Armenian-Turkish Roadmap May Harm Russia’s Influence In South Caucas

ARMENIAN-TURKISH ROADMAP MAY HARM RUSSIA’S INFLUENCE IN SOUTH CAUCASUS
Arkady Dubnov

RusData Dialine – Russian Press Digest
April 27, 2009 Monday

Armenia and Turkey announced yesterday that they planned to normalize
their relations, which includes opening up the border. Implementation
of this plan could seriously damage Russia’s influence in
Armenia. Nagorny-Karabakh is the oldest frozen conflict in the South
Caucasus. Armenia’s longest border (with Azerbaijan) looks like a
frontline, and its border with Turkey could not be described as porous.

Since the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, Turkey has regarded
Azerbaijan as its main ally in the Caucasus and supported its claim
over restoring its territorial integrity, which implies regaining
control of Nagorny-Karabakh.

Apart from a tiny window to Iran, Armenia’s only other open border
is with Georgia, which currently has problems in relations with Russia.

Russia and Iran have been Armenia’s main economic partners since 1993,
with annual trade at $700 million and $200 million respectively. Trade
with Turkey has mostly been conducted in the gray zone, and accounts
for 25% of Armenia’s foreign trade, according to unofficial estimates.

If Turkey and Armenia open their borders to each other, Armenia will
not have any serious reasons to continue to lean heavily on Russia
in its foreign policy.

The possibility of an open border is a premium offered by Turkey
during the bargaining over Nagorny-Karabakh, where Russia is the main
arbiter. Russia does not have a similar asset to offer to Armenia,
especially after the Georgian-South Ossetian war in August 2008,
which has made Azerbaijan, Armenia and Turkey more cautious in their
dealings with Russia.

In this light, the recent meetings between Russian President Dmitry
Medvedev, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian President
Serzh Sargsyan could be an attempt to snatch the initiative and jump
into the train bound for Turkey.

Nagorny-Karabakh, which Russia has used to keep Armenia and Azerbaijan
in the wake of its policies, has so far prevented the Kremlin from
formulating a stance that would suit both adversaries. If Turkey
finds a solution, Russia’s influence in the South Caucasus will be
limited to Abkhazia and South Ossetia.

BAKU: Azeri, Armenian Leaders Agreed To Meet On May 7

AZERI, ARMENIAN LEADERS AGREED TO MEET ON MAY 7

AzerNews Weekly
April 29 2009
Azerbaijan

Azerbaijani and Armenian Presidents Ilham Aliyev and Serzh Sarkisian
have agreed to meet in Prague on May 7 to discuss resolution of the
Upper (Nagorno) Garabagh conflict, an international mediator has said.

"Certainly, there are results. We have held quite lengthy talks with
President Ilham Aliyev and Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov, and the
confirmation [to hold another round of presidential talks] was the
result," Yury Merzlyakov, the Russian co-chairman of the OSCE Minsk
Group brokering the peace process, told journalists on a visit to Baku.

Merzlyakov added that the two leaders will discuss issues of Garabagh
settlement that had not been earlier agreed upon, voicing hope that
the negotiations would be productive.

The meeting of Presidents Aliyev and Sarkisian will take place on
the sidelines of a summit of the European Union leaders and partners.

The US, Russian and French co-chairmen of the Minsk Group paid a visit
to Baku on Thursday and Friday during which they held meetings with
Azerbaijani leaders. Prior to arriving in the Azerbaijani capital,
the co-chairs visited Yerevan and Khankandi, the center of the
self-proclaimed Upper Garabagh republic. The mediators headed to
Yerevan again on Saturday.

Bernard Fassier, the French MG co-chairman, told reporters he hoped
major progress would be achieved in the conflict settlement by the
end of 2009. He also said very conducive conditions have emerged
for reaching a solution to the long-standing dispute and that the
mediators are working hard to reach that objective.

Mathew Bryza, the US co-chairman, said he had left Baku in a "good
mood" after holding talks here. During a further visit to Armenia,
he went as far as saying that the Garabagh conflict may be settled
over the next few months.

"We cannot cite a specific timeframe, but I hope that reaching
a solution is possible within several months," Bryza told a news
conference in Yerevan on Monday.

Azerbaijan and Armenia fought a lengthy war that ended with the signing
of a cease-fire in 1994, but Armenia continues to occupy Upper Garabagh
and seven other Azerbaijani districts in defiance of international
law. Peace talks have not yet resulted in resolving the conflict.

`New phase` The talks on settling the Garabagh conflict are entering
a new phase, Bryza told Radio Liberty.

He noted that the two countries` presidents had taken one year
to become acquainted with each other and study one another`s
positions. "Now, we are launching a new stage [in the conflict
resolution] by holding more detailed and profound discussions regarding
other elements of the main principles that need to be resolved."

Bryza said the MG co-chairs` main goal was to foster agreement between
the sides on three main principles reflected in the Helsinki Final
Act – territorial integrity, self-determination of nations and non-use
of force.

Asked about the summit on the Garabagh problem planned for
St. Petersburg, Russia in June, Bryza told reporters "ask Russia
this question."

Bryza added that the presidents of the MG co-chairing countries –
Barack Obama, Nicolas Sarkozy and Dmitry Medvedev – are also expected
to meet to discuss a Garabagh settlement.

While in the Armenian capital before the Baku visit, Bryza said both
countries are close to signing a preliminary agreement on settling
the Garabagh conflict. The co-chairs said only a few of the main
principles of the peace process remain to be agreed upon.

Regarding the mediators` visit to Khankandi, Bryza said the visit
sought to enquire "what the people living there think."

Medvedev-Sarkisian discussions As the co-chairs held talks in Baku,
Russian and Armenian Presidents Dmitry Medvedev and Serzh Sarkisian
discussed the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict in Moscow.

The Armenian leader thanked Russia and its president in particular
for the invaluable contribution made to the Garabagh settlement.

Touching on Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev`s recent visit
to Russia, Sarkisian said: "I have to say with a great deal of
satisfaction that during the Azerbaijani president`s visit, your
position remained unchanged and resolute when this problem came on
the agenda. And, this position is that the conflict must be settled on
the basis of all principles of international law. I am delighted that
there is another country in the South Caucasus that deems Russia as
its strategic partner, and this shows Russia`s increasing role and
opportunities in the resolution of the Upper Garabagh conflict."

President Aliyev described Russia as "Azerbaijan`s neighbor, friend
and strategic partner" and pledged to do his best to maintain this
high level of partnership during talks with his Russian counterpart
in Moscow on April 17.

President Medvedev told the press following talks with the Armenian
leader that the current meeting, as well as earlier negotiations
with President Aliyev, had demonstrated that the parties were
trying hard to make a constructive effort toward a solution of this
complicated conflict. "I think the steps being taken in this area
are hope-inspiring."

Moscow has lately intensified its efforts toward settling the Garabagh
conflict, Russian experts say. They note that St. Petersburg will host
the June talks between the Azerbaijani and Armenian leaders. The
Russian president might attend the meeting as well. If Moscow
manages to accomplish results during the trilateral talks, it will
assert itself as the leading peace-making force in the turbulent
region. Analysts believe that one of the main reasons for Russia`s
recent involvement in the Garabagh peace process is that, following
its brief war with Georgia in August 2008, the superpower is trying
to repair its image by acting as a peacemaker in the South Caucasus.

Prescott To Meet With ANC Representative

PRESCOTT TO MEET WITH ANC REPRESENTATIVE
Karine Asatryan

A1+
08:56 pm | April 28, 2009 | Politics

The Armenian National Congress will probably demand the PACE to
appoint a special reporter on political prisoners soon.

Armenian National Congress representative Arman Grigoryan is in
Strasbourg for two reasons.

"First, I am here to study the possibilities, rules and regulations
for appointing a special reporter on political prisoners. We have
been thinking about that for a while and are trying to understand
the regulations and possibilities, as well as knowing when the right
moment to do that is," told "A1+" politician Arman Grigoryan.

The ANC representative will also meet with Co-reporter on Armenia
George Prescott to discuss the process of fulfillment of the last
three resolutions on Armenia.

Grigoryan also tried to find out why the issue of Armenia was not on
the agenda during the PACE April session.

"Based on what they told me, there are certain processes that are
underway and it was early to include that issue on the agenda," said
Arman Grigoryan adding that he was also informed that the issue of
Armenia will be discussed during the next PACE plenary session.

Prosperous Armenia Party Launches Official Website

PROSPEROUS ARMENIA PARTY LAUNCHES OFFICIAL WEBSITE
Marianna Gyurjyan

"Radiolur"
30.04.2009 15:23

The prosperous Armenia Party has launched its official website.

"The trilingual website aims to provide complete information about
the social and political activity of the leader of the Prosperous
Armenia Party, Gagik Tsarukyan, and to raise the level of communication
between broad layers of society and the party," coordinator of the
website Hayk Akarmazyan told a press conference today and added that
people will get answers to their questions within a week or two.

"At the time being the web resource contains 140 pages. The Armenian,
Russian and English versions are updated every day. We have recruited
young specialists trained at corresponding international structures,"
Hayk Akarmazyan said.

Rustamian: National Ideological Approaches Are Sacred For ARF

RUSTAMIAN: NATIONAL IDEOLOGICAL APPROACHES ARE SACRED FOR ARF

Yerkir
27.04.2009 18:46

When in the coalition, Dashnaktsutyun has had disagreements. As long
as they were behind the curtains, the coalition parties could find
solutions through disputes. But when steps leading to disagreements
in national issues and poise threats are taken, those disagreements
become insurmountable. This is why Dashnaktsutyun made a decision to
act as opposition.

Speaking at April 27 news conference, ARF Supreme Body of Armenia
representative Armen Rustamian said that the difference in the
Armenian-Turkish relations led to serious disagreements with the
coalition.

"Turkey’s obligation to open the border is an international one. Turkey
has to open the border and should not make it a right, moreover,
a tool to pressure Armenia for concessions," Rustamian said. "The
second issue is the Genocide. We should realize that the Genocide
recognition should be carried out in two directions: the international
recognition and the recognition by Turkey."

On April 25, ARF Bureau representative Hrant Margarian and ARF Supreme
Body of Armenia representative Armen Rustamian met with Armenian
President Serzh Sargsian to present the ARF position. Rustamian said
that during the recent meeting with the president different positions
were voiced.

Yerevan-Batumi Rail Trip To Be Launched In Armenia In Early June

YEREVAN-BATUMI RAIL TRIP TO BE LAUNCHED IN ARMENIA IN EARLY JUNE

/ARKA/
April 28, 2009
YEREVAN

Yerevan-Batumi rail trip is to be launched in early June,
Deputy General Director of the South Caucasus Railroad cjsc
for Infrastructures Marat Khakov told journalists at "Novosti"
International Press Center Tuesday.

Yerevan-Tbilisi will be operated as per the same schedule, whereas
Yerevan-Batumi is to be operated every other day, he said.

Khakov also pointed out that the company is currently considering
possible increase in rail traffic speed and that the passenger traffic
duration is possibly to reduce on this section already in May.

Chief Engineer of South Caucasus Railroad cjsc Sergey Harutiunyan,
in his turn, said that the company will try to maintain competitive
differentiated prices bearing in mind the air flight launched for
this direction.

Yerevan-Batumi rail trip is launched mainly in summer time for
Armenian tourists visiting the Black Sea resorts of Georgia. In 2008,
a ticket for Yerevan-Batumi trip cost about 18,000 Drams for two-seat
compartments and 9,300 Drams for four-seat compartments.

South Caucasus Railroad fully owned by the Russian Railways is the
concession management operator of the Armenian Railways under a 30-year
concession agreement signed on February 13 2008. ($1=371.07Drams).

Armenian Revolutionary Federation Comes Out Of The Political Coaliti

ARMENIAN REVOLUTIONARY FEDERATION COMES OUT OF THE POLITICAL COALITION

ARMENPRESS
April 28, 2009
Yerevan

The Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) declares about the
suspension of its participation in the political coalition. With
this statement the representatives of ARF party come out of all the
political and concept offices. During April 27 press conference the
representative of ARF highest body Armen Rustamian officially informed
about this.

The ARF reasoned such a step by "insuperable principle discord"
which arouse over the foreign political line and is connected with
"the adoption of a joint statement on the eve of April 24 by Armenian
and Turkish foreign ministers within the context of anti-Armenian
preconditions of Turkish authorities".

"We have always been sure that one of the directions of country’s
national security strategy is the general recognition and condemnation
of the Armenian Genocide, particularly by Turkey. This has been
regarded not only within the context of restoration of historical
justice but also within the improvement of the atmosphere of mutual
trust in the region and prevention of such crimes in the future", –
the ARF’s April 27 statement says.

A. Rustamian informed that on Saturday they met with the Armenian
President Serzh Sargsian and discussed the established situation. The
Armenian President noted that he will continue the present political
line of development of relations between Armenia and Turkey and
at the same time assured that he will not allow conditioning the
Armenian-Turkish relations by the regulation of Nagorno Karabakh
issue nor will the process of recognition of the Armenian Genocide
be speculated.

S. Sargsian denied the five points of the "roadmap" which are in
circulation in the Turkish press. But A. Rustamian noted that the
discords are insuperable and functioning through the coalition format
the ARF can no more implement the issues and aims which are considered
to be the main line of the Party. He noted that being an opposition
does not mean not to support the authorities in numerous issues.

According to the representative of ARF highest body the Armenian
foreign policy in fact consists of two most important issues –
recognition of the Armenian Genocide and regulation of Nagorno
Karabakh issue. In this context he stressed the importance of
correct juxtaposing of national and state interests. According to
A. Rustamian recognition of the Armenian Genocide must be implemented
in two parallel directions – international and Turkish recognition,
but we must not allow one process to be replaced by the other.

"Turkey dreams of suspending the international process of recognition
of the Armenian Genocide and transporting it to a field of bilateral
relations. Turkey has never refused to speak in a language of
preconditions and only changes the character of these preconditions:
if formerly it was through deadlines now it functions with a mask",
– the representative of ARF highest body noted.

Expressing the ARF position on the Nagorno Karabakh issue A. Rustamian
noted that with the 1991 and 2005 referendums the Nagorno Karabakh
people have definitely set the limit from which the authorities must
not concede. According to 1991 referendum it was fixed that Nagorno
Karabakh must not have a status less than the independence. According
to the 2005 referendum the negotiation and legal status of liberated
territories was fixed, which definitely mentions that Nagorno Karabakh
has an issue of restoration of its territorial integrity as 20% of
Nagorno Karabakh territories are still occupied by Azerbaijan. Based
on all these the ARF finds that the issues of Nagorno Karabakh status
and security are primary.

A. Rustamian noted that the ARF sees no issue for cooperation with the
"Heritage" party but he excluded the cooperation with the Armenian
National Congress as the ARF has no ideology generalities with the
ANC. According to him the ANC makes statements based on its political
interests and the given situation.

Referring to the April 24 address of the US President Barack Obama
A. Rustamian expressed opinion that if there was no April 22 statement
B. Obama would have a great difficulty in refusing to uttering the
"Genocide" word. And the "Meds Yeghern" phrase of the US President
does not have the legal consequences the word "Genocide" would have.

How Do You Say "We’re Sorry"?

HOW DO YOU SAY "WE’RE SORRY"?

Mollie

GetReligion.org
http://www.g etreligion.org/?p=11341
April 28 2009

Rather than update my previous Armenian genocide post with a link
to Julia Duin’s article on its anniversary in the Washington Times,
I wanted to highlight it separately. I noted that most stories about
the events of 1915 were solely or almost exclusively political. Very
few touched on religion in any meaningful way.

However, the Times used the anniversary as a hook to explore how
one theological concept — corporate repentance — differs across
various religions. What would contrition look like, Duin asks, from
a secular state based on a religious tradition that does not practice
corporate repentance?:

The concept of national repentance started with Jewish prophets
in the Hebrew Scriptures. Christians then ran with the idea, with
modern examples including President Lincoln’s 1863 call to a day of
national repentance and fasting. His idea lives on in the National
Day of Prayer on the first Thursday of each May.

Plus, Christians ranging from the late Pope John Paul II to bands of
evangelical Protestant missionaries have apologized for the excesses
of the Crusades. But what Islamic entity has apologized for the 300
years of conquest that provoked the Crusades?

These are the kinds of questions I wish newspapers gave more room
to explore. (Side note: I’m always somewhat amazed at the widespread
ignorance — both in the media and in the general population — about
the periods before, during and after the Crusades. There’s so much to
the larger story that is completely ignored. I’m ashamed to admit I
didn’t even know the Crusades were in response to anything until a
few years ago. It was just never mentioned in my history textbooks
or in any media reports. I knew almost nothing about the history of
Muslim expansion until I explored the issue on my own after 9/11.) And
bringing it forward, it would be so interesting to hear from people
about how different views of corporate sin, repentance and absolution
(or even individual sin, etc.) impact public policy.

Duin quotes Wadi Haddad, a retired professor of Islamic studies
and Christian-Muslim relations at Hartford Seminary in Connecticut,
saying that such corporate repentance is very Western. Other scholars
weigh in:

"Individual Muslims can express regret or repentance, but I don’t
know what the appropriate institution would be to express Islamic
regret," Georgetown University Islamic history professor John Voll
told me. Christianity has corporate bodies representing its various
divisions, he added, but "in Islam, there is no corporate structure
that represents the umma [world Muslim community]."

While many reporters are out there repeating the Armenian desire for
acknowledgment of and apology for the genocide, what a great idea to
explore how such requests are viewed from the Muslim perspective.

Georgian Armenians Appeal to the Council of Europe

YERKIR UNION
EUrope
Mail: [email protected]
Web:

ARMENIA
Contact: Robert Tatoyan
Mobile: +374 94 36 17 93
Email: [email protected]
Web:

Stop this policy of repression carried out by the Georgian authorities
against its Armenian citizens

Appeal the Members of the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly

Stop à la politique de répression menée par les autorités géorgiennes
contre les arméniens de Géorgie

APPEL AUX PARLEMENTAIRES DE L’ASSEMBLéE PARLEMENTAIRE DU CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE

27 April 2009

Distinguished Members,

During the 2nd part of the 2009 Ordinary Session on Wednesday, April
29 you will examine the «Follow-up given by Georgia and Russia to
Resolution 1647 (2009)» and «The humanitarian consequences of the war
between Georgia and Russia: Follow-up given to Resolution 1648 (2009)
».

Our NGO Yerkir Union has been working since 2005 to establish a
dialogue between Georgia and the Armenian minority in order to avoid a
new conflict which would worsen the situation in Georgia. Georgia
refuses this outstretched hand and prefers to lead a policy of
repression against Armenians in Samtskhe-Djavakheti region.

Through this letter we are willing to draw the attention of the
Parliamentary Assembly of the European Council on the fact that,
Georgia is engaged in a real concerted plan against the Armenians in
Samtskhe-Djavakheti region.

This policy reached its climax on July 17, 2008 with several Armenian
civil activists arrests in this region who were merely demanding there
language, cultural, religious and social-economic rights to be
respected.

For 8 months, the Armenian population of Samtskhe-Djavakheti region
has been suffering offenses to their rights from the police and
officials. Some NGO leaders and civil rights activists are
systematically intimidated, and even arrested under various fallacious
pretexts.

Vahagn Chakhalyan leader of the `Democratic Alliance `United Djavakhk’
movement was arrested on July 28, 2008, two weeks before the
Russian-Georgian conflict. On Tuesday 07 April 2009 he was condemned
to a 10 year prison sentence after an 8 month trial for `arms
detention’ and `organization and active participation in group actions
which grossly disrupts public order’.

This verdict is the culmination of a travesty of justice where the
rights of defense have continuously been violated. The Ministry of
Justice forbids a French lawyer to defend Vahagn Chakhalyan. Mr. Sozar
Subari, the Ombudsman of Georgia has even challenged the decisions of
the Ministry of Justice declaring them unconstitutional. April 16, the
Armenian activist was taken out from his cell and subjected to
sustained and brutal beating by prison officers.

Georgia presents herself before the international community as a
democratic state committed to the European values, respecting Human
and Minorities’ Rights and putting forward its multi-ethnicity.

Unfortunately, in fact Georgia implements a segregationist policy, by
forcing non-alternative use of the Georgian language, supporting
exclusively the Georgian Orthodox creed and pursuing a policy of
assimilation and eradication of its minorities.

Distinguished Members, you are to consider the consequences of the
Russian Georgian war. The origin of this conflict lies in the way
Georgia treated the rights of its Ossetian and Abkhazian
minorities. In order to avoid a new crisis, this time with the
Armenian minority in the Samtskhe-Djavakheti region, we ask the
Parliamentary Assembly of the European Council to take urgent and
necessary measures to stop this policy of exclusion and repression
carried out by the Georgian authorities against its Armenian citizens.

http://www.yerkir.eu/
http://www.yerkir.org/

Hovik Abrahamyan: "I Highlight The Direct Links Between The Local Go

HOVIK ABRAHAMYAN: "I HIGHLIGHT THE DIRECT LINKS BETWEEN THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT BODIES OF ARMENIA AND FRANCE

National Assembly of RA
April 27 2009
Armenia

On April 25 the President of the National Assembly Mr. Hovik
Abrahamyan received the Mayor of the French city of Calmart
Mr. Philippe Kaltenbach.

During the talk the President of the Parliament highly assessed the
cooperation of two sister cities Artashat and Calmart. Mr. Hovik
Abrahamyan highlighted the direct links of the local self-government
bodies of Armenia and France and expressed his willingness to promote
the cooperation.

The Mayor Mr. Kaltenbach presented the concrete spheres of cooperation
between the two cities to the NA President. The interlocutors
specially separated the programmes of cultural and youth exchanges
being implemented between Artashat and Calmart.

The Mayor of Artashat Mr. Gagiik Muradyan also attended the meeting.