Olivér Várhelyi also participated in the meeting.

“The meeting provided an opportunity to exchange views on the Eastern Partnership, take stock of its achievements and identify concrete recommendations for the future of the policy. At the meeting, ministers addressed (1) how the Eastern Partnership can continue to ensure that the needs of member states and partner countries are met, (2) what should be the key priorities of joint work in 2024, (3) how to accelerate the delivery of the Economic and Investment Plan for the Eastern Partnership and (4) how to increase cooperation with regions such as Central Asia and the Western Balkans and synergies with other regional policies such as the Black Sea Synergy. The EU, Member States and partners will step up their efforts to implement the Eastern Partnership’s agenda for recovery, resilience and reform, as well as tackling challenges related to the ongoing consequences of the Russian war against Ukraine for the entire region. Ministers discussed areas of cooperation, including connectivity, transport, energy, green and digital transition, and human rights, civil society, rule of law, and security matters. Ministers expressed support for concrete deliverables for 2024, notably in the area of regional roaming, road safety and transport. Ministers were addressed by the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum,” the Council of the EU said in a press release.

Towards a Brighter Tomorrow: India’s G20 Presidency and the Dawn of a New Multilateralism

 16:44,

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 30, ARMENPRESS. Today marks 365 days since India assumed the G20 Presidency. It is a moment to reflect, recommit, and rejuvenate the spirit of ‘Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, ‘One Earth, One Family, One Future.’

As we undertook this responsibility last year, the global landscape grappled with multifaceted challenges: recovery from the Covid-19 pandemic, looming climate threats, financial instability, and debt distress in developing nations, all amid declining multilateralism. In the midst of conflicts and competition, development cooperation suffered, impeding progress.

Assuming the G20 Chair, India sought to offer the world an alternative to status quo, a shift from a GDP-centric to human-centric progress. India aimed to remind the world of what unites us, rather than what divides us. Finally, the global conversation had to evolve – the interests of the few had to give way to the aspirations of the many. This required a fundamental reform of multilateralism as we knew it.

Inclusive, ambitious, action-oriented, and decisive—these four words defined our approach as G20 president, and the New Delhi Leaders' Declaration (NDLD), unanimously adopted by all G20 members, is testimony to our commitment to deliver on these principles.

Inclusivity has been at the heart of our presidency. The inclusion of the African Union (AU) as a permanent member of the G20 integrated 55 African nations into the forum, expanding it to encompass 80% of the global population. This proactive stance has fostered a more comprehensive dialogue on global challenges and opportunities.

The first-of-its-kind 'Voice of the Global South Summit,' convened by India in two editions, heralded a new dawn of multilateralism. India mainstreamed the Global South's concerns in international discourse and has ushered in an era where developing countries take their rightful place in shaping the global narrative.

Inclusivity also infused India’s domestic approach to G20, making it a People’s Presidency that befits that world’s largest democracy. Through "Jan Bhagidari" (people's participation) events, G20 reached 1.4 billion citizens, involving all states and Union Territories (UTs) as partners. And on substantive elements, India ensured that international attention was directed to broader developmental aims, aligning with G20's mandate.

At the critical midpoint of the 2030 Agenda, India delivered the G20 2023 Action Plan to Accelerate Progress on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), taking a cross-cutting, action-oriented approach to interconnected issues, including health, education, gender equality and environmental sustainability.

A key area driving this progress is robust Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI). Here, India was decisive in its recommendations, having witnessed the revolutionary impact of digital innovations like Aadhaar, UPI, and Digilocker first-hand. Through G20, we successfully completed the Digital Public Infrastructure Repository, a significant stride in global technological collaboration. This repository, featuring over 50 DPIs from 16 countries, will help the Global South build, adopt, and scale DPI to unlock the power of inclusive growth.

For our One Earth, we introduced ambitious and inclusive aims to create urgent, lasting, and equitable change. The Declaration’s ‘Green Development Pact' addresses the challenges of choosing between combating hunger and protecting the planet, by outlining a comprehensive roadmap where employment and ecosystems are complimentary, consumption is climate conscious, and production is planet-friendly. In tandem, the G20 Declaration calls for an ambitious tripling of global renewable energy capacity by 2030. Coupled with the establishment of the Global Biofuels Alliance and a concerted push for Green Hydrogen, the G20’s ambitions to build a cleaner, greener world is undeniable. This has always been India’s ethos, and through Lifestyles for Sustainable Development (LiFE), the world can benefit from our age-old sustainable traditions.

Further, the Declaration underscores our commitment to climate justice and equity, urging substantial financial and technological support from the Global North. For the first time, there was a recognition of the quantum jump needed in the magnitude of development financing, moving from billions to trillions of dollars. G20 acknowledged that developing countries require $5.9 trillion to fulfil their Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) by 2030.

Given the monumental resources required, G20 emphasised the importance of better, larger, and more effective Multilateral Development Banks. Concurrently, India is taking a leading role in UN reforms, especially in the restructuring of principal organs like the UN Security Council, that will ensure a more equitable global order.

Gender equality took centre stage in the Declaration, culminating in the formation of a dedicated Working Group on the Empowerment of Women next year. India’s Women's Reservation Bill 2023, reserving one-third of India’s Parliament and state legislative assembly seats for women epitomizes our commitment to women-led development.

The New Delhi Declaration embodies a renewed spirit of collaboration across these key priorities, focusing on policy coherence, reliable trade, and ambitious climate action. It is a matter of pride that during our Presidency, G20 achieved 87 outcomes and 118 adopted documents, a marked rise from the past.

During our G20 Presidency, India led deliberations on geopolitical issues and their impact on economic growth and development. Terrorism and the senseless killing of civilians is unacceptable, and we must address it with a policy of zero-tolerance. We must embody humanitarianism over hostility and reiterate that this is not an era of war.

I am delighted that during our Presidency India achieved the extraordinary: it revitalised multilateralism, amplified the voice of the Global South, championed development, and fought for the empowerment of women, everywhere.

As we hand over the G20 Presidency to Brazil, we do so with the conviction that our collective steps for people, planet, peace, and prosperity, will resonate for years to come.

Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi




Bzhania Lashes Out at Armenian PM Pashinyan for Backing Georgia’s Territorial Integrity

Civil Georgia
Nov 27 2023

On November 26, the de facto president of occupied Abkhazia condemned Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s statement on November 24 that Armenia “unequivocally and fully” supports “the unity, sovereignty, territorial integrity, independence and democracy of Georgia”. The Armenian Prime Minister said this while answering a question in a live broadcast on whether his country was ready to recognize Abkhazia and the Tskhinvali region as Russia-occupied territories.

According to Ekho Kavkaza, Pashinyan further noted that Armenia’s votes in the UN have changed since 2019. Before 2019, Armenia had voted against the UN resolutions recognizing the right of Georgian internally displaced persons to return to their homes in occupied Abkhazia and the Tskhinvali region. Since 2019, Armenia has abstained from voting.

In his statement, Aslan Bzhania blames the Armenian leadership’s statements on “Western influence,” claiming that Prime Minister Pashinyan’s recent statement “fundamentally contradicts the fact of sovereignty” of occupied Abkhazia.

“Today, the Armenian community in Abkhazia is represented in the central and local authorities, the Armenian language and culture are supported by the [ed. de facto] state, and the structures of the Armenian Apostolic Church function freely,” adding that “the Armenians in Abkhazia have everything that Nikol Pashinyan could not guarantee to the Armenians of Karabakh, who, as a result of his policies, faced the tragedy of the collapse of statehood and a mass exodus from their homeland.”

Bzhania called on the Armenian government to “abandon indoctrinated rhetoric and begin to take into account the actual state of affairs in the implementation of its foreign policy”.

Ethnic Armenian members of the so-called parliament of occupied Abkhazia, Ashot Minosyan, Galust Trapizonyan, Eric Rshtuni and Levon Galustyan, also reacted to Pashinyan’s statement, calling it “too cynical.” In their statement, the four representatives of the de facto legislature criticized the Armenian prime minister for “easily changing positions” and blamed him for the disappearance of Nagorno-Karabakh from the “political map of the world”.

“Unlike Pashinyan, there are no politicians in Abkhazia who would question the people’s choice and liquidate with a stroke of a pen a country that was conquered with the blood of sons and daughters,” the so-called deputies concluded.

https://civil.ge/archives/571441

Normalization with Türkiye is highly important for regional peace and development, says Armenian PM

 17:03,

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 18, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan hopes that the agreement with Türkiye on opening the land border for diplomatic passport holders and citizens of third countries will soon be realized.

“We are in dialogue with Türkiye. At least in the past we didn’t have such active dialogue, although we still don’t have any success in terms of establishing diplomatic relations,” Pashinyan said at the OSCE PA Autumn Meeting in Yerevan.

“But the normalization of Armenia’s relations with Türkiye is a highly important factor for the strategic vision of a peaceful, developing and safe environment of our region, South Caucasus. We hope to soon hear the news about the opening of the Armenia-Türkiye border for citizens of third countries and diplomatic passport holders, and this will be a very meaningful step,” Pashinyan said.

PM Pashinyan arrives in Paris

 20:25, 9 November 2023

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 9, ARMENPRESS.  The Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, together with his spouse Anna Hakobyan, has arrived in the French Republic on a working visit, the Prime Minister's Office said.
Today PM Pashinyan is scheduled to meet with French President Emmanuel Macron at the Élysée Palace.
The Armenian PM will participate in the Paris Peace Forum on November 10.

Building sustainable peace in South Caucasus is one of key objectives of EU – Ambassador Maragos

 13:01, 1 November 2023

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 1, ARMENPRESS. Building sustainable peace in South Caucasus is one of the EU’s key objectives, Head of the Delegation of the European Union to Armenia Ambassador Vassilis Maragos has said.

In his speech during the opening of the EUMA headquarters in Yeghegnadzor, Ambassador Maragos recalled that during the European Political Community summit in Granada the EU reiterated its condemnation of Azerbaijan’s military operation against the Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh and stressed the need for respect of the sovereignty and territorial integrity of both Armenia and Azerbaijan. “We remain committed to these efforts," Maragos said.

The humanitarian needs of more than 100,000 residents of Nagorno-Karabakh, who’ve found shelter in Armenia, are in the EU's focus, he said.

Ambassador Maragos said that Armenia and the EU are determined to strengthen their relations by working in the direction of fully utilizing the potential of CEPA and the EU Economic and Investments Plan.

"Building sustainable peace in South Caucasus is one of the EU’s key objectives," Ambassador Maragos said.