Asbarez: Jivan Avetisyan Tells the ‘Truth’ About Artsakh through Film

Jivan Avetisyan

Editor’s Note: Artsakh-based filmmaker Jivan Avetisyan’s latest feature, “Gate to Heaven” had its world premiere on Thursday in Yerevan. On this occasion we are publishing the interview, below, published on H-Pem, Hamazkayin’s recently-unveiled online portal to Armenian culture.

BY RUPEN JANBAZIAN
From H-Pem.com

If one thing stuck with me during my introduction to director Jivan Avetisyan about a decade ago, it was that in spite of his humble nature, he was very proud of where he was from. Fast forward several years and it seems little has changed.

“I am from Artsakh. You know, my roots run deep in Artsakh,” he tells me, without even giving me the chance to utter my first question. As we converse in his Downtown Yerevan office over strong Armenian coffee, and in between a barrage of phone calls he has to ignore, years on, his focus – and his creative output – continues to be zeroed in on one thing: his beloved, still-unrecognized nation…

“If we were to take a moment to count, there are seven or more generations of my family buried in our ancestral village [in Artsakh]. Say what you want… That means something,” he says.

And although he considers himself an Artsakhtsi through and through, it might surprise most that Jivan was actually born in Gyumri – Armenia’s second-largest city – in 1981, following his family’s relocation there. After the devastating earthquake that rattled Gyumri and nearby towns and villages, the Avetisyan clan moved back to their ancestral village, where Jivan spent most of his youth.

Avetisyan credits his school—Stepanakert’s #9—for having a “profound” impact on him. The school, including all of its classrooms, was renovated by the Hayastan All Armenia Fund in 2018. (Photo: Hayastan All Armenia Fund)

“My school – Stepanakert’s number nine – had a profound impact on my life. It was different from the other schools,” Jivan says of his cherished elementary school. “The quality of education was great, but that wasn’t all that important to us. Its impact was mostly because it was situated along a forest and the [then mostly Azerbaijani-inhabited] village of Krkzhan. It was a time of war – and whether you like it or not, war impacts your life, your journey,” he explains.

Life during the devastating war that claimed the lives of tens of thousands and displaced hundreds of thousands more was not easy for the Avetisyan family and although he doesn’t delve into details, his blank stare speaks volumes. “I won’t say much about that time, but I will say that it shaped me,” he says.

Just four years after the ceasefire was signed between Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Republic of Artsakh, Jivan was conscripted into the military for his mandatory service and between 1999 and 2001, he was able to serve his dear Artsakh as a member of the unrecognized state’s army. “[The Army] wasn’t easy, but knowing you are doing it for a greater good, for something that’s bigger than you, makes me look back at those days with a smile on my face,” he explains.

Serj Tankian (left), photographed here with Avetisyan, wrote the musical score for “The Last Inhabitant.” (Photo: Yerkir.am)

Following his service, Avetisyan made the important decision to take his passion for cinema to the next level and enrolled in the Yerevan State Institute of Theatre and Cinematography. The move, he says, was “terrifying but also exhilarating and liberating.” Alone for the first time and away from his comfort zone, he was free not to only find himself, but also to chase his passion. While studying, Jivan took a job at the newly founded Television station Yerkir Media as a security guard – he figured he wanted to be “close to the cinematic action,” even if it meant spending hours at his mundane, uninteresting job as the station’s watchman.

His plan eventually paid off as Yerkir offered him his first directorial gig – a small segment for TV, which eventually led to more jobs, and, ultimately, his promotion to chief director at the station. “They seemed to like my work – one gig led to another, until I eventually came to be in charge,” Avetisyan explains, “but it didn’t come easy. I put in my time. Who would have thought – the security guard – right?”

After 12 years at Yerkir Media, Jivan decided to establish his own production company, the Fish Eye Art Cultural Foundation, along with his friend and longtime collaborator Masis Baghdasarian. The company has, just recently, wrapped up with its third feature-length film, “Gate to Heaven.”

Jivan’s modesty does not skip a beat as he details his journey to this point. When probed about how he has been able to be so productive and release three films in the last five years (check out the trailers to all three below), the prolific director deflects the praise and instead thanks his supporting cast. “Nothing would be possible without the hard work and dedication of my team,” he says, adding that the word “team” for him goes way beyond his colleagues and production staff. “My family – my wife and three kids – my like-minded friends, my comrades, and the hundreds of folks who have contributed to my film… All of this would be impossible without them.”

Only in passing does Avetisyan admit that he has put in no less than 15 hours of work per day for the last 20 years. “You can have the best team in the world, but it would mean nothing without the hard work… That goes without saying,” he explains, looking to the floor as if he feels shame in admitting his toil.

For Jivan, the reason to establish his own company and direct films is simple: to create pieces of art, “which represent my homeland; to show the world the real Artsakh.” His full-length feature debut was “Tevanik” in 2014, a joint Armenian-Lithuanian feature, which was made in cooperation with National Cinema Center of Armenia and Lithuanian Artbox Production House. “’Tevanik’ – like all my films – is the story of Artsakh; about the war, about loss,” the director explains. Following the day in the lives of three children in an Artsakh village during the war, Jivan took famed Armenian writer and director Arnold Aghababov’s short script about the war, into a beautifully shot film about love and sacrifice.

Following its Yerevan premiere, ”Tevanik” was screened at the 67th Cannes International Film Festival, where it caught the attention of critics. “The reception was overwhelmingly positive and it seemed as though both film lovers and critics enjoyed the film, which isn’t always the case,” explains Jivan. He wasn’t off. Besides having the honor of being screened in more than 20 countries (and being translated into nine languages along the way), “Tevanik” also amassed an impressive number of awards from competitions across the globe, including Best Screenplay at the Arpa International Film Festival of Los Angeles; Best Feature Prize in the Armenian Panorama Competition at the Golden Apricot Film Festival; the Audience Choice Award at the Silk Road International Film Festival in Xi’an, China; and Most Original Work in the International Feature Films Competition of the Overlook Film Festival in Rome.

A scene from “Tevanik” (2014) (Photo: Fish Eye Arts)

Jivan followed “Tevanik” with another film about the Artsakh War, “The Last Inhabitant,” which he calls an “international endeavor.” Though filming and production took place in the tiny village of Khachmach, Arstakh (population, approximately 200), the film came to life as a result of a partnership that spanned across five countries. Along with Avetisyan’s Art Cultural Foundation and the National Cinema Center of Armenia, and Artbox Production House (of Lithuania, which had co-produced “Tevanik), Jivan’s second feature was also co-produced by Apricot Stone of Sweden, Alpha Dogs, Inc. and the Mosaics Art and Cultural Foundation of the U.S., and the Lebanese University Institute of Fine Arts . “The cast was as international as the people behind the scenes,” Jivan explains, “actors from Lithuania, Greece, Russia, and the States were featured in the film.”

He even managed to get some Armenian star power in the film. Serj Tankian of System of a Down wrote the musical score for the film, which recorded with the participation of the Armenian Philharmonic Orchestra. “Serj has always been supportive of my work and his participation was very special,” Jivan explains.

“The Last Inhabitant,” which focuses on and tells the story of one man, is, in fact, a very human story, according to Avetisyan. “[The film] is about Abgar, the only Armenian left in the village of Gyurjevan following the deportations of Armenians and his search for his daughter. But really, it’s a story about survival and how all of us, regardless of race, culture, and religion, need one another in order to survive,” he explains.

Avetisyan on the set of “Gate to Heaven” (Photo courtesy of Fish Eye Arts)

Following its initial release in late 2016, “The Last Inhabitant,” like its predecessor, did the festival circuit and took home an impressive assortment of awards, including Best Feature and Best Actor at the Scandinavian International Film Festival. The film even caught the attention of HBO execs, and the film’s Eastern European distribution rights were picked up by the storied company in late 2017. Through the deal, the film was screened throughout Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Moldova, and Macedonia.

When speaking about his latest project, “Gate to Heaven,” which set to have its world premiere in Yerevan on October 17, Avetisyan explains that the film is just another installment in an ongoing mission. “I don’t want to philosophize or politicize the matter, but telling the world of Artsakh is like a duty for me – a duty as an Armenian, as well as a personal obligation,” he details. For Avetisyan, the Armenian victory in Artsakh in the early ‘90s was more than re-claiming lost lands, but a way for all Armenians to shed what he calls their “victim complex” following the Armenian Genocide. “A century ago, we established statehood, and with the victory [in Artsakh] we cemented statehood,” Jivan says.

On a personal level, Jivan’s obligation is much simpler. “Like I explained when we first sat down today, like I always do” he says, admitting his passion, “seven generations of family tombs – I am their legacy. Both World Wars, self-defense at Baku, the Liberation War – my family has participated in every war in the region in the last century. I know why I am here.”

Avetsiyan and his crew shooting “Gate to Heaven,” a flim, he says, is a story about the truth. (Photo courtesy of Fish Eye Arts)

The director’s latest project focuses on Artsakh’s latest conflict, one that Jivan was very much a part of: the April 2016 War – often referred to as the “Four Day War.” In it, a European journalist named Robert Stenvall returns to Artsakh in 2016 to cover the war and meets Sophia, a young opera singer and the daughter of the missing photojournalist whom he left behind in captivity during the fall of Talish (1992). The connection between the liberation war of the early 1990s and the 2016 war that have been called the worst clashes there since the ceasefire was signed in 1994 are palpable in the film’s synopsis. “I wanted to show the world that the war is ongoing; that there is no peace, only a shaky armistice,” Jivan explains.

Although he came up with the film’s storyline and even took part in the writing process, Avetisyan does not consider himself a writer by any means. “[The story] may have been born in my head, but I’m just a director,” he explains, crediting Artavazd Yeghiazaryan and Mko Malkhasyan’s work on developing the plot and making it ready for the big screen. “What the public will see is the product of the hard work – the blood, sweat, and tears – of all three of us,” he goes on.

Avetisyan explains that his latest project would not have even gotten off the ground if it were not for the help of his friends, family, and loved ones, but also the financial and emotional support of hundreds of complete strangers. In March 2018, Jivan launched a crowd funding campaign to help make his dream a reality and the response, according to the director, was overwhelming. “More than $10,000 was collected in the first three days since the launch,” he explained. “Although the film’s budget is much higher than the crowd funding target, it was important for me to get the community – especially the worldwide Armenian Diaspora – directly involved with the project. This is our [Armenians’] story and all those who contributed are part of telling it to the world, are part of its success,” Avetisyan says.

“A good story with a bad cast is just as useless as a bad story with great actors,” Avetisyan explains (Photo: Nairian; courtesy of Fish Eye Arts)

Jivan is also grateful to the countless organizations, foundations, and companies – both Armenian and non-Armenian – which made financial contributions to the film. One organization Jivan mentions is Hamazkayin Armenian Educational and Cultural Society, which has supported all of his films in some capacity. “Organizations like Hamazkayin prove that when like-minded people come together and work for a common goal, their labors will bear fruit,” he explains.

Jivan does not like forgetting his talented ensemble and also credits his diverse cast for the success of his latest film. “Gate the Heaven” stars German actors Richard Sammel (best known for his role as Thomas Eichhorst on the FX television series “The Strain”) and Nina Kronjäger; Lithuanian actor Leonardas Pobedonoscevas (“Defiance”); Russian actor Tatiana Spivakova; Swiss actor Benedict Freitag; Armenian-American actor Naira Zakaryan; as well as a host of big names from Armenia, including Sos Janibekyan and Armen Sargsyan.

For Avetisyan, it was important to have a strong cast, because the actors are an integral piece of the puzzle, which makes a good film. “A good story with a bad cast is just as useless as a bad story with great actors,” he explains.

“The fact that it’s so multi-ethnic – that they are from all over – is just further proof that this isn’t an ‘Armenian story’ and that the ongoing conflict does not only pertain to Armenians and Azerbaijanis,” he says. “The story is about the truth and truth is universal.”

After wrapping up shooting and post-production, Jivan is more than happy with the result. And even though the film’s Armenian release is set for next week, and its Los Angeles premiere is scheduled for March of next year, he is hopeful for a wide release spanning continents in the coming months. “I want the world to see our story, our truth. It wasn’t easy getting here, but I must say, I am proud,” he says, putting his trademark humility aside for a moment. “Telling the truth, especially about my home, my land, warrants a sense of pride, I guess.”

“Gate to Heaven” will premiere in Yerevan on October 17. The film will be released in cinemas across Armenia on October 25.

Asbarez: ARF Bureau Representatives Meet with U.S. Ambassador to Armenia

Armenian Revolutionary Federation

As part of its series of meeting with members of the diplomatic corps stationed in Armenia, a delegation of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation Bureau, headed by its chairman, Hagop Der Khachadourian, met with U.S. Ambassador to Armenia Lynne Tracy on Wednesday.

The ARF press office reported that the meeting participants discussed the current state of relations between Armenia and the United States and explored issues related to strengthening those ties and the future scope of activities.

Regional and Armenia’s domestic political developments were also discussed, with the interlocutors emphasizing the importance of convening such meetings on a regular basis.

As part of its efforts to reach out to accredited ambassadors in Armenia, the ARF Bureau has already met with the ambassadors of Russia, Iran and France

Asbarez: ‘NerUzh’ Diaspora Startup Program Application Deadline Approaching

“NerUzh” is initiated and organized by the Ministry of Diaspora of the Republic of Armenia

There is only one week left before the deadline for applying for the “NerUzh” Diaspora Startup Program. The program is organized by the Office of the High Commissioner for Diaspora Affairs and the Ministry of High-Tech Industry of the Republic of Armenia. All Diaspora Armenians who have an innovative startup idea and want to return to Armenia to establish their startup in their homeland can apply online. Applications must be submitted by October 21.

Applicants who have passed the selection stage will have the opportunity to attend a four-day launch event in UWC Dilijan from December 16 to 20. Those in attendance will learn about Armenia’s startup ecosystem and the business opportunities available, collaborate with local partners, and further develop their ideas. By the end, the winning teams will receive $15,000 to $30,000 grants, as well as entrepreneurial support to establish their startups in Armenia.

This year’s target areas are financial, social, governance, educational, mobile, internet, agricultural technologies, healthcare, robotics, engineering, and others.

Project partners include FAST and IDeA Foundations, UWC Dilijan College, and more.

Toxic Waste Leaks From Armenian Copper Mine in Kapan

Waste water flows in the Voghji river in Kapan

YEREVAN (Azatutyun.am)—A senior government official accused Armenia’s largest mining company on Thursday of trying to cover up a toxic waste spill that contaminated a river flowing through the southeastern town of Kapan.

The accident was reported near a “tailings” dump of the Zangezur Copper-Molybdenum Combine (ZCMC) early in the morning. Officials said that a leaky pipe connecting the dump with ZCMC’s ore-processing facilities sent a stream of industrial waste flowing into the already polluted Voghji river.

According to Levon Petrosyan, the head of the regional branch of the state Inspectorate Body on Environment Protection and Natural Resources, the pipe was swiftly replaced by ZCMC workers sent to the site. “The river is still brown,” Petrosyan told RFE/RL’s Armenian service in the afternoon.

He said his agency took water and soil samples from the contaminated area and sent them to Yerevan for detailed examination.

ZCMC said that the leak lasted for up to 40 minutes. Minister for Emergency Situations Felix Tsolakyan blasted the company during a cabinet meeting in Yerevan which discussed the accident.

“They kept things secret and didn’t [immediately] say that such an accident happened,” claimed Tsolakyan. “The [ZCMC] bosses didn’t say that and carried out quick repairs.”

“I don’t know what he meant by ‘kept secret,’” Petrosyan said when asked to comment on Tsolakyan’s claims. “All I can say is that when our inspectors heard the alert and went there the pipe was already replaced.”

Environment Protection Minister Erik Grigoryan told reporters that authorities are now ascertaining the damage inflicted on the environment. He complained that Armenian environmental legislation sets “ridiculously” small fines for mining firms violating it and must be toughened significantly.

Faulty and old tailings dumps are thought to be a key source of environmental damage caused by the Armenian mining industry which generates more than 40 percent of the country’s exports.

ZCMC, which is nominally controlled by the German metals group Cronimet, is the sector’s largest enterprise employing more than 4,000 people. It is also Armenia’s number one corporate taxpayer.

Mediators Want Final Resolution to Karabakh Conflict, Moscow Says

Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova

Russia has always urged the parties to the Karabakh conflict to approach matters in a constructive manner, Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova said, commenting on Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s statement that “Karabakh is recognized by the entire world as an integral part of Azerbaijan.”

Zakharova emphasized that she isn’t Aliyev’s spokesperson and she has no idea what he meant. “We can give our assessment, but not comment,” she said.

She said that they are seeing many political statements in different emotional levels with different levels of connection to historic context and modern context. “We are moving forward from the negotiations agenda which we have on the table. Russia is working with the documents agreed between the parties and the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs,” Zakharova said.

According to Zakharova, the objective of Russia and the other mediators is to achieve a final resolution of the conflict and contribute to a maximal acceleration of the process.

“From our side we have always made calls for constructive approach to the parties. And I can’t and wouldn’t want to suspect that this itself is their goal because they are all responsible politicians and are expressing their peoples’ expectations. During the entire period of this conflict the populations of the countries involved have always delegated the conflict resolution issue to their leadership. For this reason we are dealing with our role, as we think maximally and constructively, and we are calling on everybody to undertake constructive steps in this direction,” Zakharova said.

Mnatsakanyan, Mammadyarov Confirm Another Meeting, Say Co-Chairs

OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs discuss Karabakh conflict with Armenia’s Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan

The Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers have confirmed their intention to meet again under OSCE Co-Chair auspices before the end of the year, the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs Chairs Igor Popov of the Russian Federation, Stéphane Visconti of France, and Andrew Schofer of the United States of America said in a press statement.

“The Co-Chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group (Igor Popov of the Russian Federation, Stéphane Visconti of France, and Andrew Schofer of the United States of America), together with the Personal Representative of the OSCE Chairperson-in-Office (PRCIO) Andrzej Kasprzyk, visited the region from 14 to 17 October.

The Co-Chairs met with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan in Yerevan on 15 October and with President Ilham Aliyev in Baku on 17 October, and held consultations with the respective Foreign Ministers and Defence Ministers in both capitals.

During their visit, the Co-Chairs also met with the de facto authorities in Nagorno-Karabakh. In Baku, the Co-Chairs met with the Chairman of the Azerbaijani Community of Nagorno-Karabakh. While in Nagorno-Karabakh, the mediators were briefed on humanitarian issues by the local representative of the International Committee of the Red Cross. The two leaders briefed the Co-Chairs on their recent conversation during the CIS summit in Ashgabat and presented their ideas on how to advance the settlement process. The Co-Chairs welcomed the prospect of implementing specific humanitarian and security measures to prepare the populations for peace and reduce tensions. The Co-Chairs once again stressed the critical importance of monitoring missions led by the PRCIO, in accordance with his mandate and longstanding practice. The Co-Chairs called on the sides to continue to support fully the activities of the PRCIO and his team and to ensure that any obstacles potentially interfering with monitoring missions are removed immediately. The Foreign Ministers confirmed their intention to meet again under Co-Chair auspices before the end of the year. The Co-Chairs will travel soon to Vienna to brief the OSCE Permanent Council and the members of the Minsk Group,” concluded the press statement.

168: PM Pashinyan holds meeting with mothers of fallen soldiers

Category
Society

Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan today held a meeting with the mothers of fallen soldiers.

At the meeting Pashinyan said he is ready to discuss all issues.

“During our previous meeting I stated that the list of the beneficiaries of Military Insurance Fund is expanding very quickly. According to the decision adopted, the Fund has started making payments to the families of soldiers fallen during the incidents that have taken place starting from January 1, 1998 and after that, as well as to the disabled soldiers of the 1st or 2nd group. We have gone 19 years back within one and a half year, we have solved the problem of beneficiaries of 19 years, our goal is to reach the beginning, but this requires some time and work which we will carry out”, the PM said.

The mothers of fallen soldiers raised some issues of their concern, in particular the fact that they are not included in the beneficiaries’ list. They said they expect the PM’s attention on the matter.

In response, Pashinyan said all issues are under their spotlight, the government cannot solve all the problems immediately, therefore they are moving forward with the stage by stage logic.

“We will do that and will go back to the beginning, but in this case as well we cannot state that all problems are solved. There are categories according to which soldiers fallen during the military service still are not considered as the Fund’s beneficiaries. Now our focus is on the families of soldiers, who were killed during the service but not during the military operations, to become beneficiaries. In other words, the families of those soldiers who were killed by the adversary. By the next stage we will come to the tragic incidents and so on”, the PM said.

Pashinyan assured that the government will in no way show an improper attitude to the families of fallen soldiers, or any citizen in general.

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 10/17/2019

                                        Thursday, 

Key Witness In Ex-Police Chief’s Death Probe Leaves Armenia

        • Ruzanna Stepanian

Armenia -- National police chief Hayk Harutiunian at an official ceremony in 
Yerevan, April 16, 2003.

The key witness in an ongoing investigation into the recent mysterious death of 
a former chief of the Armenian police has left the country, law-enforcement 
authorities said on Thursday.

General Hayk Harutiunian, who headed the national police service from 
1999-2008, was found shot to death in his country house on September 24. After 
questioning an unnamed person who “was with him at the scene of the incident” 
Armenia’s Investigative Committee suggested that Harutiunian most probably 
committed suicide.

A spokeswoman for the committee told RFE/RL’s Armenian service that the 
“eyewitness” assured investigators that they “will return to the country in 
just a few days’ time.” She insisted that the witness’s absence from the 
country will not have a negative impact on the investigation.

“All investigative actions requiring the presence of the witness have been 
taken and the investigating body has acquired all the evidence relevant to the 
criminal case,” said the official. Investigators are now awaiting final results 
of forensic tests conducted as part of the probe, she added.

Two Armenian news websites claimed late last month that moments before his 
death Harutiunian complained to another person that he is being pressured by 
the authorities to give false incriminating testimony against former President 
Robert Kocharian and a retired senior police officer indicted in connection 
with the 2008 post-election violence in Yerevan. The Investigative Committee 
was quick to dismiss those reports.

Two days after Harutiunian’s death, another law-enforcement body, the Special 
Investigative Service, charged Alik Sargsian, the man who succeeded Harutiunian 
as police chief in April 2008, with covering up what the SIS now describes as 
security forces’ illegal crackdown on opposition protesters in February-March 
2008. Sargsian flatly denied the accusations.

The SIS had repeatedly interrogated Harutiunian as a witness in the case. It 
claimed on September 26 that he too had signed “official documents containing 
false information and records” about the 2008 crackdown.

Former President Kocharian is currently under arrest, standing trial, along 
with three other former officials, on coup charges. He rejects them as 
politically motivated.



Authorities Deal With Toxic Leak From Armenian Copper Mine

        • Susan Badalian

Armenia -- The polluted Voghji river in Syunik province is seen after a mining 
accident , .

A senior government official accused Armenia’s largest mining company on 
Thursday of trying to hush up a toxic waste spill that contaminated a river 
flowing through the southeastern town of Kapan.

The accident was reported near a “tailings” dump of the Zangezur 
Copper-Molybdenum Combine (ZCMC) early in the morning. Officials said that a 
leaky pipe connecting the dump with ZCMC’s ore-processing facilities sent a 
stream of industrial waste flowing into the already polluted Voghji river.

According to Levon Petrosian, the head of the regional branch of the state 
Inspectorate Body on Environment Protection and Natural Resources, the pipe was 
swiftly replaced by ZCMC workers sent to the site. “The river is still brown,” 
Petrosian told RFE/RL’s Armenian service in the afternoon.

He said his agency took water and soil samples from the contaminated area and 
sent them to Yerevan for detailed examination.

ZCMC said that the leak lasted for up to 40 minutes. Minister for Emergency 
Situations Felix Tsolakian blasted the company during a cabinet meeting in 
Yerevan which discussed the accident.

“They kept things secret and didn’t [immediately] say that such an accident 
happened,” claimed Tsolakian. “The [ZCMC] bosses didn’t say that and carried 
out quick repairs.”

“I don’t know what he meant by ‘kept secret,’” Petrosian said when asked to 
comment on Tsolakian’s claims. “All I can say is that when our inspectors heard 
the alert and went there the pipe was already replaced.”

Environment Protection Minister Erik Grigorian told reporters that authorities 
are now ascertaining the damage inflicted on the environment. He complained 
that Armenian environmental legislation sets “ridiculously” small fines for 
mining firms violating it and must be toughened significantly.

Faulty and old tailings dumps are thought to be a key source of environmental 
damage caused by the Armenian mining industry which generates more than 40 
percent of the country’s exports.

ZCMC, which is nominally controlled by the German metals group Cronimet, is the 
sector’s largest enterprise employing more than 4,000 people. It is also 
Armenia’s number one corporate taxpayer.



Armenian Constitutional Court Chief Under Investigation

        • Astghik Bedevian

Armenia -- Constitutional Court Chairman Hrayr Tovmasian reads out a court 
verdict on an appeal filed by former President Robert Kocharian, September 4, 
2019.

Law-enforcement officials raided the offices of Armenia’s Constitutional Court 
and former ruling Republican Party (HHK) on Thursday after launching criminal 
proceedings against the court’s embattled chairman, Hrayr Tovmasian.

Other investigators visited and questioned his elderly father.

The developments came two days after most members of the Constitutional Court 
refused to oust Tovmasian. The Armenian parliament called for his dismissal in 
an October 4 appeal drafted by its majority loyal to Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian.

A non-partisan member of the parliament, Arman Babajanian, went further, 
demanding that law-enforcement authorities prosecute Tovmasian. Babajanian 
charged that the latter colluded with other key members of Armenia’s former 
HHK-dominated leadership to illegally become head of the Constitutional Court 
in March 2018.

The Special Investigative Service (SIS) announced on Thursday morning that it 
has decided to open a criminal case in connection with Babajanian’s written 
demand. It said it has launched an investigation into a possible “usurpation of 
state authority by a group of individuals.”

An SIS official visited the HHK headquarters in Yerevan in the following hours. 
According to the party’s deputy chairman, Armen Ashotian, he confiscated 
documents relating to the termination of Tovmasian’s membership in the HHK in 
early 2018.

The SIS also carried out what it called “investigative actions” inside the 
Constitutional Court building in the Armenian capital. The court secretariat 
refused to comment on the probe, saying that Tovmasian is on vacation at the 
moment.

Under Armenian law, Tovmasian cannot be prosecuted without the consent of at 
least five of the nine members of the country’s highest court. Two of those 
judges, Alvina Gyulumian and Arevik Petrosian, declined to comment on the 
unprecedented proceedings when contacted by RFE/RL’s Armenians service.


Armenia -- Riot police separate rival protesters outside the Constitutional 
Court building in Yerevan, September 3, 2019.
HHK representatives denounced the case as politically motivated. “Pashinian’s 
regime is looking for internal enemies in the country,” said the former ruling 
party’s spokesman, Eduard Sharmazanov.

Ruben Melikian, Nagorno-Karabakh’s former human rights ombudsman highly 
critical of Pashinian’s government, likewise described Tovmasian as a victim of 
political persecution.

Melikian also claimed that another law-enforcement agency, the National 
Security Service (NSS), has summoned Tovmasian’s father Vartan and two 
daughters for questioning. “Guys, do you realize what red line you are 
erasing?” he wrote on Facebook, referring to the authorities.

Later in the day NSS officers questioned Vartan Tovmasian in his home in a 
village south of Yerevan. Tovmasian Sr. told reporters afterwards that they 
only asked him questions about the roof of his state-owned one-story house.

“They wondered when we built the roof, how much we spent on it, where we got 
the money from and so on,” he said. “They did not ask other questions or search 
the house. They just said they want to check the roof.”

The 75-year-old added that he is ready to visit the NSS headquarters and answer 
more questions there on Friday. He did not confirm that the powerful security 
service also wants to interrogate Hrayr Tovmasian’s daughters.

The NSS said that it will comment on the matter later on. It did not issue any 
statements as of Thursday evening.

Tovmasian claimed on October 2 that the authorities are seeking to force him 
out in order to gain control over the Constitutional Court and be able to make 
unconstitutional decisions. He said he will not bow to the pressure despite 
recent arrests of two individuals linked to him.

In a September 4 ruling read out by Tovmasian, the Constitutional Court 
declared unconstitutional a legal provision used by SIS investigators against 
Armenia’s jailed former President Robert Kocharian. Pashinian called the ruling 
“illegal.” The prime minister charged earlier Tovmasian had cut political deals 
with HHK leader and former President Serzh Sarkisian to “privatize” the court.

Meanwhile, Vahe Grigorian, the court’s newest member installed by the current 
parliament in June, insisted that he sees no political motives behind the 
law-enforcement authorities’ latest moves against Tovmasian.

Grigorian also continued to challenge the legitimacy of Tovmasian and six other 
court justices appointed before the “Velvet Revolution” of April-May 2018. 
“This crisis in the Constitutional Court is much deeper than Hrayr Tovmasian 
and his past activities or current behavior,” he said.



Press Review


“Haykakan Zhamanak” says that Armenia’s former rulers are very worried about 
the current authorities’ plans to enact a law allowing them to confiscate 
“illegally acquired assets.” The law would primarily and retroactively apply to 
practices of the past decade. “This is apparently the reason why critics regard 
the law as an additional weapon in the authorities’ hands for unleashing 
repressions against ‘undesirable’ individuals,” writes the pro-government 
paper. “The law could indeed prove controversial. But one must acknowledge that 
not having such a law, allowing a few dozen families to enjoy billions [of 
dollars] from the state and the people would have much more severe consequences 
for Armenia.”

“Zhamanak” says that the latest visit to the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zone by 
the U.S., Russian and French co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group began right 
after a summit of Turkic states held in Baku. The paper says that Presidents 
Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan and Recep Tayyip Erdogan used the summit to 
reiterate their “aggressive and bellicose” statements on Karabakh. It says 
Aliyev also effectively laid claim to Armenia’s Syunik province, potentially 
setting the stage for a “regional war.” The likelihood of such a war depends on 
how the United States, Russia and France will respond to Aliyev’s statement, it 
says.

“Zhoghovurd” notes that Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian met with Karabakh 
President Bako Sahakian just before receiving the Minsk Group co-chairs in 
Yerevan this week. An official press release on the meeting said Pashinian and 
Sahakian discussed ways of further strengthening links between Armenia and 
Karabakh. The paper notes that in the meantime Aliyev and Erdogan discussed 
Azerbaijani-Turkish military cooperation at a meeting in Baku.

(Lilit Harutiunian)


Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2019 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org



DTLA Film Festival Features Its First Armenian Film, Supported by the USC Institute of Armenian Studies

For Immediate Release
 
 

 
 
USC INSTITUTE OF ARMENIAN STUDIES
University of Southern California
Los Angeles, California, USA
Contact: Syuzanna Petrosyan, Associate Director
[email protected] | 213.821.3943
 
 
DTLA Film Festival Features Its First Armenian Film, Supported by the USC 
Institute of Armenian Studies

The 11th annual DTLA Film Festival, which is set to run from October 23 to 27 
at Regal L.A. LIVE, will be featuring its first Armenian film, with the support 
of the USC Institute of Armenian Studies.

This year’s festival includes foreign films from around the globe, all making 
their Los Angeles premieres, including the narrative feature “Yeva” by Armenian 
Iranian director Anahid Abad. “Yeva” is the first film of Armenian content and 
language to ever be included in the festival, and it's the first film being 
presented that’s set in Armenia and has an Armenian director.

“It’s so important to be able to understand that real life exists in conflict 
zones, and this film does just that,” said Salpi Ghazarian, director of the USC 
Institute of Armenian Studies. “That’s why we’re so pleased that the Armenian 
participation in the DTLA Film Festival is about people and lives -- especially 
women’s lives. Needless to say the message is universal.”

The film will screen at the festival on October 26 at 6:15pm at Regal L.A LIVE. 
The screening will be followed by an audience Q&A with director Anahit Abad. 
Tickets can be purchased at 
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__www.dtlaff.com_&d=DwIGaQ&c=clK7kQUTWtAVEOVIgvi0NU5BOUHhpN0H8p7CSfnc_gI&r=LVw5zH6C4LHpVQcGEdVcrQ&m=pVbpnF2zovNV7TGWzcb2Nx3zUitePv9NZCrAeiJykzY&s=BaISReNHeuq2AeliZFGIw1EC3EbUDiVjyva-CpZhixw&e=
 . Yeva will also be screening at the Laemmle theatre in Glendale on November 
1. 

The film is an intimate drama, in which a woman suspected of murder flees from 
Yerevan to an Armenian village in Nagorno-Karaakh with her young daughter. The 
heroine, Yeva, returns to a place she briefly worked as a doctor during the 
Nagorno-Karabakh War between Armenia and Azerbaijan, hoping she won't be 
recognized. As she integrates into the rhythm of village life, Yeva's memories 
of the war come flooding back, as she tries to conceal her identity. 

"While the film is set in Armenia, the story has a universal message about the 
sacrifices and strengths of motherhood and family, which resonated with us,” 
said Karolyne Sosa, Director of Programming, DTLA Film Festival. ‘Yeva' has 
already screened and won several awards at major international film festivals 
this year. We’re thrilled to have the opportunity to present the U.S. West 
Coast premiere of the film.” 

“Yeva” was selected as Armenia’s official submission to the 90th Academy Awards 
in the Best Foreign Language Film category for 2017. The film is co-produced by 
Iran’s Farabi Cinema Foundation and the National Cinema Center of Armenia.

The 94-minute film is set in Armenia and has an all-Armenian cast, including 
Narina Grigorian, Shant Hovhanisian, Sergay Tovmasian, Vrejh Kasoni, Marjan 
Avadisyan, Roz Avadisova, Digran Davtian, Nanor Patrosian, Avalian Adamian and 
Marat Davtian. The film was banned in Turkey due to interference from 
Azerbaijan’s government.

A total of 36 feature-length movies – 17 narrative and 19 documentary — are 
slated to screen at the DTLA Film Festival, with the majority making their 
World Premiere, West Coast Premiere or Los Angeles premieres.

The DTLA Film Festival was established in 2008 with a mission of reflecting the 
vibrant and eclectic urbanism that defines downtown L.A. Through the exhibition 
of a wide array of independent films by and about groups traditionally 
underrepresented in the commercial Hollywood film industry – notably women, 
people of color, and the LGBTQ communities – DTLA Film Festival has established 
itself as a platform that has continually pushed the creative envelope. 

About the Institute
 
Established in 2005, the USC Institute of Armenian Studies supports 
multidisciplinary scholarship to re-define, explore and study the complex 
issues that make up the contemporary Armenian experience—from post-genocide to 
the developing Republic of Armenia to the evolving diaspora. The institute 
encourages research, publications and public service, and promotes links among 
the global academic and Armenian communities.
 
For inquiries, write to [email protected] or call 213.821.3943





The scandal with Garegin Nzhdeh is gaining new momentum

Arminfo, Armenia
Oct 17 2019

ArmInfo. In Russia, the church is separated from the state.  This was announced on October 17 during a weekly briefing by the official representative of the  Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Maria Zakharova, asking her to  submit her vision of resolving the situation related to the attempt  to dismantle the memorial plate to Garegin Nzhdeh, which was  iestablished in the courtyard of the Armenian church in Russian  Armavir.

Responding to the question of the journalist, Zakharova asked to  answer the question whether the journalist divides the attitude to  this issue in Armenia and in Russia into two or three aspects.  "Firstly, I did not know the aspect of this situation, that there is  a tablet on the territory of the Armenian temple, etc. We still  proceed from the fact that our Church is separate from the state, and  this applies to all religious directions.  The second point, if we  return to this topic globally, I believe that we need to return it to  a certain historicity and assessments from this point of view, "the  representative of the Russian Foreign Ministry said, recalling that  Moscow's position was voiced repeatedly at briefings, she is also  reflected in a special report by MFA of Russia.  According to her,  this assessment is relevant in principle, and if it approaches this  issue from the point of view of history. "The third point, I wanted  to say once again that if I touch on the specific situation and the  statements of MPs and local authorities, I'm not up to date and ready  to study and comment more specifically. But, I believe that the first  two points are the answer of your question," Zakharova concluded .