Azeris Who Left Armenia Not Refugees

AZERIS WHO LEFT ARMENIA NOT REFUGEES

PanARMENIAN.Net
13.01.2010 20:01 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The Azeris who left Armenia in late 1980s cannot
be viewed as refugees as they do not meet refugee criteria under
international law, political scientist, YSU Professor Alexander
Manasyan finds.

"We cannot put an equal sign between the Armenians deported from
Azerbaijan and the Azeris who left Armenia in peaceful conditions.

It’s unacceptable," he told a news conference in Yerevan.

At that, he noted that over 200 Armenian deportees have not so far
received material or moral compensation.

"It is necessary to elaborate a package of legal documents on
compensating Azerbaijani Armenians, with RA Government sparing no
effort to assist in the process," he stressed.

Twenty years ago today the Azerbaijani authorities perpetrated the
Armenian pogroms of Baku. Some 400 Armenians were killed and 200
thousand were exiled in the period of January 13-19. The exact number
of those killed was never determined, as no investigation was carried
out into the crimes.

On January 13, 1990 a crowd numbering 50 thousand people divided into
groups and started "cleaning" the city of Armenians. On January 17,
the European Parliament called on EU Council of Foreign Ministers
and European Council to protect Armenians and render assistance to
Armenia and Nagorno Karabakh. On January 18, a group of U.S. Senators
sent a letter to Mikhail Gorbachev to express concerns over the
violence against the Armenian population in Azerbaijan and called
for unification of Nagorno Karabakh with Armenia.

Real Battle Is Yet To Come, Says ARFD

REAL BATTLE IS YET TO COME, SAYS ARFD

Aysor
Jan 13 2010
Armenia

Constitutional Court’s decision on Armenian-Turkish protocols set on
foot the process against state interests, told journalists Armenian
Revolutionary Federation Executive Council of Armenia member Armen
Rustamian.

This decision to recognize the Armenian-Turkish protocols conforming
to the Armenian Constitution brings to the force the ratification
process for documents which are contrary to fundamental principles
of Armenian statehood, according to politician.

Rustamian also remind that ARFD protested against interruption of the
process of recognition of 1915 Genocide in Turkey as well as legal
recognition of the border between the countries, and any links with
the Karabakh conflict.

"We are sure that the Constitutional Court has analyzed all facts in
details and had strong reasons and basis for recognition the protocols
as contradictory to the Constitution. However, we think that the
struggle against these documents is bringing positive results,"
he said.

The protocols are result of poor working of Armenian foreign minister,
according to Rustamian.

"We can consider Court’s decision as decision made by whole people.

However, the real battle is yet to come," he said.

Armenian-Turkish reconciliation should not stare Armenia’s interests
in the face, he added.

BAKU: Abolition Of Visa Regime With Armenia Possible Only After Solu

ABOLITION OF VISA REGIME WITH ARMENIA POSSIBLE ONLY AFTER SOLUTION OF KARABAKH

news.az
Jan 12 2010
Azerbaijan

Turkish parliamentarian: Abolition of visa regime with Armenia possible
only after solution of Karabakh conflict.

"Of course, Turkey wants to normalize relations with all its neighbors,
including Armenia. I have said that if Armenia withdraws from the
occupied territories of Azerbaijan and the Karabakh problem is solved,
why not cancel visa regime with it in the future, said deputy from
the ruling Turkish Justice and Development Party Mehmet Erdogan.

"As our president and prime minister have stated repeatedly, the
relations with Armenia are possible only after the Karabakh problem
is settled. And our position on this issue remains unchanged – we
will always be close to our Azerbaijani brothers ", said the deputy.

Today the Armenian media said, citing Turkish Haberx, that Mehmet
Erdogan allegedly did not rule out the soonest lifting of the visa
regime with Armenia.

BAKU: Armenia Said To Release 5 Of 7 Occupied Regions In 2010

ARMENIA SAID TO RELEASE 5 OF 7 OCCUPIED REGIONS IN 2010

news.az
Jan 11 2010
Azerbaijan

Recep Tayyip Erdogan Moscow and Ankara are in a constant contact on
the Karabakh conflict.

Zaman newspaper reads that Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan will pay an official visit to Moscow on January 12-13 where
he will discuss the economic as well as regional problems including
the Karabakh issue.

According to Zaman, Moscow and Ankara are in a constant contact on
the Karabakh conflict. It is also noted that Russian FM Lavrov’s
visit to Armenia those days is not by accident. It will be aimed at
discussing the Armenian-Turkish protocols signed in Zurich in October
2009. Upon return to Moscow Sergey Lavrov will hold negotiations with
the Turkish delegation and share the results of his visit to Yerevan
with his Turkish counterparts.

"It is not ruled out that in the result Armenia will release 5 of
the 7 occupied regions of Azerbaijan and Turkey will open borders
with Armenia in 2010. Russia and Turkey are working at this issue",
the newspaper says adding that Abdullah Gul has recently said "Ankara
and Moscow are holding calm but active diplomacy".

Zaman is close to the ruling circles of Turkey.

Erdogan’s Visit To Moscow Regular Demarche Against West: Expert

ERDOGAN’S VISIT TO MOSCOW REGULAR DEMARCHE AGAINST WEST: EXPERT

news.am
Jan 11 2010
Armenia

The visit of Turkish Premier Erdogan to Moscow is a regular demarche
against the West, political analyst and Heritage faction head Stepan
Safaryan told NEWS.am.

According to him, after the lame visit to Washington, Erdogan wants
to show the West that if Ankara’s voice will be ignored further,
Turkey will chum up with Russia. "As to Karabakh issue, it will
undoubtedly become a key point in the course of Turkish delegation’s
visit to Moscow. Both Russia and Turkey made certain pledges to Baku
on the matter. Moscow did so as it may deem advisable, while Ankara —
fearing that will lose "its younger brother," Safaryan stated.

Commenting on Russian FM’s visit to Yerevan, Safaryan considers that
it has two purposes — to show Armenia as its strategic partner that
Russia makes no deals behind its back and plough Yerevan’s stance on
possible acceleration of Minsk process on Karabakh conflict settlement.

Constitutional Court Can Be Independent And Withstand Pressure: Hovh

CONSTITUTIONAL COURT CAN BE INDEPENDENT AND WITHSTAND PRESSURE: HOVHANNISYAN

Tert.am
14:03 ~U 12.01.10

On the matter of the Armenian-Turkish Protocols, Armenia’s
Constitutional Court has three possibilities: that they correspond to
the Constitution, that they don’t correspond to the Constitution,
or that they partly correspond to the Constitution, said ARF-D
(Armenian Revolutionary Federation – Dashnaktsutyun) parliamentary
faction leader Vahan Hovhannisyan during the rally in front of the
court building today.

"Which they will choose, I don’t know, but if the document we
presented is taken into account in its entirety, then I believe that
the Protocols cannot be assessed as completely corresponding with the
Constitution," said Hovhannisyan, referring to the proposals ARF-D
submitted to the court during yesterday’s march.

Asked whether there is pressure being exerted on the Constitutional
Court, the ARF-D parliamentary faction leader said, "with its status,
this court can, in the case of duly evaluating its responsibilities,
in comparison [with other courts], be independent." Furthermore,
Hovhannisyan believes that the issue up for discussion is so greatly
significant, that the Constitutional Court will display sufficient
wisdom in taking advantage of its position as an independent body.

"That’s why the Constitutional Court is the Constitutional Court,
so that it can withstand such pressure," he said.

ANTELIAS: Meeting b/w Prof Akcam, Armenian Scholars and Researchers

PRESS RELEASE
Catholicosate of Cilicia
Communication and Information Department
Contact: V.Rev.Fr.Krikor Chiftjian, Communications Director
Tel: (04) 410001, 410003
Fax: (04) 419724
E- mail: [email protected]
Web:

PO Box 70 317
Antelias-Lebanon

Watch our latest videos on YouTube here:

A MEETING BETWEEN PROF. TANER AKÇAM AND ARMENIAN SCHOLARS AND RESEARCHERS

On Thursday 7 January 2010 at 18:00hrs at the Gulbenkian Hall of the Cilicia
Museum Prof. Taner Akçam the Turkish Dissident Historian met with seventy
five Armenian Scholars and Researchers. It was the first time Armenian
Scholars and Historians were discussing the Armenian Genocide with a Turkish
Historian who courageously has spoken against the official position of his
government on this issue for more than a decade.

Prof. Taner Akçam spoke of the importance of dialogue between the two
peoples. The two peoples had now to talk because it was important for the
Turkish public to hear of the premeditated crime of the Ottomans. After
Akçam’s brief presentation the audience discussed with the historian the
conditions under which collective memories will heal and justice will be
restored.

In concluding the evening, His Holiness Aram I thanked the speaker and the
participants for their honest exchange of ideas, and then added: "So far
Armenians and Turks were engaged in a monologue each stating its position.
It is time to move from monologue to dialogue based on facts, hoping that
such dialogue among people will lead to a common strategy for advocacy and
action." His Holiness stated that he believes in dialogue; however "a
meaningful dialogue takes place only on the basis of truth and justice,
namely the recognition of the Armenian Genocide by Turkey".

##
View the photos here:
The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is one of the two Catholicosates of
the Armenian Orthodox Church. For detailed information about the history and
the mission of the Cilician Catholicosate, you may refer to the web page of
the Catholicosate, The Cilician
Catholicosate, the administrative center of the church is located in
Antelias, Lebanon.

http://www.ArmenianOrthodoxChurch.org/
http://www.youtube.com/user/HolySeeOfCilicia
http://www.ArmenianOrthodoxChurch.org

Turkish Pupil’s Parents Protest: Composition On Armenian Genocide As

TURKISH PUPIL’S PARENTS PROTEST: COMPOSITION ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE ASSIGNED AT AMERICAN SCHOOL

Noyan Tapan
Jan 11, 2010

NEW YORK, JANUARY 11, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. A Turkish pupil
was assigned to write a composition on Armenian Genocide at a school
of New York’s Manhattan district, in response to which his parents
sent a letter of protest to school’s administration, to Turkey’s
Consulate in New York.

According to Marmara, a video material on massacres of Armenians was
shown to the pupils before the composition.

Letter’s authors assert that the information given to the pupils was
received from biassed sources. The Consulate, in its turn, sent an
application of complaint to school’s administration and called all
Turks residing in America for immediately informing the Consulate
about such cases.

In this connection Turkish press reminded that World History has been
taught at New York’s colleges since 1966 and within the framework
of it the events of World War I and 1915 are covered from Armenian
point of view: Armenian books and documents were used as sources.

ISTANBUL: Grandchild of `Crimson Sultan’ goes to court for Mosul oil

Grandchild of `Crimson Sultan’ goes to court for Mosul oil
VERCIHAN ZIFLIOGLU
ISTANBUL – Hürriyet Daily News

Sunday, January 10, 2010Beyzade Bülent Osman, grandson of Ottoman
Sultan Abdülhamit II, is preparing to go to court to claim the rich
oil reserves of Mosul. Osman, who calls himself an Ottoman of French
origin, also has thoughts on the association of his grandfather with
the Armenian issue: `I am on the side of the truth, but we need to
look to the future now’

Beyzade Bülent Osman, grandson of Ottoman Sultan Abdülhamit II,
known as the `Crimson Sultan,’ is preparing to go to court to claim
oil reserves around the city of Mosul in northern Iraq.
Osman is the son of Abdülhamit II’s youngest daughter, Naime Sultan,
who spent the last years of her life in exile after the fall of the
Ottoman Empire. Osman spoke to the Hürriyet Daily News & Economic
Review at his modest house in the TeÅ=9Fvikiye neighborhood of
Istanbul.
`My mother lived her last days dealing with financial problems, as
many of our family members did since everything that belonged to my
grandfather was confiscated, including his personal items,’ Osman
said.
Osman’s father had been exploring legal avenues to claim the rights to
the Mosul oil reserves until his death, yet those efforts had been
fruitless, he said. `Mosul’s oil [reserves] were not purchased
by the money of the state but with money Abdülhamit owned
personally,’ Osman said.
He criticized Britain’s stance on the issue. `My family was promised
by Britain during World War I that the income would be shared.
Unfortunately, this promise was not kept,’ he said. `I have been in
contact with top officials in Ankara about the matter and the legal
process will be started as soon as possible.’
Osman recounted the story of his grandfather’s purchase of Mosul’s oil
reserves based on the details he heard from his grandmother.
`Abdülhamit II noticed the British were paying frequent visits to
Iraq and consulted palace bureaucrats on the issue,’ he said.
`The civil servants told him to see Kalust Gulbenkian, a member of
the Ottoman-Armenian community who was studying at Galatasaray High
School. He later made an international name for himself as an oil
tradesman.’
According to Osman, Abdülhamit summoned Gulbenkian, who told the
sultan that Britain was using Iraq’s oil to power their cars. `My
grandfather happened to be the owner of the oil reserves of Mosul
thanks to Gulbenkian,’ he said.

The Armenian issue and the Crimson Sultan

The world knows Sultan Abdülhamit II as a key name related to the
Armenian issue and the events of 1915, recognized as genocide by many
countries, a claim Turkey rejects. `I am on the side of truth,’ Osman
said on the issue. `The French and the Germans had also slaughtered
each other, came into conflict but still managed to establish
dialogue.

We have to leave history behind us and look ahead.’

Osman also said his family `owed their lives’ to French-Armenians
after their exile from Turkey. `We were penniless,’ he told the Daily
News. `Our Armenian friends helped us. There was an Armenian lady who
welcomed us to her chateau and we lived there for a long time. I
cannot deny the good deeds Armenians have done for my family.’
The Ottoman dynasty was ordered into exile with a law passed by the
Turkish Parliament on March 3, 1924. While their assets were seized,
the members of the imperial family were given 2,000 pounds sterling
each and special `Cone-way passports’ that could not be used to enter
the country again. The first to go into exile was the last caliph,
Abdülmecid, while the last to leave was Fatma Sultan, daughter of
Sultan Murad V.
Born in France, Osman is now 80 years old. He said he witnessed his
grandmother crying many times when he was a child. Only learning
Turkish later in life, he said: `My grandmother and mother wanted us
to learn Turkish. They thought Mustafa Kemal Atatürk would be
unsuccessful in his cause and that we would return to the old days. My
father, however, was a republican by all means and was supportive of
Atatürk’s principles.’
All suffering from financial problems, exiled members of the Ottoman
dynasty dispersed to the world’s major cities, including Paris, London
and New York. Only in 1952, under then-Prime Minister Adnan Menderes,
were some members allowed to return to Turkey, he said.
`That law opened the path for women to return to Turkey and become
citizens once more. Men, on the other hand, were only able to win this
right in 1974 through a general amnesty granted by the late Prime
Minister Bülent Ecevit,’ he said.

Heir as a Michelin employee

Osman defines himself as `an Ottoman of French origin’ and
said Turkey should `rehabilitate the reputation of the Ottoman
dynasty.’
He said his life had been hard but that changed after applying for a
job at Michelin. `During my time with Michelin, I worked in every
country that used to be a part of the Ottoman Empire,’ he said. `I
first visited Istanbul during the 1990s, shortly after my father’s
passing.’

© 2009 Hurriyet Daily News

ISTANBUL: Turkey’s Armenians have two candidates for co-patriarch

Today’s Zaman
07 January 2010, Thursday
YASEMIN BUDAK Ä°STANBUL

Turkey’s Armenians have two candidates for co-patriarch
As the Armenian Patriarchate in Ä°stanbul tries to designate a
`co-patriarch’ in light of the illness of Patriarch Mesrob Mutafyan or
Mesrob II, two religious leaders have announced their candidacy.

Sebouh Chuljyan, the primate of the Gougark diocese in
Armenia. Another is the German Armenians’ leader, Bishop Karekin
Bekjyan. Both are qualified since they were born in Turkey as required
and have impressive religious qualifications. Among six candidates,
the two replied positively to the Armenian patriarchate’s letter
asking whether or not they would put themselves forward as candidates.

Bishop Karekin is expected to meet the Armenian Orthodox community in
Ä°stanbul soon as he will travel to Turkey following the
Armenian Church’s New Year on Jan. 6.

The Turkish Armenian community recognizes Mesrob Mutafyan as their
community’s spiritual leader until the end of his life.

An announcement on the patriarchate’s Web site in December stated that
they had submitted an application to the relevant authorities toward
the selection of a co-patriarch. The statement noted that until the
emergence of health problems, Patriarch Mesrob II had served in his
position for 11 years and that on Dec. 24, 2008, the patriarchate
decided that he would be the community’s spiritual leader until his
death.

The application was accepted by Ä°stanbul Governor Muammer
Güler and has been forwarded as required to the Ministry of the
Interior, the patriarchate added.