US Envoy says Azerbaijan, Armenia must resolve NK conflict

ArmenPress
Jan 27 2005

US ENVOY SAYS AZERBAIJAN, ARMENIA MUST RESOLVE KARABAGH CONFLICT

BAKU, JANUARY 27, ARMENPRESS: In an interview to Azerbaijani MPA
news agency US ambassador to Baku, Reno Harnish, praised the “The
OSCE Minsk Group for doing a lot last year to help Armenia and
Azerbaijan resolve their dispute over Nagorno Karabagh.
“As far as the USA is concerned, its position remains unchanged.
The USA does not recognize the so-called Nagorno Karabagh republic
and respects Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity,” Harnish was quoted
as saying.
Harnish also the Karabagh conflict will be on the agenda of the
February meeting between US President George Bush and Russian
President Vladimir Putin. “Russia is playing an important role in
regional conflicts. In some cases this role is positive, while in
others negative. However, the solution to the problem depends not
only on Moscow and Washington. It is the leaders of Azerbaijan and
Armenia who must come to agreement first,” he said.
“Therefore, we are urging Russia to step up its positive role, and
Baku and Yerevan to display more constructive positions,” Harnish
said.

Reference to Armenian Genocide to be included in Turkish textbooks

ArmenPress
Jan 27 2005

REFERENCE TO ARMENIAN GENOCIDE TO BE INCLUDED IN TURKISH TEXTBOOKS,
REMOVED FROM GERMAN TEXTBOOKS

ANKARA, JANUARY 27, ARMENPRESS: Turkey’s Education Ministry
recently announced that elementary-level history textbooks will, for
the first time, include reference to the genocide committed against
the Ottoman-Armenians. The textbooks, however, will include both,
what Turkey refers to, the “Armenian version” of the genocide, and an
“official” government sanctioned version of the events.
The chairman of the Education Ministry’s committee on textbooks,
Moustafa Safran, explained that the inclusion of the genocide arose
from the fact that Armenians have insisted that the events that
occurred between 1915-1923 qualify as “genocide.” In order to address
the issue, Safran said, the committee decided to include both the
Armenian and Turkish perspectives–a move allowing students the
information necessary to form an educated opinion–according to the
committee.
Safran noted his committee realizes that it is impossible nowadays
to shield Turkish school children from “Armenian claims,” and that it
is their intention to bolster the government’s position on the issue
by including archival Ottoman documents, which reportedly prove that
the genocide never occurred.
Safran’s committee has also decided to exclude incendiary remarks
such as “we crushed the Greeks,” and be particular in its definitions
of “heroes” and “traitors.” Textbooks will note that numerous Kurdish
tribes assisted Mustafa Kemal’s efforts in establishing a “modern”
Turkey.
Meantime German DPA news agency reported that pressure from Turkey
has resulted in the removal of a reference to the Armenian genocide
from a German school curriculum.
The eastern German state of Brandenburg has eliminated half a
sentence on the Armenians included in ninth and tenth grade history
classes after a Turkish diplomat complained to state Prime Minister
Matthias Platzeck, the newspaper Die Welt reported.
In a chapter entitled “War, Technology and Civilian Populations”
the school book text said “for example, the genocide of the Armenians
population of Anatolia.” That passage has now been removed from
school textbooks, the newspaper said.
Platzeck met regularly with Turkish diplomats and was “steeled”
against their influence, the newspaper quoted him as saying. The
prime minister added that genocide was too important an issue to be
dealt with in just half a sentence. “Brandenburg’s curriculum was the
only one in Germany which up until now included a reference to the
murder of the Armenians,” said Die Welt.
The head of the Central Committee of Armenians in Germany,
Schavarsh Ovassapian told Die Welt the move was “a scandal.” “It is
depressing, if what’s in schoolbooks in Brandenburg can be dictated
from Ankara,” he said.

‘Civil Servant’ fired for expressing sympathy to Kurds, Armenians

Cyprus News Agency
Jan 26 2005

”Civil Servant” fired for expressing sympathy to G/C, Kurds,
Armenians

By Kyriakos Tsioupras

London, Jan 26 (CNA) — The violation of the right to freedom of
expression in the Turkish-occupied northern part of Cyprus was
brought before British Minister for Europe Dennis MacShane in the
House of Commons.

http://www.hri.org/news/cyprus/cna/2005/05-01-26.cna.html

ANKARA: Germany takes out Armenian Genocide from history books

Hurriyet, Turkey
Jan 27 2005

GERMAN STATE TAKES OUT THE TERM ARMENIAN GENOCIDE FROM ITS HISTORY
BOOKS

Brandenburg, which was the first German state that included the term
`Armenian genocide’ into its history books used in the 9th and 10th
classes since 2002, decided to take out the term from the curriculum
of the schools. State’s Spokesman of the Education Ministry Thomas
Hainz said that they found improper to give the so-called Armenian
genocide as the only historic example in the massacres and genocides
section in their history books, and therefore decided to take the
term out. Turkey’s Chief Consul Aydin Durusoy had sent a letter to
the state of Brandenburg, giving a harsh reaction to the use of the
term. As a result of the diplomatic initiatives of the Turkish
Foreign Ministry, Durusoy, state’s Premier Matthias Platzeck and
Education Minister Holger Rupprecht two weeks ago had agreed to take
out the term from the schools’ syllabus. /Hurriyet/

Calif. Commissioner Helps Issue $3 Million to Charity

Insurance Journal
Jan 27 2005

Calif. Commissioner Helps Issue $3 Million to Charity; Funds Initiate
$20 Million Claim Settlement
January 27, 2005

California Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi on Wednesday helped
deliver the first checks from a $20 million settlement of a class
action lawsuit to resolve insurance claims stemming from the Armenian
Genocide nearly 90 years ago.

The Commissioner reportedly played an instrumental role during the
final negotiations leading to the agreement with New York Life
Insurance Company.

“Justice has been long overdue in this case,” Garamendi said. “I am
pleased that this settlement will help resolve the insurance claims
of the heirs and beneficiaries from the tragic genocide that began in
1915. The hard work of all parties involved will help bring some
measure of closure to the descendants of the victims. Today marks the
beginning of the distribution of monies from this agreement, and I am
very proud to have helped in this healing process.”

The five organizations receiving checks for $333,333 each are: the
Armenian Church of North America Eastern Diocese (New York), Prelacy
of the Armenian Apostolic Church Eastern U.S. and Canada (New York),
Armenian Apostolic Catholic Exarchate for Armenian Catholics in the
U.S. and Canada (New York), Armenian Missionary Association of
America, Inc. (Paramus, New Jersey) and the Armenian General
Benevolent Union (New York).

Four other Armenian organizations in California will also receive
$333,333 each, including: Armenian Church of North America Western
Diocese (Burbank), Western Prelacy of the Armenian Apostolic Church
(Los Angeles), Armenian Educational Foundation (Glendale). The
Armenian Relief Society, United States Chapter of Watertown,
Massachusetts will also receive an equal portion of the proceeds.

In order to make a claim for a portion of the settlement, descendants
of policyholders killed during the Armenian Genocide must postmark
their claims no later than March 16, 2005. Details of the settlement
and the New York Life policies involved are available at

www.ArmenianInsuranceSettlement.com.

Bush Administration scraps its “coalition of the willing” list

Washington Times/UPI
Jan 27 2005

Bush Administration scraps its “coalition of the willing” list

A White House official on Jan. 21 confirmed that the Bush
administration has quietly scrapped its 45-member “coalition of the
willing” list of Iraq allies, replacing it with a smaller roster of
28 countries with troops in Iraq sometime after the June transfer of
power to an interim Iraqi government. The administration might have
acted hastily, as one plucky nation is actually sending troops into
Iraq rather than withdrawing forces. Armenia has sent a 46-member
military contingent in advance of the Jan. 30 elections. The Armenian
Defense Ministry reported that the servicemen would serve within the
Polish military contingent for six months, until after the nation’s
Constituent Assembly meets. Erevan moved quickly to deploy its
forces, as the decision to dispatch officers to Iraq was adopted by
the Armenian parliament only on Dec. 24.

Breaking into a man’s world

The Economist
Jan 27 2005

Breaking into a man’s world

Jan 27th 2005
>From The Economist print edition

Reuters
The new boss of the Sabanci group chose to wear trousers instead of
a wedding dress

TURKISH industry is dominated by two vast family businesses, both of
which have recently handed over their top jobs to a new generation of
40-somethings. The Europeanised Koc group passed the reins to Mustafa
Koc, the eldest of the chairman’s three sons, in 2003. But before
Sakip Sabanci died last year, he let it be known that he wanted
neither of his two brothers nor any of their numerous male offspring
to succeed him as head of the far more traditional Sabanci family
business. Rather, he chose his niece, Guler. It was a choice that he
had been hinting at for at least a decade.

Turks were astonished by the appointment of a woman to such a
powerful post in what remains a patriarchal society. But none was
more surprised than Ms Sabanci herself. As her uncle lay dying in an
Istanbul hospital, she recalls thinking that she would quit the
business. `I could not envisage staying on without him,’ she says.

Running a sprawling conglomerate with annual sales of $12 billion and
interests ranging from banking to cars, and from energy to food, is a
challenging task that comes at a particularly challenging time. In
December, EU leaders finally agreed to begin accession talks with
Turkey on October 3rd this year. Over the coming decade, Turkish
companies will need drastically to alter their often unorthodox
business practices if they are to thrive within the EU. Although
TUSIAD, Turkey’s powerful association of businessmen, currently
headed by one of Guler’s cousins, strongly supported the country’s
attempt to join the EU, many of its individual members fear the
abolition of protectionist policies behind which they have prospered
for decades.

Sabanci Holding went through a big restructuring of its operations
before Turkey signed a customs union with the EU in 1996. The process
was designed to prepare it for global competition. Ms Sabanci says
that the EU straitjacket can only benefit honest Turkish businesses.
For a start, it will help constrain the country’s vast black economy
(estimated at anything up to 50% of GDP), making competition for
companies like Sabanci `much fairer’. More companies will be
compelled to pay taxes and follow health and safety regulations.

The EU’s decision to start accession talks is also expected to
enthuse foreign investors for a country that they have to date
noticeably shunned because of decades of chronically high inflation,
political instability and massive corruption. That gloomy image is
slowly being altered under the group of mild Islamists who have been
running Turkey for the past two years. And slowly the world is
noticing.

This newly stable environment has prompted Ms Sabanci to look for new
alliances with foreign partners, a strategy that the group excels at.
She herself masterminded its first joint-venture, with DuPont in
1987, setting up a $100m nylon-yarn producer in the port city of
Izmit. The group’s joint-venture with Toyota, which the Japanese car
manufacturer is said to be well pleased with, was launched in 1994 as
a platform for exporting Corollas to the rest of Europe. Last year it
captured 6.7% of the highly competitive local car market.

Ms Sabanci says acquisitions are also on the cards. They may include
Telsim, Turkey’s number-two mobile-phone operator. It was taken over
by the government after its owners, the Uzan family, stole billions
from their foreign partners, Motorola and Nokia, and the company was
forced into bankruptcy.

Behind her unconventional lifestyle – she lives alone and mixes with
painters and popstars – lies a tough, conservative businesswoman who
takes only carefully calculated risks; one reason, say her business
associates, why her uncle anointed her as his successor. Some of her
male cousins were so offended that one of them, Demir Sabanci, is
rumoured to have sold all his shares in the company last month,
because he could not stomach being bossed by a woman.

>From sharecropper to shareowner
Ms Sabanci’s first brush with industry was at the age of three, when
her grandfather Haci Omer, a rags-to-riches former cotton
sharecropper in the southern province of Adana, took her to the
family’s textile factory there. Ms Sabanci’s parents divorced when
she was eight and left her in the care of her grandfather. `He always
told me that one day I would wear trousers, drive a car and work in
the factory.’

And that is what she did: her career began 27 years ago at the
family’s tyre factory in Izmit. She resisted her grandmother’s
unrelenting demands to `see me in a wedding dress’ choosing, as she
puts it, `my work instead.’ When not working she keeps an eye on the
wine she launched in 1999, under the label `G’, the same year she
launched what she calls `my big baby’: Sabanci University. The
university has matured rather better than the wines – it is already
counted among Turkey’s best privately-owned colleges. Some 40% of its
students are offered free tuition, subsidised by the $20m a year that
the university gets from the Sabanci group.

`Tough’ and `unpretentious’ are the words that employees most
frequently use to describe Ms Sabanci, a reformed chain smoker with a
gravelly Janis Joplin-like voice. Her toughness came to the fore
recently when she withstood pressure from the state to fire Halil
Berktay, an eminent Ottoman historian at the university. He had dared
to suggest that Turkey’s Armenian minority may have been slaughtered
in large numbers by Ottoman forces during the first world war.

Her late uncle similarly angered the authorities when he called for
more rights for Turkey’s Kurdish minority. `His greatest lesson to
me,’ says Ms Sabanci, `was to be a free thinker, to be tolerant,
honest and fair.’ Those who know her say it is a lesson that she has
learnt well.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

French man dies of carbon monoxide in Armenia

French man dies of carbon monoxide in Armenia, latest in rash of poisoning
incidents

.c The Associated Press

YEREVAN, Armenia (AP) – A French man died of carbon monoxide poisoning
in his Yerevan apartment, emergency officials said Thursday, the
latest in a rash of deaths in Armenia caused by gas leaks and faulty
heating stoves.

The Emergency Situations Ministry said Christophe Kyababchyan, a
34-year-old French citizen, was found dead in his apartment by his
business partner.

The ministry said an improperly installed gas heater was likely to
blame.

The incident brings the number of gas poisonings in Armenia in the
past year to 26, 16 of which occurred in December alone, according to
emergency officials. The prosecutor general’s office, however, says
there were 24 deaths in 2004 by natural gas poisoning alone.

Many people in the ex-Soviet republic use makeshift stoves and
homemade gas heaters, sometimes tapping illegally into gas lines,
because their homes lack heaters, which are expensive.

01/27/05 11:46 EST

Azerbaijan reports soldier killed by ethnic Armenian forces in

Azerbaijan reports soldier killed by ethnic Armenian forces in disputed
enclave

By AIDA SULTANOVA
.c The Associated Press

BAKU, Azerbaijan (AP) – An Azerbaijani soldier was killed on the
cease-fire line separating government troops from ethnic Armenian
forces controlling the Nagorno-Karabakh enclave and a swath of
surrounding territory in the ex-Soviet republic, the Defense Ministry
said Thursday.

The military chief in the disputed enclave, meanwhile, said
strengthened defenses on the cease-fire line mean that any Azerbaijani
attempt to take back the territory will be thwarted and could prompt
“successful counterattacks.”

The latest death on the dividing line and the bellicose warning added
to tension that persists more than a decade after a 1994 cease-fire
ended a six-year war over Nagorno-Karabakh that killed 30,000 people
and drove a million from their homes.

Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry said ethnic Armenian forces opened fire
near the village of Shurabad shortly before midnight Wednesday,
killing an Azerbaijani soldier.

Gunfire sporadically breaks out between the opposing forces, and the
dispute has raised fears of renewed war. International efforts have
failed to produce a settlement between Azerbaijan and Armenia, which
supports Nagorno-Karabakh’s internationally unrecognized government.

Also Wednesday, Nagorno-Karabakh defense chief Seiran Oganian said
that “large volume of construction work” done on the front line over
the past year would enable ethnic Armenian forces to “freely conduct
trench fighting in the case military action begins, turning aside all
attempts by the enemy to move forward.”

“We are prepared … not just to defend ourselves but to conduct
successful counterstrikes,” Oganian said.

Ethnic Armenian forces also control a large amount of adjacent
territory, including land that links the enclave with
Armenia. Disputes over the additional territory have been one of the
factors preventing Armenia and Azerbaijan from settling the conflict.

International monitors from the Organization for Security and
Cooperation in Europe, which has been seeking to foster a settlement
between Armenia and Azerbaijan for a decade, are due to tour the
ethnic Armenian-held territory in the coming days.

Oganian, who spoke at a news conference, said that Nagorno-Karabakh
authorities “cannot prohibit our citizens to farm in these
territories.”

Bernard Fassier, the French co-chairman of the OSCE’s Minsk Group,
said at a news conference in Baku on Thursday that the OSCE could not
resolve the dispute on its own.

The OSCE “can provide help in the process of dialogue, conducting
negotiations, creating productive atmosphere, but it cannot resolve
the conflict for you,” Fassier told Azerbaijan’s President Ilham
Aliyev.

Fassier said OSCE representatives would travel to Nagorno-Karabakh on
Jan. 29 for a fact-finding mission.

Associated Press writer Avet Demourian in Yerevan, Armenia,
contributed to this report.

01/27/05 14:22 EST

Armenian opposition offers gov’t deal on constitutional reform

EurasiaNet Organization
Jan 27 2005

ARMENIAN OPPOSITION OFFERS GOVERNMENT DEAL ON CONSTITUTIONAL REFORM
Emil Danielyan 1/27/05

Armenian opposition leaders have sent feelers to President Robert
Kocharian and his allies on a constitutional deal. The initiative
could break a lengthy deadlock that has prevented the president from
amending Armenia’s controversial basic law. At the same time, the
opposition’s surprise move poses political risks for Kocharian.

Political analysts have differing theories as to why the country’s
two main opposition groups are now ready to compromise after putting
up years of resistance to the constitutional changes. Most analysts
interpret the move as either a sign of a softening of the
opposition’s stance on Kocharian’s leadership, or as a ploy designed
to undermine Kocharian’s credibility.

The Ararutiun (Justice) bloc and the National Unity Party (AMK)
indicated on January 19 that they are ready to endorse Kocharian’s
package of constitutional amendments — due to be put to a nationwide
referendum later this year – provided that several changes are made.
The opposition’s proposals include giving the Armenian parliament a
larger role in the formation of the government, and making the mayor
of the capital Yerevan an elected official. The opposition also wants
to limit the president’s authority to appoint and dismiss judges.

The proposals were addressed to leaders of the three parties that are
represented in Kocharian’s cabinet, and that control the legislature.
Leaders of the governing coalition were clearly caught by surprise.
Parliament speaker Artur Baghdasarian promised to start
“consultations” with other majority leaders and deliver their common
response by the end of January.

Armenia’s post-Soviet constitution, enacted following a reputedly
fraudulent referendum in 1995, has long been criticized for vesting
too many powers in the presidency at the expense of the legislative
and judicial branches. It empowers the president to single-handedly
form and dismiss governments, dissolve the National Assembly
practically at will and name virtually all judges without
parliamentary confirmation.

Constitutional reform was among Kocharian’s key promises when he came
to power in 1998. It was also one of the conditions for Armenia’s
accession to the Council of Europe four years ago. Kocharian’s first
attempt to implement reforms ended in failure when his package of
draft amendments fell short of sufficient popular support at a
referendum in May 2003.

The opposition urged voters at the time to reject the proposed
changes, saying that they would only enhance executive power.
Opposition leaders were equally critical of revised amendments
jointly drafted by Kocharian and the coalition leaders in the course
of the last year. “The un-elected president and the dubiously elected
coalition have no right to remodel the constitution of the Republic
of Armenia,” one of them, Victor Dallakian, declared last August,
referring to the hotly disputed presidential and parliamentary
elections of 2003. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

Armenian authorities, meanwhile, are facing growing pressure from the
Council of Europe over constitutional reform. In a resolution adopted
last September, the Strasbourg-based organization’s Parliamentary
Assembly (PACE) urged them to hold another referendum “as soon as
possible, and in any event by June 2005 at the latest.” The Armenian
parliament is expected to start final debates on the issue in March.

The Justice bloc and the AMK said they will suspend their year-long
boycott of parliament sessions if the presidential camp agrees to
their proposals. Significantly, those proposals reflect the
recommendations of the so-called Venice Commission, a Council of
Europe body monitoring legal reform in the member states. In an
interim report released in December, the commission concluded that
the revised amendments represent “a shift in favor of the president”
when compared to the initial version of constitutional reform
suggested by Kocharian in 2001.

“More significant amendments, especially with respect to the key
issue of the balance of powers between the state organs, are
necessary,” read the report. It noted that the Armenian legislature
would remain “subordinated” to the president and play no role in the
nomination and dismissal of prime ministers. The Venice Commission
also said the presidential authority to appoint and sack Yerevan
mayors contradicts not only European standards, but also some
provisions of the Armenian constitution.

These recommendations are largely acceptable to at least one of the
three governing parties, the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF).
But it is Kocharian who has a final say on the matter, and it remains
unclear if he will agree to curbs on his existing authority.

The opposition hopes that Kocharian will not, according to some
observers. In that case, they say, opposition leaders might try to
take political advantage, claiming the moral high ground and
portraying the president as an inherently undemocratic politician.
The Armenian leader’s commitment to democracy and rule of law has
already been seriously questioned by the West. “If they don’t accept
[the opposition proposals], we will turn the constitutional
referendum into a referendum of confidence in Kocharian,” Dallakian
warned last week.

No wonder that Hayots Ashkhar, a Yerevan daily staunchly supportive
of Kocharian, looked for ulterior motives behind the opposition
overtures. In a weekend editorial titled “Political Games,” the paper
suggested that the opposition is bent on discrediting authorities in
the eyes of Europeans. The ruling coalition must therefore be on its
guard, it said.

Governing-coalition parties already offered the opposition to jointly
work out constitutional amendments last April, in an unsuccessful
attempt to stave off anti-Kocharian street protests in Yerevan. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive]. They now say the offer
may no longer be in force. “The situation has changed a bit [since
April],” said Armen Rustamian, an ARF leader. “So has our mood.”

The anticipated constitutional referendum should also finally clarify
whether Kocharian would like to stay in power if he completes his
second five-year tenure in 2008. The existing constitution bars him
from seeking a third term. The draft amendments currently in
circulation would not abolish this restriction, but they may still
undergo changes before being put to the vote.

Editor’s Note: Emil Danielyan is a Yerevan-based journalist and
political analyst.