Immigrants from war-torn Bosnia, Soviet Armenia and Vietnam …

Oregonian, OR
Aug 22 2004

Immigrants from war-torn Bosnia, Soviet Armenia and Vietnam bring a
bit of their homelands to their lives here through their ethnic delis

GABRIELLE GLASER

The shopkeepers arrived in Portland from the world’s most anguished
corners: Vietnam, Bosnia, Soviet Armenia. Like the waves of
immigrants who founded and shaped this country, they came in search
of a life where death and oppression were distant stories, not a
daily reality.

Picturesque Portland has delivered on that wish. But for refugees
fleeing war, life here is neither simple, nor as richly hued as it
was in their homelands.

In their hearts they will always be strangers, catering to people
who, like themselves, yearn for the smoky cafes of the former Ottoman
Empire, the bright colors and pungent smells of Saigon’s open-air
markets, or a slab of sesame flatbread fresh from an Armenian brick
oven.

In their unassuming shops, small islands between hair salons and rug
stores, they marry the sometimes-incongruous demands of business and
nurturing. Nothing can ever really compensate for longing, but food
from home can soften it.

Here are some tales from around the city — and around the globe.

NAM PHU’O’NG

Phat Nguyen stands behind his state-of-the-art cash register and
sighs. His small store on Sandy Boulevard is a long way from the
dense jungles of South Vietnam, where he fought as a soldier
alongside U.S. troops. Nguyen, 54, spends his days ordering frozen
shrimp and squid, delicate eggplants and fresh coriander, but his
thoughts turn swiftly from the mundane to the ponderous. “I think
always of war,” he says softly above the hum of his giant freezers.
“It is in my heart.” At night, after the shop closes, he switches on
news of another war. “I hear of a young soldier dying, and I think of
his brothers, sisters, his parents, his wife,” he says.

His own three brothers were killed in the fighting; three sisters
remain in Vietnam. Resettled, Nguyen lives with his third wife and
two young children.

“War destroys every family it touches,” he says. “Two marriages,
gone.” He sweeps his hand through the air.

Like many others who fled Vietnam on rickety boats, Nguyen, who left
Saigon in 1980, was among those who suffered for his allegiance to
the U.S. “I had to leave,” he says.

So did Chuong Nguyen, 62. During the war he served as a South
Vietnamese army officer, and trained with the U.S. Army in Georgia.
He was imprisoned by the Vietcong for six years. Now, he works as a
machine operator for Siltronic Corp. “I was lucky to get out,” he
says, and excuses himself to look for fish sauce.

Phat Nguyen shrugs, then steps into his aisles crowded with rice
cookers, floormats, green tea candy and canned lychees. The one thing
his customers miss the most — exotic Southeast Asian fruit — is
unattainable. Because of import laws, Nam Phu’o’ng can carry only
frozen and canned varieties. “In Vietnam we eat fruit all day long,”
he says.

Some solace exists, though, in the form of giant durians piled in a
corner freezer. The spiked, basketball-sized fruit, little-known
outside Asia, is often hailed as the “King of Fruit,” and is prized
for its sweet, smooth, yellow flesh. (It is also known for its
distinctive odor, which is often compared to that of overripe
cheese.)

He picks up the knobbed globe. “This cannot take away sadness but it
has a good taste,” he says. “For good memories.”

ANOUSH

If you by chance are in the market for some ouzo-flavored jam from
Greece, some sea buckthorn juice from Georgia, a Moldovan tarragon
drink or some dried jumbo limes from Syria, Avetis Nor-Ashkarian is
your man.

He is the owner and proprietor of the Anoush Deli in Portland’s
Gateway district, and everyone in Stumptown from behind the former
Iron Curtain seems to be his friend. For that matter, so are locals
in the area, who line up daily for the giant gyros that Avetis — his
full name means “good news” and “new world” in Armenian — provides
daily. (He himself disdains them, eating them only when he is
desperate. “So messy,” he says.)

For Avo, as he is called, is something of a neatnik, with pressed
shirts, spotless trousers, and Old World manners in his native
tongues, English and Russian.

Nor-Ashkarian, 42, arrived in the U.S. in 1980 in the midst of the
Cold War, and just before tensions between Soviet Armenia and
Azerbaijan erupted into armed conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, an
ethnic Armenian enclave in Azerbaijan.

He has had many metiers: first as a dental technician in California,
and later as a phlebotomist at Providence St. Vincent Medical Center
(he refers to this as his “vampire phase”). But perhaps history —
Armenians have been involved in the spice trade for centuries —
helped set the stage for his current endeavor.

Each day, scarved grandmothers and burly contractors enter the
pristine shop with throaty Russian singers blaring from the speakers,
and thrust tiny slips of paper into his hand. They search for nuts,
or cheese, or yogurt. And judging by his array of sour cherry
preserves — there are more than 17 different labels — sour cherry
jam.

“Sour cherries are serious business,” Nor-Ashkarian says. “It has to
be this brand, or that brand, but absolutely not this one.”

He has learned the hard way that substituting a product he thinks
might work is not a wise idea. Customers will come to retrieve their
goods, with money hard-earned as electricians or nurses, stone masons
or telephone repairmen, only to shake their heads or purse their lips
and say, “Of course not that kind, either.”

Beer — there are a dozen brands — often summons the biggest
emotions. “You cannot imagine the disappointment if the right one is
not here,” he says.

Romanian-born Ana Alexandru, 67, stops to buy puff pastry she will
fill with cheese. Victor Chika, 71, picks up some Ukrainian sunflower
oil. American brands are inferior, he says. “No flavor!”

The bell sounds, and Nor-Ashkarian is off to dish up Bulgarian feta
for a homesick Sofia native. Then he glides to the small tables with
a tray of gyros for some chiropractic students.

On the wall behind him are three large laminated maps. On either
side, bright blue oceans complement orange and green continents. In
the center, though, is Nor-Ashkarian’s new world, and everyone
else’s: It is a giant map of Portland, with streets in minute detail.

TASTE OF EUROPE

The anchor of Muhamed Mujcic’s corner store, A Taste of Europe, on
Southeast Hawthorne, is a bright red espresso maker. Mujcic, who fled
Bosnia in the midst of the war in Yugoslavia, cheerfully presses
coffee for customers with an expert hand. His demeanor betrays a
lingering sadness for his former life in the town of Banja Luka,
where he was surrounded by extended family and had a prosperous
business. “We had a beautiful life there,” Mujcic says, nibbling from
an espresso-soaked sugar cube.

Muhamed, his wife Vesna and their two daughters, Jasminka and Vanesa,
were among thousands of Muslims driven out of Bosnia by Serb-led
militias in the campaign of ethnic cleansing. In 1994, the Mujcics
arrived in Portland, where they were sponsored by Muhamed’s brother.

Muhamed, 56, set up his store in 2000. In a town where rhythms seem
driven by the barista’s hiss, he has a varied clientele: tattooed
Portland twentysomethings wander in as they chat on their cell
phones. Eastern Europeans, many from the former Yugoslavia, walk in
purposefully, first for a handshake, then coffee. They stand,
chatting, in the back of the store, beneath vivid oil paintings by
Jasminka and tapestries of Bosnia.

Amer Filipic, 37, is a psychiatric nurse at Adventist Medical Center,
and stops by each day before his afternoon shift. “This is the best
coffee,” he says, draining his small cup. “It is fuel for my soul.”

Mujcic cheers up at the sight of his friend. “Good coffee, good
chocolate, good beer!” he calls out. “Those are necessities.” He
waves his arm past rich chocolates with orange,
strawberry-and-pepper, and marzipan filling. He shows dozens of teas,
mostly from Bosnia. One, though, is universal: “To Lose Weight Tea,”
it says simply.

He imports several types of coffee, all of it lacking the bitter
taste some commercial American brands are known for. “In Bosnia, we
began drinking coffee 400 years ago. For us it is no fad, it is our
culture.”

Jasminka looks on, her face solemn. “We’re in this country now,” she
said. “But when you step outside this door, you are always reminded
that you are different.”

Behind every war, of course, are lives, and losses. Muhamed’s family
has suffered more than its share: Though his three brothers escaped
Banja Luka, they died prematurely here. “Heart attacks, brain
attacks,” he says. “In Bosnia my family always lived to be old.”

The results of war, he says, are the same everywhere. “The biggest
losers are the smart, honest people.”

ARKA News Agency – 08/19/2004

ARKA News Agency
Aug 19 2004

RA Foreign Minister met teachers from Diaspora

Robert Kocharian to leave for sochi for a working meeting with
Vladimir Putin on August 20

A mourning ceremony devoted to the anniversary of the terrorist act
against the UN Headquarters in Baghdad held in the UN Headquarter in
Armenia

Some seminars for Karabakh refugees held in Stepanakert

*********************************************************************

RA FOREIGN MINISTER MET TEACHERS FROM DIASPORA

YEREVAN, August 19. /ARKA/. RA Foreign Minister VArdan Oskanian met
today the teachers from the Diaspora that attend the professional
training classes held in Yerevan. Attaching importance to the
training programs for teachers from the Diaspora, Oskanian pointed
out to two aspects: rapprochement of Armenia and the Diaspora as two
parts of the single people and spreading of the idea of statehood
among the young generation of the schools in Diaspora. `This is a new
element, fruit of independence. Nowadays we are not a nation, but
also a state’, he mentioned.
The professional training courses of teachers from the Diaspora are
held on August 4-27. T.M. -0–

*********************************************************************

ROBERT KOCHARIAN TO LEAVE FOR SOCHI FOR A WORKING MEETING WITH
VLADIMIR PUTIN ON AUGUST 20

YEREVAN, August 19. /ARKA/. The RA President Robert Kocharian will
leave for Sochi on August 20 to have a working meeting with the
President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Putin, according to the
Press Service Department of RA President. Details of Kocharian’s
visit to Sochi are not reported. L.V. -0

*********************************************************************

A MOURNING CEREMONY DEVOTED TO THE ANNIVERSARY OF THE TERRORIST ACT
AGAINST THE UN HEADQUARTERS IN BAGHDAD HELD IN THE UN HEADQUARTER IN
ARMENIA

YEREVAN, August 19. /ARKA/. A mourning ceremony devoted to the
anniversary of the terrorist act against the UN Headquarters in
Baghdad was held in Yerevan, in UN Headquarter in Armenia. According
to the representative of the UN Department for Public Information
(DPO) in Armenia Valeri Tkachuk, it’s a personal tragedy for the
staff of UN. `It’s one of the dates which will remain in the history
of UN as a day for mourning the loss of our colleagues in Iraq’, he
added. According to Tkachuk, it was an unexampled attack on the staff
of UN, and all the members of UN were shocked by the explosion in
Canal Hotel in Baghdad. He added that the situation in Iraq is
complex, but notwithstanding this members of the UN continue their
work. `The members of the organization are always ready to render
help and work at the programs that will be implemented in the
country’, he emphasized.
on August 19, 2003 as a result of the explosion of the mined truck
near the UN Headquarter in Baghdad located in Canal Hotel 22 members
of the organization, including the Special Representatives of UN
Secretary General in Baghdad and the UN Chief Commissar on Human
Rights Sergio Viera De Mello died, and 200 people were badly injured.
That terrorist act became one of the most severe terrorist acts
against UN for the whole period of its history. According to UN
Secretary General Kofi Annan, the terrorist attack on the Canal Hotel
brought them face to face with a new danger in more intimidating form
– the danger that we, servants of the United Nations, may become the
main target of political violence. A.H.–0 –

*********************************************************************

SOME SEMINARS FOR KARABAKH REFUGEES HELD IN STEPANAKERT

STEPANAKERT, August 19. /ARKA/. Nagorno-Karabakh committee `Helsinki
Initiative -92′ with the support of Westminster Democracy Fund (GB)
held seminars from February to July 2004 for the refugees living in
Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR). According to ARKA’s reporter in
Stepanakert, the seminars were on the following subjects: `refugees
in international-legal documents’, `the rights of refugees and people
who temporarily left their homes in legal documents of the South
Caucasus’, `the role of refugees in the development of democracy and
open society’, `the Influence of refugees on the development of civic
institutes and on the conflict transformation’. The project aimed to
enrich the knowledge of the refugees in the area of international
law, to activate their participation in the development of democratic
institutes and civic society in NKR.
As a result of the seminars, a brochure titled `Legal Education of
Refugees in the Regions of NKR’ was issued with the circulation of
500 copies. It contains international -legal documents and regional
laws, concerning refugees and people who temporarily left their
homes, and the results of various public surveys. The brochures will
be delivered both among the refugees and governmental and public
figures. A.H. -0 –

ANI Helps Launch Education Program On Armenian Genocide

Armenian National Institute
122 C Street, NW Suite 360
Washington, D.C.  20001
Phone: 202-383-9009
Fax: 202-383-9012
E-mail: [email protected]

PRESS RELEASE
August 18, 2004
CONTACT: David Zenian
Phone: (202) 383-9009
E-mail:[email protected]

ANI HELPS LAUNCH EDUCATION PROGRAM ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

Armenian National Institute Director, Dr. Rouben Adalian, was in London,
Ontario, August 9-10, to help launch the General Romeo Dallaire Summer
Institute on Teaching the Holocaust and Genocide.  Named in honor of the
Canadian commander of the United Nations peacekeeping mission for Rwanda,
Dallaire warned superiors of the impending genocide in the country to no
avail.  Despite UN reluctance to authorize him to take action, Dallaire, of
his own volition, took measures that saved the lives of up to 40,000
Rwandans.

Since his retirement from service, Lieutenant-General Dallaire has become an
outspoken proponent of the need for humanitarian intervention in predictable
instances of genocide and mass violence, as well as a persuasive defender of
the argument that genocide is preventable.

Dallaire was also honored by civic and other community leaders the evening
of August 9 with a public dinner at the London Convention Center where Dr.
Adalian paid tribute to Dallaire’s personal campaign to continue to remind
the world of the lessons of the Rwandan Genocide ten years after its
occurrence, while ninety years after the fact the Armenian Genocide is just
being recognized.  For his contributions to preventing crimes against
humanity, Dr. Adalian described Dallaire as “a champion of humanity.”

Spearheaded by the Association for the Elimination of Hate, the summer
institute for teachers was convened at the University of Western Ontario,
and the inclusion of the Armenian Genocide component coordinated by the
International Institute for Human Rights and Genocide Studies, a division of
the Zoryan Institute of Toronto, Canada.

Focusing on the challenges of teaching about genocide, Dr. Adalian provided
teachers extensive background to the Armenian Genocide and introduced them
to the many educational resources now available through the ANI Web site
(), including the teachers resource book newly
issued by Facing History and Ourselves Foundation.

Following Major Brent Beardsley’s presentation on the Rwandan Genocide, Dr.
Adalian compared the Armenian, Jewish, and Rwandan experiences.  Beardsley
served as Dallaire’s second in command in Rwanda.  “I was particularly
honored by General Dallaire’s participation in the session on the Armenian
Genocide,” Adalian added.  “It was an opportunity to share views on the
subject with a distinguished and courageous individual, who himself was a
witness to genocide.”

The Armenian National Institute is a Washington-based organization dedicated
to the study, research, and affirmation of the Armenian Genocide.

www.armenian-genocide.org
www.armenian-genocide.org

Industrial output in Armenia drops 5.8% in January-July

Interfax
Aug 13 2004

Industrial output in Armenia drops 5.8% in January-July

Yerevan. (Interfax) – The monetary volume of industrial output in
Armenia dropped 5.8% year-on-year to 170.7 billion dram in the
January-July 2004, the country’s Trade and Economic Development
Ministry told Interfax.

The greatest decrease – 19.5% – was posted in the gem-cutting and
polishing and jewelry industry. Enterprises in this sector turned out
product worth 71.7 billion dram.

The ministry’s figures show sales of industrial product increased
15.5% to 168.3 billion dram in January-July. Exports were up 9.8% to
143.6 billion dram.
The official exchange rate for August 13: 519.24 dram/$1.

BAKU: Azeri Envoy Concerned About Russian-Armenian Military Ties

AZERI ENVOY CONCERNED ABOUT RUSSIAN-ARMENIAN MILITARY TIES

Trend news agency, Baku
14 Aug 04

BAKU

Trend correspondent E. Huseynov: The OSCE Minsk Group, of which Russia
is a co-chairman, should take a stricter position on a peaceful
settlement to the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict and clearly and loudly
announce that the territory is under occupation, Trend news agency has
quoted the Azerbaijani ambassador to Russia, Ramiz Rizayev, as saying.

(Passage omitted: reported details)

Voicing Baku’s concern about Moscow’s rapprochement with Yerevan in
the military field, Rizayev noted that it was particularly distressing
against the backdrop of the still unresolved conflict in Nagornyy
Karabakh.

“We know that many Armenians served and are continuing to serve in
Russia’s military units. This factor has had an exclusively negative
impact on the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict…(ellipses as published)

Suffice it to say that the 366th regiment of the Soviet army, over 70
per cent of whose servicemen were Armenians, was involved in the
bloody events in Xocali (Azeri-populated Karabakh town which was
seized by Armenians in February 1992). The issue of the illegal
handover to Armenia of Russian arms worth over 1bn dollars is also
still unresolved. But we do hope that the current leadership of Russia
will finally show wisdom in this vital issue and these problems, which
we have inherited from the past, will be resolved,” he said.

Asked about the possibility of Azerbaijan’s admission to NATO, the
diplomat said: “We do not see any need to join any military bloc or
organization.”

BAKU: Opposition party appeals to President

Azer News, Azerbaijan
Aug 12 2004

Opposition party appeals to President

The Board of the opposition Whole Azerbaijan Popular Front Party
(WAPFP) in its Thursday meeting adopted an appeal to President Ilham
Aliyev.

The document reads that the 10-year talks over settling the
Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict over Upper Garabagh have yielded no
positive results. “The party hopes that President Ilham Aliyev will
take into account the fact that this is a matter of moral importance
for the Azerbaijani people and disclose his position towards
preventing the Armenian officers’ upcoming visit to Baku,” the appeal
said.

The document also reads that if this takes place there will be no
need for protest actions, as it will be clear that the government
gives priority to the country’s national interests.

Young Turks Who Set Stage For The Century Of Slaughter

The Times Higher Education Supplement
August 6, 2004

Young Turks Who Set Stage For The Century Of Slaughter
by: William Rubinstein

The Burning Tigris: A History of the Armenian Genocide. By Peter
Balakian. Heinemann 473pp, Pounds 18.99. ISBN 0 434 00816 8

The 20th century has often been called the century of genocide, and
the first of its genocidal horrors, at least in the Western world,
was the Armenian genocide of 1915. Carried out by the Turkish
Government and its allies among the local populations of northeastern
and central Turkey against its own citizens, it anticipated many of
the enormities made familiar to the world in the Nazi genocide of the
Jews a quarter of a century later. In some respects, the Armenian
genocide provides an archetype for most subsequent state-sponsored
mass killings down to Pol Pot and beyond.

The Armenian genocide originated among the ultra-nationalist
extremists of the Committee for Union and Progress (the CUP), also
known as the Ittihad (Union), or, more popularly, the “Young Turks”,
who had seized power in the Ottoman Empire in 1908. Originally a
broadly based modernising movement, its Turkish majority became ever
more committed to extreme Turkish nationalism, entailing the
elimination of most Armenians and Greeks from the Turkish economy.
Their extremism was accentuated by the progressive loss of territory
suffered by Turkey in the Balkans and elsewhere up until 1914. In
1915, during the First World War, extremists within the CUP took the
smokescreen provided by the war as their opportunity to eliminate
most of the Armenians in Anatolian Turkey. At least 600,000 Armenians
perished – other estimates are far higher – often in ways and
circumstances that directly anticipated the Nazi Holocaust.

Many thousands were deported in sealed boxcars to remote desert
areas; many were machine-gunned in pits at the edge of towns. For one
of the first times in modern Western history, this slaughter spared
no one, not even women, children and the elderly, who are normally
protected to a certain extent in wartime. (On the other hand,
conversion to Islam spared the lives of some, while many Armenian
women wound up as Islamified wives or concubines of Turks.) This
harrowing story has attracted a growing literature in the burgeoning
and controversial field of “genocide studies”, but Peter Balakian’s
work is perhaps the first general account of the Armenian genocide
intended for a literate mass audience; it is clearly meant to
parallel the many popular accounts of the Holocaust, regularly
drawing analogies with the Nazi genocide.

Among its many merits are a full discussion of the appalling
persecutions endured by the Armenians in the decades before 1914, and
of the not-inconsiderable efforts of the Western democracies,
particularly the US, to publicise their fate and relieve their
suffering. This work is likely to become the best-known book on the
Armenian genocide. Balakian, professor of humanities at Colgate
University in New York state, is one of a growing number of
historians of Armenian descent who have assessed and publicised the
tragedy of their people. The work includes harrowing photographs of
the 1915 genocide that beggar belief.

Granted all of this, one must also point out that much about the
Armenian genocide of 1915, as diabolical as it obviously was, can be
interpreted in a somewhat different light compared with the sequence
of events typically set out in recent accounts of this event. First,
it seems clear that there was no pre-existing plan among Turkish
leaders to exterminate the Armenians, as is now frequently suggested
by many scholars. The last Ottoman Parliament, elected in 1914 just
before the outbreak of the war, saw 14 Armenians elected among its
259 members, exactly the same number as in the previous Parliament,
elected in 1908. Early in 1914, both the Armenian and Greek
communities in Turkey – the Greeks also being targeted by Turkish
extremists – carried out extensive and successful negotiations aimed
at guaranteeing their existing percentages in future Ottoman
parliaments. At this stage, a number of Armenians were major figures
in the CUP movement, for instance Bedros Halacian, the public works
minister. The contrast between this and the situation of the Jews in
Nazi Germany, ostracised from day one, is self-evident.

It was also plainly the case that Turkey did not start the First
World War and could not have foreseen the course of catastrophic war
declarations and mobilisations that unfolded in mid-1914. Indeed,
Turkey remained neutral for the first three months of the conflict,
declaring war only on October 19, 1914. In fact, most Turkish elite
opinion was originally pro-British rather than pro-German, with
Britain traditionally seen as the Ottoman Empire’s protector, and
arguably only the extraordinarily inept handling of the situation by
the British Government – something for which it has received
insufficient criticism – prevented Turkey from joining the Allies
rather than the Central Powers, with profound consequences.

>From October 1914, however, Turkey found itself at war with Russia.

Turkey’s nationalist extremists saw its Christian Armenian minority
as likely to be a subversive force working for Russia. Turkey then
proceeded to invade the Russian Caucasus, with disastrous results,
leading, in late November 1914, to a Russian counter-invasion of
northeastern Anatolia, which resulted in its seizure of much of the
area. Many Armenians supported the Russian drive against the hated
Turks. That Russia had successfully invaded northeastern Turkey in
1914-15 is obfuscated and camouflaged in the most recent accounts of
the Armenian genocide.

It was at this point, in the spring of 1915, that the CUP Government,
now dominated by extremists, decided forcibly to transfer its
Armenian population in northeastern Anatolia to the southern part of
Turkey. This forcible transfer was carried out with the utmost
brutality and inhumanity, and certainly included the deliberate
murder of tens of thousands of Armenians, by the nationalist
extremists who controlled the Turkish Government as well as their
henchmen among anti-Christian Muslim fundamentalists, Kurds and
criminals recruited especially to carry out the transfers as brutally
as possible.

The genocide occurred when the very existence of Turkey was certainly
threatened by its enemies, creating a mood of panic where murderous
fanaticism became the order of the day. While the parallels with the
Holocaust are clear, there were obvious differences as well: most
killings by the Nazis occurred in Poland and Russia, which Germany
had invaded largely for ideological reasons, the persecution of the
Jews being at the very core of Hitler’s world-view. In contrast,
Turkey inflicted slaughter on its own people while being invaded.

It is also no coincidence that the Armenian genocide occurred during
the First World War. The profoundly destructive effects of that
conflict led to the triumph of extremist, genocidal ideologies whose
impact was arguably not made good until the fall of Communism 75
years later.

William D. Rubinstein is professor of history, University of Wales,
Aberystwyth.

BAKU: Azerbaijan must take tough line on Karabakh exercises – expert

Azerbaijan must take tough line on Karabakh exercises – expert

Zerkalo, Baku
4 Aug 04

Azerbaijan must react firmly to the Armenian-sponsored military
exercises that are now under way in Nagornyy Karabakh, military expert
Azad Isazada has stated in an article in the Azerbaijani newspaper
Zerkalo. Ultimately, he added, the conflict can only be resolved by
military means. The following is the text of C. Bayramova’s report by
Azerbaijani newspaper Zerkalo on 4 August headlined “Azerbaijan must
display firmness over the Karabakh issue” and subheaded “Otherwise our
country risks losing the seized territories forever, says a military
expert”:

The start of command staff exercises by the separatist military units
was announced yesterday in Nagornyy Karabakh.

For nine days, the armed formations of the Karabakh separatists will
demonstrate their so-called fighting capacity and ability to
coordinate military action in either offensive or defensive mode. It
should be recalled that Armenian President Robert Kocharyan announced
last month that military exercises by Armenian troops would be held
shortly in the eastern sector.

Naturally, the reaction from Azerbaijani experts to such a
high-profile event was not long in coming. Several of them think that
the Armenians’ demonstration of their military might is merely for
publicity purposes and is an attempt of sorts to test the
Azerbaijanis’ readiness to resolve the conflict by military means.

The military expert Azad Isazada has spoken on the subject to the
newspaper Zerkalo. He completely agrees that any exercises constitute
a show of force, adding that exhibiting their military capability
indicates yet another attempt by the separatists to display their will
to resist.

“Our country must certainly react in an extremely tough way.
Azerbaijan should present a demand to the other participants in the
exercises, stating that it is intolerable that they are being held on
the territory of Azerbaijan,” the expert thinks.

Nevertheless, he pointed out that Armenia is going to hold the
manoeuvres in the sector where shooting has broken out too frequently
over the past few months and the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline is being
laid. Thus, according to the expert, these actions can be seen as a
lever for Armenian military pressure on the whole South Caucasus.

There is, however, a universally accepted tactic for behaviour when a
hostile side is staging military exercises. The armed forces of
Azerbaijan that are deployed in the region must, therefore, be put on
full alert and the hardware, guns and manpower in their firing
positions must be activated. The expert did not omit to declare that
Azerbaijan should justify these measures by pointing to the fact that
the enemy’s military forces were concentrated right by the line of
confrontation in the seized lands.

In reply to the question of whether Robert Kocharyan was using the
military exercises to distract public attention in Armenia, where the
political situation was strained to the utmost, the expert said: “It
seems to me that the aim you describe is unlikely to be achieved
through these exercises. After all, it is external political pressure,
and it has no particular effect on the internal atmosphere within the
country. It may well be, though, that Kocharyan wants to show Armenia
that he has confidence in his forces. It’s as though he were saying
that he always has troops to hand to suppress any dissent. He is,
thus, putting psychological pressure on the opposition.”

Since he is also a military psychologist, Isazada sketched in a few
pointers as to the possible way in which Azerbaijani and world opinion
might perceive the separatists’ holding of exercises in Nagornyy
Karabakh. In his view, the world community would most likely do no
more than utter statements consisting of smooth phrases and well-worn
formulations to the effect that any escalation of the conflict was
unacceptable. As for Azerbaijani society, any show of force by Armenia
gives rise to perfectly justified aggression within it, particularly
among refugees. This, in turn, is accompanied by heightened tension,
which, in his view, could only be relieved by appropriate action by
Azerbaijan’s armed forces.

Incidentally, our interviewee is certain that the Karabakh conflict
can only be resolved by military means. In his view, sooner or later
there will be a resumption of hostilities, since any peaceful
resolution would inevitably involve Azerbaijani concessions that
would, in effect, entail the surrender of Karabakh.

“I am well informed about the mood of the generals and the higher
echelons of the Ministry of Defence. There too the view is held that
the conflict will never be resolved by peaceful means – not because
there could be no such solution, but because it simply does not
exist,” the expert commented.

Iraq blames al-Zarqawi for bombing

Taipei Times

Iraq blames al-Zarqawi for bombing

RELIGIOUS ‘WEDGE’: The Jordanian-born militant was trying to force
Christians out of the country, officials said, while a Turkish hostage was
reportedly executed

REUTERS , BAGHDAD
Tuesday, Aug 03, 2004,Page 6

A US soldier stands guard yesterday in front of a Christian Syriac church in
Baghdad which was targeted on Sunday by a suicide car bomb.
PHOTO: AFP
The Iraqi government yesterday blamed al-Qaeda ally Abu Musab al-Zarqawi for
a series of church bombings that killed at least 11 people, saying the aim
was to spark religious strife and drive Christians out of the country.

Muslim leaders condemned the car bombings that were timed for Sunday evening
services in Baghdad and the northern city of Mosul. The attacks were the
first on churches of the minority Christian community since the start of a
15-month insurgency.

“There is no shadow of a doubt that this bears the blueprint of Zarqawi,”
said national security adviser Mowaffaq al-Rubaie.

“Zarqawi and his extremists are basically trying to drive a wedge between
Muslims and Christians in Iraq. It’s clear they want to drive Christians out
of the country,” he said.

The Jordanian-born militant has claimed responsibility for a series of major
car bombings in Iraq since former Iraqi president Saddam Hussein was ousted
last year as well as the killing of foreign hostages.

An Islamist Web site yesterday showed photographs of what it said was the
killing of a Turkish hostage by a group linked to Zarqawi. But a Somali held
by militants also linked to Zarqawi is to be freed after his Kuwaiti
employer agreed to halt operations in the country, alJazeera television
said.

Rubaie said Iraq’s national security council was to hold an emergency
meeting yesterday to discuss the blasts that hit at least five churches in
the country, including four in Baghdad.

The bomb attacks near the four Baghdad churches killed 10 people and wounded
more than 40, the US military said, adding the blasts occurred within a
30-minute period.

Witnesses and officials had said earlier that as many as 15 people had been
killed, including at least one person killed by a bomb at a church in Mosul.

The US statement gave no details of casualties from Mosul. It said Iraqi
police had found and cleared an explosive device that contained 15 mortar
rounds outside a fifth Baghdad church.

Christians account for about 3 percent of the population of Iraq, where
attempts to provoke conflict have mainly focused on Sunni Muslims and
members of the Shiite Muslim majority, who were oppressed by Saddam.

There are 800,000 Christians in Iraq, most of them in Baghdad. Several
recent attacks have targeted alcohol sellers throughout Iraq, most of whom
are Christians of either the Assyrian, Chaldean or Armenian denominations.

Adnan al-Asadi, a senior member of the Shiite Dawa Islamic party, said
Muslims shared the pain of the Christian community.

“We reject these criminal acts which want to create religious and sectarian
strife in Iraq,” he said.

“We do not differentiate between these acts which are in violation of
religious and Islamic laws because the perpetrators of these acts … are
the same people who strike Iraqi mosques and centers for the internal
security forces,” he said.

Iraqi Human Rights Minister Bakhtiar Amin said the interim government of
Prime Minister Iyad Allawi was trying its best to combat the insurgents and
uproot their networks.

“This shows there are no borders to the barbarity of the crimes of these
terrorists,” he said in response to the attacks. “No believer of any
religion would do this.”

Parish priest Bashar Muntihorda, speaking outside a Chaldean church in
Baghdad that was hit, said Christians were devastated.
This story has been viewed 533 times.

Quand l’eau de Borjomi barre la route de l’exportation au petrole

Le Temps
2 août 2004

Quand la très réputée eau minérale de Borjomi barre la route de
l’exportation au pétrole de la Caspienne;

PÉTROLE. La construction du grand pipeline à travers le Caucase vient
d’être arrêtée au beau milieu de la Géorgie. Le gouvernement de
Tbilissi demande au groupe pétrolier britannique BP de mieux protéger
l’environnement

Ses concepteurs le savaient: la route d’évacuation du brut de la
Caspienne en direction de l’Occident est semée d’embûches. Mais le
pétrolier britannique BP, chef de file du consortium international
qui dirige ce chantier, l’un des plus grands du monde (tracé de
l’oléoduc: 1760 km; coût des travaux: près de 4 milliards de
dollars), pensait les avoir toutes surmontées. Malgré les tensions
ethniques dans la région (Karabakh, Adjarie, Ossétie du Sud,
proximité de la Tchétchénie), malgré les soubresauts politiques
géorgiens liés au départ du vieux président Chevardnadze l’automne
dernier, malgré des polémiques sur le traitement réservé aux
militants kurdes des droits de l’homme côté turc, les travaux
avancent régulièrement depuis le premier coup de pioche en septembre
2001 au sud de Bakou. BP annonce régulièrement sur un site internet
spécialement dédié au projet ()
que les délais seront tenus. En théorie donc, la conduite stratégique
Bakou-Tbilissi-Ceyhan (BTC) sera inaugurée au premier trimestre 2005.
Ainsi le brut du secteur azéri de la Caspienne pourra, par monts et
par vaux, déboucher sur le grand terminal pétrolier de Ceyhan, sur la
côte méditerranéenne de la Turquie. C’est là aussi qu’arrive déjà,
quand le pipeline n’est pas saboté, le pétrole de Kirkouk, au nord de
l’Irak. Seulement voilà, une eau minérale menace de tout faire
dérailler au dernier moment!

Au coeur du massif du Petit Caucase, au beau milieu de la Géorgie, la
vallée de Borjomi recèle en effet un superbe parc naturel, réputé
pour la qualité de son eau minérale cristalline. A l’époque de
l’empire rouge, 300 millions de Soviétiques ne juraient que par les
vertus curatives de la Borjomi, dont l’étiquette était reconnaissable
sur toutes les tables. Celles des apparatchiks du Kremlin comme
celles des ouvriers des aciéries de Magnitogorsk. Avec la disparition
de l’URSS, la Borjomi s’était fait plus discrète. Mais depuis
quelques années, la Géorgie a décidé de lui redonner son prestige,
invitant des investisseurs étrangers à moderniser les chaînes
d’embouteillage.

Quand le pouvoir géorgien a découvert que le tracé du pipeline de BP
allait passer pile à travers les 17 kilomètres du parc naturel de
Borjomi, tout faillit capoter. Il fallut, en novembre 2002, une
rencontre au sommet entre David Woodward, grand patron de BP en
Azerbaïdjan et maître d’oeuvre du BTC, et le président Chevardnadze,
pour arracher le consentement de Tbilissi, au terme d’une nuit de
négociation homérique. Le Ministère de l’environnement lui-même, fort
des conclusions d’experts écologistes hollandais, s’était pourtant
opposé au tracé passant par Borjomi, estimant que l’or noir en tube
menaçait considérablement le fragile équilibre écologique de la
région. Une campagne internationale de conscientisation avait suivi,
organisée depuis Londres par des activistes verts déchaînés. Mais, en
professionnels de la communication, les gens de BP avaient fini par
noyer les mises en garde sous le flot de leurs communiqués
rassurants. Il y a dix jours, alors que les travaux ont commencé il y
a un mois dans ce secteur sensible, les nouvelles autorités
géorgiennes du président Mikhaïl Saakachvili ont exigé de BP l’arrêt
immédiat des travaux pour deux semaines, sur cette portion du
chantier seulement. Le Ministère de l’environnement géorgien et le
Conseil de sécurité nationale demandent que «les mesures de sécurité
les plus strictes» soient observées. «Nous invitons BP à respecter
ses engagements pris lors de l’accord de novembre 2002, notamment le
paragraphe 9 qui se rapporte directement au secteur de Borjomi»,
insiste Tamar Lebanidze, ministre de l’Environnement géorgien.
Consternation chez les pétroliers.

«Cette requête géorgienne n’est pas une surprise», confie un prochedu
dossier. Tbilissi entend obtenir le maximum de garanties de la part
des constructeurs. Les experts du gouvernement géorgien insistent sur
le fait que la vallée est située dans une zone à «haute activité
sismique», que les risques de glissements de terrain sont élevés et
qu’un sabotage ou un acte terroriste n’est pas à exclure. Un accident
causerait des dommages écologiques irréparables, mais aussi
économiques. Or la région a le potentiel pour attirer de nombreux
touristes. En outre, l’entreprise Georgian Glass & Mineral Water,
propriétaire de l’eau minérale de Borjomi, est l’une des rares
sociétés du pays à exporter, ce qui en fait une importante
pourvoyeuse de devises pour un Etat ruiné. Pas question pour elle de
prendre le risque de connaître les mésaventures de Perrier, dont les
ventes s’étaient effondrées en 1990, après une affaire de
contamination de l’eau au benzène.

Le gouvernement géorgien précise qu’il «reconnaît les engagements
internationaux» du pouvoir précédent et n’entend pas exiger de
«suspension à long terme» des travaux. Il n’envisage pas non plus de
faire changer le tracé du BTC pour contourner la précieuse vallée, en
passant plus au sud par exemple. Une option qui avait de toute
manière était évacuée d’emblée par les promoteurs du projet, et par
la diplomatie américaine qui le soutient: le sud de la Géorgie, dans
la région de Djavakhétie, est en effet peuplé d’Arméniens, jugés
potentiellement séparatistes, et proches de Moscou. La zone abrite de
surcroît une importe base militaire russe…

Deux semaines, c’est court. Suffiront-elles à réévaluer la situation
et à amener BP à fournir des garanties supplémentaires? Pour un
spécialiste des chantiers de pipelines, travaillant sur le BTC, «ce
délai a un côté médiatique. Cela aurait pu être une comme quatre
semaines, explique-t-il. Il est à peu près certain que le
gouvernement géorgien s’appuie sur la forte protestation des
organisations vertes pour remettre à plat les négociations avec la
BTC Corporation et BP, afin d’obtenir des conditions financières plus
favorables, notamment les droits de transit que touchera l’Etat pour
le passage du pétrole sur son territoire. Chantage? Oui, en quelque
sorte. Cela se passe toujours comme cela dans ce genre de chantiers,
aux quatre coins du monde.»

Même si l’interruption provisoire du grand chantier n’est donc pas
qu’une question de sécurité environnementale, les organisations
écologistes ont bien l’intention d’en profiter pour faire entendre
davantage leurs exigences. Peu optimiste quant à la possibilité de
faire changer le tracé du BTC, Manana Kochladze, présidente de Green
Alternative, estime que «cette mesure sera un vrai test de la volonté
du gouvernement de protéger les populations de la région et défendre
les intérêts du pays». Entre un gouvernement géorgien tout sauf
servile et des ONG tenaces et puissantes, BP et ses partenaires
pourraient avoir fort à faire dans les prochaines semaines. D’autant
que d’autres motifs de contestation – problème des compensations
versées aux propriétaires des terres où passera le tuyau;
non-réalisation de programmes d’«accompagnement» destinés à amoindrir
l’impact social du chantier – pourraient continuer à freiner
l’avancée du grand pipeline, une avancée nettement moins inexorable
que celle promise par David Woodward dans son bureau de Bakou, quand
il explique aux visiteurs comment son grand tuyau se jouera de toutes
les difficultés.

www.caspiandevelopmentandexport.com