RFE/RL Armenian Report – 06/13/2017

                                        Tuesday, 

Karabakh Peace Plan `Not Discussed' In Recent Armenian-Azeri Talks


 . Sargis Harutyunyan


Russi - Foreign Ministers Sergey Lavrov (C) of Russia, Edward
Nalbandian (L) of Armenia and Elmar Mammadyarov of Azerbaijan meet in
Moscow, 28Apr2017.

Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian insisted on Tuesday that he and his
Azerbaijani counterpart Elmar Mammadyarov did not discuss in detail
international mediators' existing peace proposals on resolving the
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict when they last met in April.

The meeting was hosted in Moscow by Russia's Foreign Minister Sergey
Lavrov. The three top diplomats were joined by the U.S., Russian and
French co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group after conferring in a
trilateral format.

"The foreign ministers did not hold negotiations on any document in
Moscow," Nalbandian said, denying Mammadyarov's effective claims to
the contrary made on Monday. "If there was any text discussed there,
it was the text of a [joint] press release that was agreed by the
ministers in the presence of the co-chairs."

"It was then published by Russia's and Armenia's foreign ministries,
while the Azerbaijani foreign ministry published its own version," he
told a joint news conference with Estonia's visiting Foreign Minister
Sven Mikser.


Armenia -- Armenian Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian (R) and his
Estonian counterpart Sven Mikser at a joint press conference in
Yerevan, .

The April 28 statement cited by Nalbandian said that the participants
of the Moscow talks "stressed the need to fulfill" confidence-building
agreements that were reached by Armenia's and Azerbaijan's presidents
last year. The agreements call for specific measures to shore up the
shaky ceasefire regime in the conflict zone.

The Azerbaijani government is reluctant to put those truce safeguards
into practice, saying that they could cement the status quo. The
Armenian side maintains that progress in substantive peace talks is
contingent on introduction of mechanisms for preventing serious
ceasefire violations.

Nalbandian told the Minsk Group co-chairs that they should take
"concrete actions" to force Azerbaijan to de-escalate the conflict
when he met with them in Yerevan on Saturday. He claimed on Tuesday
that the mediating powers are finally realizing the need for
"appropriate steps" against Baku.



Aliyev Hails Muslim Support On Karabakh


Turkey -- Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev attends the 13th
Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) Summit at Istanbul Congress
Center (ICC) in Istanbul, April 14, 2016

Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev has thanked Islamic states for
supporting Azerbaijan in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and accused the
Armenians of committing "crimes against the entire Muslim world."

"The Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) has adopted many
documents and resolutions on the conflict," Aliyev was reported on
Tuesday to tell the Baku-based ambassadors of Muslim nations. "Those
documents support the just position of Azerbaijan."

"The support and solidarity shown by Muslim countries is very
important to us. I thank members of the organization for that
support," he said.

Aliyev singled out a joint declaration adopted by the heads of OIC
member states at a summit held in Istanbul in April last year. It
branded Armenia an "aggressor" and called for more "coercive" measures
that would help Azerbaijan restore control over Karabakh. The
statement also blamed Yerevan for four-day hostilities in Karabakh
that broke out earlier in April 2016.

The Armenian government responded by accusing the Islamic bloc of
"completely distorting the essence of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict."
Armenia maintains cordial relations with some OIC member states,
notably Iran.


Nagorno-Karabakh - Yukhari Govhar Agha Mosque in Shushi, July 2011.

Meeting with the foreign envoys, Aliyev also alleged that the
Armenians have destroyed Azerbaijani mosques in the Karabakh town of
Shushi (Shusha), Aghdam and other "occupied towns.""This is a crime
against the entire Muslim world," he charged, according to the APA
news agency. "We want all Muslims of the world to know this."

While the Shia mosques in Shushi and Aghdam are in need of repairs,
they were not destroyed after those towns were captured by Karabakh
Armenian forces during the 1991-1994 war with Azerbaijan. The Karabakh
leadership claimed in 2010 to have spent over $80,000 on refurbishing
them as well as a former Islamic school building in Shushi. It said
the cosmetic repairs there were also sponsored by the Karabakh diocese
of the Armenian Apostolic Church.

The authorities in Stepanakert announced in December last year that
they have contracted an unnamed Iranian company to complete the
reconstruction of Shushi's 19th century Yukhari Govhar Agha Mosque.



Farmers Demand Government Aid After Hailstorm


 . Anush Muradian


Armenia - A farmer in Armavir province shows his fields hit by a
powerful hailstorm, 13Jun2017.

Hundreds of angry farmers blocked a road in Armenia on Tuesday to
demand that the government compensate them for massive damage caused
by a powerful hailstorm that swept through the country the previous
night.

The protesters were mainly residents of eight villages in the Armavir
province west of Yerevan which reportedly bore the brunt of the
storm. According to the Armenian Agriculture Ministry, hailstones
destroyed between 40 and 100 percent of crops grown in those
communities.

Local residents thus fully or partly lost their main source income for
this year. Many of them have outstanding debts to commercial
banks. They planned to repay their agricultural loans with proceeds
from sales of their fruits and vegetables.

"The hail destroyed the whole harvest here," said one of the villagers
blocking an Armavir highway. "Whatever money was invested here is
lost."

"We need to have some kind of assistance from the state so that we can
feel better and don't leave this country," said another man.

The protesters unblocked the road after Deputy Agriculture Minister
Ashot Harutiunian and Armavir's governor, Ashot Ghahramanian, visited
and spoke to them. The officials, who also toured the affected
communities, promised to submit compensation proposals to the
government within the next ten days. The farmers were skeptical about
those assurances.

"They say that [repayment of] our loans will be postponed until next
year," one of them told RFE/RL's Armenian service (Azatutyun.am). "But
we haven't seen such things until now."

"Last year there was an even stronger hailstorm," said another
villager. "Not a single leaf was left on these trees. Our governor
fooled us, saying that they will compensate and help us in every other
way. But they did nothing."

The protesting farmers also complained about the absence of hail
cannons in most of their communities.

An Agriculture Ministry statement quoted Harutiunian as saying that
hail cannons deployed in other parts of Armavir as well as the
neighboring Aragatsotn province "worked intensively" during Monday's
hailstorm. "Otherwise, the damage would have been much greater," the
vice-minister said.

Every year a considerable part of farming production in Armenia is
lost due to hail. The Armenian government has sought to limit the
damage by financing or subsidizing the installation of hundreds of
hail cannons across the country. Many villages still lack such
facilities.

Also, the effectiveness of the cannons is questioned by some
agriculture experts. Earlier this year, Prime Minister Karen
Karapetian discussed with relevant government officials alternative
ways of protecting harvests, including anti-hail nets.



Armenia `Reliable Partner' For NATO


 . Tatevik Lazarian


Armenia - President Serzh Sarkisian (R) meets with NATO envoy James
Appathurai in Yerevan, 13Jun2017.

Armenia is a "reliable partner" of NATO and its close ties with Russia
have caused no problems for the Western alliance, according to a
senior NATO envoy.

The official, James Appathurai, described as "excellent" the South
Caucasus nation's increased cooperation with NATO at the start of his
latest visit to Yerevan on Monday.

"We fully respect the balanced foreign policy that Armenia has,"
Appathurai told a news conference. "It causes us no complication that
Armenia is, for example, in the [Russian-led] Collective Security
Treaty Organization or the Eurasian Economic Union."

"Armenia has been a reliable partner for NATO," added NATO Secretary
General Jens Stoltenberg's special representative for the South
Caucasus and Central Asia.

Appathurai met with President Serzh Sarkisian on Tuesday for talks
that focused on NATO-Armenia ties, the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and
broader regional security. Armenia's relationship with neighboring
Iran was also on the agenda, according to a statement released by the
presidential press office.


Armenia -- NATO Secretary General's Special Representative for the
Caucasus and Central Asia James Appathurai at a news conference in
Yerevan, .

The statement said Sarkisian "recalled with fondness" his most recent
meeting with Stoltenberg held at the NATO headquarters in Brussels in
late February. Speaking after those talks, Stoltenberg praised NATO's
"partnership" with Armenia and spoke of "opportunities for us to
cooperate more closely on interoperability, defense reform and defense
education."

Despite its close military alliance with Russia, Armenia has forged
closer links with NATO -- and the United States in particular -- since
the early 2000s. It currently contributes around 130 troops to
NATO-led missions in Kosovo and Afghanistan and regularly participates
in multinational exercises organized by U.S. forces in Europe.

In 2015, Yerevan expressed readiness to participate in more such
missions abroad with specialized medical and demining
units. U.S. military instructors began training Armenian military
personnel for that purpose last year.

Appathurai cautioned that while the two sides will carry on with their
"steady cooperation" he does not expect "dramatic leaps forward" in
their relations.



Press Review



"Zhoghovurd" comments on Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian's calls
for the co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group to "rein in" Azerbaijan not
only with statements but also "concrete actions." The paper says an
Armenian Foreign Ministry statement on Nalbandian's weekend meeting
with the co-chairs did not specify what those actions should be. "We
wonder how he sees the realization of his appeal," it says. "At least,
there is no legal document giving the co-chairs the right to impose
sanctions on official Baku or Yerevan. The OSCE Minsk Group is not the
UN Security Council and its co-chairs are only mediators. So such
statements by Nalbandian may not be taken seriously by the
international community or the co-chairs."

"Hayots Ashkhar" suggests that "serious international pressure" on
Baku is now essential for preventing another sharp escalation of the
Karabakh conflict. It is only natural, the paper says, that Yerevan
now expects "tough and explicit warnings" from the U.S., Russian and
French mediators ahead of their visit to Baku. It says that renewed
peace talks in the absence of mechanisms for preventing ceasefire
violations in the conflict zone would only tempt the Azerbaijani
leadership to provoke the kind of hostilities that broke out in April
2016.

William Lahue, the head of NATO's regional Liaison Office in Tbilisi,
tells "Aravot" that Armenia's relations with Iran "do not matter at
all" to the Western alliance. "You have a cooperation framework, you
are a sovereign state, and you decide the circle of you relationships
with other countries and allies," he says. "If there is a decision to
impose an embargo on Iran, it will also be a decision by sovereign
states. And let me say this: states usually avoid embargoes and want
to have them lifted. But it's not NATO's businesses. It's up to member
states and allies."

"Haykakan Zhamanak" comments on what it sees as a suspicious increase
in food prices in Armenia that has been reported by the National
Statistical Service (NSS) for a second consecutive month. The NSS said
on Monday that they were up in May by more than 6 percent from the
same period in 2016. The paper says that it is not yet clear which
foodstuffs became more expensive in the past year. It claims that the
NSS is "hiding" more detailed information about consumer prices in the
country.

(Tigran Avetisian)


Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2017 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org

Vahe Enfiajyan: Torturer and murderer has a website claiming that killing Armenian is his job

Aravot, Armenia

Member of Parliament Vahe Enfiajyan had a speech at the “The role of the national parliaments in implementing ECHR standards” second regional seminar.

The full speech below:

 

Dear Colleagues,

Human rights protection and regional capacity building are one of today’s  urgent issues. Whatever is stated in the European Convention on Human Rights must be accepted as a law for each country and each of us. Human Rights are international moral norms yet seeking to become legal terms that must be protected anywhere, in any situation or circumstances.

The first section of the European Convention on Human rights clearly states that everyone has the right to liberty and security of person(Article 5 fifth) and no one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment(Article 3).

To my big conviction, this section must have a proper explanatory procedure for some of our colleagues to build a more civilized and trustworthy country in the region.  For instance, the ongoing human tortures can not be testimonies of a democracy. Even the wars and battles have their own civilization.

The humble thought that if the country joins a treatment or convention then it already adopts the policy stated in that paper is highly doubtful. The proof for it can be the well-known case of Azerbaijani senior Lieutenant Ramil Safarov who 16 times hit the sleeping Armenian officer Gurgen Margaryan with an ax.  With a deep sorrow, I assume that it happened in Hungary, during an international program called Partnership for Peace. No matter how was the legal solution the moral one can’t fit a human brain. Yesterday Mr. Boris Chilovich mentioned in his speech that Hungary is the capital of Human rights…Eight(8) years later he was freed and moreover, the President announced him as a national hero for killing an Armenian. The torturer and murderer and killer has a website claiming that killing an Armenian is his job and he does not regret it. We have so many cases from April’s four-day war in 2016 when the Azerbaijani soldiers tortured the Armenians, cut them into pieces, took pictures and spread through the internet.

To my high conviction, this kind of policy can be a very week proof of a civilized country which seeks to human rights protection and regional capacity building. I highly convince and ask each of us to be aware of the ongoing processes not only in parliamentary level, but also state and national policy levels. Any treatment and even any single step must get its objective assessment.International and multinational treatment must be stated concerning the human rights and fundamental freedoms. Only treating in this way we can build a secure environment for a protected citizen of the world. Thank you.

Hayots Ashkharh: Armenian parliament official calls for intn’l sanctions for truce breaches over Karabakh

Tert, Armenia

10:48 • 13.06.17

In an interview with the paper, a vice speaker of the Armenian National Assembly addressed Azerbaijan's recent attempts to escalate the situation around Nagorno-Karabakh, emphasizing the urgent need of enforcing international sanctions against the side violating the truce.

Пропустить рекламу: 5 сек
Перейти на сайт рекламодателя
Реклама 00
Пропустить
Наведите курсор,
чтобы включить звук

Eduard Sharmazanov said he is sure that the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs (who act as a peace mediator between Armenia and Azerbaijan) will inevitably issue their evaluations sometime in the nearest future.

“For many years, the co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group refrained from specifically addressed statements, a fact Armenia was all the time vocal about, but as you saw, the mediators did eventually issue such a statement, highlighting the side responsible for proactive raids. So if Azerbaijan holds on to its policy of offensive behavior, the OSCE, the Minsk Groups and the international organizations in general will, I think, establish clear-cut sanctions against that country. What the international practice requires is to avoid offering the meadow to pigs. Hence if a conflicting side blatantly ignores the norms in a negotiation process, continuing to disrespect the presidential commitments agreed in Vienna and St Petersburg, it should naturally incur sanctions,” he added.

International pressures unlikely to curb Azerbaijani aggression – Russian analyst

Tert, Armenia

11:31 • 13.06.17

International pressures alone are not enough to hold back Azerbaijan from provoking further aggression against Nagorno-Karabakh, a Russian political analyst has said, commenting on the recent developments in the zone of conflict.

Speaking to Tert.am, Alexander Skakov, a coordinator for the Caucasus Studies Center (adjunct to the Russian Academy of Sciences), also addressed the international mediators' scheduled trip to the region. “It is really good that the three [French, Russian and US] co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group are visiting the region, but we should not pin great hopes on the trip,” he said.

Пропустить рекламу: 5 сек
Перейти на сайт рекламодателя
Реклама 00
Пропустить
Наведите курсор,
чтобы включить звук

Meantime, the expert ruled out any possibility of progress in the peace talks in the visible future. “It will be possible only due to implementing the agreements reached in Vienna – after video surveillance devices are deployed along the Line of Contact and a permanent monitoring is conducted. Otherwise, we should not expect progress in terms of regional monitoring,” he added.  

Asked to comment on Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s statement that “the sides have agreed on the conflict settlement principles, but there still are sensitive and at the same time important points”, Skakov said he thinks that the Russian official meant the monitoring mechanisms “while dropping hints for enforcing pressure against the sides” (to make them abide by the arrangements reached).

“Understandably, Armenia and Azerbaijan are not ready for mutual concessions. Moreover, Azerbaijan is not ready to implement the deal agreed verbally, i.e. – expand the monitoring group responsible for deploying the video surveillance devices. What Azerbaijan is doing is trying to test the international community, Armenia and the Minsk Group by violating the ceasefire and demanding the extradition of Belarusian blogger Alexander Lapshin and, also recently, the blogger from Tbilisi,” he added.

“It is important for all the sides to exercise pressure – simultaneously, incessantly and periodically. Russia, Brussels and Washington should take a simultaneous action,” he said, agreeing that the Russian pressures often fall short of restraining Azerbaijan.

 

Large-scale war over Karabakh not in Turkey’s interests – ARF-D politician

Tert, Armenia

13:22 • 13.06.17

A large-scale war over Nagorno-Karbakh would not be in Turkey’s interests at the moment as a confrontation with Azerbaijan (which may also involve Armenia) might require intervention also by other states, including Russia, according to Giro Manoyan, the political affairs director of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation-Dashnaksutyun (ARF-D).

Пропустить рекламу: 5 сек
Перейти на сайт рекламодателя
Реклама 00
Пропустить
Наведите курсор,
чтобы включить звук

“Turkey may offer its assistance at certain points to keep the Azerbaijani leader in a good frame of mind so to speak, but I don’t think a large-scale war would be in Turkey’s interests,” he told a news conference on Tuesday.

The politician made the remark as he addressed the recent regional developments and several countries’ move to sever diplomatic ties with Qatar. Manoyan said he positively evaluates Armenia’s decision to meet the country half-way and deepen the relations. 

He also commented upon the situation in Syria. “The developments around Syria underlie the deepened tension among the Arab countries. The moment has arrived for the Arab states to eventually decide what they are going to do with respect to Syria,” he said, noting that superpowers’ involvement in the Syrian crisis signals the regional if not global (vs domestic) significance of the problems in the country.

“The end to the crisis in Syria is visible,” he said, ruling out the possibility of a higher tension over the country.

No war hazard looming over Turkey, Azerbaijan – Armenian diplomat

Tert, Armenia

16:23 • 13.06.17

Turkey and Azerbaijan are highly unlikely to face a war in the near future in the light of the current geopolitical developments, Ambassador Arman Navasardyan said today, commenting on the joint Turkish-Azerbaijani military drills in Nakicevan.

"Turkey will not provoke any escalation as long as it maintains very good military relations with Russia. Also, Turkey's relations with Azerbaijan are not virtually that bad now, so I don't see a big threat of war,” he told reporters.

 

The drills, running from 12 through 16 June, are the second round of joint military exercises bringing Turkish and Azerbaijani troops together. The first round was organized from 1 to 5 June in Baku.  

 

Navasardyan described the initiative as a Turkish-Azerbaijani attempt to incite tnension.

Пропустить рекламу: 5 сек
Перейти на сайт рекламодателя
Реклама 00
Пропустить
Наведите курсор,
чтобы включить звук

“These are the second large-scale military maneuvers,” he said citing Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavushoglu’s recent statement highlighting his country’s high-level military cooperation with Azerbaijan.

 

He noted that the Turkish official made reference to the Treaty of Kars Articles 4 and 5 whereof ban a Turkish military presence on the territory of Naikcevan,

 

Navasardyan stressed the need of strong efforts by Armenia to create its own military base in the region. “We need to be very active here to raise the issue of the treaties of Moscow and Kars. I think it is a very good moment to take advantage of in defense of our national interests and security,” he added.

 

Gurgen Yeghiazaryan, a former chief of the National Security Service also attending the news conference, warned of serious hazards to Armenia. He called attention particularly to the timing of the exercises.

 

“They are trying, in every possible way, to make the OSCE Minsk Group work. And that’s absolutely a success. I have repeatedly stated that our inaction caused the world to adopt seven resolutions against us, four in the UN and three in NATO. The world never knows our demand; they have no idea about it,” he added.

Azerbaijan’s official statements run counter to de-facto steps – Nalbandian

Tert, Armenia

14:03 • 13.06.17

Azerbaijani officials have a unique talent of focusing too much on repeated demands while taking actions running counter to them, FM Edward Nalbandian said today commenting on the Azerbaijani foreign minister's recent statement highlighting the unacceptability of the status quo over Nagorno-Karabakh.

At a news conference held jointly with his Estonian counterpart, Sven Mikser, Armenia’s top diplomat also blamed the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry for never abiding by the committment to coordinate joint press releases.

Пропустить рекламу: 0 сек
Перейти на сайт рекламодателя
Реклама 15
Пропустить
Наведите курсор,
чтобы включить звук

Citing the UN Security Council resolitions, repeatedly cited by Azerbaijan, Nalbandian also highlighted Azerbaijan's failure to take steps towards their implementation.

“There are four resolutions by the UN Security Council, because after each resolution’s passage, Azerbaijan rejected the previous one. Besides, they were not about the negotiation process but were rather aimed at ending military operations and establishing ceasefire,” he added.

http://www.tert.am/en/news/2017/06/13/nalbandian/2400762

Situation around Nagorno-Karabakh gives ground to concern – NATO official

Tert, Armenia

17:32 • 12.06.17

All the NATO allies are concerned over the increasing armament in the South Caucasus, the NATO Secretary General’s Special Representative for the Caucasus and Central Asia said today in Yerevan.


Speaking at a news confernce, James Appathurai also expressed concern over the simultaneously increasing political tension and hostilities in the region.

Пропустить рекламу: 5 сек
Перейти на сайт рекламодателя
Реклама 00
Пропустить
Наведите курсор,
чтобы включить звук

Noting that two of the NATO allies are represented in the OSCE Minsk Group (which seeks a peaceful settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict), the NATO official further highlighted the alliance’s policy of relaxing tension and hostile attitudes, and finding peaceful solutions.

 

He said that the NATO fully supports the Minsk Group efforts without any direct intervention in its mediatory role (as it isn’t directly represented in the mission).

http://www.tert.am/en/news/2017/06/12/Apaturai/2399879

Armenia is attractive for NATO

A1 Plus, Armenia

“Armenia will sooner or later join NATO,” says Davit Shahnazaryan, Senior Analyst at Regional Studies Center. He adds that the regional processes lead to membership, “In current geopolitical instable situation, the question of withdrawing from the CSTO or the Eurasian Union is out of question. But NATO is expanding, moreover NATO isn’t expanding itself, but the neighboring countries of NATO lead a policy so that NATO expands.”

The political expert notes that Turkey is already a member of NATO, and Georgia is directly moving towards NATO. Armenia simply has no alternative, “I don’t think that the CIS has chances to expand, vice versa, it seems that we have no partners in the CIS, except legally established partner- Russia. CIS is a club of countries having relations with Russia.”

Mr Shahnazryan cannot predict when Armenia will join NATO. Boris Navasardyan, Head of Yerevan Press Club, has difficulty even in predicting whether Armenia’s membership is possible or not, “I am not Vanga, anyway.”

The current developments in the region, according to Mr Navasardyan, make the predictions on Armenia’s possible membership even more difficult. But in all cases Armenia is attractive for NATO at least as a threat, “For NATO any region, which has a border or is close to NATO member states, is a potential threat or a country, nation, territory having a solution to potential security issue, and Armenia is not an exception, taking into account that there is fire very close to us and at any moment Armenia’s role may be important.”

Armenia can use NATO as a platform for discussing concerning issues, says William Lahue, NATO representative in the South Caucasus, “Every time, when Armenia goes to NATO, it speaks of Karabakh, Azerbaijan and Turkey and tries to convince member states of the alliance of Armenia’s viewpoints. Consequently it is an important platform for Armenia.”

By the way, touching upon the participation of servicemen from NATO member state Turkey in April War in support of Azerbaijan, representative of NATO Magnus Eyjolfsson noted that everything which NATO 29 member states do within the frames of independent politics, isn’t business of NATO.

President of France got acquainted with the situation on Artsakh

A1 Plus, Armenia

The issue of closure of OSCE Yerevan Office is being discussed in Vienna.

OSCE Minsk Group French Co-Chair Stephane Visconti said in an interview with “Artsakhpress”.

The newly-elected President of France Emmanuel Macron got acquainted with the situation.

“It is a pleasure for me to be in Artsakh and get acquainted with the situation. We attach great importance to issues relating to security and peaceful settlement process. France, US and Russia make all efforts to record progress on this issue”, the French Co-Chair said.