Oostlander Report Reaffirms Euro Parl Resolutions on Genocide Issue

European Armenian Federation
for Justice and Democracy
Avenue de la Renaissance 10
B – 1000 BRUXELLES
Tel./Fax : +32 (0) 2 732 70 27
E-mail : [email protected]
Web :

PRESS RELEASE
March 19th, 2004
Contact: Talline Tachdjian
Tel.: +32 (0)2 732 70 27

OOSTLANDER REPORT REAFFIRMS EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT RESOLUTIONS ON THE GENOCIDE
ISSUE

The report:
– references the resolution of 18 June 1987
– calls on Turkey to reopen the borders with Armenia

Brussels, Belgium – The European Parliament’s Committee on Foreign Affairs,
Human Rights, Common Security and Defence Policy (AFET) adopted on March
17th, 2004, the report `on Turkey’s progress towards accession,’ written by
Dutch Christian Democrat Representative, Mr. Arie Oostlander (PPE), by a
vote of 39 for, 2 against and 7 abstentions.

This vote came after 199 amendments to the report had been proposed and
considered by members and political parties.

During the Committee meeting the day before, Mr. Oostlander has presented 21
compromise amendments to the report, of which two amendments directly
concerned Armenia and the Armenian Genocide.

The adopted report `requests Turkey to reopen the borders with Armenia and
to promote good neighbourly relations with Armenia, to work together to
promote equitable solutions to the regional conflicts and not to take any
action that would stand in the way of a historic reconciliation.’

In another compromise amendment adopted by the Committee, the report wishes
for `the establishment of a dialogue between Turkish and Armenian academics,
social and non-governmental organisations in order to overcome the tragic
experiences of the past as has been expressed in its earlier resolutions (of
18 June 1987, 15 November 2000, 28 February 2002 and 26 February 2004)’.

`We hail the European Parliament’s affirmation of previous resolutions on
the recognition of the Armenian Genocide,’ declared Hilda Tchoboian,
Chairperson of the European Armenian Federation. `After many years of
intense perseverance, we have succeeded in resurfacing the resolution of
1987 and having it reaffirmed in several European Parliament reports.’

The Federation reminds that in his initial text, Mr. Oostlander had
deliberately evaded the genocide issue, citing as a pretext in its
explanatory statement, the Turkish sensitivities regarding this issue.

`Though a reasonable dialogue between peoples is always desirable, Mr.
Oostlander’s report fails to recognize that Turkey is still today far from
demonstrating the slightest serious intention to conduct dialogue with
Armenia and Armenians. Consequently, it is not possible to camouflage the
crime suffered by the Armenian people with well-meaning wishes,’ stated
Tchoboian.

Arie Oostlander’s report will be submitted to European Parliament vote
during its plenary session in the coming weeks.

#####

http://www.eafjd.org

Abkhaz officials eliminate right to mother-tongue

The Georgian Messenger
19 March 2004

Abkhaz authorities
eliminate right to mother-tongue

Regretting the fact that the local de facto government has repeatedly
refused to open a branch of the UN Human Rights office in Gali, the
head of the UN Human Rights Office in Abkhazia, Ivar Vikki, said
there many other barriers to human rights protection in the breakaway
republic. “The situation is precarious,” he said on Thursday,
explaining that the lack of effective law enforcement, the
infiltration of criminal groups, the lack of a mechanism to file
complaints and the recent reform of language curriculum all impede
human rights.

Currently the United Nations Observer Mission in Georgia operates a
human rights office in Sukhumi where locals can come and state
violations.

“And they do have complaints,” noted MR. Vikki.

Most issued relate to property disputes within the region.

The UN office also conducts regular visits to pretrial detention
centers. Speaking with the Deputy Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Georgia Roza Otunbayeva, Mr. Vikki also
criticized the de facto authorities for language reform that
eliminates the right to study in the mother tongue.

Currently there are 41 official Armenian schools and 10 unofficial
Georgian schools in the region.

BAKU: Azeri FM, Canadian official discuss Karabakh, ties

Azeri foreign minister, Canadian official discuss Karabakh, ties

Sarq, Baku
16 Mar 04

Text of Zulfuqar report by Azerbaijani newspaper Sarq on 16 March
headlined “Vilayat Quliyev received David Preston” and subheaded “They
discussed the Nagornyy Karabakh problem”

Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Vilayat Quliyev yesterday received David
Preston, director general of the Central, East and South Europe
Department of Canada’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International
Trade, the Azerbaijani ministry’s press service has reported.

The meeting discussed the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict between Armenia
and Azerbaijan and ways to resolve it, bilateral relations between the
two countries and other subjects of mutual interest. Quliyev said that
this visit will strengthen friendly relations between Azerbaijan and
Canada and will contribute to the development of fruitful cooperation
within international organizations. The visit will also expand
economic relations and will benefit the prospects for further
Azerbaijani-Canadian cooperation. Quliyev said that he supports the
purpose of the visit.

He also briefed Preston on the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict, on efforts
to resolve it and the harsh living conditions of refugees. It is
important that the international community steps up its efforts to
resolve the conflict as soon as possible and in line with
international legal norms and principles, he said.

In turn, Preston said that the purpose of the visit was to expand
relations between Canada and Azerbaijan in various spheres. Canada
attaches great importance to the comprehensive development of
relations with Azerbaijan and desires closer cooperation in
international organizations.

Speaking about the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict, Preston expressed
the hope that this problem will soon be resolved in a peaceful way
with the efforts of the international community.

Closure of nuclear plant to stimulate Armenia’s energy sector

Closure of nuclear plant to stimulate Armenia’s energy sector

Haykakan Zhamanak, Yerevan
19 Mar 04

Excerpt from unattributed report by Armenian newspaper Haykakan
Zhamanak on 19 March headlined “”A draft law on the closure of the
Armenian Nuclear Power Station”

The government yesterday approved a draft law “On saving energy and
restoring the energy sector” that will be submitted to the National
Assembly for ratification. In fact, this law may also be called a bill
“On the closure of the Armenian Nuclear Power Station”. During
yesterday’s news conference on the submission of the draft law, Deputy
Energy Minister Areg Galstyan said that it is planned to raise the
level of Armenia’s energy system through the ratification of this
draft law.

According to Galstyan, in order to solve this problem, it is necessary
to stimulate the development of domestic energy resources, i.e. the
development of energy production in hydroelectric and wind power
plants. According to the deputy energy minister, this new law
specifies the government’s steps in this sector. It is to increase
energy produced with the help of domestic energy resources.

During the news conference, Galstyan listed several figures. Last year
Armenian consumed about 5.5bn kW/h of electricity, and 2bn kW/h of
this amount were produced by hydroelectric power plants.

Passage omitted: Other figures

Georgian Armenians appeal to CoE over “violation” of rights

Georgian Armenians appeal to Council of Europe over “violation” of rights

Arminfo, Yerevan
19 Mar 04

AKHALKALAKI

The political and socioeconomic crisis in Georgia is a result of
problems that have not been resolved for many years, A-Info news
agency has quoted representatives of the public organizations of
Samtskhe-Javakheti as saying in a message to Council of Europe
Secretary-General Walter Schwimmer.

The representatives of the public organizations point out that at
present, human rights and the rights of ethnic minorities are being
violated in Georgia and the country’s commitments to the Council of
Europe are, in fact, not being fulfilled. The state is not following
the principle of self-government established by the constitution,
which has a negative impact on the development of the country’s
regions.

In this connection, such a situation is particularly topical in
Samtskhe-Javakheti, the message said. The current
administrative-territorial structure and governing policy do not take
into account the peculiarities of the region and do not meet the
people’s needs. In fact, Samtskhe-Javakheti has been pushed out of the
process of governing the country, the letter says.

Programmes on the socioeconomic development of the region, which would
meet the interests of the population, are not being implemented in the
region and the population’s poverty is approaching a threatening
scale.

The authors of the message believe that in order to extricate the
region from the crisis, it is necessary to delineate the
administrative borders of the region and endorse its autonomous status
in the country’s constitution. The representatives of the public
organizations also expressed a desire to discuss regional issues with
Walter Schwimmer.

Lithuania can regain regional leadership – foreign minister

Lithuania can regain regional leadership – foreign minister

Veidas, Vilnius
18 Mar 04

Lithuania is capable of regaining its status as regional leader
despite its continuing domestic political problems, the Lithuanian
foreign minister, Antanas Valionis, has told the magazine
Veidas. Valionis said that Lithuania’s mission was to serve as a model
for other post-Soviet countries, and that it would be helping these
countries in the future. The following is an excerpt from an interview
with Valionis, conducted by Audrius Baciulis, entitled “We have to
prove first that our democracy is strong” and published on 18 March;
subheadings inserted editorially:

Lithuania’s political isolation continues

Lithuania has been living in mild isolation for some time
already. Leaders of neighbouring countries pass Lithuania and
agreements normally signed by the presidents are signed by foreign
ministers. Estonia is aiming at taking over the position of the
region’s front-runner. The magazine Veidas discussed with the foreign
minister, Antanas Valionis, whether it was possible to regain the lost
positions.

Question More than six months ago, there was talk that, after the
completion of the second round of NATO expansion, a summit of the
Vilnius Ten group of countries which are joining NATO or seek its
membership will be held in Lithuania. Is the summit still on the
agenda?

Valionis No, it isn’t. The initiative was suspended in spite of some
support we received from several countries. Unfortunately, bearing in
mind the current internal political situation, this is not
realistic. The initiative was taken over by Slovakia. The summit of
the Vilnius Ten and the leaders of several other countries will be
held in Bratislava on 19 March . The Lithuanian prime minister will go
to the summit.

Question Is this not an example of how the presidential scandal
impedes Lithuania’s foreign policy?

Valionis You see, it is difficult to present this as an example
because the whole initiative to organize a conference of the Vilnius
Ten was abandoned at the stage of discussions. This is not an
initiative which was fully agreed and then recalled.

However, it can be seen in that light as well. Until the impeachment
process has not been completed, we will be treated differently from
before.

Neighbours benefit from political turmoil

Question Perhaps this is why the Estonian foreign minister told his
Ukrainian counterpart, arrived in Estonia from Vilnius, that Estonia
would be Ukraine’s advocate in its aspirations to join the EU. If am
not mistaken, Lithuania was engaged in this for several years until
now.

Valionis The most important instrument in our foreign policy, the
heavy artillery of sorts, has not worked in Lithuania for some months
already. Thus, understandably, Lithuania’s possibilities decreased
accordingly. The fate of Ukraine is one of the most important European
geopolitical factors, and I think that Ukraine must become a member of
the European Union and NATO. Lithuania will be Ukraine’s advocate in
any case.

Question The former president, Valdas Adamkus, said that it was
possible to regain Lithuania’s leadership in the region if we try hard
enough.

Valionis It is certainly possible. And, undoubtedly, we shall have to
make efforts. First of all, we will have to prove to ourselves and to
our partners abroad that democracy in our country is strong enough and
capable of coping with such serious challenges as the presidential
scandal.

Our regional leadership will materialize through our strategic
partnership with Poland, and through our active policy on Kaliningrad
Region, and this will enhance our role in the European Union.

Question How long could this take?

Valionis It is difficult to say. The task of the Foreign Ministry is
to do everything in order to make this happen as soon as possible. It
should not take too long because we are showing initiative and we are
persistent.

Lithuania’s presence in Transcaucasus justified

Question In spite of all the scandals, Lithuania decided to open its
embassy in Georgia. Who needs that?

Valionis There are reasons for this. This is a matter of Lithuania’s
strategic decision. The Caucasus is a very sensitive and a very
important region and, until now, we did not have an embassy there. A
resident ambassador in Georgia can represent Lithuania in Armenia and
Azerbaijan.

What our partners in Europe and the United States have been saying is
true – Lithuania can be a good expert on former Soviet countries. The
contacts we have maintained until now have shown that we are capable
of carrying out this task successfully. This is consistent with
Lithuania’s interests because, apart from the EU market of 450m
people, we are also interested in the markets of Ukraine, Moldova,
Russia and the Transcaucasus countries. The more so that Lithuania has
long-standing cultural links with these countries.

Finally, having established strong democracy in this country (the test
of impeachment will prove this), we could be a model for the
Transcaucasus countries. We feel it is our moral duty to help them as
the European Union helped us some time ago.

Having liberated ourselves from the Soviet Union we all started on the
same level. But our actions, which were more efficient, helped us to
achieve such results that these countries look at Lithuania with
admiration. Therefore, our objective now is to help them by showing
how we did it.

Political crises last long

Question Do our diplomats explain to our partners abroad what is
currently going on in Lithuania and, most importantly, why this is
taking such a long time?

Valionis We can recall the Watergate scandal – the process until the
resignation of the US president, Richard Nixon, lasted for seven
months. The impeachment process against Bill Clinton also lasted for
several months. The drawback of democracy is that all procedures take
a long time. However, there is no other way out. Otherwise, Lithuania
could hardly be described as a democratic country.

Question Journalists of neighbouring Poland wonder what will happen if
Lithuania accedes to NATO and the European Union with a “lame-duck”
president.

Valionis Not only Polish journalists ask me this question. I do not
know either how the European Union and NATO would treat a president
who has been handed down a ruling by the Lithuanian Constitutional
Court.

Question However, a certain international isolation does exist. It
will be the prime minister and not the president who will go to the
ceremony of signing NATO entry documents.

Valionis There will be no signing of documents. The Seimas parliament
has ratified the North Atlantic Treaty and it will be deposited at the
US State Department on 29 March. From that moment, Lithuania will be a
member of NATO and the prime minister, Algirdas Brazauskas, will
attend the festive membership inauguration ceremony, which will bear a
symbolic rather than legal significance. Like hoisting the Lithuanian
flag at the NATO headquarters in Brussels on 2 April. Passage omitted

Agreement on EU constitution to be reached soon

Question What is the situation with regard to the EU constitution? As
of 1 May Lithuania will be an EU member, yet the internal rules
regulating the EU’s internal life still do not exist.

Valionis This only demonstrates the existence of internal democracy in
the European Union. This is not the first or the last case when EU
members failed to agree . This proves that there is no diktat in the
EU, and that each member state has its voice and its point of
view. Moreover, this demonstrates the importance of the search for
compromise in the EU.

I think that the matters related to the EU constitution will start
moving forward in the near future. In principle, all the issues have
been resolved, except the issue of defining the qualified majority
voting. Germany has tabled a new proposal which is similar to
Lithuania’s proposal and we discussed it at the conference of foreign
ministers in Naples. The proposal concerns linking the percentage of
votes given to countries and their population. It is beneficial to
Lithuania. The reaction of Spain is not known yet because of the
recent elections there after which a new government came to power ,
and it is not yet clear how France will react to the proposal. Poland
was a strong opponent of the new voting procedure as defined in the
draft EU constitution and it is still not known how it will react to
the new proposal.

In any event, this is a step towards a compromise. I think that the
agreement will be reached.

NATO security guarantees in real terms

Question And what about the split inside NATO that surfaced last year?
It has been patched up by smooth talk so far.

Valionis I would not say it was patched up by words. We must recall
the history of NATO – many things happened in the past. We must not
forget that some time ago NATO’s headquarters had to be moved from
France to Brussels. However, the willingness to talk and to reach
agreement prevailed. What is important for us is what is taking place
now. After Lithuania ratified the North Atlantic Treaty, political
security guarantees stipulated in its paragraph five will evidently
turn into defence guarantees in real terms.

Question Military bases were also mentioned.

Valionis The talks about military bases are some kind of
misunderstanding which stems from our mentality problems. We have been
saying “We and NATO”, as if some sort of a military base is moving
from NATO to Lithuania. NATO does not have military bases outside its
territory that would not be subject to the laws of the country on the
territory of which they are set up. Lithuania is NATO. If we are
talking about airspace policing, the aircraft will be deployed at
Lithuanian military bases. This must be understood. Therefore, talks
about amending some article in the constitution presumably to allow
NATO bases is some kind of misunderstanding.

Apart from this, there are no reasons to think that we live in a
conflict region. On the contrary, our NATO membership will further
increase stability in the region.

Russia does not pose military threat

Question Is it possible to live peacefully in Russia’s neighbourhood
when we see that not much democracy is left in that country?

Valionis We watch closely the processes in Russia because we cannot be
indifferent to them. We are prepared to cooperate and we have proved
this more than once, and the example of this can be the solution of
the Kaliningrad transit issue or discussing the issues of the transit
of goods and delivering supplies to Kaliningrad Region after we join
NATO.

Concerning the political situation in Russia, it is better to leave
this to political analysts to discuss. Ministers should be rather
careful about what they say. However, we do not see any signals
indicating a military threat. Passage omitted

As a member state of NATO and the European Union, we will feel more
secure and will be therefore able to be more open in cooperation with
Russia.

Armenian minister, NATO chief discuss ties

Armenian minister, NATO chief discuss ties

Arminfo
19 Mar 04

YEREVAN

Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanyan and NATO Secretary-General
Jaap de Hoop Scheffer have discussed the prospects for the development
of relations between NATO and Armenia. The meeting was held in
Bratislava today within the framework of the conference “Towards a
Wider Europe: The New Agenda”.

The Foreign Ministry press service told Arminfo that they paid special
attention to the murder of Armenian officer Gurgen Markaryan in
Budapest on 19 February.

Oskanyan also met the co-chairmen of the OSCE Minsk Group on the
Nagornyy Karabakh conflict settlement. However, no details of the
meeting have been reported yet.

Armenian public organizations settling families in Karabakh

Armenian public organizations settling families in Karabakh

Arminfo
19 Mar 04

YEREVAN

About 80 poor families from Armenia will be resettled in the Nagornyy
Karabakh Republic in 2004, the executive director of the Yerkir
(Country) union of public organizations for repatriation and
settlement, Sevak Artsruni, told a news conference at a club of
journalists today.

He said that about 35 families from Armenia would settle in Karabakh
in the next two months. The settlers will be provided with cottages
and land plots of 1,500-2,000 sq.m.

Moreover, Artsruni said that the settlers would be legally given some
privileges, for instance, they will be exempted from taxes. It should
be noted that Yerkir (the union includes five public organizations of
Armenia and Artsakh Karabakh ) has operated since November 2002.

He said that developing border zones is very important for Armenia
like for any developing country. Several schools, kindergartens and
hospitals were built in 2003 in Karabakh’s Novyy Shaumyan District New
Shaumyan – Azerbaijan’s Goranboy District and Hadrut District thanks
to Yerkir. The total sum of the programme was 186,356 dollars and
22,732 euros.

Artsruni also said that construction work will be conducted in
Mardakert Agdara , Hadrut and Novyy Shaumyan Districts of Karabakh, as
well as in Tavush and Gegharkunik Districts of Armenia (over 300
settlements). The total sum of the programmes for 2004 is over 400,000
dollars. The programme is financed by the French, Canadian and US
charitable funds France-Karabakh, Armenia, Monte Melkonyan and by
ethnic Armenian families living abroad and engaged in charity
activities.

He said that Yerkir is currently registering families from Russia and
other CIS countries who have expressed their desire to return to their
historic motherland, but have no opportunities to do that.

CIS unified air defence system to hold exercise on 7 April

CIS unified air defence system to hold exercise on 7 April

Interfax-AVN military news agency web site, Moscow
19 Mar 04

TVER

A command post exercise of the CIS Unified Air Defence System is
scheduled for 7 April, Russian Air Force Commander-in-Chief Vladimir
Mikhaylov said on Friday 19 March .

“The command post exercise of the CIS Unified Air Defence System will
take place on 7 April. The exercise will involve representatives of
all nations participating in the CIS Unified Air Defence System,”
Mikhaylov told reporters in Tver, summing up results of the 20th
session of the Air Defence Coordination Committee under the CIS
Defence Ministers Council.

Participants in the exercise will practice counteraction to aerial
terrorism and prevention of the violation of CIS aerial borders, as
well as interaction of air force and air defence headquarters of the
nations participating in the CIS Unified Air Defence System, Mikhaylov
noted. “On-duty forces will be checked as well,” he added.

Mikhaylov said he will personally supervise the exercise from the
Russian Air Force’s central command post. The Unified Air Defence
System brings together forces and assets of Russia, Armenia, Belarus,
Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Ukraine.

New Armenian party set to protect businesses

New Armenian party set to protect businesses

Noyan Tapan news agency
18 Mar 04

YEREVAN

The main goal of the new Party of Democracy and Labour (PDL) is to
assist the development of small and medium-sized businesses in
Armenia, the head of the initiative group of the party and former
deputy chairman of the Armenian Democratic and Liberal Party (ADLP),
Spartak Melikyan, told a news conference on 18 March. He said that
this sphere in Armenia was in a catastrophic state, as the country’s
parliament adopted laws hindering their development.

Members of the initiative group of the new party called on the owners
of small and medium-sized businesses to enter the party, win a seat in
parliament and protect their interests.

Melikyan said that the party would pursue a pro-state policy and
cooperate with both pro-government and opposition forces to ensure
people’s welfare and prosperity. “There is no idea of the third force
in Armenia’s political spectrum today and this is what our party is
going to be,” Melikyan said.

Passage omitted: minor details