The cloak of love

The Guardian (UK)

Saturday September 24, 2005

Books Review – Commentary

The cloak of love

Sylvia Paskin on the all-encompassing passions of the Turkish Chekhov

“Each day thousands of trains are bringing in thousands of stories and
carrying away thousands of stories”

A20-minute ride from the maelstrom of Istanbul is the Adalar, the
archipelago of nine islands which lie off the Asian coast of the Sea of
Marmara. The principal islands have long been an enchanting maritime
alternative to the city and have taken on the distinctive cultural
lustre of various communities; Buyukada, the largest island, has a
strong Jewish contingent and Kinaliada is predominately Armenian.
Burguzada is known as the Greek island, but in Turkey it is more famous
for being the home of Sait Faik, Turkey’s greatest short-story writer,
whose work is compared to Chekhov and whose family home where he lived,
worked and died is now a museum.

Sait Faik’s life was brief, intense and alcoholic. He was born in 1906
into a well-off mercantile family who dealt in lumber. Restless,
bisexual and unfocused, he studied in Turkey, Switzerland and France,
where he travelled widely. He never finished any course of studies and
rarely stayed in a job longer than he could help. He returned to
Istanbul in 1935 where he taught Armenian orphans before becoming a
court reporter for the Istanbul daily Haber. The job lasted only a
month, but this was long enough for him to gather material for his short
stories.

As a writer he was prolific, in contrast to his sporadic employment
record. By the time he died in 1956, of cirrhosis, Faik had established
a formidable literary reputation based on more than 190 short stories,
two novellas, numerous essays and 40 poems.

A passionate, maverick humanist, Faik’s writing took time to be accepted
in Turkey. First, in an era of rampant nationalism, his work was not
considered sufficiently nationalist in tone. His first story was
rejected by a magazine as being too kozmopolit because it featured Greek
“nationals” as principal characters. Second, Sait Faik’s stories
embraced “ordinary” people’s lives – “our forlorn, beautiful, everyday
faces”. His fiction deals with the lives of Armenian fishermen, Greek
Orthodox priests, the workers, waiters, clerks, children, the whores and
criminals of Istanbul, the bored, the disillusioned and disenfranchised.
This too was heavily criticised at the time.

Under his piercing, democratic gaze these characters took on immense
stature and resonance. “I love people more than flags,” he wrote. And he
illustrated this love in his choice of a name. After the Turkish
Republic passed its Surname Law in 1934 – which enforced the mandatory
registration and use of fixed surnames – he became Sait Faik Abasiyanik.
The name derives from his family name of Abasiyoglu. Aba means a heavy
felt-like material, which is worn as an outer garment, and is associated
with poverty. Sait Faik’s subtle modification to Abasiyanik means
someone whose aba is scorched, itself a figurative expression for “a
person desperately in love”.

His was a boundless love; for nature and the natural world. He writes
lyrically and pantheistically of island life. “Getting out of the city
is like escaping from yourself. Our memories, our passions, our
friendships, our infidelities, the good and bad things in us, our
wretchedness and our shame are all left behind in the city. Here we are
surrounded by trees, fruit, vegetables and animals” (“Life Outside the
City Walls”). It was a love which extended to unloved everyday objects
as in the story of “The Gramophone and the Typewriter”, in which he uses
the two everyday machines as the basis for a meditation on the use and
function of writing. And it was a love for his characters and their
marginalised lives. In the poem “Sunday” he writes:

On Sundays
I drink beer
With radishes and pistachios.
A young boy
Serves me for a pittance
But all I want
Is to be his father.

One criticism of his work has been a perceived lack of unity and
dramatic intensity. But as the distinguished editor Talat S Halman
wrote, “Sait Faik wrote the way he lived – spontaneously, sensually,
impressionistically, experientially, always stressing the authentic
touch and the ring of truth. He probably felt that a story is a
microcosm or slice of life and cannot be, should not be, any more
perfect than life itself … In exploring human situations, his stories
reflected, not only in substance but in form as well, the flaws of life.”

In “The Story that Dropped in My Lap”, a hapless waiter is delivering
lunch to an office and drops the plate with “A brain, green salads and
three stuffed peppers” on it. He picks up half of the broken plate but
leaves the food, abandoned and dust-covered on the floor. A porter comes
along, picks up the other half of the plate and daintily arranges the
food on it, saying to the nearest old lady “it’s a sin, Auntie, a shame.
At least it ought to go into somebody’s gut.”

“One could not resist the sweet smile that this beautiful heaven-sent
coincidence had brought to the unshaven face of a lowly porter,” Sait
Faik continues before concluding the story: “And at the cost of a brain
salad and three stuffed peppers it has fallen to his servant Sait to sit
down and write it up.”

· Sait Faik – books in English: A Dot on the Map: Selected Stories and
Poems (Indiana University 1983). Sleeping in the Forest: Stories and
Poems edited by Talat S Halman, associate editor Jayne L Warner
(Syracuse University Press 2004).

BAKU: Armenian National Detained In Northern Region

ARMENIAN NATIONAL DETAINED IN NORTHERN REGION

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Sept 22 2005

Baku, September 21, AssA-Irada
An Armenian national, Abrik Abramian, has been detained in Chilagir
village of Gusar District, north Azerbaijan, local ANS TV reported.

The district police detained him following the local residents’
information.

Abramian, 65, born in Aghdara District of Azerbaijan, had been treated
in the Mashtagha mental hospital before being handed over to Armenia
through the Red Cross.

The law-enforcement are determining the circumstances and reasons of
Abramian’s arrival in Gusar. He is currently kept in the pre-trial
detention cell of the district police department.*

Turkey event on Armenians blocked

Turkey event on Armenians blocked

Aljazeera.Net

Thursday 22 September 2005, 21:11 Makka Time, 18:11 GMT

AFP

A Turkish court has blocked an unprecedented conference that was to have
questioned the country’s official line on the massacres of Armenians under
the Ottoman Empire.

The planned university conference, entitled Ottoman Armenians of an Empire
in Decline, was to have opened on Friday. It already had been aborted once
after Justice Minister Cemil Cicek in May branded such discussion as
“treason” and a “stab in the back of the Turkish nation”.

Thursday’s court order followed a complaint by a non-governmental
organisation of lawyers opposing the three-day event.

“We received an order from the court, asking us to supply the court with
information on the case within 30 days and ordering us to suspend our
activities during this period,” Nukhet Sirman, an academic on the organising
committee, told AFP.

EU concerned?

Sirman said the organisers had received a telephone call from the governor
of Istanbul, Muammer Guler, “who apologised but said he had to implement the
law”.

The nature of the complaint against the conference was not immediately
clear.

Cicek’s outburst raised eyebrows in European diplomatic circles about
Ankara’s commitment to democratic reforms, a requirement for the 3 October
negotiations over its adhesion to the European Union.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan then distanced himself from the
minister’s remark, calling it “a personal statement” and said he encouraged
researchers to carry out their work.

The Armenian massacres constitute one of the most controversial periods of
Turkish history.
Armenians claim up to 1.5 million of their people were slaughtered in mass
killings under the Ottoman Empire, forerunner to the present-day Turkish
republic.

Increased importance

Ankara categorically rejects claims of genocide and argues that 300,000
Armenians and at least as many Turks died in civil strife during World War
I, when the Armenians took up arms for independence in eastern Anatolia and
sided with Russian troops invading the crumbling Ottoman Empire.

The issue has taken on increased importance as some European politicans have
pressed Turkey to address the genocide claims in what Ankara sees a
politically motivated campaign to impede its bid to become a member of the
European Union.

Much to Ankara’s anger, the killings have already been acknowledged as
genocide by a number of countries, including France, Canada and Switzerland.

“Our aim is simply to bring together Turkish intellectuals in an appropriate
setting for the discussion of a subject that until now has been carefully
avoided,” said historian Edhem Eldem, who was to have participated in the
conference.

“It is not a question of setting up a tribunal or reaching definitive
conclusions,” he told AFP.
Several nationalist groups expressed outrage over the planned conference.
The Hur party called it a “perfidy” and the small left-wing Workers’ Party
called for demonstrations outside the Bogazici University, where the
conference was to have been held.

The meeting had been expected to bring together about 60 researchers,
including critical intellectuals, to examine events in eastern Anatolia
between 1915 and 1917, as well as genocide denials made by the Turkish state
since that time.

Threats

Any questioning of the official line that a genocide did not occur has
proved dangerous to writers and intellectuals.

Orhan Pamuk, the widely translated author of such internationally renowned
works as The White Castle and Snow, is set to go on trial in December for
telling a Swiss newspaper in February that “one million Armenians were
killed in these lands and nobody but me dares to talk about it”.
Pamuk said he subsequently received several death threats and a local
official ordered the seizure and destruction of his works.

In Switzerland, where holocaust denial is a crime, the leader of the
Workers’ Party, Dogu Perincek, is under investigation for calling the
genocide claim “a historical lie”.

http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/84FAE38E-40F2-4A2E-85B4-5B7D28534D31.htm

Jack Scott: Utmost Attention Should Be Paid To Armenian Genocide Iss

JACK SCOTT: UTMOST ATTENTION SHOULD BE PAID TO ARMENIAN GENOCIDE ISSUE

Pan Armenian News
22.09.2005 06:07

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Two resolutions referring to the Armenian Genocide in
the Ottoman Empire in 1915-1923 were passed in the California Congress
with much difficulty, stated California Senator Jack Scott at a news
conference in the Armenian MFA. In his words, the strong Turkish lobby
caused this. “Their representatives were trying to persuade there had
been no Genocide. They were presented some facts, but we did not hear
them,” the Senator noted adding at that, “The Armenian Genocide is a
very important issue that should be paid utmost attention.” Mr. Scott
also stated, “We will made every effort for the Armenian Genocide
Resolutions to be passed by the US Senate.” In his turn Armenian FM
Vartan Oskanian stated that the Senator “is a good friend of Armenia
and has made an important contribution to promotion of the Armenian
issue in California,” reported IA Regnum.

BAKU: Elections: Ruling party accuses Opp. of ties with Armenia

Azerbaijani TV Channel One, Baku, in Azeri
19 Sep 05

AZERI ELECTION: RULING PARTY ACCUSES OPPOSITION OF TIES WITH ARMENIA

Ali Ahmadov, executive secretary of the ruling New Azerbaijan Party,
slammed Musavat Party leader Isa Qambar for “lying”. He disproved a
statement by Isa Qambar that only wages of rapid reaction forces were
raised. Ahmadov also tried to disprove Isa Qambar’s statement that
allegedly officers in the army were paid less than police. He accused
the opposition of supporting Armenians. Ahmadov said that orange
flags carried by the Azadliq election bloc and shirts worn by
representatives of this bloc resemble Armenia’s flag.

Malik Islamov from the Liberal Party of Azerbaijan said that he had
resigned from the law-enforcement agencies in protest against
lawlessness and arbitrariness. He slammed the head of the Azizbayov
district executive authorities and election officers for interfering
in the election and propagating for a candidate of the ruling New
Azerbaijan Party. He urged voters to be careful and attentive in
making their choices. By voting for me, you will vote for democracy,
justice, he concluded.

Rauf Arifoglu, deputy chairman of the Musavat Party, said that he had
planned to speak on certain issues. However, as the first speaker in
the election broadcast, Ali Ahmadov, slammed Musavat Party leader Isa
Qambar, he decided to change his topic and disprove what “the
representative of the tribal regime” tried to say. Azerbaijanis want
to be free from the current clan regime, Arifoglu said. He said that
the only possible way to get rid of the clan and tribal regime is to
vote for opposition representatives. He rejected President Ilham
Aliyev’s statement on creation of 300,000 jobs as incorrect.

Speaking on behalf of the New Policy (YeS) election bloc, the
director of the Media Rights Institute, Rasid Hacili, said that a
businessman had wanted to commit suicide at the Azerbaijani Supreme
Court. He stated that bureaucracy in courts runs against the
president’s statements to create suitable conditions for the private
sector. Equality and justice will always be violated if courts make
decisions against the constitution and without respecting human
rights. He called to vote for candidates who are really able to live
up to their pledges and change the country.

Russian President Congratulates Armenian Leader On Independence Day

RUSSIAN PRESIDENT CONGRATULATES ARMENIAN LEADER ON INDEPENDENCE DAY

The Associated Press
09/21/05 10:46 EDT

MOSCOW (AP) – President Vladimir Putin on Wednesday congratulated
Armenian counterpart Robert Kocharian on his country’s independence
day, underlying Russia’s strong ties with its staunch ally in the
volatile Caucasus region.

“It is good that Russian-Armenian relations, which are dynamic and
wide-ranging, have become a major factor of stability and security in
the region,” Putin told Kocharian in a letter posted on the Kremlin
Web site.

While many other ex-Soviet nations are looking increasingly toward
closer integration into Western structures, Armenia has remained
loyal to Russia. It hosts a Russian military base, which has become
even more important for Moscow after neighboring Georgia pushed for
the withdrawal of Russian troops.

Russia’s energy monopoly Unified Energy Systems controls Armenia’s
only nuclear plant and manages Armenia’s national grid company.

Armenia also depends on Russia for natural gas supplies.

Armenia, an impoverished landlocked nation of about 5 million, gained
independence after the Soviet collapse in 1991.

NKR Self-Determination Through Struggle

NKR SELF-DETERMINATION THROUGH STRUGGLE

A1+
| 18:59:48 | 19-09-2005 | Politics |

The RA Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanyan has addressed the UN Assembly
General 60th session.

According to the RA Foreign Ministry message, the Minister spoke
about the Millennium Development Goals finding the combat against
poverty and economy development extremely important.

In his speech the Minister also referred to the regional conflicts
and the course of their settlement. He has mentioned that “in case
of regional conflicts preaching of military solutions is not only
unreal but also reflects the absence of democracy, human rights and
the perception of civic society”.

Speaking about the rights of the people of Nagorno Karabakh, he
underlined, “Self-determination is the right of every person. The
people of Nagorno Karabakh have fought and won the right of
self-determination. In order to win it, they have fought the political
and military aggression of a government which was not elected by
them and which tried to suppress them by force. The fight for their
rights was no their choice. Their rights were neither abstract nor
exaggerated. They wanted what most of us have, that is the right to
live in their houses on their lands peacefully. Despite everything,
they reached their aim. From that time on they have shown their
ability of governing and developing democratic institution”.

Finding the realization of Millennium Development Goals, the Minister
noted that we are responsible for the coming generations. “And our
answer to ourselves and to our children must be the united effort,
united measures and united answers on the part of United Nations. The
UN can still be the answer”, said Vardan Oskanyan.

Switzerland Brings More Charges Against Turkish Politician For Denyi

SWITZERLAND BRINGS MORE CHARGES AGAINST TURKISH POLITICIAN FOR DENYING ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

The Associated Press
09/19/05 12:09 EDT

BERN, Switzerland (AP) – Swiss authorities brought two further charges
against a Turkish politician for allegedly breaking Switzerland’s
racial discrimination laws by denying that the killings of Armenians
around the time of World War I was a genocide, police said Monday.

Dogu Perincek, the leader of the Turkey’s Workers’ Party, made the
remarks Sunday in a speech in central Switzerland, Bern cantonal
(state) police said in a statement. He then repeated them Monday in
a news conference in Zurich, and was charged by the city’s police,
spokesman Marco Cortesi said.

Perincek already had been charged twice by Swiss authorities for two
previous, similar incidents.

Denying that the Holocaust or other cases of genocide took place is
regarded as racial discrimination under Swiss law, and can be punished
by up to three years in prison and an unspecified fine.

“Based on the fact that, in the course of his address, Dogu Perincek
denied the Armenian genocide and expressed prejudices against the
western world, the Bern cantonal police has put down a complaint
because of suspicion of racial discrimination,” the police statement
said.

Perincek will be questioned Tuesday by police in neighboring Vaud
canton, where he already is under investigation for similar remarks
made in May, Bern police spokeswoman Anastasia Falkner said.

Swiss authorities launched a second investigation into Perincek in
July for making similar remarks in northern Switzerland, and Perincek
was briefly detained after that speech. Turkey called the Swiss
ambassador to the Foreign Ministry to protest Perincek’s detention
and investigation.

Similar disputes have erupted in the past between Turkey and
Switzerland. In June, a Turkish Cabinet minister postponed a visit
to Switzerland to protest an investigation of a Turkish historian
who denied in a separate speech that the killings were genocide.

In July, Turkey canceled a proposed visit by Swiss Economics Minister
Joseph Deiss because of “schedule clashes,” Deiss’s spokesman said.

BAKU: NK currency ‘not to be internationally recognized’

AzerNews, Azerbaijan
Sept 15 2005

Upper Garabagh currency ‘not to be internationally recognized’

The ‘national currency’ that Upper Garabagh plans to illegally
release into circulation will not be recognized by any country, the
National Bank deputy board chairman told journalists last week.

Alim Guliyev said, however, that Azerbaijan cannot prevent the
release of the new currency.
“The National Bank will object to the move, but it has no real
opportunities to prevent the issuance of the currency.
We can simply convey to the international community the illegitimacy
of the process.”
Guliyev added that the currency may not be used anywhere outside
Garabagh

BAKU: Turkey “uneasy” about US parliamentarians’ resolutions

Turkey “uneasy” about US parliamentarians’ resolutions

Anatolia news agency
16 Sep 05

ANKARA

Turkey has stated that it felt uneasy over adoption of two resolutions
acknowledging the so-called Armenian genocide by the Committee on
International Relations of the US House of Representatives.

The Turkish Foreign Ministry stated on Friday [16 September] that the
US acting assistant state secretary for legislative affairs, Matthew
Reynolds, sent a letter the day before to the Committee on
International Relations chairman, Henry Hyde, stressing Turkey’s
importance for the United States.

“Turkey welcomed the letter which stated that the US administration
was against the adoption of these resolutions and an Armenian
resolution which is brought onto agenda of the House of
Representatives general assembly can harm Turkey-US relations,” noted
the ministry.

“On the other hand, Turkey believes that in the next period US
congressmen will show the responsibility appropriate to Turkish-US
relations. Turkey also expects that these resolutions would remain in
committee level and would not be submitted to the general assembly,”
said Turkish Foreign Ministry.