"Principles Of Theology" By McGreat And "Prayer" By Grigor Of Nareka

"PRINCIPLES OF THEOLOGY" BY MCGREAT AND "PRAYER" BY GRIGOR OF NAREKATSI PUBLISHED IN ARMENIA

/PanARMENIAN.Net/
13.10.2009 19:08 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Publishing house of Holy Echmiadzin with the
blessing of the Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin II, issued a
work "Foundations of Theology" written by the outstanding theologian
of XX century Alister Mc Great and "Prayer" with excerpts from the
"Prayer book" of Grigor Narekatsi (Gregory of Narek).

"Foundations of Theology" introduce readers with the basic theological
themes: God, Jesus Christ, faith, creation, salvation, Holy Trinity
Church. Topics are presented in the form of chapters with a short
description of the theme, its historical development, the biblical
texts.

"Prayer" is a collection of excerpts from "The prayer" written by
the Gregory of Narek in Armenian and Russian.

Ankara: Uneaten Macaroni And A Democratic State Of Law

UNEATEN MACARONI AND A DEMOCRATIC STATE OF LAW
Riza Turmen

Hurriyet Daily News
Monday, October 12, 2009

Only 14, shepherd girl Ceylan Onkol had hardly seen any of the world
through her big black eyes. She was supposed to put the sheep out
to pasture, then go back home and eat the macaroni her mother had
cooked. The macaroni went uneaten. It got cold. Onkol was shattered
into pieces by a mortar shell to her stomach. Pieces of her body
spread around the surrounding area were collected from tree branches
and dumped into her mother’s lap. Who will be held accountable for
Onkol’s death?

Who will be held responsible for the injury of Guney Tuna, a young
man who did nothing but drink alcohol and play guitar in a park with
his friends yet was beaten by police? He was saved from death from
internal bleeding in the brain but has fractures in both legs.

Who will give an account for Ferhat Gercek who was left paralyzed
by a police bullet at the age of 17 while selling newspapers in
Bahcelievler two years ago?

What about Engin Ceber? Is anyone exerting effort to bring those
responsible for killing him while in detention to justice?

Are we willing to hold accountable the murderers of the
Armenian-Turkish journalist Hrant Dink?

Measures sought by the European Court of Human Rights

The state should be held accountable for the above events. It is
obliged to launch thorough investigations into similar incidents. The
purpose of the probe should be the punishment of the guilty and the
implementation of national laws. With an eye on these, the European
Court of Human Rights recommends that the following measures be taken:

a. Individuals conducting investigation should be independent and
impartial. The European court does not consider probes launched
by administrative bodies against civil servants as independent and
neutral investigations.

b. Investigations should be satisfactorily conducted and should aim
to capture and punish those responsible for crimes. Everything should
be done to acquire evidence. Inspect ements as well as ballistic and
autopsy reports should be completed. If the necessary individuals
are not cross-examined, the investigation will be ineffective.

c. Investigations should be launched promptly and ended within a
reasonable time frame.

d. The public should be informed about the investigation and its
outcomes.

The expectations of courts

In an incident grabbing public attention like the Onkol case, it is
critical to inform the public about the on-going investigation. People
have the right to know what degree of investigation has already been
conducted. This, at the same time, is necessitated by the freedom of
expression. The prosecutor’s decision to waive the reading of documents
is about information. That doesn’t set him free of informing the
public. On the contrary, because of the waiving of reading, lawyers
cannot have access to information and documents that are relevant to
the investigation file. Therefore, only the investigation authorities
can inform the public.

This is not the end of the state’s responsibility. The European court
envisions that courts should act diligently in the trial process;
for instance, they should not allow statutes of limitation or rule
for deterrent punishment.

Violation of two articles is enough

>>From a legal point of view, ineffective investigation is sufficient
for the violation of two articles regarding the right to life. Since
security forces were fortunate that no one got killed even though
they applied brute force in cases like that of Tuna and Gercek,
similar incidents are included in the scope of these two articles.

The effectiveness of an investigation is closely related to the
trust people have for the state. Is the state protecting citizens’
right to live or merely its own members? Is the state making
serious efforts to punish those responsible, or is it protecting
those responsible? Answers to these questions go, at the same time,
toward deciding whether citizens trust or distrust the state.

Accountability is important

The European court :

On the subject of the death of Zubeyir Akkoc, a murdered trade
journalist whose death was blamed on the state by the man’s family,
"the court found that these defects undermined the effectiveness
of criminal law protection, permitting or fostering a lack of
accountability of members of the security forces for their actions
incompatible with the rule of law in a democratic society respecting
the fundamental rights and freedoms guaranteed under the convention."

The problem with state liability in the punishment of those responsible
and the conducting of an effective investigation of its own forces in
the case of Onkol and others is whether or not we have a democratic
state of law that respects fundamental rights and freedoms.

* Mr. Rıza Turmen is a columnist for daily Milliyet in which this
piece appeared Monday. It was translated into English by the Daily
News staff.

President Sargsyan: ‘No Ratification – Nothing Binds Us’

PRESIDENT SARGSYAN: ‘NO RATIFICATION – NOTHING BINDS US’

Aysor.am
Tuesday, October 13

Aysor’s correspondent passes from Zvartnots International Airport the
comments made by Armenia’s President Serzh Sargsyan on Turkey’s Prime
Minister and Foreign Minister’s statement that "The Turkish side will
open bilateral border only after Armenia withdraws its troops from
the territory of Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh".

President Sargsyan in particular said: "Unfortunately, our
society meets these statements on Azerbaijan’s Internet-sites,
which authors are trying to distort and belittle Turkey’s official
statements. Nevertheless, those statements really have occurred,
and in my opinion, are first of all addressed to Azerbaijani audience."

"Under these circumstances we will show surprise if Turkey should not
adopt the ratification. Then why did they sign it yesterday [October
10]? Whether they thought that we couldn’t be strong enough to back?"

Mr. Sargsyan nevertheless pointed that "the ball is now in Turkish
court, so we must be patient waiting for developments."

"We openly declared our steps and will take them unhesitatingly. If
Turkey ratifies the protocols and goes in conformity with schedule,
we will continue the process; no – then nothing binds us, and we will
do what we have announced earlier."

Suspects In Dink Assasination Acknowledge Murder Weapon

SUSPECTS IN DINK ASSASINATION ACKNOWLEDGE MURDER WEAPON

Asbarez
suspects-in-dink-assasination-acknowledge-murder-w eapon/
Oct 12th, 2009

ISTANBUL (Daily News)-Two suspects accused of conspiring to murder
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink acknowledged that the gun
presented before them during the 11th trial of the case on Monday
was the weapon used in the murder, news agencies reported.

The gun used to kill Dink was brought to the courtroom while the
culprits were removed from the courtroom one by one so that they
could be shown the gun.

"I was going to kill a man. I was not going to a wedding ceremony,"
said Ogun Samast, the confessed murderer of Dink, when he saw the
gun. Later he took the gun and looked at it. Samast said the gun
he used in the murder had had a problem in its safety lock and that
the gun he was holding in the courthouse had a similar problem. "It
was this gun," he said, according to the Anatolia news agency. Yasin
Hayal, who is a suspected co-conspirator, also said, "I acknowledge
100 percent that this is the gun."

Meanwhile, the attorneys for Dink’s family demanded the court bring the
files of two other important ongoing cases they alleged to be connected
to the Dink case. The first file is for the Ergenekon gang, a group
currently on trial for allegedly plotting to topple the government by
creating turmoil in society. The second file, meanwhile, concerns the
Zirve publishing house case, in which three missionaries were killed
in the southeastern city of Malatya.

Fethiye Cetin, the attorney for the Dink family, said that in a report
commissioned by Parliament’s human rights body about the murder,
Ramazan Akyurek, the intelligence chief of the Black Sea province of
Trabzon at the time of the murder, had said that he left Trabzon on
May 8, 2006, and began work in Ankara on May 9, 2006. According to
him, Dink was murdered because of national sensitivities; he said he
already had the intelligence about the murder from intelligence units.

Cetin alleged that public authorities hid Dink’s murder at every
stage. Cetin also said it is evident that missionaries, Christians,
Jews, Kurds and Alevis were targeted, according to the briefings
Ergenekon case suspect Sevgi Erenerol gave to the General Staff
in 2006.

http://www.asbarez.com/2009/10/12/

ANKARA: Hungarian FM Balazs: No turning back from Nabucco

Sunday’s Zaman
11 October 2009, Sunday

Hungarian FM Balazs: No turning back from Nabucco

The Hungarian foreign minister argued that the economic recovery is
well on track and said the government has taken all necessary steps,
in line with international partners such as the International Monetary
Fund and the European Central Bank.

We have reached critical mass on the realization of the Nabucco
Pipeline project — a natural gas pipeline connecting Caspian reserves
to the Central and Eastern European markets — and there is no turning
back from this project, a top Hungarian diplomat declared on a visit
to Turkey on Friday.
In an exclusive interview with Sunday’s Zaman, Hungarian Foreign
Minister Peter Balazs said he expects more and more source countries
to come forward with the capacity to add natural gas supplies to the
projected pipeline once it is built. `You can’t simply calculate the
load of traffic on a highway without first building it,’ he said,
stressing that many questions hovering over the feasibility of the
pipeline have vanished, especially after the signing of the Nabucco
agreement back in July.

Hungary and Turkey, along with Austria, Bulgaria and Romania, are
partners in the Nabucco natural gas pipeline project. The prime
ministers of the these countries signed a deal in Ankara to allow the
pipeline to transit their countries, linking Europe to gas resources
in Central Asia and the Middle East. Balazs concedes that much remains
to be resolved in details of the financing side. `I am confident and
very optimistic that we’ll see through the completion of this
pipeline,’ he added.

Touching on Turkey’s bid to become a member of the European Union, the
Hungarian foreign minister said, `We are in favor of an enlargement in
general and ready to share our expertise with Turkey on the road to
fulfilling its obligations as a candidate country.’

`We have an excellent team of people who are experts on EU affairs and
maintain an institutional experience when it comes to dealing with EU
negotia
ding border protection systems in line with EU requirements and issues
such as dealing with the environment, noise levels at airports and
sewage systems in small villages as examples of areas where Hungary
can help Turkey.

Asked whether he thinks Turkey will become a member even if it
fulfills all criteria laid out in its accession chapters, Balazs said
he is sure Turkey, as a great country, will be a full member of the
EU. `The important thing,’ he said, `is to finish your homework and
fulfill all criteria on technical fields.’ He added a caveat, however,
noting that the full membership decision partly depends on how the
bloc will shape itself in the future. Balazs signaled that the EU
bureaucracy is becoming increasingly cumbersome and commented that the
principle of unanimity should be reformed and limited to only a few
important areas.

The Hungarian foreign minister did not find a receptive audience in
the Turkish capital for his country’s bid for a non-permanent seat on
the UN Security Council in 2012-2013, simply because Turkey has
already pledged its support to ethnically close, Turkish-speaking
Azerbaijan. `We perfectly understand Turkey’s engagement and
obligations,’ Balazs said, adding that Turkey signaled it may lend its
support to Hungary in event the Azerbaijani bid cannot secure enough
votes in the first round.

Excellent relations with Turkey

Commenting on the Turkish government’s recent democratization
initiative aimed at solving its long-standing Kurdish problem, Balazs
expressed his appreciation for Turkey’s efforts. `I can understand the
sensitivities over the problem, and I think it is a move in the right
direction,’ he remarked. He congratulated Turkey on another
initiative, namely the normalization of its relations with Armenia,
and described it as `a decisive step in the right direction.’

`The historical past and the present need to be separated,’ he
underlined, adding, `Let’s leave the history to historians and not mix
it into current politics.’ He expressed
two sides have all the assets in place to solve the problem and
encouraged the parties to keep the dialogue moving forward on the
solution.

Balazs described Hungary’s relations with Turkey as `excellent’ but
noted both sides need to work on making institutions function
better. `We have the structure on cooperation already in place,’ he
said, stressing that more meetings between high-level government
officials should be held to promote ties.

Turkey and Hungary currently have about $2 billion euros in trade
volume, a figure the minister described as sizable but not nearly
enough. `It could be much more, as Turkey is a big market by itself,’
he said. He explained that once the Hungarian economy gained more
stabilization and Turkey’s EU bid moved in a more promising direction,
trade volume would rise substantially. `Turkey can be a gateway to a
wider region for Hungarian business,’ he underlined.

There are already signs that Hungary is laying the groundwork for that
expansion. During Balazs’ visit, Hungary announced that it will open
an honorary consulate in Gaziantep, a major industrial city in the
south of Turkey. `Konya, another big city in the heartland of Turkey,
will be next,’ Balazs revealed, confirming the widely held view among
the Hungarian business community that Turkey can act as a stepping
stone to further markets to the south.

The top Hungarian diplomat also called on Turkish businesses to take
advantage of a huge export surplus in his country. `It is very
important for Turkish firms to seize the opportunity, which is valued
at several hundred million dollars,’ he said. The country’s current
account posted a quarterly surplus of 476 million euros last month,
versus a deficit of 1.55 billion euros a year earlier. Balazs also
noted that Hungary is a very friendly country for foreign investors
and that the government is working hard to ease bureaucratic
procedures for international investors.

Economy is well on track for recovery

The Hungarian foreign minister argued that the
rack and said the government has taken all necessary steps, in line
with international partners such as the International Monetary Fund
(IMF) and the European Central Bank. Hungary became the first EU
member last year to seek international aid — a $25.1 billion IMF-led
rescue package that prevented a financial meltdown. Despite the
rescue, however, the country’s economy will shrink by some 6.7 percent
in 2009 and 0.9 percent in 2010, due to deep spending cuts to contain
the budget deficit and collapsing demand in both domestic and external
markets.

Balazs is optimistic that the Hungarian economy is gaining the
confidence of international investors, yet conceded that the budget
deficit will still exceed EU criteria next year, amounting to 3.8
percent of gross domestic product (GDP). He said the economy hopefully
will pick up speed afterwards. He stressed that the country has gained
currency stability and that the Treasury can now finance itself in
international markets.

The fact that international investors continue to invest in Hungary is
another sign indicating that the country is moving in the right
direction. Balazs mentioned that Daimler, the world’s second-biggest
luxury car maker, is planning an 800 million euro investment to build
a manufacturing plant in Hungary. Daimler’s new plant, to be built in
Kecskemet, about 80 kilometers southeast of Budapest, will employ
2,500 workers. Audi, a German premium car maker, also has a plant in
Hungary and is one of the country’s biggest exporters.

11 October 2009, Sunday
ABDULLAH BOZKURT ANKARA

Balayan explains the reason delayed the signing of the Protocols

Tigran Balayan explains the reason delayed the signing of the
Armenian-Turkish Protocols
11.10.2009 00:33 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Armenia’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Tigran Balayan
explained the reason of delay of signing of the Armenian-Turkish
Protocols. As a PanARMENIAN.Net correspondent reports from Zurich,
after the ceremony Tigran Balayan, noting that a very important step
in Armenia-Turkey relations has been made today, welcomed by the
international community, said that a temporary delay in the signing
ceremony of the Protocols was caused by the attempts of the Turkish
side to make changes in the verbal statements, scheduled after the
signing. The Armenian side disageed with those changes being of
historic nature. Discussions with the mediators and ministers resulted
in the signing Protocols without previously announced verbal
statements.

Turkey’s Citizenship Law

TURKEY’S CITIZENSHIP LAW

Altinkum Didim Today
Thursday, 08 October 2009 12:05 Didim Today

Citizenship

All good news is welcome. I have been staring at e-mails dropping into
my inbox about revisions to Turkey’s citizenship law. People from all
over the world are now looking to acquire Turkish citizenship. This is
in absolute contrast with times when people fled Turkey and abandoned
their past and everything there.

The annual gathering of the World Bank and the International Monetary
Fund (IMF) is taking place next door. Fifteen years ago, it would
have been difficult to believe that these meetings would take place
in Turkey. People were very desperate and had lost confidence in
everything about their home country.

I can also hear the sound of police sirens and shouts coming from a
small crowd of protestors outside my office. I read that protests on
the first day of the events took on an international standard throwing
a shoe at the speaker.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan gave a very nice speech during the
Justice and Development Party (AK Party) congress. The speech centered
on taking significant action toward peace efforts. The Turkish Cabinet
fairly recently gathered for a joint session with the Syrian Cabinet
and decided to lift the visa requirement between Turkey and Syria.

The approach to Syria and the welcoming approach from the Syrian
side is unbelievable many international lawyers will concur that we
experienced difficulties in legal matters with Syria due to a lack
of agreements between these two countries in several areas.

I heard of several people interrogated by the Mukhabarat (Syria’s
intelligence agency) for hosting Turks in their houses. Furthermore,
the Turkish Cabinet and the Iraqi Cabinet are planning to hold a joint
session in the coming days. I feel Iraq will be the next country to
become rich as a result of its oil resources, and this will carry
the country’s living standards to a higher level, I hope. Having rich
neighbors is always good.

Turkish contractors and businessmen ar sed in Iraq. We have even
stronger ties with Iraq than with Syria. There is a significant
Turkish population living in Iraq. Iraqi Turkmens will have more say
in the coming period and will hopefully have an opportunity to gain
their rights. There is also President Abdullah Gul, who is working
to gather Turkic-speaking leaders.

Turkey is looking to strengthen its relations with Central Asia and
beyond. There is an ambitious effort to overcome century-long problems
with Armenia. The Armenian influence on Turkish architecture is now
widely being discussed.

There was a time when people dared not even speak about this topic. The
Turkish Radio and Television Corporation (TRT) now has a channel
broadcasting in Kurdish. I remember times when we, as young children,
used to watch Greek TV cartoons. They were broadcasted on two channels
and in color. TRT has now covered a wide range of Ramadan programs
live from Iraq to Bosnia, in an effort to showcase that we have
common roots.

These are all good news for countries with an interest in this
region. Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu has used all the resources
at his disposal to build a strong and solid Turkish foreign policy.

Turkey is a modest country, and once its foreign policy is successfully
sorted out, local matters will be much easier to handle. There is
always one best way to go. I wish to see a unified Parliament pick
up on that best way especially in foreign policy matters.

Berk Cektir This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You
need JavaScript enabled to view it
[email protected] m This e-mail address is being protected from
spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it This e-mail address is
being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

The information provided here is intended to give basic legal
information. You should get legal assistance from a licensed
attorney at law while conducting legal transactions and not just
rely on the information in this corner. http://www.todayszaman.c

http://www.berkcektir.av.tr/

VivaCell Offers Agence France-Presse (AFP) Latest News In Your Mobil

VIVACELL OFFERS AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE (AFP) LATEST NEWS IN YOUR MOBILE PHONE

ArmInfo
2009-10-08 11:42:00

ArmInfo. VivaCell-MTS subscribers now have an exclusive opportunity
to get the latest world news from the Agence France-Presse
(AFP), a leading French news agency, directly from their mobile
phones in English, French and soon also in Russian, VivaCell-MTS
reported. VivaCell-MTS subscribers should visit the Company’s Mobile
Portal (wap.vivacell.am) and follow the AFP link.

VivaCell-MTS (K-Telecom CJSC) is the leading Armenian mobile
operator, providing a wide range of Voice and Data services. Since
its launch on 1st July 2005, in a short period of time VivaCell-MTS
has managed to build a nationwide network and a considerable customer
base. VivaCell-MTS drives the development and offering of innovative
mobile communications products, services and features in the Armenian
mobile communications market.

Mobile TeleSystems OJSC ("MTS") is the largest mobile phone operator
in Russia and the CIS. Together with its subsidiaries, the Company
services over 95.65 million subscribers. The regions of Russia, as
well as Armenia, Belarus, Turkmenistan, Ukraine, and Uzbekistan, in
which MTS and its associates and subsidiaries are licensed to provide
GSM services, have a total population of more than 230 million. Since
June 2000, MTS’ Level 3 ADRs have been listed on the New York Stock
Exchange (ticker symbol MBT).

Serzh Sargsyan: My Short Yet Too Eventful Trip About Diaspora’s Comm

SERZH SARGSYAN: MY SHORT YET TOO EVENTFUL TRIP ABOUT DIASPORA’S COMMUNITIES GAVE ME VERY IMPORTANT IMPULSES

Noyan Tapan
Oct 8, 2009

YEREVAN, OCTOBER 8, NOYAN TAPAN. RA President, National Security
Council Chairman Serzh Sargsyan convened a National Security Council
enlarged meeting on October 8. According to a report by the RA
President’s Press Office, besides members of the National Security
Council, Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin II, Bargavach Hayastan
(Prosperous Armenia) party Chairman Gagik Tsarukian, Public Council
Chairman Vazgen Manukian, and Minister of Diaspora Hranush Hakobian
also participated in the meeting.

At the National Security Council meeting the participants discussed
the current stage of normalization of Armenia-Turkey relations and
country’s future tasks in this direction, summed up the public
discussions over the normalization process of Armenian-Turkish
relations, as well as RA President’s pan-Armenian trip.

Serzh Sargsyan opening the National Security Council meeting said:

"Dear colleagues,

We have a single issue on today’s agenda of the National Security
Council meeting, the current condition of our initiative to
normalize the Armenia-Turkey relations and our future tasks in this
connection. Now it is time to sum up the public discussions lasting
for nearly six weeks. My pan-Armenian trip has also finished, during
which I had a possibility to get acquainted with opinions of our
sisters and brothers in the Diaspora, their concerns and proposals.

Today I will tell you my impressions and conclusions from
that trip. Then we will touch upon the problems of signing the
Armenia-Turkey initiated protocols and the next stages of the process.

During a week I visited the most important centers of Armenian Diaspora
– Paris, New York, Los Angeles, Beirut, and Rostov-on-Don. Regional
meetings were held in each place, and representatives of Armenian
national structures functioning in each community and of separate
communities were present at the meetings. From the very start
we realized that we could not ensure a level of representation
to please everybody. However, I think we managed to ensure a
circle of invitees that permitted to provide a wide spectrum of
opinions and approaches. As the goal of my visit was not to give a
numerical analysis to Diaspora’s collective opinion, we did not attach
importance to ensuring equal representation of each view’s supporters
in the hall. For us, it was more important to listen to all possible
approaches and to receive the whole possible consultation in this
issue. I think we managed to.

A question was often voiced during my trip: aren’t these consultations
late in consideration of the fact that the protocols have been
already initiated?

I think it is only the opinion of people who sincerely believe that
normalization of Armenia-Turkey relations is limited to initiation of
protocols. Certainly, it is not so. For me, the discussions in the
Diaspora were too important in the respect of planning our strategy
and tactics in each link of the chain from initiation to signing,
from signing to ratification, and from ratification to fulfillment.

A concern was often voiced during my meetings that Armenia does not
have sufficient resources – human, financial-economic, political
to organize those relations as an equal side. I think it is a wrong
approach. Yes, we need to mobilize our resources, to use Diaspora’s
potential completely.

However, in my opinion, that argument cannot be enough for shutting
ourselves up inside our country.

There were concerns that establishment of relations and opening of
the border can result in an economic and demographic expansion. I
think it is the same as to suppose that beheading is the best method
of getting rid of a headache.

I had an occasion to reaffirm our approach that we do not consider
that the protocols can be interpreted as documents binding Armenia’s
negotiations positions in the Nagorno Karabakh conflict. Moreover,
I reaffirmed our approach to possible settlement conditions – without
a limitation, through expression of free will, determination of its
legal status by the Nagorno Karabakh people. I consider it important
that U.S. President Barack Obama once more reaffirmed it when I had
a telephone talk with him during my stay in Los Angeles. The concerns
of our compatriots, as well as statements on this issue periodically
voiced by the Turkish leadership are understandable.

Certainly, in our small region all processes can influence each other.

Another thing is important here: we are not ready and will never make
one-sided concessions in the issue of Nagorno Karabakh, irrespective
of the thing what we can be suggested for it.

The next main concern is the alleged possible retreat in the issue of
international recognition and condemnation of the Armenian Genocide. I
think it is obvious that any Armenian cannot but voice the reasons
of our being a people spread throughout the world and deprived of its
territory. We have a duty in the issue of recognition and condemnation
of the Genocide and will do that duty to the end. I feel sorry that
giving way to their emotions some of our sisters and brothers lost
the ideological basis of their steps. If the fair demand of all of
us is voicing the importance of accepting the fact of the Genocide
in the Armenia-Turkey relations, then it was the very purpose of
starting my pan-Armenian trip, as a symbol, with paying the tribute
of our respect to the Genocide victims at the monument to Komitas in
Paris. I expected that not with a provocation of 100 people but with
an action of protest of many thousands of people we should have shown
our consolidation and position in this issue.

And lastly, there was a concern in the issue of recognition of
the current borders. My answer was unchanged: making territorial
demands is not the best start for normalizing relations. There are
facts of political culture of the 21st century we are obliged to
take into consideration. I also had an opportunity to emphasize and
repeatedly heard the fair approach of our sisters and brothers in the
Diaspora that the Armenian-Turkish relations are much wider than the
Armenia-Turkey relations.

Dear colleagues,

My short yet too eventful trip about Diaspora’s communities gave me
very important impulses. I had an occasion to once more appreciate
the potential of our collective identity. I had an opportunity to
once more feel how different we are depending on our birthplace,
community where we live, organization where we work and meanwhile how
much alike we are thanks to our collective Armenian identity. I also
heard many words of support and encouragement in the Diaspora. I do
not want to touch upon them separately because it is us as a state
and state officials who bear full responsibility for the signing and
we are not going to lay the burden of responsibility on someone. My
goal was not returning from the pan-Armenian trip to say that the
Diaspora is for signing the Armenia-Turkey current protocols."

Then the National Security Council discussed the current stage of
normalization of Armenian-Turkish relations. The report read that
all participants of the National Security Council enlarged meeting
expressed their support for the initiated documents.

In Karine Danielian’s Opinion, Initiation Of Armenian-Turkish Protoc

IN KARINE DANIELIAN’S OPINION, INITIATION OF ARMENIAN-TURKISH PROTOCOLS ENTRAPPED ARMENIA

Noyan Tapan
Oct 8, 2009

YEREVAN, OCTOBER 8, NOYAN TAPAN. The Institute of Open Society NGO
held a telephone survey in Yerevan to find out society’s opinion
of the normalization process of Armenian-Turkish relations and the
initiated Armenian-Turkish protocols. As organization head Edgar
Hakobian reported at an October 8 press conference, 1306 citizens
above 18 took part in the survey.

The majority of respondents, 61.6% is aware of the latest developments
in normalization of Armenian-Turkish relations. 58.7% of them treats
positively the initiative of normalizing the Armenian-Turkish
relations, 29.2% treats negatively and 12.1% is neutral. In the
opinion of 48.5% respondents, the protocols have no preconditions
and 37.2% considers that they have preconditions. 22.4% considers
that the opening of the Armenian-Turkish border is rather necessary
for Armenia, 16.3% for Turkey and 22% for Armenia and Turkey.

In the opinion of RA Public Council member Karine Danielian, very
often people do not answer sincerely to such questions. "They often
think that it is a check of how they treat the authorities," she
said. K. Danielian is among the few members of the Public Council
who thinks that the protocols contain more risks than positive
elements. "In my opinion, we are caught in a trap. The initiation
has already taken place, the process has started, the international
community has welcomed it. And if we renounce it now, we will meet
a very negative attitude," K. Danielian said.